8 Epic Wrestling Matches That Would Be Better If They Happened Now
This calls for a rematch!
Rematches have always been an important part of pro wrestling. When a bout draws major money, the first thing on any promoter's mind is how the wrestlers involved can face off again and hopefully draw even more. It is a business, after all.
Unfortunately, sometimes a rematch just doesn't live up to the first contest. A few major examples jump to mind - such as the second encounter between John Cena and The Rock, for instance. While a less-than-stellar rematch doesn't really taint the power of the original bout, it does stand as a disappointing corollary.
By contrast, a great rematch of a good contest makes for a stellar feud, and when an improved match follows a disappointing bout, the wrestlers involved get a chance to show how much they've grown or what they can do under different circumstances.
Some contests don't get rematches - which is a shame. There are plenty of times where two wrestlers could easily outdo their previous match (or matches) with one another if they were only given the chance. Again, they've improved over time, or storylines have changed, or fans take the talent more seriously after a while.
If these matches happened again in today's circumstances, they'd probably eclipse their forebears.
8. The Miz Vs. John Cena
WrestleMania XXVII - and more specifically, the Miz-John Cena main event - is often derided, and for good reason. The entire show was one of the worst 'Manias in recent memory, and the top match was an utterly forgettable throwaway designed only to build up interest in a Cena-Rock match the following year.
Still, fans of Cena and Miz had higher expectations - Cena almost always delivers in big matches, while Miz had improved greatly over the previous couple of years. Something just didn't click, though, and it was made worse by the fact that Miz suffered a concussion during the bout. Miz's career really took a tumble after that match, but during his 2016 renaissance, fans wondered if another Cena bout could be far off.
They ended up clashing at WrestleMania 33, but in a mixed tag team match also featuring Maryse and Nikki Bella. That bout was more angle than contest, though, and the four-star Cena-Miz match that fans of both men are still looking to see has yet to materialize. Now that Cena is spending more time in Hollywood than Stamford, it seems the opportunity may have sadly passed.
7. Jeff Hardy Vs. Matt Hardy
The Hardy Boyz may have had success as a tag team and as singles wrestlers, but when it's been time for them to feud with each other, the results have usually underwhelmed. A brief program following Matt teasing a heel turn in 2001 went nowhere, and when Matt did turn on Jeff in 2009, their bouts weren't anything special.
The exception to the rule came in TNA, when Jeff "broke" Matt by beating him in a match, resulting in Matt's new character and "The Final Deletion." After years, Matt had finally found a character that made him the more talked about of The Hardyz, and when Jeff joined his Broken Family, his career was similarly refreshed.
Unfortunately, TNA in 2016 was far from wrestling's grandest stage. The pair returned to WWE in 2017 as a tandem, but their ultimate dissolution came as a result of injury, not enmity. Matt's career came perilously close to ending last summer, but now he's back in action, the company seem content to maximise one last nostalgia run, with the Boyz better together than apart.
6. Braun Strowman Vs. Sami Zayn
When Braun Strowman first made his WWE debut in 2015, it was clear he was in over his head. Fans scoffed as the giant seemed lost in the ring, and it was obvious to all that he only had his spot because of his size. That was all true, but it was also worth mentioning that he had less than a dozen matches to his name.
When Strowman was split off on his own in 2016, he got the chance to improve, and improve he did. His first feud was against Sami Zayn, and when Zayn lasted 10 minutes in a match with him at Roadblock: End of the Line, that technically counted as a defeat for Strowman. Still, for all who saw how far he had come, it was clearly a victory.
Strowman went from strength to strength following his early tutelage under Zayn, but has since seen his momentum utterly flatline thanks to months of indecisive, inappropriate booking. Perhaps going full circle by targeting Sami Zayn, fresh but fragile from injury, would be just the tonic needed to reset the Monster Amongst Men?
5. Samoa Joe Vs. Jay Lethal
Most of the matches on this list could happen fairly easily, given that in those examples, the competitors mentioned are currently working for the same promotion. That's not the case here - Samoa Joe is a star on SmackDown, while Jay Lethal is the MVP of Ring of Honor. Still, it doesn't make this bout any less tantalizing.
Joe and Lethal first crossed paths in ROH, where Joe was the resident bad-ass and Lethal was a young up-and-comer. When Joe joined TNA, Lethal soon made an appearance to take him on, but the bout was little more than a glorified squash match. Lethal would end up joining TNA full time, and despite his poor usage, he had some great matches - among them, some bouts with Joe.
