8 Ups And 3 Downs From Last Night's NXT (5 Feb)

You're not dreaming.

Velveteen Dream
NXT

NXT's getting into a strange pattern these days. Put together a show with hotly-anticipated matches that are advertised well in advance and get our pulses racing in mere anticipation, and it'll deliver a Very-Good-At-Best evening. But throw things together during the week with no real hype or logic and normally, normally, you get a banger.

This week definitely fell into the latter category. After the B+/A- brilliance of the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic Final, and the non-starter that was Tegan Nox vs Dakota Kai, this week felt understated by comparison. Nothing on the line, nothing we've been waiting weeks to see, just another episode of NXT TV on the way to TakeOver Portland.

These are usually the situations in which the show thrives, so fans would have been forgiven for letting themselves get slightly carried away. The belatedly confirmed appearance of Charlotte Flair also giving even casual viewers a reason to tune it. Could it deliver? Well, let's find out...


Downs...

3. We've Been Here Before... A Lot

Dominic Dijakovic Kieth Lee
NXT

I like Dominic Dijakovic, and I love Kieth Lee, but there is nowhere near as much interest in this rivalry as NXT thinks there is. We've seen brilliant matches between the two over the past few months, but that's precisely the point, we've seen them, loads of them. Since NXT moved to the USA Network we have seen these two sharing a ring seven times.

There's a lot of trust in the process on this show, and I've got no doubt that the pair will deliver a perfectly watchable TakeOver match, but when Lee stripped Strong of the North American title it felt like a world of new possibilities had just opened up. This definitely isn't one of them.

The way to go was a series of fresh challengers whom Lee could have new and inventive matches against, all the while Dijakovic toils away separately climbing his way to the top of the mountain. Yes, Priest and Dain have made him look like a worthy opponent, but neither has really informed some pulsating need to see Dijakovic on the TakeOver card.

Absence, as they say, makes the heart grow fonder, and we really needed some breathing room before putting these two back together again.


2. Save Kushida

Kushida Bin
NXT

They don't give out Academy Awards for poetic irony, but whoever pitched the idea of the Undisputed Era dumping Kushida in bin almost certainly deserves one. I wouldn't even put it past WWE to know exactly what they're doing here, hoping to inspire thousands of outraged fans into tweeting out the GIF with the caption "THEY LITERALLY JUST PUT KUSHIDA IN A BIN! HAHA SYMBOLIC OMG".

And far be it from me to play along with this but... they literally put Kushida in a bin and the symbolism of this will haunt my dreams for a lifetime.

The man was, at the time, NXT's biggest signing since Nakamura. They put hin ringside at TakeOver New York, proudly unveiled him for the world's media (with Triple H alongside for good measure) and fed the audience umpteen video packages to make sure the former 6-time IWGP Junior Heavyweight Champion got the reverence he deserved.

Since then he's tagged with Breezango, been demolished by Walter, exited the Dusty Classic in the first round, and gone 50/50 with Cameron Grimes over a hat. Yes, injuries have played their part in this, but... they literally put Kushida in a bin.


1. Oh Good, A Brawl!

nxt bRAWL
NXT

Minor minor minor minor gripe this, but after how good the opening segment of the show was (more on that later) giving us the 8,000th feud-furthering mass scrap since NXT arrived on the USA Network elicited a bit of an eye-roll when it's supposed to raise your heart rate. After a strong promo and some fun backstage stuff, it all just broke out into a fight between Ciampa and UE again.

The weird thing is that, for once, this one was actually quite good. It spilled into the ring, got joined by Dunne and Riddle, and after a few cool spots William Regal arrived to cut his usual masterclass on less-is-more GMing. He was sick of this ruining his show, so the 7 men would settle it in the main event instead. This is pretty much how you book these things.

But the sad thing is that the goodwill towards these segments has just worn too thin. This one carried virtually no impact because we see them every single week now. NXT needs to save them for times like this when they matter, not overuse them to the point of parody.


Ups...

8. The Broserweightmobile

Dunne Riddle
NXT

I've worked really hard in my career. So hard in fact that I've arrived in a position whereby, if I want to award a conceptual plus point to a wrestling show purely on the basis that it included a customised, neon golf cart, without any real explanation for why, that I can.

So here you go. The Broswerweightmobile is an Up. It's a thing now.


7. Riddle Me This

Pete Dunne Matt Riddle
NXT

Here's the thing right, the opening promo between Matt Riddle, Pete Dunne, Bobby Fish and Kyle O'Reilly wasn't particularly good.

No, honestly. The writing on it was a bit hokey, the delivery of some of the lines felt incredibly hammy, and it did precisely nothing to really further the feud for the upcoming Takeover: Portland Tag Team Championship match. Strictly speaking, that's a bad promo for a wrestling show to open with, but for NXT it was a breath of fresh air so strong, you can't normally get it without opening a window in Riddle's living room.

NXT is an intense wrestling show. The matches are intense, the promos are intense, the beatdowns are intense and the whole thing rattles through it's two hours without ever giving you a chance to catch your breath or... laugh. "How much fish could Bobby Fish fry if Bobby Fish could fry fish is stupid", but it's also hilarious and immediately got over.

It popped everyone in full sail, further cemented the Broserweigts as the most entertaining thing on the show, rattled their upcoming opponents, and didn't have a single line of corporate, scripted WWE buzz words. If I've said it once, I've said it a million times. Just. Let. The. Wrestlers. Talk.


6. Shared Universe

Angel Garza
NXT

It's really important for NXT for it not to be received as somehow still the "lower leagues" when compared to the main roster, but the reality is that (for now at least) being on Raw or SmackDown is a bigger deal than being in Full Sail. The way things are going this may change, but as Angel Garza made his entrance this week he felt 10x the star he did at Worlds Collide.

