8 Big Concerns Raised By WWE's Injury Crisis

The grimmest prognosis.

dean ambrose injury
WWE.com

Former WWE Divas Champion Paige was dealt a cruel hand this weekend, with her employers reportedly 'medically disqualifying' her from in-ring competition following her latest neck injury.

Her wrestling career is effectively over, at least as far as WWE are concerned, but while her case is easily the most severe, Paige isn't the company's only long-term absentee. Big Cass, Jef Hardy, Samoa Joe, Drew McIntyre: there's a strong chance none will be back before WrestleMania 34. Dean Ambrose, meanwhile, isn't expected to return until September, and we may have seen the last of the injured Big Show, whose contract expires in February.

With 16 signed wrestlers on the sidelines, WWE are currently in the midst of a full-blown injury crisis. Most will recover, but Raw is particularly short-handed at the moment, and it feels like a new name joins the wounded every single week.

Wrestling is inherently dangerous, and some injuries are to be expected, but not to such an extent. How did this deep-rooted problem arise, what does it say about the company, and what steps can WWE possibly take to further similar build-ups in the medical room? Let's have a look...

8. An Ageing Roster

Big Show Retirement
WWE.com

Much was made of WWE's ageing roster ahead of Survivor Series 2017, and rightly so. At 34 years old, Braun Strowman was the youngest performer in the night's main event, with Triple H and Kurt Angle the oldest (48). Throw both teams together and you have an average age of 40, once again highlighting the company's youth problem.

Half of the main roster wrestlers currently sidelined with injury are over the age of 35, with only Paige and Noam Dar under 30. Granted, older bodies are more susceptible to wear and tear, but these numbers only heighten the concerns surrounding their roster composition.

The ageless AJ Styles is an obvious exception, but WWE shouldn't have to rely on 40-year-olds anymore. It's clear that the company have no idea how to best utilise a roster crammed with exciting young talent. If they did, then they wouldn't have to put guys like Big Show in positions where their battle-scarred bodies could get hurt, as was the case in seven-footer's steel cage war with Strowman.

This is a colossal problem, and one that directly impacts almost every aspect of the product. Sadly, a solution doesn't seem to be forthcoming.


7. WWE's "Safe" Working Style

AJ Styles Clash Of Champions
WWE.com

WWE's in-ring restrictions are legion.

Piledrivers, apron brainbusters, back drop drivers, and other gratuitous head-drops are banned, as are risky top-rope moves like the Shooting Star Press (unless you're Shane McMahon, apparently). Blading? Absolutely not. Unprotected chairshots? Get out of here.

All of these things were outlawed in the name of safety, and it's hard to argue with WWE's stance. There's absolutely no need for performers to take such risks on mainstream television, and while matches often feel diluted, conforming to a PG-friendly style has been an objective financial success for the company.

... but is it actually working? WWE's injury problems suggests that no, it isn't.

We're not arguing for a switch to a stiffer, more impactful philosophy, but something's got to give. This company's injury list rarely drops below double figures. 'Soft' it may be, but the WWE style still hurts dozens of performers each year, and while some can be written off as freak accidents, it's impossible to apply that argument to this many individual cases.

WWE's intentions are noble, but it's tough to say they've been effective when so many performers are sidelined at once, though it's hard to see how they could possibly tone it down further.


6. The Brutal Road Schedule

John Cena Live Event
WWE.com

Success in WWE comes at a cost. No other company can match their mainstream exposure and financial clout, but the lifestyle is often described as a brutal, relentless grind. Not only are wrestlers expected to work four or five times a week, but jet themselves from city to city in the process, leaving little time for rest and recovery.

This takes an obvious physical and mental toll. The schedule has shortened countless careers over the years, with many wrestlers citing it as a major problem, but WWE show no signs of easing off. The company held a total of 280 shows in 2016. We're still awaiting year-end reports, but they were projecting 300+ at the start of 2017. This is nuts, and while the roster split eases things somewhat, WWE are pushing their wrestlers to breaking point.

Stylistic changes don't mean a thing with such a ruthless schedule, as no matter how 'easy' wrestlers take things at untelevised events, their bodies aren't given a chance to recover. Such is life in the world's biggest wrestling promotion, where refusing to 'work through the pain' is considered an affront.


5. The Pursuit Of Star Ratings

Cesaro Mania XXX
WWE.com

Pro-wrestling working standards are through the roof in 2018, which is great for the fans, but hard on the wrestlers.

Having a 'solid' match is no longer enough. With genuinely excellent bouts happening all around the world every single week, 'good-to-great' is the new norm, and anything that doesn't hit that level is considered a disappointment. Star ratings are a divisive subject, but several wrestlers have revealed they now actively seek Dave Meltzer's seal of approval, amplifying the pressure to go all-out, which itself amplifies the danger.

