8 Struggling WWE Stars Who Would Excel In NJPW
A Real American, a Geordie, and an Irishman walk into a dojo...
Vince McMahon’s purchase of WCW in 2001 effectively turned America’s professional wrestling market into a monopoly. There are alternatives, sure, but with TNA barely limping forward on the back of their bang average WWE-lite product and Ring of Honor struggling to truly break through, it seems unthinkable that another company will rise up to match WWE’s might any time soon.
Aside from offering less choice for the viewers, diminished competition means fewer options for the wrestlers themselves. Athletes looking to make a full-time living from in the business had dozens of potential places to work a few decades ago, but only a small handful in 2016.
For many, the answer lies across the Pacific Ocean. NJPW are the world’s second-biggest wrestling company, and their western audience has never been greater. Many predicted the company would falter following AJ Styles and Shinsuke Nakamura’s January departures, but NJPW continue producing some of the planet’s most exciting wrestling shows, and they remain the only option for any worker looking to maintain a top-level career outside of WWE.
WWE’s roster is crammed with under-used and under-appreciated wrestlers who’d be better suited working elsewhere, and a number of them fit the NJPW mould. While NJPW do incorporate some western influences, their product largely eschews contrived sports entertainment concepts in favour of epic matches, hard hitting action and patient long-term storytelling: a stark contrast with WWE.
Here are 8 struggling WWE stars who would excel in NJPW.
8. Andrade Almas
The former La Sombra hasn’t had an easy time of it in WWE.
Once one of Mexico’s most lauded heels, “Cien” has become “just a guy” in NXT, and is grossly unsuited to playing the awkward babyface role he currently occupies. From debuting against the immensely popular Tye Dillinger to the almost offensively stereotypical hispanic entrance music, his NXT career thus far has been a series of missteps, and if recent rumours are to be believed, he may already be looking for a way out.
Reports suggest there’s a heel turn on Almas’ horizon, but it’s hard to predict whether or not this will capture the imagination of the Full Sail crowd, who’ve already lost interest in him. If his struggles with adapting to the American style are as great as the stories suggest, however, he would be a huge boon to NJPW, and a highlight performer in the heavyweight and junior heavyweight divisions.
The evidence? He’s done it before.
While never a full-timer in Japan, Almas was a hugely successful freelancer while under contract with Mexico’s CMLL. He’s a former IWGP Intercontinental Champion, having defeated Shinsuke Nakamura for the strap, and never looked out of his depth while working with The King of Strong Style.
On his day, Andrade is one of the best luchadors on the planet, and he’d benefit immensely from having the WWE reins taken-off.
7. Jack Swagger
SmackDown’s long-term success will partly be determined by the writers’ ability to turn its ailing workers’ careers around. Their attempts at rebuilding Dolph Ziggler as a main eventer fell flat when his SummerSlam WWE Title match with Dean Ambrose was met with wide scale disinterest from the crowd, and Jack Swagger looks to be next on the checklist, albeit at a lower level.
A listless former World Heavyweight Champion, Swagger’s career has declined to the point where it’s tough for most fans to muster a single reason to care about the guy. He’s always been awkward on the microphone, and has largely been used as a Main Event/Superstars-level enhancement talent since his alliance with Zeb Colter disintegrated. WWE’s attempts at rebuilding him against Baron Corbin are noble, but he might be a lost cause at this point.
Swagger was heavily rumoured to be leaving WWE earlier in the year. He’s still around, but if his latest push falls apart, there’s surely a home for him in NJPW. For all his misgivings, Swagger remains a great power wrestler with an incredible amateur base.
Jack lacks charisma on the mic to make it to the top in WWE, but that won’t matter in Japan, where wrestlers are expected to get over almost entirely on workrate. He’d be right at home alongside fellow bruisers Tomohiro Ishii and Michael Elgin, and it’s hard to imagine him not having great matches with veterans like Satoshi Kojima and Yuji Nagata either.
