7 Worst WWE Title Reigns Of 2017

Can we list Jinder twice?

jinder mahal
WWE.com

WWE’s rollcall of champions looks very strong as we close out 2017, although Sunday's Clash of Champions pay-per-view could yet throw a Jinder Mahal-shaped spanner in the works.

The biggest draw in the industry (Brock Lesnar), the best wrestler in the world (AJ Styles) and the face of the company (Roman Reigns) hold the three most prestigious singles titles.

Further down the card, a pair of teams who have produced career-best work this year are deserving RAW and SmackDown Live Tag Team Champions; the Women’s titles adorn the waists of two of the most well-rounded performers on either brand, and Enzo Amore has shown, in his own unique way, that there is life in the Cruiserweight division after Neville.

And, Baron Corbin - well, there could be far worse United States champions. He should probably thank Orlando Jordan for setting that curve.

However, the championship picture has not always looked so rosy throughout the past 12 months - and there are some title reigns that WWE will want to put behind them as we head into 2018.

Unfortunately, we may not be able to forget them as quickly as WWE do...

7. Dean Ambrose - Intercontinental Champion (January 3 - June 4)

Dean Ambrose
WWE.com

‘The Lunatic Fringe’ badly needed The Shield reunion to freshen up his character after an underwhelming first half of 2017, in which he had a laborious Intercontinental title reign.

Ambrose’s rivalry with The Miz started off hot on SmackDown, with the reality aspect of the Renee Young involvement, but that the feud dragged over onto RAW defeated the whole point of the Superstar Shake-Up, when both men were in need of something new.

His WrestleMania programme with Baron Corbin had a decent narrative to it - that Ambrose kept costing ‘The Lone Wolf’ big opportunities. But it was Corbin who shone in the build up, memorably using a forklift to kayfabe squash the champion during a backstage attack - and the wrong man went over in an average bout that was bumped to the pre-show.

The mediocre match quality and cheesy humour on the microphone made this the worst run of Ambrose’s main roster career, and would not have inspired much confidence in WWE management that he can return to the top of the card.

At least, not as a babyface.


6. Bray Wyatt - WWE Champion (February 12 - April 2)

Bray Wyatt WWE Champion
WWE

After years of building up Bray Wyatt only to knock him down, it appeared as though creative were finally ready to pull the trigger on him as a monster heel when he won the WWE Championship at the Elimination Chamber pay-per-view in February.

However, ‘The Eater of Worlds’ dropped the title to 2017 Royal Rumbler winner Randy Orton 49 days later at WrestleMania, and has since rediscovered his losing streak on RAW.

The long build to his clash with Orton flirted with excellence, but the match was full of terribly-conceived projection theatrics. It killed Wyatt’s momentum in its tracks.

This World Title reign, which sadly yet conceivably could be the only of Wyatt’s career, would rank lower on this list, had ‘The New Face of Fear’ not beaten AJ Styles and John Cena cleanly to both capture and defend the gold in very good matches, before all of the absurdity.


5. American Alpha - SmackDown Tag Team Champions (December 27, 2016 - March 21, 2017)

american alpha
WWE.com

American Alpha were expected to dominate the doubles division on SmackDown upon being drafted from NXT, especially after they were crowned champions in December.

Taking the straps off Randy Orton and Luke Harper was a big rub for Chad Gable and Jason Jordan, but it soon became clear that the title change was only designed to precipitate the Wyatt Family split, rather than create a platform for the decorated collegiate wrestlers.

It was through no fault of their own that American Alpha’s reign failed to meet expectations. The SmackDown Tag Team Champions were rarely on television in the months after their triumph, and were reduced to a series of lazy multi-team matches upon their return.

They quietly dropped the titles to The Usos before WrestleMania, and had almost been written off as a team by the time they lost to The Shining Stars on SmackDown in April, which was a pity - because it would have been awesome to watch them tackle Jimmy and Jey, as well as The New Day, throughout a special summer of tag action on the Blue Brand.


4. Naomi - SmackDown Women’s Champion (April 2 - August 20)

Naomi, SmackDown Women's Champion
WWE.com

Naomi deserved another shot with the SmackDown Women’s Championship after her first reign was ended nine days in by a knee injury - but she failed to make the most of it.

