7 Ups & 8 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (11 Oct)
The WWE Draft kicks off with a bang. Or was that just the sound of a Bayley Buddy getting axed?
A show that probably should have been the climax of WWE's Premiere Week considering the state of Sunday's WWE Hell In A Cell, the first edition of SmackDown on Fox was a beautiful and brilliant festival of WWE's best bullsh*t.
The set was stunning, the booking was shocking and The Rock was talking - it was all the best ingredients for a superb two-hour shift of Sports Entertainment. The company were even smart enough to tee up a gimmick for the second episode too, if only to prove that the near-four million viewing figure wasn't a total fluke.
It's Draft season!
A staple event for WWE any time the rosters are split, Drafts, Superstar Shake-ups et al have always found drama in the fundamentally undramatic. Never once have we the audience been given a storyline reason as to why red is better than blue or Monday better than Tuesday/Thursday/Friday, but that very question would unpick too many loose threads. Instead, let's make like the "war rooms" and celebrate/commiserate as appropriate!
In the immediate aftermath of the broadcast, it felt as though the latter dominated the discussion.
Downs...
8. Human After All
Funny how when WWE completely butcher a character they expect the heart still to beat.
The Fiend's run/crawl-in during the Seth Rollins/Roman Reigns opener was, presumably, a one-and-done makegood from WWE to repair some of the damage done to the character at Sunday's Hell In A Cell. Predictably, it didn't really work.
Ahead of Bray Wyatt's drafting to SmackDown, there was a dread that this feud would subsequently continue, but the company will probably count this segment as him getting his heat back before the two possibly go belt-for-belt at the Survivor Series in November. For Wyatt, this particular stunt was more about getting his breath back - the poor f*cker looked as knackered as his gimmick now is having to run to the top of the ramp after his ring-breaking theatrics with 'The Architect'.
The road back to where he was a week ago is far longer than the SmackDown ramp.
7. Coming Up Short
The f*cking state of that graphic. The f*cking state of this company.
Your writer was one of the few to defend this forcefully futile angle during Chad Gable's inspired King Of The Ring run, but not anymore.
Now, he's a guy taking his name from the bully heel that gave him it who ultimately lost to the bully because those are always the stories WWE tell. It's possibly not a career-killer, but imagine aiming for a bar that low for your supposedly pushed projects. SHORTY GABLE PROBABLY WOULD LOL.
And as for the match...
6. Canis Canem Edit
To talk of diminished returns would sound like the set-up to a sh*t "Chad Gable Is Short" joke, but Gable and King Corbin have wrestled so much since their quality King Of The Ring final that the only way was going to be down for the two.
The aforementioned result was the most frustrating element. The bore they assembled at Hell In A Cell was some way below the standard they'd set, but Gable's victory at least appeared to put a bow on their business until Big Banter Baron battered him backstage.
Victory here was the final tell that "Shorty Gable" isn't going to overthrow the King anytime soon, and a worrying reminder of 'The Lone Wolf's trolling past. Easy to mask under other high profile failures currently ongoing within the organisation, this was another waste of an awful lot of work.
5. Secondary Measures
Despite the company's best efforts to keep the format fresh (more on that later), the Draft already felt like a drag by the end of Round 2.
Braun Strowman will get another go at being the big deal he should have been years ago, but the rest weren't exactly all that inspiring.
Though she's still a hot character coming out of her programme with Becky Lynch, the decision to place Sasha Banks as SmackDown's third overall pick was lost to the lagging nature of the show. On paper, this protects her as the brand's most valuable commodity beyond the Champion herself. Within the body of this broadcast, she was just part of the pack.
4. Fury Road
More Tyson in 2009 than Tyson in 1998, the 'Gypsy King' and Braun Strowman's big man battle ironically doesn't feel all that...big.
A pathetic press conference pull-apart between them earlier in the day spoke to how listless the match currently feels, though as usual this doesn't really seem like a case of WWE catering to their customer base.