Having been introduced on Raw by Zelina Vega and then posted an absolute banger of a match against Rey Mysterio, this didn't feel like an up-and-coming wrestling hopeful, but an established part of WWE lore. If anything, the fact that he was back on NXT just two days removed from his main roster debut showed how important affairs on this brand actually are to people.

We'll get to the match later, but putting him with Isaiah Swerve Scott was also an interconnected masterstroke. Scott's been sporadically featured on the show over the past few months, but massively over-delivered every time he has. The rub that came from Garza working Mysterio is immediately transferrable to someone like him, even in defeat.


5. Cruiserweights

Jordan Devlin
NXT

Surely, surely, it's now time for the Cruiserweights to be a cemented part of TakeOver shows. Yes, we're already on 6 matches for what's classically a 5 match show, but their level of performance demands that they're not overlooked anymore. The banger at Worlds Collide showed that it belongs on the bigger stages, and Garza vs Swerve tonight only furthers that argument.

Given the opening slot on the show the two absolutely dazzled with both their invention and their athleticism. Swerve's 180 turnbuckle powerbomb (which really needs a name) feels like a move that should have been invented years ago, and the constant counters to each other's high-flying gave it a genuine edge of serious peril.

In the end, Garza prevailed and called out Devlin; the man who took his championship without ever actually beating him. Devlin, for his part, gave us a surprisingly even and engrossing match with Tyler Breeze later in the night. The two will come face to face eventually and deliver a TakeOver match, let's just hope they're given the TakeOver show on which to do it.


4. Climbing The Ladder

Martinez Catanzarro
NXT

Mercedes Martinez vs Kacy Catanzaro was a match that felt, on its surface, like a quick squash designed to do little more than show you what the former's finisher was while reminding you the latter exists. That's not inaccurate as an assessment, but it also highlighted precisely how deep this women's division actually is.

Ask yourself, by picking up this win, how far up the ladder do you think it moves Martinez? Certainly nowhere near the three women who were in the women later in the night, but definitely far up enough that there's a genuine interest in seeing her work someone like Shotzi Blackheart in the coming weeks.

Likewise, since the title last changed hands she's got more wins under her belt than an established star like Candice LeRae, and when Io eventually returns she could find her slot taken by someone else. The future combinations, and the matches that will bring, really create the feel of an actual division for the women, rather than simply a string of random challengers.

As for Kacy Catanzaro, she got over huge in defeat at the Mae Young Classic, so there's hopefully plenty more to come from her after tonight.


3. The Respect She Deserves

Belair Ripley Flair
NXT

When news leaked that Charlotte would be using her Royal Rumble win to challenge Rhea Ripley for her NXT Championship, questions were immediately raised about how they'd build to this when the focus surely has to be on Bianca Belair's match at TakeOver: Portland. Given how seamlessly they managed to spin all the plates leading into Survivor Series, we shouldn't have worried.

Somehow, the advertised appearance of Charlotte that the entire broadcast was promoted around ended with the one woman who won't feature at WrestleMania coming out of it he best. Belair came out, taking issue with being forgotten in all of this WrestleMania talk, and despite Flair's best efforts to sideline her in the segment, she persisted.

Her delivery on the mic has really emerged as a bright spot in the division recently as well. Crowd-popping moments like "you don't even go here" and her visual reactions during the segment were the highlight of the whole bit. We'll get to Ripley and Flair eventually, but right now the spotlight's on the current challenger, and that's how it should be.


2. "Go And Get Your Gear On"

Pete Dunne Adam Cole
NXT

While the brawl that set the match up was a tired old trope of the show, the match that it led to was worth any booking cliche. NXT might struggle for variety at times, but the talent on its roster means that the matches we do get almost never disappoint.

The TV time that was sunk into getting this match could also be considered excessive (we'd had an opening promo in the ring, and several backstage skits before the brawl broke out) but it's actually a new move for NXT to drag a narrative out from the top of the show all the way through to the evening's main event. It gave us a cohesive feel and, best of all, an absolutely classic Regal-is-the-best-GM-on-earth spot. Arrive, "Go and get your gear on, this is getting settled tonight", and leave.

After nearly 20 minutes of hard-hitting tag action that saw everybody afforded their chance to shine, Roddy Strong ran interference and the whole thing was thrown out. Under normal circumstances a pointless ending to a 2-hour long-running scrap that serviced absolutely nothing in the long run but, given what it was setting up, a thrilling main-event that can be examined in isolation.

The lights went out, and...


1. No, You're Not Dreaming

Velveteen Dream
NXT

Velveteen Dream is back. I could spend a full 2000 words telling you all the reasons why this should excite you but you almost definitely know them already. The man has been out for months, and he's come back just as we're getting into WrestleMania season. Truly, my friends, dreams do come true.

The fact that he's returned to layout the entire Undisputed Era, and then revealed a set of tights with Roderick Strong's family printed on the leg and the words "Call Me Up Marina" on his backside, shows you precisely what we've all been missing while he's been away. All of these criticisms of the show being one-note and just obsessed with intense, serious wrestling... well, here's a remedy for you. A tonic of variety and excitement and fun.

Whether or not there's room for another match at TakeOver is a question for another time (specifically next week), but in the here and now it's great to have one of the brand's most watchable assets back where he belongs.


Managing Editor
Managing Editor

WhatCulture's Managing Editor and Chief Reporter | Previously seen in Vice, Esquire, FourFourTwo, Sabotage Times, Loaded, The Set Pieces, and Mundial Magazine