7 Ups And 6 Downs From WWE Extreme Rules 2016
Fatal Fourway for the IC title, thumbtacks and a returning former world champ, oh my.

Just when you thought that WWE was going to just give us another PPV with Roman Reigns holding the title over his head as fans lustily boo and JBL extolls the virtues of freedom of choice, the company mixed things up and closed Extreme Rules with a returning Seth Rollins making his impact felt.
Beyond that, WWE delivered another solid, if unspectacular, PPV. There wasnt enough to consider it great by any stretch, but at least most people showed up to work Sunday night. Unsurprisingly, the Intercontinental Championship match stole the show, leaving fans spent after cheering almost nonstop. Most of the other matches were pretty good themselves.
Still, Extreme Rules on the whole wont go down as a classic PPV. Parts of it were forgettable (Ziggler/Corbin and Kalisto/Rusev), while others you will have to watch a couple more times to really appreciate. The specialty matches themselves also were lacking, with six of the eight having special stipulations, and a couple stips just pertaining to the number of opponents involved in the match.
Through it all, WWE managed to put on a decent show last night with some solid matches and a killer finish. But will Rollins return make a difference? Time will tell
So what powered through it all and what folded like a tent. Lets get to it
Downs...
6. Corbin Moving On

Watching the Baron Corbin/Dolph Ziggler match, you get the feeling WWE wanted Corbin to take advantage of the no-DQ stipulation to put over a ruthless side of him at least, thats what you have to assume given how he won the match.
Corbin hit a blatant low blow in full view of the referee perfectly legal in the bout and hit an End of Days to win the match. He laughed about doing it while announcer Mauro Ranallo speculated that if you asked Baron about it, hed say he did it because (he) can.
Heres the problem with that: Corbin was a punching machine during the match. There was nothing extreme about the bout until the low blow. Baron never used a table, ladder, chair or even the steel steps before the end. If the goal was to show that Corbin was a callous, sinister competitor, then WWE failed.
If that wasnt their intent and they just wanted him to use a low blow to win, then thats just foolish when trying to build a monster heel.
5. Passion

This might seem redundant from last weeks Raw, but if JBL is going to say ridiculous things like this, then it deserves to be called out.
If you were listening during the Usos/Club match, you could clearly hear fans booing Jimmy and Jey Uso during their intro and throughout the bout. It was so loud that the announcers had to acknowledge it, with Michael Cole figuring that it was due to their association with Roman Reigns.
JBL said that Reigns is one of the most polarizing champions WWE has ever had, using the same lame line that they used with John Cena for years. He added that whether you boo or cheer for Roman, you have passionate emotion, which means the champ is a megastar. Thats rather specious reasoning, and it frankly is insulting to give Roman the Cena treatment. Want proof? Wait to see whether the ratings go up when Cena returns.
4. Dana And Charlotte?

This one is going to need some time to digest, but the initial reaction after watching Dana Brooke seemingly join forces with Charlotte and Ric Flair was confusion.
Sure, Dana was in no (wo)mans land with Emma landing on the injured list a week after Brooke debuted, and she probably needed an experienced partner, but teaming her with the Womens Champion? It just feels forced right now, like they needed to stick her somewhere with a villain, and Charlotte fit the bill. Brooke is nowhere near ready to stake out on her own, so she could provide muscle for the biggest heel on the roster.
But is this a good fit? The initial vibe is no, but a more serious determination can be made after some interactions involving them. One thing though: Dana needs to never do the Flair strut again. That one is not negotiable.
3. Going Insane By Boredom

A match between Chris Jericho and Dean Ambrose, contested inside a steel cage with weapons dangling from it: What could go wrong?
Unfortunately, the answer involves some yawning. The first ever asylum match in WWE might also be the last, if Sundays bout was any indication. The match was built around one thing: someone getting dropped into a pile of thumbtacks and becoming a human pincushion. Other than that, everything else was just killing time.
And that was evident by the slow, plodding nature of the match, which just seemed to meander toward its conclusion, not to mention the often quiet crowd in the early going. And while the ending was entertaining as hell, it cant make for slow climbs, going through the motions, a mop as a weapon and the comedy that went along with it.
Thankfully, Ambrose won definitively, and hopefully both men can move on to different rivalries now.
2. Nattie Slips On A Banana Peel