Its spot on yet another hugely problematic Saudi Arabian supershow already undermines the supposed excitement at the expense of WWE's grubby deal with the country, whilst Sky Sports in the United Kingdom are selling the show through their Box Office service at what'll likely be double the price of a Network subscription.
Would this feel more prestigious as part of another pay-per-view? Possibly so. Do WWE give a single f*ck either way? Categorically not.
3. Sh*ts & Cain
Cain Velasquez isn't brand spanking new to wrestling, having ran the ropes in Triple A as well as WWE's Performance Center before being trotted out on television for his blockbuster debut against Brock Lesnar.
By all accounts and scant clips, his grasp of the in-ring basics is reasonable. His grasp on a microphone simply shouldn't exist.
Best kept as the silence behind the violence, Cain was horrific in the Crown Jewel press conference earlier that day, and couldn't follow Paul Heyman's magnificent promo even with Rey Mysterio working as his ventriloquist.
It takes time and tenure to learn to be a great talker in WWE, but the company have rushed him to this stage so everybody gets paid the big bucks from a pile marked "blood money" backstage. They'll subsequently be judged in kind.
2. Same Old New Day
Most agreed that Kofi Kingston was done extremely dirty by his squash loss to Brock Lesnar on the maiden edition of SmackDown on Fox, but if The New Day man isn't booked to care, then why should the audience?
Not since Finn Bálor's 2017 return has a former Champion cared less about reclaiming a top prize, and it did him no good back then too.
Clearly in an attempt to buy the gimmick at least a week, WWE positioned Kofi, Big E and Xavier Woods in this episode's Breast Cancer Awareness month segment, but the sight of them f*cking about in the Gorilla Position that Brock Lesnar was literally about to walk through felt just as damaging to the former Champion as last week's loss.
1. The Best Of What's Left?
Those War Room executives sure looked thrilled to score Randy Orton et al during the various cutaways to the two sides, but the suited and bespectacled actors were obviously paid well for those pops as the Draft ROLLED ON.
Round 4's groupings, for example, were so bereft of excitement that barely Michael Cole and Corey Graves could put it over.
Nikki Cross was an illogical waste of a pick, considering how she could have been selected alongside Alexa Bliss. The Street Profits got minimal response upon Stephanie McMahon's announcement, damning their Statler & Waldorf run on the red brand to this point. Lucha House Party, with respect to all three men behind the mask, are booked to f*cking suck, yet got the jump on Otis and his big belly.
And for that matter, if you think Heavy Machinery were kept amongst the upper echelon for any other reason than that, you've simply not been watching the product closely enough.
Ups...
7. Believe In The Shield
Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns kicking off SmackDown with a high quality television match was everything 'The Beastslayer' needed after a catastrophic night at Hell In A Cell.
It was by no means a full recovery job - not least considering the non-finish and further involvement of The Fiend in the post-match - but the pair know how to wrestle one another to maximum effect even without an ideal ending. The move/counter-move chemistry was electric towards the end, especially after the pair recreated their blistering Spear-into-a-Pedigree sequence from Money In The Bank 2016.
It's rare that Roman punching that pillow won't get an Up, not least until the novelty wears off. The fans showed willing respect for both rather than what may have been anticipated disdain. This, for WWE, must have been of some relief.
6. SPORTS Entertainment
The gentlest of ups for WWE's effort to get across the significance of the Draft, particularly following some deathly dull "Superstar Shake-up" episodes over the past couple of years.
With War Rooms and various Fox Sports analysts chiming in their (admittedly, valueless) insights throughout the night, there was a noble effort here to get across that this was actually a battle between the television stations and shows to capture as many quality superstars as they could.
One of the biggest gripes around Survivor Series season is just how meaningless the battle for "Brand Supremacy" actually is. Should they go down that route for this year's Thanksgiving Classic, they'll at least have this particular episode to lean on for partial credibility.
