8 Biggest Turncoats In WWE History

These guys take "good and evil are just subjective" to a whole other level.

The Big Show
WWE.com

Morality is a fickle thing, or at least it is in WWE. Given that its storytelling is rooted in broad strokes and pantomime, the switch of a character’s moral alignment from good to evil or vice versa is usually obvious and very sudden. Face and heel turns are a core component of storytelling in WWE, and many characters made their big break by turning to the dark side or through seeing the light.

Likewise, there have been many characters who are famous for staying on one side of the fence for protracted periods of time. John Cena being a face who refuses to turn heel has basically been his character for a decade. Likewise, wrestlers such as Kevin Owens and Bray Wyatt are likely to be heels for life, as everything about their look, style, and demeanor lend themselves to the side of "baddie for life."

However, this list looks at the folks who are... shall we say, less hesitant when it comes to switching their allegiances. Some would say they have a revolving door moralities. They are the famous turncoats of WWE.

8. Edge

Edge Elimination Chamber World Heavyweight Championship
WWE

Edge is low on this list because despite turning face and heel many times in his career, he made most of his impact during his heel run from 2004 to 2009, becoming both the 'Rated-R Superstar' and the 'Ultimate Opportunist', racking up several world titles in the process. Still, the guy has had a hard time deciding if he’s a baddie or not. Debuting in 1998 as an edgy (haha, get it) loner, Mrs. Copeland’s baby boy was portrayed as a face, teaming with mega faces such as Sable. Soon, however, The Brood came to television, and recruited Edge as part of their evil vampire cult, with Edge tagging with Christian.

Once that dissolved, Edge and Christian spent a cup of coffee as just good-looking young guys before finding their characters as annoying, offensive dorks. However, when they split as a team in 2001, Edge was just a whitemeat babyface for a number of years before finally becoming the horrible, calculating knob we all love.

When he was injured in 2009 and came back as a shock Royal Rumble winner in 2010, fans were willing to accept Edge as a face. He ended up triumphant in his feud with Chris Jericho, but upon being drafted to RAW, Edge became a baddie again, attacking his friend Christian. But months later, he was turned face by attacking the anonymous RAW GM (i.e. smashing a computer) and being traded to SmackDown, and he remained a face until his retirement, even siding with Christian once again.


7. Triple H

Batista Triple H
WWE

Most people know Triple H as one of the greatest heels of the modern era, and that reputation is justified. However, looking at 'The Game's history, it’s clear he’s not above flip-flopping on his alignment.

Debuting in 1995, Hunter Hearst Helmsley was a heel, through and through. Though his character eventually evolved from a Connecticut aristocrat to an edgy teen who joked about his penis, he still made it his mission to be as utterly hateable as possible.

Still, by 1998, when Triple H became the leader of D-Generation X, fans were so smitten with the group’s raunchy antics, they were turned face by default in their feud against the Nation of Domination. DX remained one of the most over face acts throughout ‘98 and ‘99 until Triple H’s turn at WrestleMania XV, when he joined Vince McMahon’s corporation.

While briefly flirting with the light as a tweener in 2000, Hunter remained one of the company’s top heels until 2001, when an injury took him out for months. He returned in 2002 as a face, won the world title, and then months later, turned on his buddy Shawn Michaels, becoming once-again the top heel in the company. Then, in 2006, thanks to a reunited DX, Helmsley turned face once-again and remained as such for a baffling seven years, before finally returning to his destined role of evil mastermind at SummerSlam 2013.

If 'The Game' were Dungeons and Dragons, Hunter would drive his dungeon master crazy with how noncommittal he is to alignments.


6. Kurt Angle

Kurt Angle
WWE.com

Kurt Angle is one of those cases where he’s naturally disposed to being a villain, but at the same time, we can’t help but cheer for him. While he found his calling as a dopey, delusional heel, the man’s genuine integrity and unparalleled wrestling ability made him someone the fans could get behind in a heartbeat.

Debuting in 1999 as a geeky, self-righteous jerk, Angle eventually found himself in a face role when opposing the Steve Austin-led Alliance. Angle worked well in this role, but he soon found himself back into his tried-and-true role as a scummy heel, though this time, with a bit more of a tough-guy edge to him. Eventually, he took time off for injury, and became a universally-beloved badass. By 2004, however, he turned his coat once more to evil, and began doing naughty things such as attack Marty Jannetty and sexually assault Booker T’s wife. In early 2006, he re-emerged on SmackDown as a face, won the World Heavyweight Championship, and was the face “wrestling machine” until his departure in the summer.

Angle has returned to the company as a face, but don’t be surprised if you see him deck his son Jason Jordan in the face and once-again become his destined role of heel.


5. Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho Return
WWE.com

Chris Jericho is one of the few performers in WWE history who can say he has been equally as good as a heel or a face. True, while most of his main event success has come as a heel, it’s safe to say that Y2J’s charisma, range, and ability to tap into the zeitgeist has made him an effective character with both alignments.

Debuting in 1999 as an obnoxious heel, Y2J soon endeared himself to the audience and became the classic Ayatollah of Rock-'n'-Rolla. He would then turn heel, face, and then heel again by 2005, shifting between cocky and cool to cocky and delusional. By the time he left the company after putting over John Cena, he was a sniveling sycophant to Eric Bischoff.

When returning in 2007, Jericho took on a grizzled veteran variation of Y2J, but this time around, it only kept him mired in the midcard. Jericho found rejuvenation in 2008 when he turned heel on Shawn Michaels, and invented the now time-honored trope of wearing a suit and cutting morose promos to signify that you’re a bad guy.

