8 WWE Stars Who Need To Go Back To NXT
Sometimes the grass isn't greener.
NXT has to be considered the biggest success story in WWE over the last few years.
With a state of the art training facility, world class trainers and a weekly show on the WWE Network which is arguably better than either Raw or Smackdown, NXT has provided a great base for WWE to produce the stars of the future.
For a developmental wrestler working in NXT, it's the ultimate dream to finally get that call up to the main roster and be handed your chance to work for the fabled WWE.
However, for every Seth Rollins, Kevin Owens or Charlotte, there's also a heck of a lot of superstars who find that the grass really isn't greener once they're thrown into the strict TV environment of Raw or Smackdown.
And when you look at some of the wasted talent on this list, you start to think that maybe it isn't such a bad thing if Shinsuke Nakamura stays put in Full Sail for a little while longer (seriously, Vince if you screw him up!)
The likes of Tyson Kidd, Emma and Zack Ryder all benefited from returning to the developmental territory for a short while to reboot their characters and show off their talent in the ring. Many other current main roster stars would profit from a similar strategy.
So with another bound to be brilliant NXT TakeOver on the horizon this weekend, we've taken a look at eight talented WWE superstars who might benefit from heading back to NXT for a while.
8. The Ascension
How did WWE ruin these guys so badly, so quickly?
The Ascension are still, to this day, the longest reigning NXT tag team champions in the company's history and the most dominant team ever to perform in Full Sail.
Now, sure, that was during a very different period in NXT, when the tag division was nowhere near as strong as it is now but it still remains an incredible achievement.
And standing at 364-days it's unlikely to beaten by any team anytime soon; although we're sure the Revival will give it a good old go.
Konor and Viktor seemed like a can't miss opportunity to have a classic big guy dominant tag team on the main roster, yet WWE instead ensured that these guys were doomed from the start.
Debuting wearing face paint and looking like a knock off Legion of Doom/Demolition combo, they then began to tear down classic tag teams in their promos, which only conspired to show how the Ascension were not on the level of those legends.
Despite their cool look and awesome 'Fall of Man' finishing move, it took less than a month before Konor and Viktor were treated like a joke by the crowd; a sad state of affairs for a team so dominant in Florida.
A return to the developmental ranks would only benefit the Ascension at this point and give them a chance to reboot their characters. Plus, the opportunity to see these guys lock up with Dash & Dawson, Ciampa & Gargano, TM-61, Strong & Aries, and the Authors of Pain seems like a no brainer to us.
7. Dana Brooke
A simple case of a wrestler being called up to the main roster too quickly.
While her peers Alexa Bliss, Carmella and Nia Jax were given the time to learn and improve in NXT, meaning all three are now killing it on the main roster, Dana was very much just thrown to the wolves.
Brought in as Charlotte's sidekick to help her cheat to beat Natalya, Dana has a great look and plays the irritating heel heater role brilliantly.
However, in the ring, she still has a way to go.
Her brief feud with Bayley should have helped to bring out the best in her but the matches were dull and lifeless, with the finish to one of their Raw bouts completely screwed up when Dana failed to put her feet on the ropes for the dirty pin as planned.
It also doesn't help matters that, much like all of the female wrestlers outside of Charlotte, Sasha Banks and Bayley on the Raw roster, Dana is pretty lost in the shuffle on the big show.
During her time in NXT, Dana played the heel sidekick role to a tee alongside Emma and always came across as a threat at ringside. On Raw, sadly, she's lost her shine.
More time in NXT to improve her ring work and character would benefit Dana greatly.
6. Neville
Oh, Neville. Things should have been so much better for the likeable Geordie flyer when he finally got the call up to WWE.
Coming in with a big reputation from the independent scene, the former Pac made a real impact in NXT, capturing the imaginations of the fans with his spectacular athleticism and high flying arsenal.
The longest reigning NXT champion (until Finn Balor came along), Neville's feud with Sami Zayn over the title was absolute fire, with the two producing an absolute classic at NXT TakeOver: [R]Evolution in December 2014.
He debuted on Raw with a bunch of hype (and without a first name), running through Curtis Axel in a short match which was basically an excuse for him to show off all his cool moves, especially the Red Arrow, to a new audience.
However, within weeks, the exciting Neville was just another guy, not helped by the fact that he got no mic time or any opportunity to develop his character on the main roster. Doing awesome moves is something which can only get you so far.
It seemed like things would all change when the cruiserweight division was brought to Raw. As an established main roster superstar, Neville would have been the perfect guy to be one of the figureheads of the new division and yet he's stuck making cameo appearances in multi-man matches and working house shows.
A performer this unique and impressive should not be so stale. Neville needs to go back to NXT and tear it up with Nakamura, Joe, Aries and Roode.
The treatment of Neville also makes you fear for the future of Ricochet/Prince Puma if the fellow sensational high flyer does sign with the company in 2017 as is rumoured.
5. The Vaudevillains
Aiden English and Simon Gotch were given a decent push when they first came up to the main roster and it looked at first like they might do very well indeed.
They debuted strong, defeating the Lucha Dragons on Smackdown, before getting to the finals of the No 1 contendership tournament for the WWE tag team titles against Enzo & Cass.
While that match ended disappointingly quickly when Enzo Amore was legitimately knocked out, the accidental finish only made the Vaudevillains look even more dangerous and despicable.
A feud with The New Day over the tag titles followed but after they came up short at Extreme Rules and Money in the Bank, English and Gotch were sent to the back of the line again.
And sadly, since they were drafted to Smackdown, the Vaudevillains have barely done anything.