6. Luke Harper
Luke Harper was recently cleared to return to in-ring competition after a lengthy spell on the sidelines. It’s tough to tell what WWE have planned for him at this point, however.
Bray Wyatt and Erick Rowan have continued their affiliation on SmackDown, but Braun Strowman was split from the group in the 2016 Draft, and it’s unclear whether or not WWE intend to push forward with The Wyatt Family as a long-term going concern. Wyatt and Rowans’ split gets teased on a bi-weekly basis, and there’s every chance Bray will cut his henchman loose before long.
Whether operating as a Family member or alone, WWE are yet to find a way to best utilise Harper’s tremendous abilities. Strong, hard-hitting, and shockingly light on his feet, Harper has become one of the best “big men” in the sport. He combines these athletic elements with a strong sense of psychology and expert selling to make him a hugely-compelling in-ring performer for a company that doesn’t always value great wrestling skills, and he’d be a great success in NJPW.
Harper would immediately stand out from the crowd in Japan. His look is unique enough in WWE, but there’s nobody even remotely close to him in NJPW. Moreover, the incredibly limited Bad Luck Fale currently operates as NJPW’s sole monster character, and as menacing as the big Tongan is, he can’t do half of what Harper can in the ring.
5. Sheamus
Sheamus has become an almost poisonous presence in WWE television. Angles like his Money in the Bank 2015 victory and the dead-end League of Nations stable looked to have ran Sheamus’ WWE career in the ground earlier this year, but the decline started a long time ago, and he’s become a wrestler that’s close to impossible to get behind.
The recent “Best of Seven” series with Cesaro has gone some way to reviving his fortunes, but it’s unlikely that Sheamus will ever make a full recovery. That’s a shame, because he’s fantastic in his role as a vicious, bullying brawler, and the quality of the Cesaro matches has had just as much to do with the Irishman as the Swiss Superman. He may have been booked into oblivion, but there’s nothing wrong with Sheamus’ in-ring skillset: he just lacks the ability to captivate an American audience long-term.
Regardless of the series’ conclusion, it’s hard to see where Sheamus goes next. He’s likely doomed to an eternity going round in circles through WWE’s midcard, and if he wants to be something bigger than that, he’ll likely have to leave the company. As with Swagger, his brutish style of wrestling would be more than welcome in NJPW.
Sheamus might be a direct product of WWE developmental, but he’s talented enough to make the necessary adjustments.
4. Neville
Making sense of Neville’s current situation is incredibly difficult. When Raw’s Cruiserweight Division was announced, it was widely assumed that the affable Geordie would play a starring role. His name hasn’t even been mentioned in the same breath as the Cruisers since then, however, and it looked like he was being set up in a tag team with Sami Zayn at SummerSlam, but that alliance has already dissipated.
Simply put, WWE have done nothing with Neville since his return. He’s in dire need of a change of scenery to revive his fortunes, as it’s increasingly unlikely that he’ll get any considerable opportunities to impress on Raw.
New Japan’s junior heavyweights are expected to do much more than flip and dive around the ring. Division stalwart Kushida is one of the world’s best technical wrestlers, and he and his cohorts are expected to supplement their immense athleticism with subtler attributes. This is where Neville comes in: he can do all the spectacular flippy stuff, but he’s an incredibly powerful wrestler capable of deadlifting anyone in his weight class, and his mat game is criminally underrated too.
Neville is as close to a complete junior heavyweight wrestler as you’ll find. His penchant for the spectacular is well-established, but there’s not a style he can’t wrestle, and his well-rounded skillset deserves better than to be rotting away on Raw’s reserve list.
3. Hideo Itami
It almost goes without saying that a world-class Japanese pro-wrestling would be a huge hit with NJPW, but Hideo Itami has never worked for the company. He was a big part of Pro Wrestling Noah’s success at the height of the company’s powers, but as that particular company nosedives towards an all-time low, there’s only one legitimate option for him should he eventually return to Japan.
