9 Best WWE Attitude Era Gimmick Changes
Fake MMA fighter ain't easy, but pimpin' sure is.
Yup, we're still talking about. Fifteen full years since it ended, we're still examining, debating and reminiscing about the much-vaunted Attitude Era, that incredible period between (roughly) mid-1997 and March 2001, where WWE reversed their fortunes by throwing caution to the wind, accentuating the sex and violence that young adults craved to turn the tide in the Monday Night War.
While we often look back at the era with rose-tinted glasses, choosing to neglect the fact that not everything was first-rate television and that a lot of it has actually aged rather poorly, a good portion of WWE's Attitude Era is nonetheless solid gold.
No matter how many times you see footage of Tyson and Austin squaring off, Mick Foley flying from the top of the Cell or DX 'invading' Nitro, their power to compel, shock and entertain remains.
The Attitude Era gave birth to some of sports entertainment's most enduring characters, too. Whether it was porn star Val Venis, do-gooder Kurt Angle or the bizarre Goldust, gimmicks back then certainly stood out and made an impact. They got over.
Of course, those winning gimmicks were given to wrestlers coming into the company. Others were not so fortunate and had to shed the stink of another poor persona before they could forge a connection with the rabid audience.
There were many notable positive gimmick tweaks and changes during the Attitude Era, but these are, for my money, the nine most effective.
9. Rikishi
Solofa Fatu Jr. actually went missing for a major part of the Attitude Era, simply because WWE had no idea what to do for him. A previous run as one half of The Headshrinkers tag-team (1992 - 95) had been fruitful, but once the team split he was saddled with a bunch of shoddy gimmicks that did nothing but derail his career.
First there was so-called 'Make a Difference' Fatu, who encouraged the youth of America to stay in school, stay away from crime and help to improve the communities they lived in. You can't fault the message, but the presentation was so passé and fans didn't really engage with the character.
Make a Difference Fatu was quickly dropped and repackaged as 'The Sultan', a masked wrestler who never spoke because he had supposedly had his tongue cut out. It was an improvement, but only just. The presence of managers The Iron Sheik and Bob Backlund made the whole thing appear even more anachronistic, though.
This was just when WWE were starting to push boundaries and get a little 'attitude', so a tongueless savage flanked by past-it stars of yesteryear didn't quite cut the mustard.
After sliding further and further down the card The Sultan disappeared from WWE television screens just as the Attitude Era was hotting up. Fatu was sent to Dory Funk Jr's training facility to keep in ring shape while creative came up with something new for him. His newest guise, Rikishi, debuted in the summer of '99, and this one was a winner.
With his massive frame, bleach-blonde hair and revealing thong ring attire, the Sumo-inspired character was an instant attention-grabber. Joining with the similarly directionless Scott 'Scotty 2 Hotty' Taylor and Brian 'Grandmaster Sexay' Christopher to form Too Cool was a masterstroke, as the three men went from anonymous and about to be released to one of the most over acts on the roster.
8. The Godfather
Charles Wright had to try and try and try again until he found the gimmick that suited him. He debuted in WWE in 1991 as 'Sir Charles', which wasn't really much of a gimmick (it was essentially Wright wearing some lavish robes) and then moved on to portray Papa Shango, a character that just about sums up the company during the cartoon era.
The gimmick was silly and angles such as the one where he cast a spell on Ultimate Warrior, making him puke black sludge, were an embarrassment to most wrestling fans. Wright left for a while and came back as Kama, an odd pseudo-MMA fighter with a flattop and a disjointed style. It was hard to define, and didn't get over.
A move to the Nation of Domination as Kama Mustafa wasn't so great, either. Wright finally got over as 'The Godfather', a fun-loving pimp who implored the audience to 'light a fatty'. The fact that Wright - who legitimately owned and operated a Las Vegas strip club - came out surrounded by a gaggle of scantily-clad 'hoes' didn't hurt his popularity with the 18-35 male demographic, either.
The Godfather was never going to be a WWE Champion or anything like that, but he consistently garnered one of the loudest reactions on any show he was performing on. No easy feat back then, I can assure you (and one of the primary reasons the gimmick was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame this year).
When WWE turned him heel and had him join the holier-than-thou Right to Censor, Wright hated it, because he knew the Godfather gimmick worked so well.
7. Lita
Amy Dumas made her way to WWE via Mexico, where she travelled in 1998 after watching Rey Mysterio wrestle on WCW Nitro, and then ECW, where she worked as 'Miss Congeniality'. Dumas' first role in WWE was as one of The Godfather's hos but after that she was given a more prominent role as high-flying Mexican sensation Essa Rios' valet.
Rios was an undercard guy, wrestling primarily on weekend shows Jakked and Heat, but Dumas, performing as Lita, caught the eye. Not content to just stand at ringside and cheer Essa on, Lita would mimic Rios' moonsault on his downed opponent in the post-match.