Her initial coronation at the Elimination Chamber pay-per-view in February got the ‘you deserve it’ treatment following years of under-appreciated and exciting ring work, but her second, after a Six Pack Challenge squeezed onto a packed WrestleMania card, fell flat.

The former Funkadactyl carried the belt from 'Mania to SummerSlam, but only had one pay-per-view defence during that time - an awful singles match with Lana at Money In the Bank.

It was seen as a surprise when Naomi dropped the title to Natalya in August, but WWE had nothing for her, and needed to shift the belt to a heel to set up Charlotte’s eventual triumph.

This reign should not deter WWE from putting the belt on Naomi again, but creative need to have better plans in place to allow her to shine as an entertaining fighting champion. She is not an Alexa Bliss, who can carry a feud on the microphone; Naomi needs a dance partner.

And no, we're not talking about Cameron.


3. Randy Orton - WWE Champion (April 2 - May 21)

Randy Orton
WWE.com

This was Randy Orton’s ninth WWE championship reign, and one nobody wanted to see.

Luckily for them...?

The Viper is as smooth as ever in the ring, but his return to the top of the mountain at WrestleMania brought an early end to what should have been a long tenure for Bray Wyatt.

As Wyatt’s acolyte, Orton had found a much more interesting role than the bland babyface who would dethrone ‘The Eater of Worlds’. Considering the long build that they gave it, this feud should have worked - but WWE pulled the split six months earlier than they should have.

As discussed in Wyatt’s own entry on this list, their WrestleMania match was little more than cheap parlour tricks, and their non-title House of Horrors bout was equally unwatchable.

The silver lining we were promised from Orton’s victory was a dream match against AJ Styles, but instead, he dropped the title to Jinder Mahal at Backlash, after only 49 days.


2. Bayley - RAW Women’s Champion (February 13 - April 30)

Bayley WrestleMania 33
WWE.com

Bayley’s first main roster title win was poorly executed from start to finish.

The former NXT favourite was seemingly being lined up to beat Charlotte Flair’s undefeated pay-per-view streak at WrestleMania before she dethroned ’The Queen’ in a RAW title win completely overshadowed by the famous, fabulous Festival of Friendship segment.

This victory came on the back of clean and comprehensive defeats to Flair and Nia Jax, and did not do anywhere near as much for Bayley as a WrestleMania coronation would have. The ending of Flair’s well-documented streak would also have carried far greater weight on ‘The Grandest Stage of Them All’, rather than the throwaway show that Fastlane was.

Sometimes the simplest idea is the best idea, and WWE shot itself in the foot here by needlessly overcomplicating Bayley’s rise to the top of the RAW Women’s ranks.

What's worse, once Bayley became champion, she was made to publicly question her credentials. Although she held onto the belt through WrestleMania, this made her look incredibly weak when she dropped it to RAW newcomer Alexa Bliss at Payback.


1. Jinder Mahal - WWE Champion (May 21- November 7)

jinder mahal
WWE.com

The Jinder Mahal experiment was a disaster.

When WWE shocked the world by putting their most prestigious championship on a jobber they released in 2014, and re-signed in the same role in July 2016, it was seen as a short-term stunt designed to peak interest in the post-WrestleMania months.

Mahal would go onto hold the WWE title for 170 days, in which SmackDown died a slow death in his hands. His dramatically improved physique could not hide his flaws in the ring. The quality of his title matches were consistently second-rate, and his promos were poor imitations of much better anti-American characters that had come before him.

The biggest crime of the Mahal reign was that WWE sacrificed the most exciting superstar to ever come through NXT - Shinsuke Nakamura - to put this guy over. ‘The Modern Day Maharajah’ beat Nakamura at successive pay-per-views, with the help of the Singh brothers.

Early reports from the recent tour of India suggest that Mahal’s push has made little difference to the company’s position in that market.

So, not only did it contribute to the worst year in the esteemed history of the WWE title, it wasn’t even best for business.


In this post: 
Jinder Mahal
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Sports Journalism graduate. Writer on football, WWE, film and TV. The greatest TV show ever is The West Wing, and the greatest footballer ever is Harry Kane. One of those claims carries greater weight than the other. Disagree? Discuss with me on Twitter @JoeFish08