Admittedly, the thing which seems to have stalled their momentum is the very real fight that Simon Gotch got into with Sin Cara backstage, and it could be that the team are being punished for that indiscretion.
However, if WWE have no immediate plans for the team, then NXT would be the best place for them.
The Vaudevillains gimmick is still one of the coolest and most unique on the entire roster, and there is a whole lot more that WWE could be doing with it through vignettes, promos and unique match stipulations.
Some time in NXT working with the tremendous tag teams of Full Sail would give the Vaudevillains a much needed boost.
4. Bo Dallas
You wouldn't know it now, but Bo Dallas was quite brilliant during his reign as NXT champion.
As a bland babyface character, Bo Dallas had completely lost the respect of the audience and fans would often literally turn their back on his matches to express their displeasure.
In classic NXT fashion - and something we really wish the main roster would do more (we're looking at you Roman Reigns) - the writers harnessed the negative crowd reaction and slowly turned Bo to the dark side.
Playing a character who was oblivious to the fact that the audience hated him, he began to use the exposed turnbuckle to secure victory and throw tantrums when he didn't get his own way. Soon after losing the NXT championship to Adrian Neville, Bo was booted out of NXT.
When he appeared on the main roster shortly after WrestleMania XXX, Bo seemed to be channeling a similar sort of character, citing the power of positivity and how people should 'Bo-lieve', yet displaying heel tendencies and cheating to win.
However, pretty soon, despite how over the gimmick was with the audience, Bo was just another guy, losing to just about everyone and basically being the butt of the joke for whichever WWE legend was in town that week.
The formation of the Social Outcasts should have been the catalyst for Bo to make more strides on the main roster but WWE mostly squandered the gimmick. Nowadays, he's desperately fighting for any TV time he can get on Raw.
We Bo-lieve in Bo and we wish WWE did too. Some time back in NXT would remind people how good he is.
3. Kalisto
Kalisto is another talented worker who could be one of the stars of the Raw Cruiserweight division, but instead he's been thrown onto Smackdown Live with relatively little of note to do.
The former Samuray del Sol worked primarily in tag matches in NXT, first alongside El Local (aka. a masked Ricardo Rodriguez) and later Sin Cara.
Kalisto and Sin Cara, as the Lucha Dragons, became the team to end the 364 day reign of the Ascension and the duo's high flying tag team style gained them many fans.
They were soon both on the main roster and got off to a flying start, with Kalisto capturing the imaginations of the audience with his unique offence.
A single's run followed as he captured the United States championship and it wasn't long before the Rey Mysterio comparisons started. To be fair, Kalisto certainly has the kind of cool look and the connection with the younger members of the WWE Universe that made Rey such a major star.
And yet, WWE seem unable or unwilling to fully harness that into a significant run for Kalisto on the main roster. Since he dropped the U.S. title to Rusev, Kalisto has done little of note, besides losing to Baron Corbin on house shows.
Fortunately, things have started to turn around for Kalisto recently, as he's set to challenge Raw's Cruiserweight champ Brian Kendrick at Survivor Series, with the added stipulation that the entire division will move to Smackdown should he win.
In many ways, that would be the best thing for the division and for Kalisto. So when it inevitably doesn't happen and Kalisto is lost in the shuffle again, a return to NXT would do him the world of good.
2. Apollo Crews
Another superstar who was probably called up to the main roster too early.
Apollo was going great guns in NXT, with the unique combination of power wrestling and high flying that had made him stand out as Uhaa Nation on the indie scene translating well to Full Sail.
His matches with Finn Balor, Tyler Breeze, Baron Corbin and Tye Dillinger had him on a fantastic upward trajectory and most were predicting that once Balor was inevitably called up to the main roster, Crews would be one of the favourites for a run with the NXT championship.
Instead, Apollo actually beat Balor to Raw, making his main roster debut the night after WrestleMania 32 in a great moment.
The problem is, that would have actually been better had it been a one-off showing and Apollo had returned to NXT afterwards. You see, WWE have invested next to no time in developing Crews' character which means he is basically just an athletically gifted and super smiley babyface on Raw.
Besides a brief run at the Intercontinental title against the Miz in the summer, Apollo has done little of note on the main roster.
He's supremely talented in the ring but Crews would really benefit from some more time in NXT to hone his character and his promo skills, both of which will help him get over with the WWE crowd in the long run.
1. Tyler Breeze
How did WWE get it so wrong with this guy?
With a fantastic character and renowned as one of the most reliable hands in NXT, Tyler Breeze had a great run in Full Sail. The fans loved his narcissistic heel character and knew he could be relied on to produce great matches on a regular basis.
A selfie loving 'Ravishing' Rick Rude for the modern era, Breeze was something of a big deal in NXT - if you wonder how respected he was, remember that he was chosen to face the legendary Jushin 'Thunder' Liger when the Japanese superstar made the trip to Florida.
In Full Sail, Breeze had a defined character and was given plenty of promo time to develop it.
Sadly, when he was brought up to the main roster, it's clear that the WWE writers had no such plan for how to get him over with the audience. Poor Tyler was simply sent out there with his entrance and selfie stick, while those backstage hoped for the best.
Breeze could be one of the best guys on the roster right now; imagine him feuding with the likes of The Miz or Dolph Ziggler, for instance, over the Intercontinental championship. Instead, he's a joke, thrown into a tag team with the similarly underutilised Fandango because the Smackdown writers simply have no clue what to do with him.
It's a sorry state of affairs for such a talented wrestler. He could be a star again in NXT.