8 Ups And 5 Downs From Last Night's WWE Raw (Nov 12)

The battle for Brand Supremacy leads to surprisingly strong show.

becky lynch
WWE.com

Pop quiz: Who was the biggest star on Raw Monday night?

If you don’t know right away, you absolutely have to watch the last 15 minutes of the show. Let’s just say that WWE has a huge star on its hands if they want to actually make one, or they can do what they usually do: stick their fingers in their ears and follow the blueprint drawn up a while ago.

Raw’s go-home episode for Survivor Series actually was a pretty solid show, but it still is leading to a show that is all about vagueries like “brand supremacy,” “momentum” and “bragging rights.” And while that can work at times and actually is a great motivating factor in at least one of the matches, it’s such a flimsy concept for an entire PPV with nothing else on the line.

We saw several superstars step up, with Ruby Riott delivering a decent promo, Ronda Rousey firing up, Braun Strowman standing up to Stephanie McMahon, Elias looking strong in defeat, and Drew McIntyre and Dean Ambrose jockeying for position as the top heel.

We also saw stupidity in the ring and behind the commentary desk and a decimation of an entire Raw division – and no, not what happened in the main event.

With that said, let’s find out what dominated and what meekly crawled away. Let’s get to it…


Downs...

5. Dumb Things Announcers Say

Ember Moon Tamina
WWE.com

You really can’t make this stuff up.

Michael Cole was trying really hard to sell Nia Jax’s backstabbing as a devastating blow to Ember Moon, but it’s difficult to take him seriously when he says something unintentionally hilarious.

Cole asked about Moon’s state of mind, noting that Ember “idolized” Nia Jax, that they trained and came up together. First off, idolized? That’s an awfully strong word to throw out there to describe your friendship. And consider that Nia got drafted to Raw in 2016 after being unable to win the NXT Women’s Championship, before Ember even made her televised debut in NXT. So they didn’t “come up together” either.

There was an established friendship there to play up, and that’s a perfectly reasonable thing to do. But it was an immediate record-skipping moment when Cole started freestyling.

You know what would’ve helped more than Cole making stuff up? An inset promo from Moon talking about how she was hurt by Nia’s actions. It would’ve shown character development, motivation and angle advancement in the time it took for her to walk down the aisle.


4. Stupidity Reigns Supreme

Jinder Mahal Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

Jinder Mahal is an idiot.

That’s not hyperbole. That has to be what WWE wants us to think, after he willingly walked into the ring to try to get Brock Lesnar to meditate. Literally everyone on Earth saw this coming a mile away, and Jinder still marched down to the ring with the Singh Brothers in tow, only for them all to get decimated by the Beast.

We’ve only been seeing this for the past six years from Brock, so it’s understandable that Mahal would be dumb enough to waltz into the ring willingly. He clearly needs a couple more years of data to form an opinion on the matter.

Sure, this is reading way too much into something that was part-joke, part-demolition, but former WWE Champion Jinder Mahal is still going to be here after Lesnar’s part-time act departs for good, and he just got to look like a total goof.


3. Renee Pleads Ignorance

dean ambrose seth rollins
WWE.com

For weeks, we’ve had to endure an unbelievable performance from one of the Raw announcers, and it has to stop.

Every time Dean Ambrose has come out to explain his actions – and then stop short – Michael Cole has turned to Renee Young and asked if she knows what’s going on. After all, she knows Dean better than anyone – because she’s married to him.

And every time, Renee has pleaded ignorance, saying that Ambrose doesn’t tell her anything. Monday, she said that Dean “has a story to tell” and is speaking in riddles that make no sense to her. What doesn’t make sense is a spouse not understanding anything about what her significant other is doing every week.

Unless Renee is going to turn heel herself and protect Dean, she should say that Ambrose isn’t talking to her and has moved out or something, anything better than expecting us to buy the “he doesn’t talk and I don’t pursue” line. It just feels hollow.


2. ‘Brand Supremacy’

smackdown tags
WWE.com

This will undoubtedly come up again during the Survivor Series column, but it bears mentioning here: The entire “brand supremacy” message that WWE tries to push about Survivor Series is stupid, nonsensical and insulting all at the same time.

