8 Times WWE Dropped The Ball With Alex Riley
Alex Riley was bound for big things in WWE. Was.
One of the biggest mysteries among WWE fans for years has been: What the heck happened with Alex Riley?
Once a breakout babyface on the rise, he seemingly fell out of favor with officials in mid-2011. Rumors ran rampant that John Cena played a part in Riley's demise, and the former NXT standout responded to the speculation on a recent episode of “The Ross Report” by claiming an incident with Cena had indeed “changed the path of his career.”
What those cryptic comments might entail remains unknown, but don't be fooled: regardless of what happened between Riley and Cena behind the scenes six years ago, there were plenty of other instances where WWE missed the boat with him. Riley appeared to be primed for big things during his time in developmental, but upon his arrival on the main roster, WWE was never truly able to tap into his full potential.
Following his departure from the organisation in May 2016, fans were left to wonder what might have been, had they utilised him the right way.
These are just eight
times where Riley could have amounted to more - but didn't due to bad
booking and other unfortunate circumstances...
8. Feud With Jerry Lawler
Interestingly enough, The Miz's first real rivalry as WWE champion came against Jerry Lawler, and Alex Riley was by The Awesome One's side every step of the way. Miz and Lawler battled over the WWE Championship for months, culminating at the Elimination Chamber pay-per-view in a surprisingly great match, won by Miz.
Riley received a rub simply from being in the corner of the champion during Miz's many months as WWE champion, though in addition to coming down to ringside for Miz's main event match against John Cena at WrestleMania 27, he should have been in action on the card as well.
For months, it had speculated that Lawler would face Riley at WrestleMania, allowing him to achieve his lifelong goal of competing on the grand stage. It was also a seamless transition from Lawler vs. Miz, and although Lawler ended up wrestling at 'Mania that year, it wasn't against Riley. Rather, he did battle with his fellow Raw broadcast partner, Michael Cole.
It wasn't a major deal that Riley vs. Lawler never came to fruition, but at least it would have spared us from one of the worst 'Mania matches of all-time.
7. Not Becoming A Regular On SmackDown Commentary
Alex Riley recently admitted on "The Ross Report" that, although he enjoyed his stint as an announcer, he belonged in the ring. Truth be told, commentary was a fitting role for him considering his father was a broadcaster and he had always been a talented talker. Besides, he was hardly doing anything of note when he transitioned to the booth in mid-2013. It was worth a shot.
He quickly developed chemistry alongside Josh Mathews on Superstars and eventually called the action on NXT. In fact, he called one episode of SmackDown with Michael Cole in August, which should have been his opportunity to move up to the main roster as a colour commentator. After all, by that point, Cole and JBL were essentially on every show, and SmackDown was "Raw lite" at the time, so having Riley replace JBL would have added a fresh feel to the blue brand.
As time progressed, Riley became more and more obnoxious as an announcer as a result of his heel tendencies, so his in-ring return couldn't have come at a better time.
But perhaps his time spent as an analyst could have been more enjoyable, if he was given more of a chance to shine on a bigger platform.
6. Not Winning NXT Season 2
From Daniel Bryan to Wade Barrett to Skip Sheffield, there were several rookies involved in the inaugural season of NXT that had the potential to be stars. But that wasn't quite the case with the subsequent season, aside from Alex Riley.
It's no coincidence Bryan was eliminated first from NXT because he wasn't hand-picked by officials to be the winner. Likewise, they weren't high on Kaval, either, but he was the one who continued to rank higher in the fan polls over Riley despite losing the majority of his matches.
Riley had the look, charisma and the mic skills to be a breakout heel. That was his season to win. After all, even prior to when he was ultimately eliminated from the competition in shocking fashion on the season finale, he was already accompanying Miz down to ringside for his matches, so it was apparent officials had plans for him in the long-haul.
Although he didn't win the contract, he ended up on Raw anyway. Meanwhile, the eventual winner Kaval was released a mere three months later. The show's credibility tanked from that point forward, and thus Riley would have been better off the victor.
5. Moving To SmackDown
The WWE draft tends to provide wrestlers with the opportunity to experience a change in scenery and possibly make a name for themselves on a new show. That was nearly the case with Alex Riley, who was separated from his protege of one year, The Miz, in the 2011 WWE draft. While Miz remained on Raw as the WWE champion, Riley was sent packing to the blue brand as part of the supplemental draft.
