8 Reasons NXT Takeover Was Better Than WWE SummerSlam
Take notes Vince...
With SummerSlam and NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn in the books, which of the two shows came out on top? SummerSlam definitely had its moments with The New Day winning the tag title, Cesaro/Owens, Jon Stewart costing John Cena his title and the controversial ending to Undertaker/Lesnar, but the show as a whole was fairly average. WWE has trouble filling a 3-hour Raw with intriguing entertainment, so how could they do any better with a 4 hour show?
Well, they couldn't.
NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn was a compact ball of energy that rarely let up. From Jushin Liger cracking jokes at Tyler Breeze's expense to The Vaudevillians capturing the tag team titles for the first time, the entire undercard thoroughly entertained.
Even the arena was more interesting to look at; slight changes to the lighting and use of video boards helped make the product "feel" different.
Need more positives? NXT comprises of 100% less Ryback and Big Show, while Balor and Kevin Owens put on a fine ladder match that would have been match of the night had it not been for the absolute classic Sasha Banks and Bayley put on. If you didn't enjoy their match, well, someone should kick steps against your hand and stomp on them for good measure.
Here are 8 reasons why NXT outdid SummerSlam.
8. Opening Match
Jushin "Thunder" Liger vs. Tyler Breeze or Randy Orton vs. Sheamus; which would you pick? On one hand you have two guys who have met 118 times in the WWE and no longer offer anything of interest in their matches. Sure, Sheamus and Orton are solid wrestlers, and can provide a quality spot or two, but honestly it only received a positive reaction from the live crowd because it was the first match. Had they swapped with Cesaro and Owens, that match would have died a very slow death.
NXT was smart enough to bring out their special guest right off the bat and he provided some fun moments; posing like Breeze on the turnbuckle and even using his selfie-stick midway through the match. By bringing in an international legend it made fans feel like they had to tune in. Who knows when Liger will return? It also shows what NXT and Liger think of Breeze to give him this opportunity. He may not be in the main event scene, but his status is very solid within the brand.
7. Fresher Look
The logo and branding of this event was very simplistic using black, white, and grey. These colors helped set the stage for a very different feel than what is expected of a WWE branded show. The bright white ring ropes were an eye-popping contrast to the black mat inside the ring. It was easier on the eyes and allowed for all the colors the wrestlers brought to the ring stand out that much more.
Video boards were heavily used as well throughout the show. They circled the arena, were on every side of the ring, and even on the entrance ramp. Apollo Crews actually stopped and pointed at his logo on the floor exclaiming; "hey, that's me!" Another minor detailed used was darkening the crowd during matches. Usually WWE has the lights on the crowd during matches (sometimes red or blue), but for this show the spotlight was completely on the ring, and it looked great for the home audience.
6. No Ryback Or Big Show
Pretty much no one had any interest in seeing Ryback vs. Big Show vs. The Miz on Sunday. The Intercontinental Title has lost all of its mojo since Daniel Bryan had to drop it due to injury and this match was proof. Ryback has a few goofy chants that live crowds follow along with, but the guy doesn't draw and can't hold an interesting feud or think outside the box in the ring. Big Show is even worse and should have retired years ago. His matches plod along at a snail's pace and they are still sloppy; did you see him roll off the second turnbuckle during the match? Now that was ugly.
The positive of people continuously moving up from NXT allows for new and younger talent to fill the holes. With the WWE's main roster there are some members who are allowed to hang on for just a bit too long which hurts the overall product.
5. Clean Finishes
Every single match had a nice clean finish on NXT. Some fans might consider that boring, but I enjoy booking that is going to commit to a winner and a loser. Being a developmental promotion, the endings don't necessarily need to be controversial.
Take for example Jon Stewart costing John Cena the U.S. and WWE titles. I get why that was done; it got the WWE tons of mainstream press that they always look for, but when you really think about it a 52-year old comedian cost "Super Cena" the match. Needless to say he's been through some wars this year and has been able to win nearly all of them. Then the former "Daily Show" host comes along and suddenly he's Cena's kryptonite.
The same goes for Undertaker and Lesnar, their ending might be good for the over-arching story that's being told, but it was kind of a letdown for that individual show. This weekend, NXT allowed championship to be won or lost on the merits of only the wrestlers and the live crowd showed its appreciation for that.
4. Not Four Hours Long
For SummerSlam, WWE was able to pack in 10 matches which is good for the roster as a whole, but not so much for fans. Just at a basic level, four hours is a long time to watch anything, let along wrestling. NXT's show was about 2 hours and 20 minutes, with very little filler and much better pacing. Yeah, Samoa Joe vs. Baron Corbin wasn't the best match, but Samoa Joe getting the win made up for it in the end.
With SummerSlam easily 3 or 4 matches could have been removed and the show wouldn't have suffered one bit. Sometimes less is more and I found myself more engaged with TakeOver as it was much easier to walk away from SummerSlam.
3. Tag Division Trending Up
To give credit, the Fatal 4-Way Title Match was a lot of fun and seeing The New Day coming out on top was awesome. To counter that was the reaction Blue Pants received to counter Alexa Bliss' evil ways against The Vaudevillians. Speaking of Alexa, she made a huge fan out of me with this storyline of acting way tougher than she should be. If you haven't paid much of attention to her, I'd recommend it as she's becoming a wonderful heel on the NXT roster.
The match between Blake/Murphy and The Vaudevillians was deliciously old-school with plenty of double team moves and distractions. Now that Simon Gotch and Aiden English are champions it helps shake up the divsion a bit. To add to the fun, a "Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic" Tournament is already planned to help determine the next championship match.
On WWE tag teams are almost always an afterthought so if you enjoy them, pay attention to NXT for the next couple months as they should become the focus of their shows.
2. Balor Vs. Owens - NXT Title Ladder Match
Depending on your preferences in a match, this was anywhere from the second to the fourth best match of the entire weekend. Clocking in a 21 minutes and 45 seconds, this match was also given the most time. It's fair to say KO was the workhorse of both shows by putting in just over 36 minutes of in-ring time.
Even though it was the main event with a fairly predictable ending, it was put in a tough spot after that fantastic encounter between Bayley and Sasha Banks. The crowd was so spent that they didn't really give the reactions that this match deserved. Owens knew he had a big match against Cesaro the very next night and still took some major bumps to put Balor over.
A fantastic match that topped nearly everything that SummerSlam had to offer.
1. Bayley Vs. Sasha - A Classic
If you haven't seen this match, go watch it, right now, go!
Forget best WWE women's match of the year, some have said best WWE match of the year, period. To set the stage, Bayley has had multiple attempts at the NXT Women's Title, each time coming up short. She finally got another chance and it's against someone who is the polar opposite of her: Sasha Banks. While Bayley hugs her way to the ring, Sasha gives looks of disgust.
Even before the match began "The Boss" was laughing at how Bayley wore the "Dusty Dots" in a tribute to Dusty Rhodes. The match itself was built at a fantastic pace where fans found themselves incredibly invested with the hopes of Bayley winning that elusive title. With the energy, passion, and some huge top rope spots - including Bayley almost landing on her head - this match could have easily been WrestleMania's main event.
Ultimately, SummerSlam couldn't come close to topping Sasha vs. Bayley and that's why it's the number one reason NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn won last weekend.