8 Times Fighters Won When They Should Have Been DQ'd

These fighters utilised illegal techniques and came out with a victory.

Bisping Knee
UFC

Compared to most professional sports, MMA has a pretty lax ruleset. I mean sure, fighters need to remember not to stomp their opponents in the head while they lay prone, and to avoid targeting eyes, or groins, but apart from that there really isn't all that much to fall afoul of throughout the course of a fight.

Even when compared to other combat sports such as boxing, the rules of MMA are pretty unrestrictive, so you'd assume that infractions are rare, right?

Wrong.

Though they generally aren't to the level of those seen in the fights featured on this list, it isn't out of the realms of possibility for fighters to commit fouls that go unpunished throughout the course of a bout. From a fence grab to defend a takedown, to the threat of an eye-poke to dissuade a would-be infighter from closing the distance, it is far from uncommon to see the rules of MMA flouted in the cage, with referees often failing to properly sanction offenders.

Sometimes though, fighters can commit more than just a petty infraction. This almost seems like karmic justice when they go on to lose their fights, but, unfortunately, knowingly or otherwise, these guys bent the ruleset to their advantage and went on to get the win.

8. Santiago Ponzinibbio Rakes Gunnar Nelson In The Eye Before Knocking Him Out

One of the most common rule infractions in all of MMA is the eye poke.

Due to the fingerless design of MMA gloves, it's not exactly surprising that fighters will often retreat with outstretched fingers in order to maximise their reach, inadvertently poking their opponent in the eye in the process.

This has proved a bigger issue in the UFC than it did in promotions such as the former Japanese MMA giant PRIDE, which may be due to the design of the gloves, that UFC president Dana White has been attempting to remedy for years now.

When an eye poke is involved in the finishing sequence of a fight it is even more frustrating for both the fighter affected and also for fans who are left wondering how the fight would've played out if the foul hadn't taken place.

A prime example of this came when welterweight contenders Gunnar Nelson and Santiago Ponzinibbio faced off in the main event of UFC Fight Night 113 in Glasgow. As Nelson closed the distance to attack with an uppercut, Ponzinibbio's outstretched finger caught the Icelandic fighter in the eye, and within a minute, Ponzinibbio capitalised and Nelson was KO'd.

Though the offence almost certainly wasn't intentional, Nelson's attempt to have the result overturned was denied, and Ponzinibbio was given a $50,000 Performance of the Night bonus.


7. Michael Bisping Illegally Knees A Grounded Jorge Rivera

Loved and hated in almost equal measure, Michael Bisping has long established himself as one of the most polarising figures in the history of the UFC.

What has separated Bisping from many of his contemporaries during his rise was his ability to talk trash. The Cypriot born scrapper had the capacity to really get under his opponent's skin.

Though Bisping would later be known for his legendary feuds with Georges St-Pierre and Luke Rockhold, the Brit's sworn enemy during his rise up the UFC ranks was Jorge Rivera.

Rivera was riding a three-fight win streak coming into the bout and the fight was seen as a battle of rising contenders at 185lbs.

The pair engaged in a war of words prior to the fight that was capped off by a cringeworthy video released by Rivera that was intended to get under Bisping's skin.

It worked, but possibly not in the way Rivera might have hoped.

Bisping was quick to take the fight to his opponent, but perhaps his emotions got the better of him when he landed a brutal illegal knee to a downed Rivera that threatened to bring an end to the bout.

Rivera bravely continued but Bisping would ultimately get the finish in the second round.


6. Bryan Caraway Gets A Little Handsy Trying To Secure A Choke

Of all the fouls chronicled on this list, none were quite as rare as that committed by former UFC bantamweight contender Bryan Caraway in his fight with Erik Perez back in 2014.

After a stint on Team Mayhem on Season 14 of The Ultimate Fighter, Caraway became known for his wrestling and submission grappling skills, ultimately reaching the semi-finals of the competition.

Caraway's ability to finish opponents once he reaches their back is incredible. Of his 18 professional wins leading up to the fight with Perez, 15 of them were by way of submission, with ten by rear-naked choke alone.

Needless to say, Caraway was a talented and crafty fighter, especially when the bout hit the mat.

However, during the first round of his fight with Perez, he committed a foul rarely seen in combat sports: the fish hook.

After securing a dominant position, Caraway attempted to take Perez's back by sinking his finger into the mouth of his opponent as they scrambled for position.

The illegal technique would go completely undetected by the referee, and Caraway would go on to secure his patented rear-naked choke in the second round to earn one of the biggest wins of his career.

Despite the controversy, both fighters remarked after the fight that they were unaware that the incident had taken place during the fight, and Caraway went on to issue Perez a public apology.


5. Yoel Romero Fails To Get Off His Stool In-between Rounds

The Cuban Olympic silver medalist Yoel Romero is something of an enigma in professional fighting.

Having only started training in the sport of MMA after turning 30, the distinguished wrestler has gone on to have an incredible career in the UFC, becoming one of the most feared men at 185lbs in the process.

What makes Romero so fascinating, however, is his propensity for being involved in truly strange fights, though none more unusual than when he took on Tim Kennedy at UFC 178.

