8 Match Star Ratings For AEW Revolution

AEW fills the pro wrestling-shaped hole in North American pro wrestling.

Jon Moxley
allelitewrestling.com

AEW had built Revolution with a streak of near-perfect episodic television.

Cody Vs. MJF, a classic beloved babyface versus sociopathic heel dynamic, peaked like damn Everest with its heart-wrenching - and life-affirming - major segments. It's sort of unreal; these people love Cody and they despise MJF, ardently and earnestly. The Elite Explodes saga stood in wonderful contrast to it. This is a different, untapped breed of wrestling storytelling; every character has a legitimate grievance tempered - but perhaps not saved - by an enduring brotherhood. It is nuanced, intelligent business that moves bravely away from binary machismo and has generated real, emotive anxiety. Chris Jericho Vs. Jon Moxley, and yes this does need to be pointed out, is precisely why WWE should entrust its talent with their own creative input. This epic saga intersected comedy and violence superbly.

Jack Swagger Vs. Goldust was an excellent prospect (!) better built than anything WWE managed with Jake Hager for nine years. Darby Allin Vs. Sammy Guevara was as inventive as hell: initiated with a classic injury angle, but built with artistic short films. This is the perfect illustration of AEW's ability to create stars, and the perfect riposte to gotten-to hAHa aEW iS MAin EvENted BY WwE guYS! takes.

All the while, AEW engineered an even grander anticipation by threading several compelling story beats across a storm of in-ring classics on Dynamite. AEW Revolution was the best-built pay-per-view in decades, much less years.

Did Revolution live up to this level of hype?

8. BUY-IN: SCU Vs. The Dark Order

Revolution Dark Order
AEW

Brawling with fire early, consistent with the storyline, this was fought with a real intensity by Kazarian in the early going.

All dangerous suplexes and impactful high spots, it was an inspired choice for the Buy-In - remember the ultra-sh*tty comedy? - because it was compact, well-worked, and obscured the tentative-at-best interest in the Dark Order through a crowd fired-up for a major show, if not a major match.

But as ever, much of the excellent work was undermined by the amateurish presentation of the Dark Order. They transitioned into the heat very well, in such a way that it didn't frame Kazarian as a moron, but the reaction to the Creepers' attack sounded like a put-off drone, and not legit heat - a not ideal atmosphered intensified by chants of "spooky perverts!" during the heat. This audience, as high as hell on a white-hot fan-servicing product, continues to banter off the concept.

That heat spot dragged - and again, it probably wouldn't feel that way, if the reaction to the act was loud or earnest - but Kazarian's acrobatic tag-in was fabulous in its ingenuity, and Scorpio Sky's explosive hot tag looked typically crisp and physical.

It was a familiar story - the Dark Order's tandem work was convoluted but coherent, and when the wrestlers bled through the act, it bordered on awesome - but the Exalted One reveal needs to manifest itself as one hell of a chapter to make it worth reading.

Star Rating: ★★★


7. Jake Hager Vs. Dustin Rhodes

Dustin Rhodes Jake Hager
AEW

This match divided opinion - many thought it shouldn't have opened - but it needed to open. It might have died altogether in any other spot because the enthusiastic crowd and their profound love of Dustin Rhodes carried it.

The hot, logical start - Dustin Rhodes in badass babyface vengeance mode targeted Jake Hager's arm - simmered down when Hager took control in a match that had a certain generic WWE main roster vibe about it. This punishing arm work didn't factor into much else, either, which on any other night would have marred it. But this Chicago crowd adored Dustin, which elevated the match as much as the man himself did. He sold for Hager brilliantly, but in a match designed to get Hager over as a killer, this did not succeed in its remit.

Aspects of his work looked very good - a vaulting lariat crashed into Dustin's neck, and it looked brutal - but elsewhere, Dustin barely looked in grave danger in the face of this built-up MMA killer. It dragged, wasn't dynamic, and Hager didn't do enough to project himself as a specialist capable of tapping Rhodes in an instant.

AEW somehow conspired to make Goldust Vs. Jack Swagger something to look forward to in 2020, and Goldust Vs. Jack Swagger is what we got. We didn't get a new, motivated, legitimised Jake Hager.

The most gentlemanly of...

Star Rating: ★★★


6. Darby Allin Vs. Sammy Guevara

Sammy Guevara Darby Allin
AEW

A blistering, hate-fuelled, über-dangerous sprint, this was an awesome maximise-your-minutes match that reflected how both men arrived at it.

