8 Big Concerns Heading Into WWE Hell In A Cell 2017
So much could go wrong on October 9th.
WWE's Hell In A Cell pay-per-view returns this Sunday, October 9th, and while last year's event was a Raw exclusive, 2017's sees some of SmackDown's biggest stars go at it inside the imposing structure.
There are two HIAC matches this year, with The Usos challenging for The New Day's SmackDown Tag Team Championships in the opener, and Shane McMahon fighting Kevin Owens in the main event. These bouts take precedent, but each of the blue brand's singles titles will be contested throughout the night, with Jinder Mahal facing Shinsuke Nakamura, Natalya defending against Charlotte Flair, and Baron Corbin challenging AJ Styles.
The card looks promising on paper, but SmackDown is struggling at the moment. The blue brand's quality has nosedived throughout 2017, and none of these bouts have had a perfect build, particularly the WWE Title match. Hell In A Cell may well succeed, but the company's big PPV have been a regular source of disappointment this year, and SD's consistency issues increase the odds of another major flop.
Let's take a look at every that could go wrong this Sunday, starting with some lower-card quibbles, then working all the way to the top...
8. Prolonging The Inevitable
Shelton Benjamin and Chad Gable will wrestle The Hype Bros on Hell In A Cell's Kickoff Show. It's a match we've already seen on SmackDown a few weeks ago, with Benjamin and Gable's victory spawning from more cracks in Rawley and Ryder's relationship, continuing the "split" teases the two lowly grapplers have been working for months.
It's time to move on. The story started shortly after Ryder's comeback in June, and was then shelved for a short while, before returning to television in recent weeks. WWE have now sapped as much life from these teases as they're going, so while this bout will unfold on the under-watched pre-show, it's the perfect place to pull the trigger.
There's no point in persisting with an angle when so few people are invested in the tag team in the first place. Splitting the duo will give WWE the opportunity to do something with both men, and while Mojo's long-term potential is particularly dubious, a Zack Ryder heel turn could be interesting. Really, though, we'd settle for anything that saves us from the tedium of more will they/won't they moments.
7. Hot-Shotting The Tag Titles
While Shane McMahon vs. Kevin Owens has snatched most of the headlines lately, there hasn't been a better SmackDown feud than The Usos vs. New Day in 2017.
The blue brand's top two tag teams have been on fire. Their PPV bouts are routinely excellent, and their weekly segments are always a highlight on Tuesday nights. Frankly, they could probably wrestle each other every week until the end of the year without fans getting tired of it - that's how strong their work has been.
They'll probably knock their Hell In A Cell match out of the park, but there's one big reason to be wary of the bout: the SmackDown Tag Team Championships themselves.
The Usos and New Day have passed the belts back and forth at will since July, trading reigns three times within that timeframe. Hot-shotting works every now and then, but as good as it'd be to see the gold around Jimmy and Jey's waists again, another switch would put a dent in the division's considerable prestige. Booking them to lose is the right decision, with The New Day going on to have a long, prosperous reign.
6. Roode's PPV Debut, Ruined
Dolph Ziggler's current act is awful. Playing on a wrestler's misuse rarely works, and 'The Show-Off' is currently portraying the absolute worst version of the 'overlooked' gimmick, with his ring entrance parodies getting progressively less funny with every passing week. He's nothing more than an airtime thief at the moment, and it's not getting him over.
Dolph faces Bobby Roode at Hell In A Cell, and while this would ideally be a nice, quick, 5-6 minute win for 'The Glorious One,' there's a strong chance WWE will bury it in nonsense.
Ziggler has promised "an entrance you've never seen before" for the PPV, and there's a good chance this means he'll mock Roode's own walk to the ring. Whatever he does, he hasn't nailed a single funny entrance yet, so there's little reason to believe he'll turn the corner at HIAC.
These shenanigans could also seep into the match. Dolph has been focused exclusively on messing around lately, so while him vs. Roode sounds like a solid bout on paper, it'll likely get derailed by Ziggler's antics, wrecking Bobby's first pay-per-view match in the process.
5. Rusev Gets Squashed... Again
Randy Orton and Rusev will go one-on-one for the third time at Hell In A Cell, and with their two previous matches lasting a cumulative total of 20 seconds, there's a chance it could be the shortest bout on the card.
'The Viper's' quick SummerSlam squash of Rusev was a destructive move, and undermined 'The Bulgarian Brute' greatly. Fortunately, Rusev gained a measure of revenge by reversing the outcome a few weeks later on SmackDown, though Randy had just worked a seven-minute match with Aiden English, which kept him protected.