Jericho eventually turned face in 2012, and while he lacked direction for a few years, found his footing once again as an eccentric, list-making heel, which got him so over, that now, he’s a babyface, and will likely get a huge hero’s welcome when he eventually returns to the company for another run.


4. Randy Orton

Randy Orton WWE World Heavyweight Champion
WWE

There’s a certain rhythm when it comes to Randy Orton’s heel and face turns. It’s what you would call “The Circle of Orton,” and it’s a beautiful process.

First, Randy is a bored, unmotivated worker, and the fans don’t care about him, and that indifference turns to dislike. Then, that dislike is channeled into a heel turn, and suddenly, Randy becomes very motivated, putting on excellent matches with cool spots. The people are now behind him. Then he’s turned face due to being so well-liked, but after a brief honeymoon, WWE realizes they have no idea what to do with him as a face, and he’s placed in filler feuds. Randy loses his motivation, which means his matches become worse, and the fans stop caring about him, which means the cycle begins anew.

It’s because of this cycle that Randy, despite most of his great work coming as a heel, has seen his fair share of face runs. He debuted in WWE as a bland babyface before becoming a smarmy heel and joining Evolution. Once he was kicked out of the group, his smarm was turned into blandness, with him becoming a listless face. He then became a cocky, vicious heel in 2005 and remained as such until 2010, where he became a face once more, and the Cycle Of Orton truly began. Since then, he’s been in a semi-regular revolving door of morality, with him currently at the stage of the cycle where he’s a face whom nobody cares about.


3. The Bella Twins

10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About The Bella Twins
WWE

Being the faces of WWE's reality TV output, the Bellas have been two of the most prominent women in the company. As such, it really spoke to how little WWE cared for Divas given how shoddy the Bellas’ characterizations were, especially when it came to their morality.

Written with a distinct “Oh, who cares?” philosophy, Brie and Nikki just sort of drifted between face and heel whenever it was convenient. Usually, if Total Divas was about to air a new season, that meant the Bellas were to be portrayed as heroic, since after all, it’s prudent to have your stars be, y’know, likeable. Otherwise, however, the Bellas were portrayed as snotty heels, which fit their strengths as performers. However, the way they would transition from heel to face and vice versa was so wishy-washy and nonsensical. Despite being the top heels in the Divas division for months in 2015, the two were randomly the faces in a month-long feud with Naomi and Tamina, and by June, Brie and Nikki were once again the top heels. What sense does that make?

Even more confusing was Nikki and Brie’s relationship. Sometimes, they managed rival wrestlers, oftentimes they were a tag team, and other times, they were feuding over very silly things. In 2014, Nikki turned on Brie and told her that she had wished Brie died in the womb... and then, by the end of the year, they were a tightly-functioning unit with zero explanation of why Brie forgave Nikki. Love conquers all, I guess.


2. Kane

Kane Royal Rumble 2001
WWE.com

Kane’s status as a moral flip-flopper is somewhat more justified than the others on this list. While many of his turns were less organic than others, you could always say that his unclear allegiances fit his mysterious character. Kane is the quintessential chaotic neutral: a wild, unpredictable creature whose whims are fleeting and ever-changing. His status as a monster made it easy for him to play either side of the fence in the Attitude era. One minute, he could be the big evil monster for The Undertaker to slay, and the next, he could be by ‘Taker’s side trying to destroy everything in their path.

Really, where Kane’s morality became a problem was when the writers tried to humanize him. From taking off his mask to revealing his personal history to giving him love interests, the veneer of chaos and mystery shrouding Kane was removed. He wasn’t an unhinged, unpredictable monster, but rather, a confusing, boring giant who gave the fans no reason to care what side of the fence he was residing on.

WWE would realize this at times, however, and have occasionally hit the reset button with the character, making him once-again an unhinged monster with unclear motives... but then, they end up abandoning that. Most famously this occurred in 2012, when Kane started off the year as a re-masked arbiter of evil and destruction, and by summer, he was in comedic therapy sketches with Daniel Bryan.

Kane is indeed a flip-flopper, which makes him a perfect political candidate.


1. Big Show

Big Show Crying
WWE.com

Ah yes, the King of Turns. The man who has been both a face and a heel so many times, at this point, the two are just separate characters. The epitome of WWE assuming fans have short attention spans, Big Show is just plopped into the face or heel role willy-nilly whenever the writers don’t have better ideas. Is the Big Show a gentle giant who stands up for the little guy, or is he a big, mean ogre who imposes his will on all those weaker than him? I don’t think Big Show could answer that question, as he seems just as confused as we are.

Since Show’s debut in 1999 for WWE as a heel, the company have had him flip-flop with seeming regularity. People have counted up to 23 distinct times Show has made the switch from heel to face or vice versa, and I bet you’d find lists that count more.

It's honestly hurt Big Show a great degree. While it’s true many wrestlers are capable of seamlessly transitioning from face to heel multiple times (see Chris Jericho), the way the Giant has been so carelessly and frequently tossed between alignments made it difficult for people to take him seriously during his prime. Nowadays, with him being a face since early 2016, fans have steadily become more accepting of him and his character, which is a shame, because he's likely to retire soon.

Whatever legacy Big Show leaves behind, he’ll always have the distinction of being WWE’s biggest turncoat.


In this post: 
The Big Show
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A mystery wrapped in an enigma wrapped in bacon wrapped in wrestling listicles wrapped in tin foil wrapped in seaweed wrapped in gak.