After enjoying considerable success during the early going, Romero had started to tire towards the end of the second round allowing Kennedy to begin to turn the tide. With the bell fast-approaching, Kennedy landed a volley of uppercuts straight on Romero's chin while illegally holding on to his glove that went unpunished.

Things would only get stranger as the round ended.

Romero's corner poured a considerable amount of water on their fighter, allowing the exhausted Cuban to take an extended break on his stool.

While Kennedy protested that the fight should be stopped as Romero had technically failed to answer the bell, referee John McCarthy made Romero's corner dry their fighter off before the third round could begin.

Rejuvenated from his prolonged break, Romero immediately turned on the pressure in the final round and finished Kennedy via TKO just a minute later.


4. Daniel Cormier's 'Towelgate' Controversy

Daniel Cormier is one of the most renowned nice guys in the sport of MMA. Aside from his obligations as a professional cage fighter, Cormier devotes time as a high-school wrestling coach in California.

Though Cormier has immortalised himself in the MMA canon as the face to Jon Jones' heel, the American still hasn't managed to avoid controversy entirely.

After one of Jones' numerous mishaps left him on the sidelines, Cormier defended his UFC Light Heavyweight Championship against perennial contender Anthony 'Rumble' Johnson at UFC 210. But, unlike other fighters featured on this list, its wasn't Cormier's conduct in the cage that made him worthy of inclusion.

The cut to 205lbs was always difficult for a guy of Cormier's stature, but up to this point he had never failed to make weight for a light heavyweight fight. However, on his first trip to the scale, the defending champion missed weight by over a pound with just minutes remaining.

Cormier then returned just minutes later having miraculously lost the required weight.

It later became clear that Cormier had held the towel in front of him to decrease his weight in order to keep the title on the line and not have to forfeit any of his purse to Rumble.

Celebrated arbiter of human morality Jon Jones later called Cormier's antics "one of the dirtiest things" he'd ever seen.


3. Travis Browne Eye Pokes Matt Mitrione Several Times En Route To Victory

Though Travis Browne is possibly better known now for his relationship with Ronda Rousey, there was a time when the nearly 7-foot tall behemoth was one of the most feared fighters in the UFC heavyweight division.

In his thirteenth appearance in the organisation, Browne faced off against former American Football player, and TUF alum Matt Mitrione.

As a fairly tentative first round between the two fighters drew to a close, Browne caught his opponent with a sickening knuckle-deep eye poke. Things didn't get much better after the break either, as Browne again caught Mitrione with an outstretched finger, causing a large welt to swell up over Mitrione's right eye.

With Mitrione effectively blinded in one eye, Browne would go on to dominate the majority of the contest and went on to secure a stoppage victory with less than a minute left in round three.

Much like several of his contemporaries on this list, Mitrione would later attempt unsuccessfully to appeal the result of the fight, with the athletic commission ruling that the referee should have intervened at the time.

Despite getting the W, Browne's career would take a downturn following his tainted victory over Mitrione. After a promising 9 wins from his first 13 bouts in the UFC, Browne would go on to lose four consecutive fights and hasn't competed since.


2. Germaine De Randamie Repeatedly Strikes Holly Holm After The Bell

A fight for a UFC title is the pinnacle of a mixed martial artist's career. It represents the culmination of a lifetime of hard work, rising up the ranks and dispatching contenders all in order to earn the right to compete for UFC gold.

With all that in mind, when a fighter engages in some questionable actions during the course of a title fight, with the possibility of serious damage already compounded due to the longer length of the bout it is even more egregious.

So when Germaine de Randamie took on Holly Holm in a battle of elite strikers to determine the first UFC Women's Featherweight Champion, The Iron Lady would receive a torrent of abuse post-fight following her questionable actions in the cage.

During the end of both the second and third rounds, de Randamie continued to throw strikes after the bell had signified that the round had ended. One of these strikes visibly wobbled Holm and likely affected the outcome of the fight, but the referee decided not to take a point on either occasion.

De Randamie would ultimately take a controversial unanimous decision on the judges' scorecards, before being stripped of the belt after refusing to fight Cris Cyborg.


1. Rousimar Palhares Refuses To Let Go Of A Submission After The Fight Is Over

Much like the aforementioned Yoel Romero, Rousimar Palhares has made a habit of bizarre antics inside the cage.

Rising up the UFC ranks as an almost impossibly strong grappler with a penchant for leg attacks, Palhares wasted no time in becoming one of the most feared fighters on the roster.

In a fight with Nate Marquardt, Palhares was KO'd after complaining to the referee that Marquardt was greasing, mid-fight! The guy literally tried to have a conversation with the referee while his opponent was actively trying to knock him out.

The strangeness only continued throughout the Brazilian's UFC tenure, leading to his release in 2013 after again failing to let go of a submission after the referee had stopped the fight against Mike Pierce.

Perhaps Palhares' most egregious performance, however, came against Jake Shields in the World Series of Fighting promotion. During the fight, Shields repeatedly attempted to earn positional control against the Brazilian but was repelled after his eyes were gouged on several occasions to the point where he was temporarily blinded.

In the closing sequence of the fight, Palhares secured a kimura and forced Shields to submit but presumably decided he hadn't been villainous enough already and continued cranking the submission well after Shields' tap.


Contributor
Contributor

Adrian Bishop hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.