Still, over the past few years, Lethal has really come into his own as the franchise of Ring of Honor - the longest reigning TV Champion ever and a World Champion for over a year. It would be amazing, hypothetically, to see Joe return to ROH for an evening to face the man who holds the position he once did. Unfortunately, we shouldn't hold our breaths - it's purely fantasy booking.
4. Drew McIntyre Vs. Kofi Kingston
The focal point of Kofi Kingston's WrestleMania 35 angle is that he has been one of the most underrated workers on WWE's roster for a decade, and part of being underrated means putting over stars who don't deserve it. Such was the case in 2010, when Kingston feuded with Intercontinental Champion Drew McIntyre.
At the time, McIntyre was a star with the look and little else, but it was enough for Vince McMahon to declare him a future WWE Champion on TV. He was pushed hard and given the IC title, then placed into a feud with Kingston, who did his best to make him look good. Still, it was clear that McIntyre wasn't ready, and by 2011, his push faded. He soon got a reputation as damaged goods, and despite quietly improving, he was released in 2014.
McIntyre hit the indies and quickly salvaged his reputation, winning titles in TNA, EVOLVE, and WCPW en route to becoming one of the most talked-about wrestlers outside WWE. He's now a big - if not quite top line - player on Raw, just waiting to be heated up again. If Kofi succeeds in his title tilt this April, a Superstar Shakeup could very realistically produce a rematch against Drew as his first challenger.
3. Neville Vs. Seth Rollins
One of the best TV matches of 2015 came when new WWE Champion Seth Rollins issued an open challenge to anyone... provided they were under 6'0" and 200 pounds. It was Neville who answered the challenge, and despite his place on the card, he took the champion to the limit.
Fans loved the match, especially one false finish where Neville hit the Red Arrow and seemed to have pinned Rollins, only for the referee to point out that "The Architect" had gotten his foot on the rope. Ultimately, of course, Rollins was victorious, retaining his championship in yet another one of his great performances that year.
Since then, Rollins has withstood a mid-career slump to establish himself as WWE's workhorse, rewarded with a WrestleMania tie opposite Brock Lesnar. Neville's arc with the company on the other hand, has been a much more dismal story. Frozen out of his contract after growing unhappy with languishing in the Cruiserweight division, the Geordie finally left in 2018, and is now set to star in AEW. Never say never of course, but for now, this rematch is off the table.
2. AJ Styles Vs. Kurt Angle
AJ Styles and Kurt Angle have probably had more matches against one another than any other combination of wrestlers on the list. Angle's signing in 2006 was the biggest feat TNA ever pulled off, and even though his first feud was against Samoa Joe, it was inevitable that he and Styles - TNA's ace - would eventually face off.
They ended up wrestling several times over the years - sometimes Angle was the face and Styles was the heel, and sometimes it was the other way around. From 2007 to 2013, they battled in 38 one-on-one matches.
As good as AJ Styles was in TNA, though, he was even better in New Japan. Once he headed to NJPW, he proved that he was the greatest wrestler in the world and rewrote his legacy. While he hasn't always been able to put on the same kinds of matches in WWE, the opportunities he's gotten have shown that he hasn't lost a step.
Unfortunately, this one seems impossible now. Angle has just one more WWE match left in him - and it's unlikely to be opposite Styles, whose tentatively penned in for Randy Orton come WrestleMania 35.
1. Brock Lesnar Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura
Many wrestling fans who follow WWE exclusively would be stunned to hear that Brock Lesnar and Shinsuke Nakamura already faced each other one on one. Those same fans would probably be even more shocked to find out that the match was pretty bad.
Lesnar and Nakamura met on 4 January 2006, colliding in the main event of Toukon Shidou Chapter 1 for Lesnar's IWGP Heavyweight Championship. The bout was nine minutes long, which means it was actually longer than Lesnar's usual Universal title defences (though far less explosive), but still quite short for a typical main event. The styles clash managed to be both awkward and boring, with Lesnar hitting clubbing blows and Nakamura trying to grab submissions.
Today, the match would be much different. Nakamura would try to be as explosive with his strikes as Lesnar is with his suplexes, and no matter who won, the contest would be a thrill ride. That's no secret to Nakamura, who said upon his signing with WWE that he wanted another chance to have a classic battle with 'The Beast'. Sadly, he looks about as far away from the Universal Title picture right now than at any stage since joining the company.