The high point of her partnership with the former Papi Chulo was a short programme with Chyna and Eddie Guerrero, but it was clear that the flame-haired diva was outgrowing the man she escorted down to the ring. Soon after scrapping with Latino Heat and his Mamacita, Lita split from the one-time WWE Lightheavyweight Champion.
Aligning herself with real-life friends The Hardy Boys, Lita ditched the silver and metallic red spandex and began dressing in a more casual manner, rocking the Hardys' baggy pants (with whale tail always on display) and crop tops. She also began adding more moves to her arsenal, surprising opponents with a hurricanrana or a plancha.
Lita grew in the role and was one of the most popular performers of the year. Considering she started out the year as the second to a go-nowhere cruiserweight (regardless of how talented Rios was), the gimmick change has to be considered a massive improvement.
6. Eddie Guerrero
When Eddie Guerrero showed up in WWE in January 2000 along with Chris Benoit, Perry Saturn and Dean Malenko, he was already one of the most respected in-ring performers in the world. Guerrero had great matches everywhere he went, from AAA to New Japan Pro Wrestling to ECW and WCW, earning a reputation as a real wrestler's wrestler.
When The Radicalz turned up on Vince's doorstep, the WWE chairman (along with President of Talent Relations Jim Ross) felt as though Benoit was the one with the most potential to become a main event player/star. Hence why The Crippler received a downside guarantee of $400,000 per annum, $150,000 more than his fellow defectors.
Eddie's WWE career started poorly when he dislocated his elbow performing his patented Frog Splash in his very first match. While out on the sidelines, he began a feud with Chyna. The night after the two clashed in a six-person tag match at WrestleMania 2000, The 9th Wonder of the World turned on Chris Jericho and sided with Eddie.
It was the start of a wonderful partnership, as Eddie turned from vicious heel to fun-loving, comedic babyface. Indeed, he was a riot in backstage segments, even if they were a little stereotypical. He began to stand out from the pack, able to carry his side in the ring but also provide genuine entertainment in interviews or vignettes or whatnot.
Eddie's transition into 'Latino Heat' really helped him become a star in the land of the giants. Had he stayed the course and remained a straight wrestler without any real character or gimmick, it's probably he would have ended up getting lost in the shuffle.
5. The New Age Outlaws
The Road Dogg and Billy Gunn looked liable to be cut at any moment when they were thrust together at the tail end of 1997 and essentially told to get over or get lost.
Gunn had enjoyed some success as a member of the Smokin' Gunns tag team, winning the WWE Tag Team Titles on three occasions. Since splitting from partner Bart, though, he'd floundered. A turn as Rockabilly, country music protege of The Honky Tonk Man did him no favours whatsoever.
Road Dogg, meanwhile, had enjoyed a gig as Jeff Jarrett's Roadie but languished in the undercard when J-E-Double F split for WCW. In 1997, 'The Real Double J' Jess James and Rockabilly engaged in a feud that precisely nobody wanted to see. Realising they were fighting an uphill battle and that their careers were going nowhere, James suggested onscreen that he and Billy boy team up.
Billy agreed, blasting Honky with his own guitar and never looking back. As the Outlaws (soon to be New Age), 'Bad A*s' Billy Gunn and Road Dogg were allowed to go out there and express themselves, running down their opponents and spouting off catchphrases. Their we-don't-give-a-sh*t attitude, complete with wearing officially-licensed South Park apparel, helped them connect with the rabid Attitude Era audience.
The duo went from going nowhere to being the most over tag team on the roster, shifting a tonne of merchandise along the way.
4. Hardcore Holly
When Bob Holly received his WWF contract in 1994, he thought he was being ribbed. The name his employers wanted him to wrestle under was 'Sparky Plugg'. Holly, a genuine race car enthusiast, was wrestling under a racing car driver gimmick, which was completely in fitting with the occupational-gimmick-obsessed Titan.
Tough guy Holly would cringe and squirm whenever he'd have to reveal his name to members of the general public and, inside the ring, he was struggling, too. A polished performer, Holly was tasked with getting other members of the roster over and rarely did he win matches himself.
Holly was repackaged in February of 1998 as 'Bombastic Bob', a member of the New Midnight Express team. Holly teamed with 'Bodacious' Bart Gunn and the duo were managed by former Midnights second Jim Cornette. The act elicited little more than the sound of crickets. In an era of Stone Cold Steve Austin, The Rock and DX, the tired 80s retread was understandably met with indifference if not outright derision.
After competing in the ill-conceived Brawl for All Tournament, Holly was thrown together with Al Snow and 2 Cold Scorpio, collectively known as the J.O.B Squad, a reference to their roles as perennial losers. The gimmick lasted a few months before Snow and Holly began breaking out on their own.