The squashes are likely over, but there's still an outside chance WWE could repeat SummerSlam this Sunday night. This is a terrible idea, and would cement Rusev's status as the most under-utilised and underappreciated wrestler in the company today, but it's definitely something that Vince McMahon would do.
WWE will always find ways to keep Randy Orton in the spotlight, no matter how listless his performances become. He's one of the company's golden geese, and while Orton might be among SmackDown's least inspiring performers at the moment, the promotion may put a bullet in Rusev's skull with another 10-second RKO.
4. Undermining AJ Styles
He's one of the best wrestlers on the planet, but AJ Styles hasn't had a good run as WWE United States Champion. His reign started through some unnecessary hot-shotting with Kevin Owens, then devolved into a platform for KO's feud with Shane McMahon. Styles started working with Baron Corbin (one of SmackDown's dullest performers) shortly after, and the feud has since been expanded to include Tye Dillinger in a peripheral role.
This reign should've turned AJ into SmackDown's workrate king, allowing him to put on fun, exciting bouts against a wide array of different opponents every week. Instead, it has turned into a sloppy, confusing mess, and this could well continue at Hell In A Cell.
Corbin has been written to look like a loser lately, but that doesn't mean a victory is out of the question, particularly in the land of 50/50 booking. Him walking away victorious would render Styles' reign a massive missed opportunity. It'll also mean extending this dull feud until at least the next pay-per-view, which is something nobody should be hoping for at the moment, particularly after the last few weeks.
3. Jinder's Turgid Reign Continues
Jinder Mahal's reign of error as WWE Champion is fast approaching its 140th day. Among others, 'The Modern Day Maharaja' has now topped The Undertaker, The Rock, Ric Flair, and Kurt Angle's longest runs with the belt, and there are strong suggestions that he could hold the title into 2018, with his reign potentially stretching as far as WrestleMania 34.
WWE are hell-bent on swimming against the tide with Mahal. Despite no clear evidence that his reign has achieved its goal of spiking business in India, they continue to poison SmackDown's main event scene by maintaining his position as the figurehead. He'll face Shinsuke Nakamura on Sunday, and the likeliest outcome is a win for Jinder, extending his run through another PPV arc.
The duo's previous encounter was Nakamura's worst match since joining WWE in 2016, and there's little chance their rematch will be any better. This is small-fry compared to the long-term consequences of Jinder winning, though. SmackDown is crying out for a WWE Champion the fans are invested in and actually want to root for after the torment of Bray Wyatt, Randy Orton, and Mahal's reigns, and Nakamura losing would only compound the division's status as WWE's most skippable scene.
2. Super Shane Conquers All
The Shane McMahon vs. Kevin Owens feud has picked up steam after a bad start, but this week's SmackDown delivered a few worrying signs.
KO destroyed the Commissioner by the fans' concession area. He crushed his boss with powerbomb through a merch table, which should've put him out of action, but didn't. Owens came down to the ring to cut a gloating promo, and out stumbled Shane, who then proceeded to fire back into action with his best Superman routine.
He was overcome in the end, but McMahon was still able to leap from the barrier, then pepper Kevin with some of his trademark terrible strikes, proving once more that his family will always be the most protected people in WWE.
We already know that Shane's probably going to do something crazy inside Hell In A Cell, but what if he wins? What if he survives KO's onslaught, pulls off one of his death-defying stunts, and actually scores a pinfall over the former Universal Champion? The outcome doesn't bare thinking about, and there's no justification for a part-time executive to go over a brute like Owens, but there's every chance it'll happen, particularly after what transpired on SmackDown.
1. The PG Problem
While WWE's PG rating has been a clear net positive for the company as a whole, its detrimental effect on shows like Hell In A Cell can't be denied. PG's restrictions have completely destroyed the danger and violence that formed the stipulation's appeal in the first place, reducing bouts like last year's match between Rusev and Roman Reigns to 'Mild Peril In A Cell.'
WWE are promising something they can't deliver on Sunday night. These matches won't be "hell," but standard one-on-one contests within the needless confines of a big steel structure, with a potential Shane McMahon dive the only notable exception. They'll be watered down, diluted, and homogenised, and while The Usos vs. New Day will still rule regardless, there'll be an element of disappointment regardless.
The company are better off without "extreme" stipulations in 2017, as they simply can't live up to the standards set in previous eras. Their obsession with gimmick pay-per-views means they'll never abandon them, though. WWE's identity crisis will continue, and while nobody's calling for a return to the days of Mankind's needlessly dangerous war with The Undertaker, these bouts will continue to leave the audience frustrated.