Any sports fan will tell you that the reason you have big head-to-head matches isn’t just for bragging rights (though it can be a big part of it), it’s to win something. Anything. If the PPV is billed as “the one time of the year that Raw and SmackDown go head-to-head” (which is a lie), then it should be treated like the Super Bowl, World Series, or World Cup.

There is nothing on the line or at stake at Survivor Series except the egos of the two McMahon siblings. That’s it. And that’s a pretty crappy motivation for a PPV.

WWE could alleviate this by simply putting something on the line: the #30 spot in the Royal Rumble matches. Whichever brand wins the most matches at Survivor Series gets the coveted #30 spot (or maybe even the last 2-3 spots if you’re daring). That alone would be something to get excited about.

But no, it’s Shane McMahon’s theft of the meaningless WWE World Cup that is the motivating factor. Whatever.


1. Embarrassing Tag Team Division

tag team divisions
WWE.com

Last week, AOP reached the top of the Raw tag team division by defeating one man – Seth Rollins – who defended the tag titles alone.

Monday, we saw the entire tag division wiped out by one man – Braun Strowman.

Suddenly, that mountain AOP climbed looks like more of an anthill.

We’ve seen main-event stars beat up lesser wrestlers before, so that’s nothing new. But having Braun mow through every other tag team in the division single-handedly does nothing except ensure that no one buys any of them as challengers to AOP in a fair fight.

If WWE wanted to have Braun do something like this, book an Ascension/B-Team match to open Raw and save the other four teams that were in there. At least that would have been a bit more believable too.

It’s just absolutely stupid booking, getting a momentary pop at the expense of any planning whatsoever.


Ups...

8. Rousey Motivated

Ronda Rousey
WWE.com

Heading into Sunday’s PPV, the match that fans probably are most interested in would be the women’s champion versus champion bout, pitting Ronda Rousey against Becky Lynch.

Lynch’s self-absorbed, anti-hero persona has rallied fans around her, while Rousey has exceeded expectations during her short time on the roster (while also being very well-protected). With two women who use arm-based submission holds, it could be a really fun match that could elevate both women if given the opportunity.

So when Ronda came out Monday night and told Stephanie McMahon to save her pep talk, that she was amped already to show “The Man” how to rip someone’s arm off, it felt like real anticipation. The fans chanting “Becky!” at her probably helped with that, as Rousey is going to find herself as the villainess simply by not being Lynch. Her promo later seemed to acknowledge that as she again mocked Becky’s previous jobs.

And that could make for a very interesting dynamic on Sunday. Of course, there were some other developments later on that fueled the fire…


7. Balor Perseveres

Finn Balor Dolph Ziggler
WWE.com

There’s a very real possibility that Finn Balor will be served up to Drew McIntyre as a high-level babyface to defeat, which would stink for card-carrying members of Balor Club, but if it seriously elevates the Scot, then so be it.

But for an evening, it was good to see Balor prevail in his struggle, warding off McIntyre (after stepping up to him) and defeating Dolph Ziggler in a match that started slow but picked up steam rapidly toward the end. It was particularly heartening to see him take Drew down a peg before reversing a rollup for the pin, allowing him to not only get a ring win, but a moral victory too.

Don’t look for that win to stand forever, though. McIntyre is likely WWE’s pick to rise to the top in the long term.


6. Riott Finally Does Something

riott squad
WWE.com

Ever since coming over from SmackDown, the Riott Squad has done little more than perform juvenile pranks backstage and serve as cannon fodder in the ring.

Monday, we finally got some substance behind the pranks and improving in-ring action. Ruby Riott cut a promo about breaking Natalya’s sunglasses, which belonged to her late father, Jim “The Anvil” Neidhart. It isn’t the first time a deceased family member has been used as fuel for a feud, but this seems to be more about getting Ruby and the Riott Squad over than Nattie, who has been around for a decade.

And Ruby did a nice job on the mic, talking about Neidhart and how she turned happy memories into nightmares. And when the turn in the promo came, Riott talked about enjoying everything she did, and how she didn’t go far enough. When Nattie jumped Ruby from behind, they trio overcame her and hit her with – what else? – a Hart Attack.

