8 One-Time WWE Champions Who Deserved A Second Reign

These guys really should have gotten another chance to hold the top strap.

Just how important are World Championships in wrestling? There are a couple of schools of thought regarding this, with some believing that they are merely props in the show and that too much stock shouldn't be put into them. After all, you don't really win championships, you are assigned to win and they are given to you. But you still have to work exceptionally hard to get into a position where you would be considered for a World Title reign (most of the time). The saying 'if you don't want to be World Champion, then you shouldn't be in the company' is a phrase oft-repeated by WWE superstars. This is true, to a point. After all, it is still the top prize, something that most wrestlers dream about attaining one day. Being World Champion signifies your status as being at the top of the industry, the very best in the business and the man whom the product should revolve around. Once you reach that World Championship plateau, the odds of having another two or three reigns are in your favour. Most champions hold the belt multiple times, since there are only a select few wrestlers who can compete at the very top level. Yet some of the industry's most talented performers were only given a single run as World Champion. What went wrong? Did they tank in the role or did some other factor lead to them being recognised as one-time champions? Whatever the case, these eight men deserved another chance to hold the top strap.

8. Booker T

Booker may have been a five time, five time, five time WCW World Heavyweight Champion, but he only held the big gold belt once while on the books in WWE. Newly crowned King (of the ring) Booker rolled over Rey Mysterio at the 2006 Great American Bash in July, capturing his first and only WWE Heavyweight Title. The Houston, Texas native was an absolute riot as the robe-wearing, pinky-waving King Bookah (take notes, Mr. Barrett). One of the best workers on Smackdown and a respected veteran to boot, nobody was complaining when he won the title. He fit the role. Besides, most felt Booker was ready to carry the title in 2003, before Triple H torpedoed his push. Booker held the WWE World Heavyweight Title until the Survivor Series in November, dropping it to Batista (whom Booker infamously fought with for real backstage in May). Booker never really received another shot at the title, drifting into the midcard and feuding with the likes of Kane by the time 2007 rolled around. He would leave the company in October, after failing a second WWE drug test and being suspended for sixty days. Really, considering how great King Booker was during his 2006 reign, he should have been a mainstay in the Heavyweight Title picture.

7. Chris Benoit

Chris Benoit's World Heavyweight Title triumph in the main event of WrestleMania XX at Madison Square Garden was a story book moment that few, least of all Benoit, thought would ever happen. Told for years that he was too small, not charismatic or marketable enough to be on top in WWE, Benoit proved everyone wrong when he made Triple H tap out in the world's most famous arena. Despite being champion, Benoit was never really the focal point of Raw. After retaining the title in the main event of Backlash, the Rabid Wolverine found himself playing second fiddle to The Game's conflicts with Shawn Michaels and Eugene. Benoit's own dispute with The Game was an afterthought, even if the matches were good. If you want an example of how Benoit was booked during his three five month reign, look no further than the Bad Blood PPV: Benoit wrestled in the opener, teaming with Edge against La Resistance, then defended his title against Kane in a midcard match. Triple H and Shawn Michaels, meanwhile, received almost a full hour to have their self-indulgent Hell in a Cell snoozefest. Benoit relinquished the title to Randy Orton in a good match at SummerSlam. At next month's Unforgiven, he was teaming with William Regal to battle Batista and Ric Flair in the PPV opener. Benoit never received another significant shot at the World Heavyweight/WWE Titles, instead becoming a fixture of the United States Championship scene.

6. Mark Henry

Welcome to the Hall of Pain! Who would have thought that Mark Henry would have been a great World Heavyweight Champion? Henry had signed a ten year, $10m contract in 1996. It was hoped/believed that The World's Strongest Man would become a genuine star and be worth the investment. He wasn't. Proving to have little aptitude for the grap game, Henry was so bad that WWE decided to punish him with a series of demeaning gimmicks. When it did try and push him seriously, such as in 2006, it proved to be a mistake: despite his massive size and legitimate athletic accomplishments, fans just didn't take him seriously. WWE had turned him into a midcard. With the WWE roster paper thin in autumn 2011, WWE tried again. Adopting a super-serious, ass kicking attitude, Henry went on the war path and finally looked the dominating force that he should have been for years. Henry won the World Heavyweight Title from Randy Orton at Hell in a Cell. He dropped the belt two months later at TLC, when Daniel Bryan cashed-in his Money in the Bank contract following Henry's match with Big Show. Mizark never got a run with the belt and, now that his career is winding down, it's doubtful that he ever will.

5. JBL

The Texan became WWE Champion almost by accident. With Brock Lesnar leaving to try to make it in the NFL and Kurt Angle and The Big Show out injured, Smackdown were thin on heel headline talent. So they decided to thrust longtime midcarder/tag teamer Bradshaw into the spotlight. It was a real sink-or-swim moment for Bradshaw. Transformed overnight from a beer-drinking, barroom-brawling redneck to a suit-wearing, limo-riding financial wizard, it was a tough change for some to accept. Matters weren't helped much when JBL resorted to racist cheap heat in his feud with WWE Champion Eddie Guerrero. After their first match, an incredible blood bath at Judgement Day, was called to a halt when Eddie was DQ'd, a Texas Bullrope match was set up for The Great American Bash. Astonishingly, JBL won the match and the WWE Title, when Smackdown GM Kurt Angle reversed the decision. Those in the arena, online and in the wrestling press were stunned. How could this man, who had for the longest time been associated with mediocrity, be the WWE Champion? Then, something even more surprising happened: JBL got good. A true heel, he would only ever escape by the skin of his teeth. He was dynamite doing promos and angles, too. JBL had a long, 280 day reign. Eventually, he dropped it to John Cena at WrestleMania 21. JBL got a couple of tile matches over the next couple of years, sure, but WWE didn't put the belt on him again. Which is a shame, because JBL proved he was a worthy champ during his 2004-05 reign.

