8 Mistakes WWE Have Already Made With Jason Jordan's Push
From American Alpha to anti-climax and antagonism.
Jason Jordan has often been referred to as an underutilised player since his arrival on WWE's main roster. Before it happened, if you had informed the fanbase that Jordan was on the verge of receiving a significant push, you would mostly have been met with positive reactions, so it might be to the bewilderment of some that his elevation has been so poorly received.
Pushes are delicate things to handle. Countless Vince McMahon experiments have fallen by the wayside, never escaping the midcard (or lower) despite clear care and attention from those running the show. Billy Gunn's exit from the main event scene was as quick as his ascent. Jinder Mahal is mostly only tolerated as champion due to frustration and ironic, detached enjoyment. Baron Corbin has been supposedly the next big thing on SmackDown for months, but he hasn't won a singles PPV match in 2017.
Attempting to push Jordan by revealing him as Kurt Angle's secret illegitimate son was a bold move, to say the least. It's a storyline that feels out of touch with modern sensibilities, but given his popularity and widely acknowledged untapped potential, it could equally be seen that any vehicle designed to get him over is a welcome one.
Given the lukewarm reaction he's received so far, it's clear to see that there's already been a whole host of issues with how WWE have attempted to boost Jordan's standing in the company.
8. Pushing Him As A Singles Wrestler
Jason Jordan had been making televised appearances on NXT for nearly three years before the formation of American Alpha and their eventual breakout success. Jordan might have many of the most desirable tools looked for in a professional grappler, but despite his talents, Jordan teaming with Chad Gable was vital to any popularity that he managed to achieve.
The excellence of both men's combined in-ring work was more than the sum of their parts, and the two gelled together in a way that served to highlight their skills and elevate their standings with the fans.
Cutting Jordan off from his partner both weakens his appeal and reduces how impressive he can look in the ring. Much of American Alpha's playbook consisted of tandem manoeuvres, so the recognisable aspects of his moveset have instantly been cut in half by the split.
Additionally, it's easier to frame the imposing-looking Jordan as a figure of sympathy when he's working with a smaller, more natural underdog like Gable. Now that he's no longer the hot tag who charges in to rescue his partner from peril, even if he's performing the same moves, the change in context makes him seem much less heroic.
7. New Theme Music
Altering Jason Jordan's theme music now that he's a singles competitor is only a small change, and a logical one at that. But it speaks volumes about the overall issues with his push.
Jordan has abandoned the rousing theme music of American Alpha, a move that even more clearly separates him from his former tag team. Chad Gable, however, has kept the same music and Titantron, allowing him to maintain that affiliation to the past glories the team achieved together.
However, Jason Jordan's new music is incredibly similar to the American Alpha theme, still composed of blaring brass and hyped-up horns. So while ditching his prior theme music instructs the WWE universe not to associate Jordan with his former tag team, the nearly identical display fails to make Jordan feel distinctive or important on his own merits.
This is symptomatic of the overall presentation that is damaging Jordan's push. He's supposedly a new man, but not in any way that makes you care for him. The WWE Universe are subtly told in this one move that Jordan is not the man you've grown to love, but fundamentally hasn't evolved or changed into somebody else either.
6. Treating The Storyline Seriously
Although it's been instantly panned by a large portion of the audience, this 'Kurt Angle's illegitimate son' storyline isn't necessarily all that ridiculous, at least within the confines of pro wrestling.
In the current WWE landscape, we have literal Fashion Police, a manic movie producer who covers himself in gold paint, and two different wrestlers who antagonise their opponents through singing insults about the city they're in. Hell, we're less than four months removed from The House Of Horrors. By comparison, this angle looks downright sensible.
Being this po-faced and serious about it, however, is still a mistake. It's soap opera material but still lacking a sense of drama, so the silliness of the material is unavoidable. Embracing the ridiculous aspects or at least trying to find some humour in the angle would make it a much more endearing story, but alas, WWE seem committed on treating this with total sincerity.
Look at the tedious, unremarkable interview given by Angle and Jordan shortly after the reveal - somehow utterly devoid of charm or a single memorable moment. Angle's a funny guy, and a sense of self-awareness or at least levity in this storyline would do wonders to increase the audience's investment in both Jordan and his future role in WWE.
5. Acknowledging The Boos
Jason Jordan walking out to a few boos wasn't the end of the world - Roman Reigns gets nuclear heat, and even Bayley now receives the occasional jeers from the crowd, so he wasn't looking in too bad a shape, relatively speaking.
The real error was Jordan so openly addressing them. The negative reactions were quiet enough that WWE could have got away with ignoring them, but instead they chose to make their entire audience aware that the storyline was being negatively received, without offering anything as a substantial counter argument.
