8 Reasons Shane McMahon Vs. The Undertaker Just Didn't Work

A one-spot wonder with many flaws.

the undertaker shane mcmahon.jpg
WWE.com

In many ways, it was the most anticipated match of WrestleMania 32. The dearth of star power due to an endless list of injuries necessitated dusting off a sentimental, albeit aged, favorite in Shane McMahon. We'll never forget the deafening cheers he received on February 22, nearly busting the roof off of the Joe Louis Arena.

From there, it was quickly all downhill. While the announcement of a high-stakes WrestleMania match with The Undertaker piqued everyone's senses with the immediate thought of, "That's crazy, how are they going to do that?!", the beams couldn't support the weight, and on a weekly basis, the chips became cracks. From Shane flubbing multiple promos, to his Ralph Parker-esque punches, to the storyline making less and less sense with more time to think about it, the road to WrestleMania was filled with more potholes than there are in all of Canada.

Then there was the match itself. Some fans are hailing it as a masterpiece, largely on the merit of one insane bump that will be in highlight packages for years to come. Others found it dreadfully boring, a heavily-disguised Mr. Pibb rendition of an Attitude Era standard, and that the earlier 'action' didn't justify the stuntman leap.

Here's where the match went off the rails.

8. Where Were Vince, Triple H, And Stephanie?

vince triple stephanie
twitter

So jobs were essentially on the line here. If Shane McMahon somehow felled the Lord of Darkness inside Hell in a Cell, Vince's daughter and son-in-law would wield less power, the very power that they brandish like weaponry every Monday night. In story, we're supposed to think that Triple H and Stephanie would be scared lifeless that Shane would win, and disrupt their malevolently happy lives.

In the parts where Shane had control of the match, where was Vince to send out the cavalry, any WWE midcard geek he could afford to pay off, to run down and cut off Shane's moments of dominance? For a match with high stakes, in which villainous characters stand to lose everything, there were few outside twists. You know, the opposite of Attitude Era showcases.


7. For That Matter, Why Is Nobody Helping Shane?

shane mcmahon.jpg
WWE.com

I get that The Undertaker is on the Mt. Rushmore of most intimidating WWE performers ever with Brock Lesnar, Andre the Giant, and whoever you'd want to put in the fourth spot (it's highly negotiable). I understand that anyone running in, in storyline terms, is doing so at their own risk. I also get that most wrestlers, out of respect, would not necessarily want to be responsible for ending The Undertaker's career as a result of Vince's spiteful decree.

But still, a chance to rid WWE of The Authority should, ostensibly, trump everything. If Shane is the 'agent of change', wouldn't this be the time for John Cena or The Rock to hit the ring and say, "Sorry, Taker, but it's just business," and beat him into dust? Also, Shane's rich: why doesn't he pay off Lesnar to break Taker in half once and for all? He barely broke a sweat with Ambrose, so it wasn't like he was tired. Just glaring holes in character motivation.


6. Shane's Outwrestling The Undertaker

shane mcmahon the undertaker.jpg
WWE.com

I understand that with Shane McMahon matches, you have to suspend more disbelief than you're normally used to. As someone that's sat through a few Air Bud movies, I understand that it can be charming to see an 'outsider' co-opt enough athletic skill to defy the odds in a clutch situation. Sometimes, Shane O'Mac fits that bill.

But against The Undertaker? He's escaping Hell's Gate (which hardly anyone does) and turning it into the sharpshooter (which nobody does). It doesn't help that in this age of evolutionary wrestling, particularly with the NXT call-ups turning the wheel, that a 46-year-old caked in ring rust is going to look positively awkward going through the motions of a 'main event style' match. This is why it'd have been better if somebody interfered for him: to cover for his weaknesses.