The preview column for this piece talked about WWE doing a good job rebuilding Natalya into a credible challenger, to the point where fans are sympathizing with her and would completely buy her winning the title at Extreme Rules.
Yeah, well, about that
WWE took what could have been a really good match that put Charlotte over as either a dominant or dastardly heel and instead just made Nattie look foolish. The challenger got distracted when Ric Flairs music hit, thinking he was breaking the big rule of the match and coming down to ringside, giving her the title.
Instead, it was Dana Brooke, wearing a Flair robe and wig, strutting down to the ring. That was enough to distract Natalya, who continued jawing with Dana and ultimately getting caught with a Figure 8 for the tapout loss. And thus ends Natties run as as credible challenger, falling victim to a simple distraction.
1. Not A Good Guy Or A Bad Guy

Look, this whole, Im not a good guy, Im not a bad guy, Im the guy routine is just getting silly now. Sunday night, the Usos blatantly not only leveled the playing field in the main event by taking out Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows, they also interfered in the world title match.
WWE can try as much as they want, but general rules say that babyfaces do not interfere like the Usos did. Thats something villains do especially if the bad guys dont do it first. It seems like WWE is trying to make Roman Reigns into a tweener champion, which is really tough to pull off. Steve Austin was wildly successful, both on camera and in being a draw and a sale for the company. Reigns is likely far from that, with fans tuning out rather than tuning in.
WWE needs to pick a character and stick with it. If Roman is turning heel and is going to hold onto the title through any means necessary, then so be it. But if hes going to be protected and allowed to straddle the line, then there are going to be problems down the line.
Ups...
7. Look Of Shock

While the asylum match between Chris Jericho and Dean Ambrose was a yawner, there was one aspect of it that does deserve some kudos, and that came once Ambrose retrieved the bucket and revealed its contents.
When Ambrose started spreading thumbtacks all over the ring, the camera cut to a petrified Jericho who looked like he had seen a ghost. Without missing a beat, he scrambled up the cage and tried to escape, only for Dean to drag him back inside. The two then spent the last couple minutes of the bout avoiding the corner with the tacks, only for Y2J to fall victim and then quickly lose.
Jerichos reaction to discovering the thumbtacks, and his actions after the match as the ref tried to pull a few out of his back, was highly entertaining and were easily the highlights of a pretty disappointing match.
6. Xavier Shoots His Shot

Xavier Woods must have had the night of his life last night: He picked up the pinfall in the Tag Team Championship match, and he got to use the arena as his own personal Match.com dating site. Wanna bet he was swiping right on Tinder later on?
During New Days pre-match promo, Xavier lamented the loss of his time machine (which Big E rightly pointed out was just a decorated refrigerator box) and suggested that the ladies and gentleladies get on Twitter and direct message him some pics or videos to comfort him in his hour of need..
When his teammates got on his case, Woods asked to let me shoot my shot, drawing a surprisingly big chant from the fans. It was a harmless non sequitur, and it also was entertaining. Xavier showed that he still is one of the better guys on the mic when it comes to engaging the audience. And hopefully, the rest of his night went well too.
5. Winning With Authority

Give it up to Byron Saxton for nailing it with his comment during the Usos/Club match when he remarked that we have barely scratched the surface of what Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson can do in the ring. Saxton was on-point in describing what could be termed a coming-out party for the former Bullet Club, as they toppled the Usos in impressive fashion.
The match, contested under tornado tag rules, was a fast-paced, aggressive bout with both teams attaching throughout. But it was Anderson and Gallows who really impressed with how they tore through Jimmy and Jey with an array of kicks, clotheslines and other strikes.
It was exactly the kind of win Gallows and Anderson needed, convincingly beating the Usos and (hopefully) putting the rivalry to bed for now. There was no shenanigans in how they won (aside from Jimmy hitting the ring bell when he jumped off the top rope) and no reason to see yet another iteration of this match for the foreseeable future.
4. Rebuilding Rusev

