8 Things Everybody Gets Wrong About The Montreal Screwjob
The controversial moment provides conflicting stories.
A full generation has passed since the fateful night of November 9, 1997. Yet, to many wrestling fans that had what would become known as "The Montreal Screwjob" anywhere near their frame of vision, the incident provides many talking points to this day.
It's professional wrestling's equivalent of the Kennedy assassination, where questions about what actually happened still ring long after, and conspiracy theories continue to burrow through the woodwork.
Through the various perspectives of the principals involved, from Bret Hart to Shawn Michaels to Vince McMahon to every secondary player, different sides of the stories have been told. Through conflicting claims, the truth about what actually happened in both the planning and the actual 'hit' can be a bit murky.
These contradictions have led to the curious readers and fans assuming some things about the incident that just simply are not true.
In the forthcoming Titan Screwed: Lost Smiles, Stunners And Screwjobs (dispatching on June 1st for pre-orders now!), WhatCulture's James Dixon and I thoroughly break down the entire Montreal incident, from the first sign of trouble in paradise regarding Hart's WWE contract status, through the fallout of everybody directly involved.
As a little taste of what readers can expect out of the book, here's a little primer on Montreal itself, specifically what one should not believe.
8. Bret Wanted To Leave WWE Over Creative Direction
Even as WWE was veering off into smuttier storylines and presentation, something that Hart admits he was lamenting from his longtime employer, he was by all means happy to stay on with his wrestling home of thirteen-plus years.
When Hart re-signed with WWE for a twenty-year contract in the fall of 1996 that would pay out $10.5M in total, he was actually due to make $4.5M over the next three years as a wrestler. Had he signed with WCW at the time, he would have made between $7M-$9M in that same time frame.
Hart was goaded out the door by McMahon, who was claiming an inability to pay out Hart's contract, starting in the summer of 1997. McMahon flat out told Hart he was intending to breach the deal, and urged Hart to try and see if Eric Bischoff would make him the same offer from the previous year.
In reality, McMahon was trying to get Hart's large obligation off the books to make the company attractive for when he eventually went public with the stock market.
7. Bret Could Have Showed Up On Nitro The Night After Survivor Series
The rationale for forcibly taking the belt off of Hart at Survivor Series stems from the theory that a spiteful "Hitman" could have showed up on Nitro the next night with the WWE Championship belt, and trashed it in Madusa-like fashion.
For one thing, Bischoff, at his most nefarious, would not have allowed that, owing to the fact that WWE sued Turner over the Madusa act. Bischoff had to keep things on the up-and-up.
Even then, Hart was bound to WWE until at least December 1. He couldn't show up on WCW programming until after that date. WWE's concern was that Bischoff would go on Nitro on November 10 and announce that he'd signed away WWE's champion, which would make WWE look like idiots.
In McMahon's mind, Hart could not leave Montreal with the belt for that reason.
6. Bret Refused To Lose In Canada
While it's true that Hart thought of himself as a Canadian hero (not that he isn't), the idea that he refused to lose in Canada whatsoever is false.
The month before the pay-per-view, Michaels told Hart in front of a locker room filled with wrestlers that he had no intentions of laying down for him. Hart saw this as a sign of disrespect and refused to lose to Shawn, and Shawn alone.
Hart was determined not to let Michaels beat him at Survivor Series; instead, he wanted Michaels to atone for his out-of-line comments.
Hart had offered to lose the belt the next night on Raw in Ottawa to whomever, even Michaels himself, provided that Michaels humbled himself by letting Hart escape Survivor Series as champion. He would have put anyone over at Survivor Series for the belt if asked - just not Michaels, for those reasons.
5. Bret Refused To Drop The Belt, Period
This idea stems from the fact that Hart admits suggesting to McMahon that on the November 10 Raw, he could just cut a goodbye speech, hand over the belt, and then leave with his head held high. One could understand McMahon not wanting to go that route - his unbeaten champion simply saying, "Here's your belt" before headed south for WCW would have been a devastating blow to WWE.
While Hart did suggest that idea, he also suggested putting over other wrestlers at different times on his way out, including Austin, Michaels (again, just not in Montreal), Shamrock, and even The Brooklyn Brawler if it would make things right.
The handover suggestion is used by some to claim that Hart refused all jobs out of hand.
4. Vince Russo Suggested The Screwjob
Vinnie-Ru, if nothing else, is an enthusiastic self-champion. Russo was certainly part of McMahon's inner-circle at the time the events took place, but most reliable sources shoot down the idea that he suggested anything about low-bridging Hart on his way out the door.
Jim Cornette will tell you in the immediate aftermath that Russo was dumbfounded by the premature bell ringing, and needed to have it explained to him. Then again, Cornette rarely says a good word about Russo anyhow.
On Wednesday, November 5, a frustrated Cornette offhandedly told McMahon, "God**mn Vince, it’s your fu**ing belt. Just double-cross him". Later in the day, McMahon spoke to Michaels and Triple H via conference call, an occasion where Helmsley suggested "doing business for (Hart)" if Hart didn't want to lay down.
It was there that McMahon began seriously considering the unthinkable.
3. Pat Patterson And Jim Ross Had Advance Knowledge Of It
Patterson was the agent for the match, and Ross was obviously the commentator. In Patterson's case, he approved of the spot where Michaels snared Hart in the Sharpshooter before Hart's planned reversal, but that's been chalked up to a coincidence.
Ross' reiterations that the match was likely the last time one would ever see Hart and Michaels face off was simply because he knew Hart was leaving.
In reality, McMahon intentionally kept both men out of the loop. Fearing a locker room mutiny in the aftermath, he didn't want the wrestlers to be unable to trust the head road agent and the head of talent relations, respectively. There needed to be elder statesmen with clean souls.
Among the few office personnel clued in the night before were Kevin Dunn, Gerald Brisco, and Bruce Prichard.
2. Earl Hebner Was Voluntarily In On It
Hebner's made a habit out of fanning flames of the incident by wearing a "Damn Right I Did" t-shirt under his officiating attire, exposing it against chants of "You Screwed Bret" at TNA house shows. That's nothing more than a way to co-opt heat from the residual life the story's had over the past two decades.
In reality, Hebner hated doing what he did.
After promising Hart he wouldn't screw him over, Hebner was stopped by Brisco, who forcefully told him that if he didn't do what he was told, he would effectively be finished with WWE. He was also reminded that he was mic'd for the match, so if he tipped Hart off to the conspiracy, they would know it, and he'd be out of a job for non-compliance.
1. The Whole Thing Was A Work
An attempt at savviness from folks who are 'too hip' for simple reality, it's been alleged over years that Hart helped concoct the ending to his WWE career, and it was all an elaborate scheme to get people buzzing about a crazy story. The idea that any of it could be fake is crazier than the reality of it all.
In the two decades that have passed since, had it been a work, somebody inside would have blabbed about it by now. Hart's animosity with Michaels had stretched back for some time, and he hated breaking his lucrative contract with his longtime employer to go work for "the unknown".
There are simply too many moving parts for everything to have stayed as under wraps for this long if it were all a con.

To read the full account of everything regarding the Montreal Screwjob and the events leading up to and immediately after, pre-order Titan Screwed: Lost Smiles, Stunners and Screwjobs today for June 1st dispatch.