7 WWE Wrestlers Who Should Return In Superstar Shake-Up

Will any of these be pulled from the hat next week?

neville wwe
WWE.com

For WWE fans, April is the month that keeps on giving. In addition to WrestleMania and the Greatest Royal Rumble event in Saudi Arabia, the company is also staging its annual Superstar Shake-Up next week on Raw and SmackDown.

While nights like these can sometimes disappoint, they almost never fail to arouse some excitement in the build-up. The prospect for marquee stars to switch shows and make acquaintances with fresh opponents is what keeps many of us going through the endless rematches of the previous 12 months.

Here's something else they're great for: unexpected returns. Several major WWE stars over the years have taken their first steps back in the ring on the draft show - a tradition that began back in 2004 when Edge was picked for Raw following more than a year on the shelf.

This time round, there are a whole of host of previously injured or inactive stars who could make their comebacks in the Superstar Shake-Up, and though it's unlikely that they will all be reintroduced on the same night, it's possible that at least one or two will get the go-ahead.

7. Big Cass

Big Cass
WWE.com

Big Cass is one of a few WWE wrestlers who was said to have been declared fit in the run-up to WrestleMania, leading many to suggest that he would either take the role of Braun Strowman's mystery tag team partner or appear in the night's pre-show battle royal.

In the end, he did neither. It seems his return (presuming he is ready) will be a more low-key affair, which is probably appropriate given that his levels of "over" took a massive nosedive mid-last year after he split from Enzo.

Coming back as one of the supplementary draft picks for SmackDown and then fighting no-name jobbers for a few weeks as he rebuilds his reputation seems like a far more likely path to take than, say, attacking one of the world champions on night one.

That said, there is definitely some potential there, and getting stuck into the mid-card over on Tuesday nights hasn't done the likes of Jinder Mahal and Bobby Roode too much harm (though it hasn't massively helped them, either). He should be right at home in this kind of company.


6. Big Show

Big Show
WWE.com

Last month, Big Show reminded everyone on Twitter that he hasn't formally retired just yet. The fact that you need to remind people of that probably isn't a great sign, but we're not going to say that to his face.

He's still very much an active member of the WWE roster, basically, and has even been scheduled to compete in the Greatest Royal Rumble later this month (a match which he will, naturally, be the odds-on favourite to win).

Since sharing a brand with Braun Strowman hasn't really done him too many favours - the latter is basically a younger and more mobile version of him - you fancy there's a good chance his long-term future lies over on Tuesday nights instead.

Nobody's saying he's going to play a large part on either show, of course, but they're keeping him around for a reason: he's a big live event attraction, he obviously has a great deal of wisdom to impart backstage, and beating a 500-pounder looks great on the resume of any young up-and-comer.


5. Neville

Neville WWE
WWE.com

Neville's name has been appearing in lists like these for the last six months, mainly because there is constantly talk of the Brit staging showdown talks with WWE management over a possible return to the ring.

At this precise moment, granted, there isn't a huge amount of noise, but that needn't necessarily rule out the possibility of an appearance this week on Raw. The sheer fact that he is still technically on the company's books is evidence that hope isn't totally lost.

Should The Man That Gravity Forgot return, there can be no question about which brand would be a better fit. SmackDown has historically been far kinder to mid-card talents looking to punch above their weight - and he would even have a fellow Brit in the role of GM.

Just thinking about potential matches with the likes of Shinsuke Nakamura and Daniel Bryan is enough to get you excited, but - again - it's probably better that we exercise some caution here. There's only an outside chance this will come true.


4. Drew McIntyre

Drew McIntyre NXT
WWE

It seems inevitable that Drew McIntyre is headed for the main roster once he returns to the ring. He's already worn the NXT Championship, and - this being his second WWE stint - it's not as though he needs more time to acclimatise to the company's style either.

The Scot is said to be at last nearing full fitness as well, having featured in many fans' predictions for surprise competitors in the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal at WrestleMania.

He'll be back on our screens by the end of the month, in all likelihood, and the Superstar Shake-Up next week is the natural place to reintroduce him to the fold, billed as one of the top free agent picks for whichever brand that pulls him out the hat.

To answer the burning question: Raw, for all its pitfalls, is possibly the better destination in this instance. The Miz taking a break from the ring means that there is now a vacancy in its midcard, and McIntyre would be able to put on some super work with the likes of Seth Rollins and (should he remain there himself) Finn Bálor.


3. Alicia Fox

Alicia Fox
WWE.com

If you think the main roster arrivals of Asuka and Ronda Rousey have been bad news for wrestlers like Becky Lynch, then spare a thought for poor Alicia Fox. Barely anyone has even realised she's currently nursing a tailbone injury.

It's been nearly three months since Fox was taken off TV, and although WWE didn't disclose a firm timescale for her recovery at the time, you have to assume she's approaching full fitness (it's April, after all - everyone comes back in April).

Happily, she's also a prime candidate to be switched from Raw to SmackDown. The former, in the shape of Alexa Bliss and whichever one of Bayley and Sasha Banks goes rogue, already has plenty of heels in its female division. By comparison, Paige's show is looking kind of threadbare.

Incidentally, don't forget that Fox was experimenting with that whole "crazy" character at the tail-end of last year as she captained her brand to victory at Survivor Series. She could come back with at least a small amount of momentum, although she'll likely need a big rivalry from the off.


2. Chris Jericho

chris jericho
NJPW

It was confirmed last week that, a couple of months after ending his New Japan jaunt, Chris Jericho is to return to the WWE ring at (or possibly in the build-up to) the Saudi Arabia-hosted Greatest Royal Rumble event on April 27.

With Rusev getting the bump, Y2J's first task is surviving a Casket Match with The Undertaker - which is perhaps the most random bout thrown together by the company's creative team since that time Kofi Kingston got thrown around by Brock Lesnar at Beast in the East.

Presuming he makes it out alive, however, you figure that the Fozzy frontman will need a place to lay his hat afterwards, either as a full-time, on-TV-every-week star or - as is more likely - a part-timer who occasionally swings in when his schedule permits it.

We could well find out his fate at the Superstar Shake-Up on Monday. Jericho's is exactly the sort of name that these drafts tend to throw out, in that it's technically a big one, but switching it from one brand to the other won't leave any immediate hole in the roster.


1. Rey Mysterio

Rey Mysterio
WWE.com

We can probably predict with a degree of certainty that Rey Mysterio will be a full-time member of the WWE roster before the end of 2018. There's just no way the company can hear the reaction he received at the Royal Rumble and not offer him a contract.

If previous reports are to be believed, it was only the fact that he got injured at an indie show shortly after that prevented him playing a marquee role at WrestleMania 34 (although, admittedly, that Cena rumour now looks a little far-fetched).

You imagine Vince McMahon and co. might want to keep Rey fresh for April 27, but a return for the draft show - on live TV - would reach a far bigger audience.

Toss a coin for which brand he ends up on. SmackDown, and a potential showdown with AJ Styles at some point, is incredibly appealing, but it's not as though he'd be short of high quality match-ups over on Monday nights either.


In this post: 
Neville
 
Posted On: 
Contributor