Shaving off his thinning mullet, hitting the gym like a man possessed and wrestling predominantly in hardcore matches, the former Sparky Plug was rechristened Hardcore Holly. The gimmick and attitude change were a major improvement and meant that Holly would be a fixture for the rest of 1999 and into 2000.
3. The APA
Like the New Age Outlaws, Bradshaw and Farooq were two singles wrestlers that were going nowhere fast. Both men were well-liked by management and certainly well-respected backstage, but they're gimmicks were hindering them. They, like the Outlaws, needed each other.
Justin 'Hawk' Bradshaw's mountain man schtick was impressing nobody when he showed up in 1995. He wasn't pinned or made to submit on television for the better part of a year, but he wasn't exactly beating anyone noteworthy, either. The character lost a lot of steam and was old news by the end of 1996.
In early 1997, Bradshaw teamed up with veteran Barry Windham to form the 'New Blackjacks' but when big Baz's injury woes got worse, the team was quietly split up, with Bradshaw becoming a singles wrestler. He bounced around the midcard thereafter, until he was teamed up with another fellow drifter.
Ron Simmons, former NWA Champion, was brought into WWE as Farooq Asad, something of a gladiator figure (complete with ridiculous blue helmet). Understandably annoyed with having to don the silly garb, he then went on to form the Nation of Islam-inspired Nation of Domination, a black power stable that cut pretty close to the bone.
Unfortunately for Farooq, he was supplanted as leader by The Rock, who himself was finding his feet after a rotten run as blue chipper Rocky Maivia. Kicked out of his own group, he found himself teaming with Bradshaw not long afterwards. Now known as The Acolytes, they became members of The Undertaker's Ministry of Darkness.
Once that angle had run its course, the Acolytes became the APA, a protection service for fellow wrestlers. They looked so much more at ease drinking beer, smoking cigars and beating people up for cash than they did performing under the lame gimmicks they'd been given over the previous few years.
2. Al Snow
What does everybody want? A gimmick that doesn't suck! What does everybody need? Creative freedom to express themselves!
Al Snow had a pretty tough time of it during his first stint in WWE. After cultivating a strong reputation as a superior worker on the independent scene, he was hired and then sandbagged with a couple of lame duck gimmicks that never really had a hope of working.
The first was Avatar, a blatant ripoff of FMW's Hayabusa. His routine of walking to the ring without a mask, putting a mask on to wrestle and then removing it after the match did little to inspire punters and so WWE changed tact. Enter Shinobi, a 'ninja assassin' that had 'opening match jobber' written all over it.
Another gimmick change soon followed, with Snow performing as 'Leif Cassidy', new tag team partner of Marty Jannetty in the 'New Rockers'. Similarly to the 'New Midnight Express', fans didn't care about the tandem, which was a poor substitute for the awesome original.
After exhausting his options in WWE, Snow was sent to ECW (the two organisations had a talent-trading agreement at the time). There, Snow came up with a new persona. Bringing a mannequin's head to the ring - which he talked to during the match - Snow was portrayed as being unhinged, years of jobbing in WWE having tipped him over the edge. It was a hit, and Snow quickly went from afterthought to ECW main eventer.
WWE were watching and they were also impressed, drafting Snow back and having him be one of the featured members of the hardcore division. Snow's personality change helped him get back to the majors when, odds are, he would have been left in ECW had he not done something quick.
1. Mr. McMahon
Sometimes in wrestling the greatest things happen simply by accident. A million-dollar catchphrase can result from an off-the-cuff remark. A devastating finishing maneuver can come about due to a fortuitous botch. And, sometimes, a winning character can catch fire due to some very real behind-the-scenes business.
Such was the case with the creation of Mr. McMahon, who became the most despised heel in the wrestling world in the wake of the Montreal Screwjob. After being outed as the man behind the most controversial episode in sports entertainment history, Vince had no choice but to embrace the jeers and become an on-screen performer.
It's not like he could remain a ringside commentator/interviewer after the 1997 Survivor Series. That had been Vince's role until then, but Montreal changed all of that. Incredibly, Vince thought he would be embraced as the babyface in the aftermath of it all, looked at as the noble promoter saving his company from a power-mad tyrant.
Obviously wrestling fans had a little more sympathy for the man who had just had his legacy p*ssed on after thirteen years of tireless service.
As 1998 wore on, McMahon began inserting himself more and more into the storylines, hell-bent on stopping the renegade Stone Cold Steve Austin from ruining the image of his company. Vince was a revelation in the role, hamming it up with glee and constantly putting his body on the line for the sake of the business.
It was a far cry from the guffawing announcer who didn't know the proper names for about half of the wrestling holds or moves he was attempting to call.