They weren't given time - possibly as a result of Guevara's bothersome ankle - but they made astonishing use of it, as they had on Dynamite to get themselves over as the two breakthrough stars of a competitive midcard.

Reviewing a show so soon after viewing it often results in recency bias, but Darby Allin definitely hit the greatest suicide dive of all time to kickstart a scorching sequence fought before the bell rang. He botched the follow-up, but it didn't matter; it felt in-character, and Sammy threw a skateboard in his face immediately afterwards, anyway. The match benefitted from it. Sammy capitalised by - Jesus Christ - smashing Allin through a table with a 630 senton.

When the match formally started, Allin kicked out of the resulting pin attempt to fight from underneath, as Guevara creatively targeted his injured throat in a match that intersected the spot-fest and the story. Allin secured the win in blinding, turnabout-is-fair-play fashion by monkey flipping Guevara neck-first into the exposed turnbuckle. Clever, faithful work germane to the story that was so exciting some will claim otherwise. It can be both.

This was.

This f*cked.

Star Rating: ★★★★


5. Kenny Omega & Hangman Page Vs. The Young Bucks - World Tag Team Championship Match

Revolution Hangman
AEW

One of the greatest tag team matches in the history of professional wrestling, this was a storytelling masterpiece with boundless layers and a thick, agonising atmosphere worked with an electric poignancy and thrilling energy that escalated and escalated and escalated and escalated and f*cking escalated to an unforgettable conclusion.

Kenny Omega protested Hangman Page's snug, nasty offence early. He wanted to wrestle a gentleman's contest with his best friends. This was echoed by Nick Jackson, but Page and Matt Jackson could not and would not adhere to the code. Page spat in his face. Matt roared through his injured back to work an overt heel role that was still so admirable that the molten Chicago fans could not bring themselves to truly hate him. Conflict pervaded everything: the heart of the audience, the work, even the teams.

Late in the match, Hangman Page struck the One-Winged Angel. Just days earlier, to vanquish PAC, Omega did not borrow from Page's arsenal. He used former partner Kota Ibushi's Kamigoye. This exceptional narrative masterclass, told - congruously - through jaw-dropping, state-of-the-art in-ring content, built several matches within a match and a match beyond itself.

The Bucks attempted to put Omega away with the Golden Trigger, and in an absolutely transcendent moment, Omega kicked out at one, incensed at the disrespect shown...to his old partner. Again, he showed far more love to Kota Ibushi than his current teammate. This subtext doubled as an exhilarating sequence that didn't require prior knowledge to get over as a moment of all-time pro wrestling drama.

The Elite have pioneered, perfected and now transcended a new mode of pro wrestling narrative enriched by unsurpassed detail. To use a video game analogy, it can be enjoyed equally between beginner and expert mode.

This was the best wrestling match of 2020.

Star Rating: ★★★★★


4. Nyla Rose Vs. Kris Statlander - Women's Championship Match

Nyla Rose Kris Statlander
AEW

A misfire that bordered on an insult salvaged, just, by two determined women who deserved better.

Nothing could follow the World Tag Team Championship match, so of course the women were made to. This had a depressing air of obligation to it that of course bred an apathetic atmosphere. If AEW positioned this in such a way that felt careless, why should the fans have cared?

Really, this dynamic was failed as soon as the match graphic was made. The appeal of this monster mash should have lay in its parity. It should have followed a spree in which Nyla had killed, over a prolonged period, all manner of smaller babyface opponents before being confronted, at last, with somebody her own size. Then what?

How would she adapt, or measure up?

That was the hook of Nyla Rose Vs. Kris Statlander. That was the drama, but with no such story told - nor any story - they had to orchestrate their own from an impossible position.

After a slow and sluggish start, bereft of heat, they almost succeeded. They exchanged bombs that would have detonated big, in an alternate timeline, and Statlander's counter to Nyla's deadly flying knee-drop was creative, in-character brilliance.

They weren't totally blameless - the finish was rough in places - but they did more than enough to shame the promotion.

Star Rating: ★★¾


3. Cody Vs. MJF

MJF Cody
AEW/Fite TV

Cody Vs. MJF was a captivating and mostly very heated match that lulled at times, incorporated a million interesting ideas that threatened to betray the core thrust of the story, and delivered a finish that verged on repetitive and anticlimactic. Had coach Arn Anderson not studied MJF's recent match with Jungle Boy?

As uneven as a hell of a match gets, to put it succinctly.