One promo won’t set them on a rocket to the top, but it was good to see a little real character development rather than just some mindless actions.


5. Ambrose Burns It Down

dean ambrose fire
WWE.com

Dean Ambrose finally has started speaking out about why he turned his back on The Shield and attacked Seth Rollins last month.

And while Ambrose initially gave this writer’s absolute least favorite reason – “I don’t owe you an explanation” – he actually said a lot more than nothing. Dean said that The Shield made him weaker, not stronger, and being Rollins’ backup didn’t help either. He talked about regretting his actions before denying the remorse. He hinted at how Seth treated him like a lunatic all the time.

There was a lot there, but the gist is that Ambrose felt like he was an overlooked, underappreciated, undervalued member of the group who never got as much out of the group as he put into it. And Ambrose is poised to become a top heel once we get on the other side of Survivor Series. Hopefully, it will come to fruition.


4. Elias Looks Strong In Defeat

elias samson bobby lashley
WWE.com

Whenever WWE does instantaneous 50/50 booking, you immediately have to cringe.

But Monday, we saw Elias shine throughout his entire segment: before, during and after his match against Bobby Lashley. Elias took Lio Rush to task, feigning a call to Child Protective Services about Lio being a 10-year-old kidnapped and forced to point to Lashley’s muscles.

And then Rush got his revenge, preventing Elias from getting back in the ring, giving Lashley the countout win to be the fifth member of Team Raw at Survivor Series. But that joy didn’t last, as the troubadour attacked Lio and then managed to stay ahead of both Lashley and Rush.

It stinks that Elias won’t be on the Raw squad, but he continued to show growth as a babyface, and fans continued to respond to him throughout the entire segment.


3. Braun Won’t Back Down

Braun Strowman Raw
WWE.com

It’s a rare sight to see a wrestler refuse to cower at Stephanie McMahon’s feet, so when someone stands their ground, they deserve immediate praise.

Braun Strowman declared that he was done chasing acting GM Baron Corbin and was going to hold Raw hostage until he got what he wanted. Stephanie tried to refocus him onto Survivor Series, but Braun didn’t take the bait, yelling at Steph that he didn’t give a damn about brand supremacy.

He then “negotiated” with McMahon for a Universal Championship match and a bout against Corbin in the future, with the Raw commissioner agreeing to his demands in exchange for helping lead Team Raw at Survivor Series.

It was an effective powerplay by Strowman, so kudos to him.


2. Top Heel

drew mcintyre dolph ziggler
WWE.com

Given the end of Raw last week and his promo this week, it’s pretty clear that Drew McIntyre is being positioned as the top heel on Monday nights.

The Scottish Psychopath unleashed a scathing promo that peaked with him declaring that Raw is his show now, and that he would destroy anyone displaying weakness. He laid into Finn Balor, and then went a step further in saying he wouldn’t lower himself to Balor’s level – but Dolph Ziggler would.

That little comment could be a telltale sign – and the announcers even mentioned it – that Drew could be preparing to jettison Dolph for being weak. The fact he lost to Finn couldn’t have helped his case.

Regardless, McIntyre is definitely being positioned for big things, and it looks like the right call.


1. The Man

Becky Lynch Raw
WWE.com

It really says something when the biggest star on Raw Monday night was the SmackDown Women’s Champion.

Becky Lynch led an all-out assault on the Raw women’s division Monday, first attacking champ Ronda Rousey backstage, then marching to the ring to provide a distraction so the SmackDown women’s division could attack.

During the melee, Becky got busted open hardway, leading to her to continuing the assault with a bloody face, hands and arms (as she had to repeatedly wipe away the blood). The result was a phenomenal visual you just don’t get to see in the women’s ranks or even in WWE at large today.

Lynch took out a charging Rousey with a steel chair, then preened around the ring and paraded into the crowd – all while still sporting a bloody face. It seriously was a fantastic moment that had fans openly chanting for Becky even more enthusiastically. To say that Becky Lynch “arrived” Monday night might not be an understatement.

It’s tempting to say that WWE has to hear that and capitalize on her ungodly popularity right now, but hey, it’s WWE.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.