It took some doing, but WWE finally has managed to make Rusev look dominant again. All it took was having him demolish United States Champion Kalisto and force him to tap out and take his title. Funny how that works.
The Bulgarian Brute clearly has been the best off since the League of Nations disbanded, winning matches and now capturing the U.S. title for the second time. Hes also regained regular use of his valet and fiance, Lana, who had been relegated to backstage segments and a weird feud with Brie Bella before WrestleMania.
In doing so, WWE has begun the process of rebuilding Rusev into a strong heel one who hopefully wont simply be sacrificed to John Cena in a couple weeks. Rusev is very talented and has noticeably gotten himself into even better shape, so heres hoping he fits into WWEs long-term plans.
At the very worst, at least they got the U.S. Championship off Kalisto, who had done next to nothing with it.
3. A Solid Brawl

Kudos have to go to AJ Styles and Roman Reigns for putting on a pretty good match to close out Extreme Rules. Sure, they used every trick in the book, destroying two announce tables, having four men run in, using a steel chair and having several false finishes, but it was a good match overall.
Still, its pretty obvious that WWE was desperate to put Roman over as a killer (something they used to do quite well before they got away from it), and AJ did everything in his power to make Reigns look lethal. All of that succeeded to some extent, though the crowd wasnt particularly buying it (chanting You still suck! after back-dropping AJ through a table).
However, the fans were off when they said Reigns cant wrestle. He put on a good performance Sunday night, and Styles really carried it to a main event level. Its a shame Styles didnt win in some ways, because it wouldve made him, rather than have Roman overcome the odds once again in the hopes that 10% of the fanbase comes around to him.
2. Rollins Returns

Well well, it looks like WWE was capable of pulling off an awesome shocker to end Extreme Rules after all.
Moments after Roman Reigns speared AJ Styles to retain the WWE World Heavyweight Championship in a hectic brawl, former champ Seth Rollins made his shocking return, hitting a Pedigree on Reigns and leaving him laying as fans chanted, Thank you Seth! Just like that, the landscape changed dramatically.
When Rollins vacated the title last fall due to injury, it seemed like he wouldnt sniff the title again for a while, given the low ratings during his reign, but viewership isnt better under Roman, so who knows what WWE is thinking right now.
More importantly, will WWE try to make Rollins a heel to fight Reigns, or finally give in and let Roman be a villain of sorts? Lets face it, fans arent going to boo Seth, so they can keep doing their stupid Roman elicits a strong response! nonsense or finally pay attention.
1. Expectations Exceeded

Holy Hell.
When the fatal fourway was announced for the Intercontinental Championship, fans knew it had the potential to be a classic, but Sami Zayn, Cesaro, Miz and Kevin Owens ran away with the show Sunday night, keeping fans on the edge of their seats if any were foolish and lazy enough to not stand.
Things got started right away with Sami hitting a Helluva Kick on KO and Cesaro uppercutting Miz out of the match, but it really picked up to a frenzied pace in the last third of the bout, when everyone kept hitting huge moves on someone, only to have the pinfall broken up.
For example: Cesaro hit a Neutralizer on Owens for two (Zayn saved); Zayn hit a sunset bomb on Cesaro for two; Samis Helluva Kick was countered with a Cesaro uppercut, then a Zayn Exploder on Cesaro; Helluva was countered with a KO superkick; Pop-Up Powerbomb on Cesaro for two (Miz saved). And all of that happened in maybe a minute.
Forget the outcome (which was the right one). This was an absolutely incredible match. Worth watching again and again.