5. Scarred Past
Earlier this week, Chris Jericho cut one of the money promos of the year on AEW Dynamite. Whilst probably few people were particularly listening for it, Paul Heyman followed suit with a magnificent sell of the Brock Lesnar/Cain Velasquez WWE Championship clash.
It's a shame the match will take place at Crown Jewel, tainting what could be one of the biggest results of the year, or at very least a spectacle for the ages. The mention of the scar under Brock's eye where Cain smashed him during their 2010 UFC contest was perfect fodder for the feud too, as was Heyman's insistence that Lesnar was facing a fear he intended to conquer, rather than just a mere opponent.
As noted, Velasquez' rebuttal was hampered by his efforts on the microphone, but Rey Mysterio and some powerful UFC photos did much to enhance the programme even further. Booked well, and these two could theoretically go again at WrestleMania. Then, all this good stuff might be easier to celebrate.
4. Think Pink
Finally beginning to make the best of their bad situation (based on innumerable stories about Susan G Komen over the years), WWE got away from The Ultimate Warrior and other absurd missteps from previous cancer campaigns to simply celebrate those that have defeated it and those still trapped in such a devastating battle.
The New Day's moment with this week's special guests was just nice, and how often do WWE fumble when presented with that exact emotion?
And (sort of) speaking of the 'Power Of Positivity"...
3. Paradise?
...for all Kofi Kingston's frustrating lack of follow-up hurt his chances of getting anywhere near the belt now slung back over Brock Lesnar's shoulder, full credit to him for slotting straight back in alongside Xavier Woods and Big E for a mini-banger of a six-man tag team match with the Raw-bound OC trio.
All about the quick tags and hope spots for the bulk of the lean six minutes it was afforded, a series of impressive reversals fed into a Kingston pinfall victory over AJ Styles after slipping out of a calf-crusher as well as just about everything else the 'Phenomenal One' tried.
Though tepid at times, Kofi's title reign may have done much for his Trouble In Paradise finisher over the summer. Now an out-of-nowhere move, the lack of an intricate set-up offers the opportunity for shock wins such as these.
2. Here's BAYLEY
Bayley taking a literal f*cking axe to the wacky waving inflatable arm flailing tube men will surely make more children cry than the poor lad currently doing the rounds on Twitter after a Fox retweet, so impactful was this permanent and proper reintroduction of her as a bonafide heel.
A good argument for WWE against the many reasoned arguments that they can't tell longer form stories, the turn was well earned following weeks of her no-selling what a sh*thead she'd become since linking arms with returning partner-in-crime Sasha Banks.
The SmackDown Women's Championship loss to Charlotte Flair at Hell In A Cell clearly wrecked her wiring for good, even if that wasn't abundantly clear in her middling acting job on the night. This, brilliantly, left no cause for doubt. The new hair, gear, entrance and theme were all tells of a huge commitment in a new phase of the former 'Hugger's career.
It was important the booking followed through to a natural conclusion...
1. Misery Business
Completing a big night for Bayley, her main event Championship switch with Charlotte Flair yielded a very good television match between the two that saw 'The Queen's face bloodied as per the intensity shown throughout.
As good as she's ever been since going rogue, Bayley was in the mood to brood, constantly rowing the referee in between extra-brutal attacks on the woman that defeated her just five days ago. As always, Flair turned in a powerful babyface display, selling the agony of the assaults more than usual in a noble effort to ensure the character got all the way over in such a high profile spot. Perhaps the most underrated pairing of all the Four Horsewomen offerings, Bayley and Charlotte had high quality matches on the opposite side of the divide in 2017, but they both precisely two years better here.
Winning after a handful of Flair's hair secured a small package, new two-time blue brand Champion Bayley cut her most confident promo to date simply by cutting down the entire audience as she had her inflatable friends 11 minutes earlier. "B*tch" of course featured in the verbiage, but this one at least felt worthier than the company's typically haphazard deployment of the dated riposte. As the show went off the air, there was the prevailing sense that the former 'Hugger' may put further tired old demons to rest in the weeks to come.