5. The Van Terminator Didn't Quite Work

shane mcmahon the undertaker wrestlemania 32.jpg
WWE.com

Part of this falls on the production team, which missed more shots on Sunday than a drunken gunslinger. I will say that it's impressive that a 46-year-old can still criss-cross the ring after balancing slightly on the top rope, and throw a front dropkick. You can't take that away from Shane; it's still an impressive visual.

But after the table elbow from the go-home Raw (where he only grazed 'Taker with his wrist), Shane hits the trash can with a one-footed kick, embedding it into Undertaker's thigh, as opposed to a more impressive strike. The replay even spotlighted that the trash can didn't hit anywhere critical, and ended up a waste of a photographic stunt. If there's not going to be any blood, the spots really need to hit.


4. It Was Hard To Pick A Favorite, As A Fan

undertaker shane mcmahon
WWE Network

Given the stipulations, it was the quintessential, 'damned either way' match. If Undertaker loses, you're saying goodbye to one of the seminal characters in professional wrestling history, but Shane would be able to overthrow the corrupt regime that plagues Raw (in story only; the writing would barely change). So do you root for Shane if you hate what Raw has become, or do you root for Undertaker to keep his illustrious career alive?

Neither man had done anything particularly evil en route to the match, unless you consider standing up to the other with a stiff upper lip to be heinous. Both men were consumed by pride and self-preservation, and you didn't want either to be short-changed. The only 'evil' that needed conquering couldn't bother to make a run in.


3. It Was Slooooooow

shane mcmahon the undertaker cell.jpg
WWE.com

Before you say, "C'mon, Shane's 46 and Undertaker's 51, what did you expect?", I'd counter by saying that they didn't need a half hour. The story itself would be fine receiving an epic length of time, but given the limitations of the performers (especially Shane), giving them thirty minutes to creak their way through a duel was as excessive as it can get.

Would anyone have felt short-changed with fifteen minutes? Whenever there's a match that goes too long, ask yourself if the essential elements could have been satisfied with abbreviation. You could have probably gotten everything in with a match that lasted half as long. In going thirty, Shane's arms were so soaked in sweat, he could have irrigated all of Nebraska just by spinning around in a circle with his arms out.


2. It Was All An Excuse To Build To One Spot

shane mcmahon the undertaker.jpg
WWE.com

Can't make this a whole lot clearer. You knew Shane had to do something out of his mind in order to justify his only match in the past seven years (and what could possibly be his last match ever). You knew he was going to be jumping off something, and with Mick Foley setting the top-of-the-Cell precedent, you knew it was going to be the Cell.

Almost nothing of note happened before Shane began climbing the cage. That's over 25 minutes of Crash TV in slow motion, just so Shane could ascend the cage, throw himself off, and miss Undertaker. Yeah, it looked pretty cool, and it's good that Shane survived with little more than the requisite soreness, but in the end, it just felt like an excuse to ensure a 'WrestleMania moment' as opposed to being completely satisfying. What was accomplished, besides Shane jumping off of something?


1. The Lure Of Change Was Extinguished

the undertaker shane mcmahon.jpg
WWE.com

Shane did get to run Raw for 'reasons' the night after, with Triple H and Stephanie absent, but his rabble-rousing speeches really didn't mean anything. All of that talk about how his family is killing the business he loves for reasons of greed and pettiness (paralleling elements of reality) was to have been paid off with a Shane win. The most excited ones were the fans that could justify Shane rehiring Undertaker to spite Vince.

On a night where so many crowd favorites went down in defeat (Sasha, Ambrose, Styles, Owens, Zayn, New Day), Shane was latest in a hefty string of them, and the crowd showed obvious signs of demoralization afterward. Some theorize that WrestleMania 32 was booked to spite outspoken fans, and given the booking choices, it's hard to argue against.


Contributor
Contributor

Justin has been a wrestling fan since 1989, and has been writing about it since 2009. Since 2014, Justin has been a features writer and interviewer for Fighting Spirit Magazine. Justin also writes for History of Wrestling, and is a contributing author to James Dixon's Titan series.