Itami has endured an awkward transition in NXT. His signing marked the beginning of WWE’s long period of stacking NXT’s deck with hugely talented wrestlers who’d already made their name elsewhere, but Itami has often had a rough time of it. He’s always been popular with the crowd, but his lack of charisma and English fluency are huge stumbling blocks, as is the toned-down wrestling style.
As KENTA, Itami made his name as a nasty, vicious in-ring bully who’d beat the tar out of his opponents without remorse. He looked like he was out to legitimately hurt the competition with his brutal offense, and WWE’s PG style has neutered much of that. Things have improved somewhat since his injury return, and his GTS on Austin Aries and TakeOver: Brooklyn II provoked a huge reaction, but it’s unlikely he’ll ever be able to truly be himself in WWE, regardless of how far he goes.
Itami would immediately be a major star in NJPW. His reputation remains intact following his immense Noah run, and he’d be welcomed back to his homeland with open arms. The likes of Tetsuya Naito and Kenny Omega have stood up to fill the void left by Styles and Nakamura, but there are still a few spots to fill at the top of NJPW’s cards. Itami is an ideal candidate to occupy one of them.
2. Cesaro
Hundreds of thousands of words have been written on Cesaro’s apparent misuse in WWE. The Swiss Superman might be the best technical wrestler in the company today, but he’s unlikely to ever reach the heights his in-ring talents warrant.
Even today, when he’s regularly putting on some of the company’s best matches, Cesaro is hamstrung by a corny ring entrance and the company’s reluctance to give him any promo time. Sure, he’s clumsy on the microphone, but he’s never going to improve if he isn’t given a chance, and his post-Draft shoot-style rant proves Cesaro can deliver the goods when not hampered by a contrived script.
There have been rumblings that Cesaro’s WWE contract is set to expire, and he’s not interested in renewing. There’s a strong chance he’ll had back to the American indy circuit should this happen, but the prospect of Cesaro in NJPW is beyond exciting.
In Japan, Cesaro would be allowed to reach the top on the back of his unparalleled wrestling ability alone. There are very few wrestlers who can match him inside the squared circle, and NJPW is already packed with some of the world’s best technicians and brawlers. Imagine an epic 30-minute affair between Cesaro and IWGP Heavyweight Champion Kazuchika Okada, or a series of breathless G1 Climax bouts with Hiroshi Tanahashi, Katsuyori Shibata, and Tetsuya Naito.
It’d be disappointing to see Cesaro not reach his full potential in WWE, but his NJPW signing would have fans salivating
1. Daniel Bryan
This is comfortably the most difficult situation that Daniel Bryan has found himself in throughout his career. If his concussion history is scary, reports of him suffering seizures away from the ring are downright terrifying. There’s a strong chance he’ll never wrestle again, but it’s clear that the itch is still there. Bryan has said himself that he hopes to eventually wrestle again, but it’s not gonna happen in WWE, nor will it be any time soon.
Bryan sought advice from a series of medical professionals prior to his retirement earlier this year. If he’s to be believed, every single one of them cleared him to return apart from the one that matters the most: WWE’s medical team.
We’ll leave the debate on whether or not he should actually wrestle again to the professionals, but there’s a strong chance he’s just waiting-out his WWE contract at this point. Bryan’s been great as SmackDown’s general manager, but it’s clear that his heart remains inside the ring, and it’d goes without saying that he’d be an immense success in NJPW.
His skillset is perfect. Daniel Bryan is one of the best technicians of his generation, he can strike with the best of him, and while he’s not going to be pulling off wild corkscrew flips at this stage in his career, he’s always been an elite athlete. There’s not a performer in the world that he can’t have a good match with, and he’d mesh perfectly with NJPW’s elite-level talent.
Removing all the hearsay surrounding his current situation, a wrestler of Daniel Bryan’s calibre deserves to work with complete freedom at a high level. There’s only one place he’s going to get that, and it isn’t WWE.