MJF was tremendous value early - his nasty, hilarious stalling ramped up the heat that Downstait's shoddy live performance cooled off - and his heat segment while spotty was intelligent, charismatic and effective. He drew booming "You sick f*ck!" chants by biting on Cody's injured toe, which was a fantastic touch, but his arm work wasn't as effective. Excalibur tried his best, but MJF hadn't been built as a submission expert. The all-important plight and suspense elements weren't there in the middle phase. In general, a match of that length, with those stakes, felt maybe - maybe - beyond his level of experience.

In the best moment, one that put MJF over as the most evil heel in the company, even the referee allowed Cody one strap of the belt. This was a fantastic touch that highlighted the scope of the character's treachery.

This was far more entertaining than it was intense and hate-fuelled. The tone was electric, if perhaps off. When it soared, it reached its awesome potential. Cody's Great Muta tribute was ace, his use of strategic distraction informed a spot that furthered his aura as a classic, whip-smart babyface, and MJF's crying fit at the finish was committed, earned, and most importantly, fuel for the stipped-up rematch.

The resulting net effect was that of a successful first act on a pay-per-view that didn't require a euphoric resolution in this programme. Not yet.

Star Rating: ★★★¾

Extra quarter of a star without the neck tat.

Genuinely.


2. PAC Vs. Orange Cassidy

Orange Cassidy PAC
AEW

A superbly-worked match that the crowd went apesh*t over, this was just fantastic.

It didn't just follow the Orange Cassidy formula - he f*cks around, heel gets pissed, f*cks him up, unlikely comeback - it told that story in such an interesting and powerful way.

Cassidy didn't f*ck around for too long to lean too heavily into comedy. In virtually every AEW Cassidy appearance thus far, the man has grazed the calves of the heel to draw the lunging strike, which he ducks. But PAC, a master, protected himself. He didn't put up with it; he grabbed Cassidy's hands immediately, but Cassidy put him on his ass after a standing switch. This pissed PAC off. They earned the hell out of the usual transition, and the deafening pop, with classic babyface versus heel psychology veiled in that intoxicating irony.

This initiated an inspired sequence in which PAC played along with the Superkick before shoving Cassidy out of his soul. Cassidy used his dormant athleticism to run rings around PAC, and the Bastard's work was as creative as this next-gen pioneer. When he kicked out of a DDT in an exhilarating sequence, he shoved Cassidy out of it at 1.5, fuelled not by instinct nor adrenaline but fury in the face of this chancer.

A technically awesome, pulsating, hilarious, dramatic match that blurred the face/heel dynamic as effectively as that seminal tag, in its own way, this triumph was as fun as it was life-affirming.

This was so outrageously great that it turned Jim Ross around; he bemoaned Cassidy wearing his shades at the opening bell, but popped his t*ts off when he taunted PAC with his beaming smile.

Star Rating: ★★★★¼


1. Chris Jericho Vs. Jon Moxley - World Championship Match

Jon Moxley AEW World Champion
AEW/Fite TV

Jon Moxley captured the AEW World Championship from a fiendishly difficult position in both storyline and in reality.

That crowd had witnessed an all-timer of a match, stage one in the hottest feud of the year, and received a new hero into their exhausted hearts. Moxley and Chris Jericho could not compete with the athleticism and emotion elsewhere. They had to work their asses off to get this grand occasion over with a masterfully-crafted story, and they did, with both shortcuts and substance.

They brawled early to set a violent, proper main event-level tone and to engage the crowd. Moxley's bump through the timekeeper's table was gnarly, and because these men are professional, seasoned masters, they subverted a legitimate complaint to get their sh*t in when that sh*t was required to get the match over. Jericho tried to kill Moxley in a blatant attempt to get disqualified. Aubrey Edwards recognised this and refused to fall for it, in a story beat that deftly allowed for smoke, mirrors and brutality.

In a match worked around Moxley's injured eye, he fought through wave upon wave of Inner Circle attacks, one of which was caught and dealt with by Aubrey to restore her legitimacy.

This story got Moxley over as the true World Champion of AEW. He could not be denied. He was too gutsy, too tough, too good of a pro wrestler - his Liontamer reversals were done excellently - and ultimately, too clever. He revealed the ruse by ducking the Judas Effect, removing the eyepatch, and nailing Le Champion (sniff RIP) with the Paradigm Shift. This was a lesson in how to strap a babyface.

In Jon Moxley, AEW have built a total hoot of a badass who looks totally unbeatable and as hard as bastard nails without it feeling forced, inevitable or boring.

Star Rating: ★★★★


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!