"They're gonna boo, they're gonna cheer, they're gonna do whatever they want, and that's cool". That doesn't make Jordan sound like an open-minded guy who supports the fans, it makes him sound apathetic and uncaring towards what the fans think, which is hardly an endearing trait.
Subsequently insulting The Miz for getting more boos was just straight-up nonsensical, as Jordan had stated mere moments ago that getting booed didn't bother him. You can't insult a man on the same charges you just defended yourself against. Besides, it was just a really lame insult.
4. Squashing A Local Jobber
Toronto wrestling crowds are primarily known for two things - their local pride and being smarks. It was pure foolishness, then, to have Jordan come out and dismantle a local wrestler in front of a heated Toronto crowd, and the vocal reactions are evidence enough.
The poor jobber looks like the biggest underdog in the world in this position for facing off against an established superstar - one that's in the midst of an incredibly transparent push, no less. This puts the jobber in a position that more naturally endears him to the crowd and thus turns them away from Jordan, his opponent. There's a reason that it's normally heels who face off against random enhancement talent.
This is an effect that is especially compounded by having this jobber be a local boy, further aligning the crowd towards him and not Jordan. Commentary then calling it a "Rocky Balboa moment" for Jean-Pierre Goulet further frames Jordan as the antagonist in this situation.
Despite the impressive performance Jordan gave in the squash, beating a nobody does little to enhance his credibility, and defeating an underdog in his home town is absolutely not how you get someone over as a lovable babyface.
3. Putting Him Opposite The Miz
The Miz is possibly the best heel in the whole company right now, so it makes a certain kind of sense to immediately position your rising babyface opposite him.
The issue is, however, that The Miz is capable of cutting absolutely lethal promos, especially when honing in on the flaws of his opponents, so letting him take an open swing at Jordan was a grave error if the company's priority is putting Jordan over with the WWE Universe.
Jason Jordan is not particularly famed for his talking abilities, and he seemed powerless to meaningfully counter any accusations of nepotism or to match The Miz's eminent confidence on the microphone. Jordan was given incredibly generic scripted comebacks and naked appeals to the crowd, which really don't work when pitted against the passionate delivery and inventive promos that The Miz has become especially known for over the past year.
If Jason Jordan is to become a major player on Raw, then he'll need to be able to hold his own in segments like this, but throwing him right in at the deep end was a poor decision, and he most certainly looked out of his depth.
2. Immediate Intercontinental Title Contention
As a singles wrestler, Jordan hasn't had a chance to showcase much personality yet. Ideally, his first feud should have been a highly personal one, in tandem with these highly personal revelations about his lineage. Having him wrestle an Angle-hating heel just to defend his Dad could be an endearing storyline.
Instead, immediately shoving him into the Intercontinental Title picture against The Miz has the dual flaws of failing to establish any sense of personality to Jordan, and that immediately placing him into title contention is just too transparent a push for modern fans to accept.
Title opportunities should always feel like they've been earned, and while nobody is suggesting that Jordan is undeserving or unready to be a midcard champion, this opportunity coming so quickly after the revelation of his parentage is too much too soon.
In kayfabe, it smacks of nepotism. Jordan's tangling with The Miz actually has nothing to do with Kurt Angle, but having him do no wrong just furthers the generic boy scout babyface personality that's currently failing to do anything for him.
Jordan's incredible wrestling ability speaks for itself, so he doesn't need a title shot to build his legitimacy - he needs an interesting, personal feud in order to build the fan investment that he's been lacking on the main roster so far.
1. Not Turning Him Heel
WWE want Jason Jordan to be the new Kurt Angle, this much is clear. He has the moveset, the wrestling background, and the patriotism to make it all happen. But while these might be what brought Angle to the dance, it was his entitlement, arrogance, and brilliant heel tactics that made him a main event figure.
Jordan is in the perfect position to mirror that self-righteous arrogance - claiming his pedigree makes him superior and more deserving than his opposition. He's been handed the biggest opportunity of his lifetime and a clear connection with backstage management - exploiting that and bragging about it only seems natural. He could even adopt Angle's old patronising motto of "Intensity, Integrity, and Intelligence" as he so openly flouts the second of The Three I's.
Both in and out of kayfabe, the most reviled heel in modern WWE is the company's own management, and from both perspectives, Jordan feels like he's receiving preferential treatment. There's no more surefire way to strengthen a wrestler's unpopularity than through this association - it's what got Seth Rollins over as the company's top heel, and the reason why Roman Reigns has entered to thunderous boos for several years. Hopefully, Jason Jordan can experience a similar level of success - he just needs to start playing against the fans rather than trying to win them over.