4. Shawn Michaels

OK, so Michaels is technically a four-time WWE Champion, having won the WWE Title one in 1996, twice in 1997 and the World Heavyweight Title once in 2002. But it is the 2002-2010 period of his career, the post-back surgery, reborn Christian years, that I am going to focus on. When HBK returned to the ring at SummerSlam 2002, it was almost like he had never left. While there were initially concerns about how well Michaels would hold up, he felt fine the days and weeks after his five-star street fight with Triple H. With Michaels physically able and the fans eager to see more of him, WWE booked him in the World Heavyweight Title Elimination Chamber match at Survivor Series. Michaels won the match, sending the MSG crowd into a frenzy. It was an unexpected, feel good moment. Shawn Michaels was WWE Champion again, four years after he'd been forced to retire due to a serious back injury. His moment didn't last for long, however, and he dropped the title back to The Game at Armageddon a month later. The argument has always been that HBK was so good and over on his own, that he didn't really need the title. Plus, he made a great challenger on many occasions (such as his 2007 rivalry with Randy Orton and 2008 conflict with Chris Jericho). Then there was the fact that he only worked a limited schedule, and Vince typically expects the champ to work most/all house shows. Still, considering how much Michaels gave in the ring each and every night, his hard work could and probably should have been rewarded with a more sustained WWE/World Heavyweight Title reign. His 28 days on top don't really seem like enough for this Hall of Famer.

3. Rob Van Dam

Jim Ross would for years refer to Rob Van Dam as 'the best wrestler never to hold the World Heavyweight Championship'. It was a claim that few would disagree with: despite his immense popularity and decent performances, WWE never seemed serious about pushing Mr. Monday Night. Van Dam had a few shots, here and there, but it was usually obvious the company wasn't going to pull the trigger. Then RVD announced that he was cashing in his Money in the Bank contract at ECW One Night Stand 2006, suddenly the odds seemed more in his favour. Indeed, Van Dam won the WWE Title in a breathless match with John Cena. The Hammerstein Ballroom crowd were decidedly pro-RVD, adding to the moment. Paul Heymnan presented Van Dam with the ECW Title, making him a double champion. He was on top of the world. Then he and Sabu were found to have drugs in their car after they were caught speeding by a police officer after a Raw taping. WWE were forced to suspend Van Dam, meaning that he had to drop both titles after only holding them for a few weeks. Okay, so RVD messed up. He did something he shouldn't have been doing and he paid for it. After that, WWE didn't trust Van Dam, and he was kept far away from the title picture, with Vince McMahon going with Big Show, Bobby Lashley and eventually himself as ECW Champions.

2. Ultimate Warrior

The late Ultimate Warrior is another WWE Hall of Famer who surprisingly only held the company's main title the one time. IC Champion Warrior pinned Hulk Hogan in the main event of WrestleMania VI, becoming the first wrestler to hold the IC and WWE Title concurrently. Vince McMahon had hoped that the oddly charismatic, larger-than-life Warrior could take over from Hogan and become the man in WWE. It wasn't to be. Warrior was a disappointment as champ, under-performing at the box-office and not catching on like top officials had thought he would. Warrior dropped the title to Sgt. Slaughter at the 1991 Royal Rumble and segued into a programme with Randy Savage. Returning to the company after a hiatus (well, firing) at WrestleMania XII in 1992, Warrior gave interviews to the media where he said it was only a matter of time before he was made Champion again. That was the plan, but it never happened: Warrior was suspended after it was revealed that he had been experimenting with Human Growth Hormone, which was in contravention with the WWE's drug policy at the time.

1. Eddie Guerrero

Few stories in wrestling are as inspirational as Eddie Guerrero's. After being fired by the WWE due to his drug and alcohol abuse in 2001, Latino Heat rebuilt his reputation on the indies and was re-hired by the company. Becoming one of the most popular wrestlers on the roster, Eddie was deemed ready to hold the company's top prize in February 2004. Eddie, who talked candidly about his substance struggles in promos, overcame the mighty Brock Lesnar in a superlative match at No Way Out. Jumping into the crowd and celebrating with his family, the emotional Eddie had fulfilled a lifelong dream, one he'd thought to be impossible. You couldn't keep the smile from his face. Unfortunately, while Eddie may have been ready to become champion, he wasn't totally ready for what lay ahead. Eddie let the pressure get to him and he began taking things like television ratings and PPV buyrates very personally. He was also exhausted by the main event schedule. Eddie began to crack and WWE decided to take the title off him, for his own good. He dropped the belt to JBL and never really received another crack at it. Impressed by his world-class performances during the year, Eddie was under consideration for another reign at the time of his death in 2005.

Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...