8 WWE Commentators Vince McMahon Soured On
No WWE commentator is safe from the wrath of Vince McMahon.
WWE goes through commentators as frequently as Vince McMahon changes his mind regarding creative plans, and very rarely does the company settle on a single announce team for one of their shows for a substantial amount of time.
Commentators can be called up from NXT and then demoted back down to developmental in an instant, as well as be switched from SmackDown Live to Raw and vice versa. Obviously, some announcers are better than others, but at the end of the day, it's merely a matter of how high officials (and specifically Vince McMahon) are on them.
There have been some pretty deplorable commentators over the years in WWE that were around for a lot longer than they should have been because they had support from the boss. In other cases, talented talkers have been close to becoming the next voice of WWE before one mistake cost them their spot behind the booth.
Either way, McMahon ultimately soured on them all, regardless of whether they deserved to be or not. It's no secret McMahon plays favorites and has pet projects of his own, even on commentary, and the following eight announcers are prime examples of individuals who were at one time favored by the boss -before Vince became disenchanted with them.
8. Jim Ross
Not even one of the greatest wrestling commentators of all-time is safe from the evil Irish madman Vince McMahon and his controlling ways.
Jim Ross will forever be known for his amazing body of work as a commentator in the 20 years he spent in WWE from 1993 to 2013. While McMahon recognized he was among the best in the world, that didn't stop him from embarrassing the Oklahoma native at almost every turn, including in his hometown on more than a handful of occasions.
From drafting him to SmackDown without prior notice to mocking his Bell's Palsy, McMahon hasn't been shy in bullying Ross on air, despite knowing his worth to the company's commentary team. By 2013, Ross, still in the prime of his career, was hardly being utilized and was eventually sent to the back of the classroom even though Ric Flair was the one talking.
Instead, McMahon thought it was time to move on from the J.R. era and start grooming new broadcasters for the future. That's all fine and dandy, and Ross is back with WWE as of this writing - but think about all the classic matches he could have called from the last few years had Vince put his personal animosity toward Ross aside.
7. Joey Styles
Regardless of what you think about his commentary skills, you have to commend Joey Styles' ability to call complete shows by himself during his time in ECW, serving as both the play-by-play guy and the color commentator.
WWE, on the other hand, must not have thought too highly of his skills; it wasn't until ECW One Night Stand 2005 that he was finally brought in by the company. Needless to say, he added a ton to that event from behind the booth, and was hired as a full-time commentator for Raw soon after. It was reported that he had signed a five year deal to call the action on Raw, so WWE must have had faith he would be a suitable long-term replacement for Jim Ross.
However, he did not call most of the Raw matches at WrestleMania 22, and ultimately he was moved from the Raw announce team to the ECW announce team by mid-2006. The move made sense at the time, given his ties to the extreme brand, but it was apparent he was not long for the job.
In April 2008, Styles was removed from WWE TV all together and replaced by Mike Adamle (remember that name), instead working with WWE.com.
So much for being the future voice of Raw, huh?
6. Todd Grisham
Unlike Jim Ross and Joey Styles, Todd Grisham was never all that good as an announcer in WWE. In fact, he was downright deplorable at times. Nothing against him, though, as he was merely trying to do his job to the best of his ability, but there was never anything special about him or his skills behind the booth.
Nevertheless, he enjoyed a lengthy stay in WWE from 2004 to 2011 and served as a commentator on pretty much every brand: Raw, SmackDown, ECW, Superstars, and Heat. He started out as a backstage interviewer, but over time, he slowly made his way up the ladder, despite never really improving.
At one point, he called the action on SmackDown alongside Jim Ross, and if you aren't rising to the occasion under the learning tree of one of the greats, that job probably isn't for you. Vince McMahon quickly realized that and demoted him to NXT. He left for greener pastures at ESPN in 2011, where he spent five years before becoming a play-by-play commentator for UFC.
To answer your question, no, he is no better an announcer now than he was a decade ago.
5. Rich Brennan
Rich Brennan started out every bit as generic as your typical WWE announcer (see: Tom Phillips and Vic Joseph), but at least he was passionate about the product based off his tenure as a commentator in Booker T's Reality of Wrestling promotion. He debuted on NXT in late 2014 and grew into the role of the voice of NXT quite nicely.
After thriving there throughout 2015, he was eventually promoted to SmackDown as its lead play-by-play guy that August, essentially switching roles with Phillips. He did solid work on the blue brand in the months that followed, and he likely would have continued to do well, but WWE signing world-renowned commentator Mauro Ranallo at the onset of 2016 spelled the end of Brennan's stint on SmackDown.