Apparently, there had been talks for months from officials to split Riley from Miz. Riley would have had a whole other career for himself on SmackDown, and while that would have spared fans their awesome feud, Riley would have had more of a chance to find his footing on Friday nights.
At the time, Raw was loaded with star power - whereas there might have been an opening for him higher up on the card on SmackDown had he stayed. But following only one appearance on the blue brand in April 2011, he re-signed with Raw to resume his feud with The Miz - though that would ultimately do more harm than good.
4. Chasing The United States Championship
Once Alex Riley's feud with The Miz fizzled out over the summer of 2011, there was an opening for him to become a mainstay in the midcard on Monday nights by chasing the United States Championship. Around August, Dolph Ziggler hadn't been doing anything worthwhile with the star-spangled prize, so Riley would have been the perfect candidate to take it off of him and boost his own momentum.
Although the seeds had been planted for a Riley vs. Ziggler feud prior to SummerSlam, nothing ever came of it, and tension was teased between Ziggler and Jack Swagger instead. Riley remained in contention for the championship, but he was far from the focus. He, John Morrison and Swagger all vied for the title in a Fatal 4-Way match at Night of Champions, and despite making a strong impression, Riley fell short of victory.
That was the last fans saw of Riley in a regular role on WWE TV. He could have benefited huge from holding that championship, but officials saw it fit to keep him in the doghouse and off programming instead.
3. Returning To The Ring
As skilled as Alex Riley was in the commentary role, his place was inside the squared circle. He had unfinished business as a wrestler, and after petitioning on social media for months to be "unleashed from his cage," Riley was finally allowed to return to it at the onset of 2015.
Needless to say, there was no way Riley was going to beat Kevin Owens at any point during their feud, but it was a nice way to get him out from behind the booth. Moreover, he benefited from working against the NXT champion at the time, and fared well for himself in each of their outings. The only issue with the rivalry was that Riley was made to look like a loser every time. He was beaten so decisively, by that point, the rebirth of his wrestling career was already off to a sour start.
Before Riley could build any real steam, he suffered a shoulder injury, sidelining him for nearly nine months. Of course, that wasn't the fault of management, but they could have done more with him beyond his feud with Owens.
His story in stepping back between the ropes was fun to follow.
2. Turning Heel
Upon Alex Riley's return from injury in January 2016, the commentators acted almost shocked that he was back - but in a way that they didn't really seem to care.
Truth be told, this was how most fans felt about Riley, considering he had been out of sight and out of mind for so long. However, that was the whole point: Riley was fed up of being overlooked. He was now going to take out his aggression on the newest batch of NXT competitors.
His heel turn got off to a solid start when he made short work of Bull Dempsey in his return match - but things turned decidedly weird once he went one-on-one with fellow heel Tye Dillinger and lost in the matter of two minutes. Dillinger walked away from the match unscathed, and nothing came of his victory whatsoever. It was simply a waste of time, and yet another sign that officials had nothing notable in mind for Riley.
Riley's gimmick in taking out the talent of tomorrow, from Finn Balor to Hideo Itami to Sami Zayn, could have been a blast - but instead, he was relegated to the role of an enhancement talent up until his release from the company in May 2016.
1. Feud With The Miz
If he wasn't going to be drafted to SmackDown in 2011 and start a singles career for himself, Alex Riley turning on The Miz was the next best thing, especially after all the beatings he had taken at the hands of his protege for almost a year. The feud wrote itself. Only, it didn't.
After Riley unintentionally cost Miz the WWE Championship on several occasions throughout the spring. The Awesome One then fired him as his personal assistant, leading to Riley snapping on Miz and unleashing all hell on him.
The crowd went nuts for Riley on that night, and the sweet new entrance music by Downstait he marched out to the very next week helped him stand out as a star. He got the better of Miz at every turn for an entire month, even beating him in a singles match in his hometown of Washington D.C. at Capitol Punishment.
Oddly enough, Riley's red-hot push was cut short there.
He was involved in a few more higher-profile matches that summer, but he was no longer presented as "the next big thing" as he had been hyped up as for months. Despite still receiving reactions from crowds, Riley was instantly dropped from the spotlight coming out of a series that never had a proper conclusion.
And, for the remainder of his run with WWE, he was never utilised the right way again.