There's no metric to point to to prove the hypothesis that the workrate revolution has worsened the injury crisis, but it makes sense. If wrestlers are more drawn towards critical acclaim in 2018, then of course they're going to push their limits, despite what it could potentially mean for their bodies.

Jason Jordan has been busting his ass for months, resulting in a long series of fantastic TV matches with the likes of Roman Reigns, Cesaro, and Samoa Joe. Now, he's sidelined with an undisclosed injury, and may be kept out of the ring for sometime. Was it worth it? Perhaps in the moment, but wear and tear is eternal.


4. More Forced Retirements?

daniel bryan retirement
WWE.com

That Daniel Bryan will eventually wrestle again is a given. Whether it's for WWE or a competitor, the SmackDown General Manager is hell-bent on returning to the squared circle, despite his February 2016 retirement. The extent of his concussion issues make it a divisive issue, but for better or worse, the wheels are already in motion, and we'll likely see Bryan lace up in 2018.

It's a murky situation made worse by the fact that Bryan's 'retirement' wasn't his decision, but the company's. Though several other medical professionals cleared him to compete, WWE's did not, and it's unlikely they'll ever give him the 'okay' again.

A similar scenario came together this past weekend. Neither WWE nor Paige have confirmed it yet, but it looks like the former Divas Champion has been medically disqualified from wrestling for the company following an injury suffered on a December 28th house show. A huge shame, particularly in the aftermath of the hellish 18 months Paige has endured.

As WWE's injury problems deepen, are situations like this about to become more commonplace? Will this company, often so negligent when it comes to protecting their performers in other ways, start taking less chances with high-risk cases like those above? Time will tell, but it's a possibility.


3. Nowhere To Hide

samoa joe roman reigns
WWE.com

While it'd be ridiculous to hold Japan's notoriously stiff wrestling style as a bastion of safety (Mitsuharu Misawa literally wrestled himself to death in 2009; Katsuyori Shibata came within a hair of doing the same eight years later), WWE could learn much from the way puroresu promotions structure their cards, particularly when it comes to match composition.

The average NJPW card comprises largely of multi-man tags. Though not as exciting as blockbuster singles bouts, they're a great way of protecting from wear and tear. Part of the reason Hiroshi Tanahashi remains such a thrilling performer at 41 years old is because he's able to hide in such contests during PPV builds, only tagging in to pop the crowd. Every NJPW singles star does the same, because it helps them preserve their bodies for bigger matches, ensuring they're ready to go all-out come pay-per-view time.

In contract, the average Raw, SmackDown, or house show is comprised largely of singles and regular tags. Performers are in the ring for longer, meaning their chances of getting hurt are far higher. Booking more multi-mans would be a tremendous way of alleviating the strain, and while we don't want to see WWE undercards become a crowded mush, protecting the wrestlers must take precedent.


2. The Growing Backlash

Sasha Banks
WWE.com

There's a growing tendency among wrestling fans to point the finger as soon as somebody gets injured. When Paige's 'medical disqualification' was announced, Sasha Banks, whose kick hurt the former Divas Champion in the first place, faced torrents of venom and bile. The same thing happened to Seth Rollins when Sting and Finn Balor were injured while working him, with even Bret Hart calling out 'The Kinglsayer's' apparent sloppiness.

This has got to stop.

Perhaps there were certain things that Rollins and Banks could have done differently, but there needs to be an acceptance that wrestling is an inherently dangerous sport, and neither were malicious. Freak accidents happen. It sucks, but it's the truth, and there's absolutely nothing to gain from demonisation.

Though social media has benefited wrestling in a number of ways, it has hurt it in others, with this being one of them. It has become far, far to easy to jump on a toxic bandwagon and make wrestlers feel worse about something they're probably already wracked with guilt over. All injuries are upsetting, but the situation becomes worse when we create a villain, so why bother?


1. Is There Even A Solution?

Drew McIntyre Biceps Injury NXT
WWE

And so we reach this: the scariest point of all. Anyone can analyse the causes of WWE's injury epidemic, but unfortunately, there's no quickfire solution to any of these problems.

Easing the ageing roster would require rebuilding WWE's broken star-making machine - something they've been trying to do for years. Further in-ring restrictions would render the company's already watered-down style unwatchable. Live events accounted for $144.4 million in revenue last year, and reducing the schedule would put a dent in that. An increase in multi-man tags, meanwhile, would necessitate a complete revamp of WWE's booking practices, and may turn fans away from the product.

Nobody likes seeing wrestlers get hurt, but facts are facts, and every available solution flies in the face of how WWE do business. Tragically, it may take a Katsuyori Shibata-esque catastrophe to force them into taking action. We sincerely hope it doesn't come to this, as WWE have shown an admirable dedication to cleaning up their product since the Chris Benoit tragedy, but there's your precedent.

For now, we can only hope that the company's wounded return to the ring fit, healthy, and at the height of their powers, with few others joining them in the treatment room.


In this post: 
dean ambrose
 
Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.