Instead of being brought back down to NXT, Brennan remained on the main roster, just serving as an interviewer on Raw and SmackDown. The writing was on the wall for him even then, and by April 2016, he was gone from the company. Here's hoping he returns down the road because he did show promise before having the rug ripped right from underneath him.
4. Josh Mathews
It's amazing that, for as long as Josh Mathews was with WWE (nearly a dozen years), he never once came close to clinching that sacred spot as the voice of WWE.
You have to believe Michael Cole and possibly others thought he would one day assume that role, but it just wasn't meant to be. Perhaps that was due to how he was simply an average announcer at best, and an obnoxious one at worst, and there was a reason why he was tucked away on ECW and Superstars for so many years.
Vince McMahon must have liked what he saw (er, heard) in 2010, however, when Mathews replaced Todd Grisham as SmackDown's play-by-play commentator. Unfortunately, he and Michael Cole were an absolutely atrocious pairing, especially considering Cole was a heel at the time and Mathews often spurred him on.
Throughout Cole's feud with Jerry Lawler in 2011, Mathews often worked as a color commentator on Raw - and even called a good chunk of WrestleMania 27. That was his chance to shine. and he fell flat. Unsurprisingly, he was booted from the booth not long after.
Matthews largely worked as a backstage interviewer until his release in June 2014.
3. Mauro Ranallo
It isn't often that WWE acquires big names from the broadcasting world for its commentary team, but they made headlines when they signed Mauro Ranallo in early 2016 to serve as the play-by-play commentator for SmackDown. This was in an effort to give the blue brand a fresh feel with an established voice, and in one night, he made an immediate impact and found instant chemistry with Jerry Lawler.
Even before the Brand Split was instituted in the summer of 2016, SmackDown was fairly entertaining for the first half of the year with its exciting in-ring action, and Ranallo played a major role in that. In addition to his enthusiasm for the product, the best part about his commentary work was that he didn't feel as cookie-cutter as everyone else in the company.
One can only assume that was why he was brought in to begin with, but it was later revealed that was why Vince McMahon lost interest in him, too. The more time passed, the more Ranallo bled into the background, and by March 2017, he opted not to return to SmackDown after one of the year's more divisive controversies.
Thankfully, he has since re-signed with WWE and can now be heard on NXT, but you'd think Vince would have done everything in his power to keep him on their second biggest show, not allow JBL to constantly berate him and force him to leave.
2. Mike Adamle
Mike Adamle came across as larger-than-life when hosting American Gladiators, and similar to Mauro Ranallo, he had a pretty big reputation before coming to WWE. Unlike Ranallo, however, he failed to adapt to the WWE style upon arriving in the company in early 2008.
It was all downhill from there.
The weird thing is that, despite failing at every job he had, WWE continued to promote him to more prominent roles. After becoming notorious for always botching people's names as an interviewer, he became the play-by-play commentator for ECW. He then bombed at that gig, but for whatever reason, Vince McMahon remained confident that he could be a valuable asset to them. Thus, he was soon appointed the new Raw General Manager.
The "Adamle Era" is better off forgotten, but in the company's defense, perhaps they were simply trying to make it feel like they weren't wasting the obscene amount of money they were paying him. That didn't last long, and once Vince McMahon realized the Adamle experiment was a miserable failure, he pulled the plug on it and fired him in November 2008.
1. Matt Striker
There is something to be said for being extremely knowledge about the WWE product as well as passionate, but Matt Striker's overbearing personality sometimes led him to becoming a bit of a nuisance behind the booth.
Interestingly enough, that was exactly why Vince McMahon was so high on him for a few years. Striker traded in his wrestling boots for a headset in late 2008 and quickly flourished in the role on the ECW brand. It was when he arrived on SmackDown in 2009 that he became almost unbearable to listen to, but at least his fun facts about the industry were always a treat.
His time on the blue brand came to a screeching halt when he used some wrestling lingo while calling the 2011 Royal Rumble match ("This is a mark out moment! I'm marking out, bro!"), which is obviously a big no-no. He spent his remaining two years in WWE as a host for NXT and backstage interviewer, receiving his release in June 2013.
It's unknown as to whether McMahon ever saw him as the future of WWE commentary, but as a result of that Rumble incident, we'll never known what he would have amounted to there.