9 Live Observations From WWE WrestleMania 38 Night 2

WWE fumbles the follow-up for the second year in a row, even when Steve Austin almost saves the day.

Stone Cold Steve Austin
WWE.com

It's still somewhat hard to parse the events of WrestleMania 38 Night 1.

On an evening where WWE structured a card similarly to how NJPW might put it all together, an AEW Executive Vice President was confirmed to have left his post for the buzz of being a Superstar once more and Stone Cold Steve Austin got in the squared circle for an honest-to-god-holy-sh*t-the-bell-actually-rung main event match against Kevin Owens, everybody left the Dallas megastructure with a sense that they'd witnessed pro wrestling history books ripped up before their very eyes.

If either night had a chance of doing this, it was the first one. Tonight's event was to be leveraged heavily on the shoulders of Brock Lesnar snd Roman Reigns and their winner-take-all main event. Could the company survive this up-and-down undercard on the good will earned last night. Would fans have the patience for it, not least if they'd been up late the night before toasting all the good times from the monumental event they'd just seen?

The night would ultimate decide for itself, though the omens were strange within the first fifteen minutes...

9. Triple H Returns

Triple H Boots
WWE.com

Starting hotter than Night 1, Triple H's unannounced arrival gave WrestleMania's second evening a more WWE-centric start than the Dallas Cowboys cheerleaders had managed to do 24 hours prior.

This meant a lot to a lot of people, not least 'The Game' himself, who cut an emotional figure as he thanked fans for the support during his time off and symbolically left his boots in the ring to confirm a retirement that was sensible and inevitable.

'The King Of Kings' will forever have a complex legacy thanks to a strange route to the top of the industry and a host of absolutely rotten matches at the highest level for a very, very sustained period of time, but try having those long chats with those inside AT&T Stadium. Understandable sentiment notwithstanding, this was a monumental love-in and Hunter's welcome to the show was as good a way as any to kick things off.


8. RK-Bro (c) Vs. The Street Profits Vs. Alpha Academy

Randy Orton Riddle Street Profits
WWE.com

The Randy Orton hot tag, live, is a thing of beauty.

Hot tag, but not a hot take. Nonetheless, this article is about live observations and that’s the main takeaway from RK-Bro and indeed the reason the company have kept the belts on Randy Orton and Riddle instead of expediting their inevitable split.

Other than that, what else was there to discern from this opener?

This match was good throughout and great in places but what can be said about Raw’s version of the 2002 SmackDown Six by this point? Rotations of these and select others in the Monday night doubles division have been having rippers for weeks and this was no different. Orton caught Gable with an RKO as he flew down from the top rope in a spot you can picture but still impresses all the same. Gable Steveson was back again afterwards, but the response to his suplex on Chad Gable was tepid thanks to a limp build the night prior.

Living up to expectations warrants praise, but truthfully the pairings have had better matches on the red brand than on ‘The Grandest Stage’. That happens when you hire tremendous wrestlers but tell nonexistent stories.

More on that later.


7. Bobby Lashley Vs Omos

Bobby Lashley Omos
WWE.com

It was nice to have Bobby Lashley on the WrestleMania card.

‘The All-Mighty’ had such a strong 2021 that this time last year he was unexpectedly chosen to score a victory over heavy WWE Championship match favourite Drew McIntyre. He won the feud conclusively in fact - imagine wins and losses mattering! - and got even more over as a result.

Injury at the worst possible time almost robbed him of this, but it’s a good thing it didn’t. From a rather simplistic idea of this battle of the giants, he may now have be even more over as a top babyface than he was as a heel.

Omos, to his immense credit, was fired up for this too. He hit the ropes like he’d never done before, bumped well enough off the spears and had a quickness he’d clearly wanted to exhibit on the ‘Grandest Stage’.

He’s got a long, long way to go but he can at least claim success in one of wrestling’s most crucial areas - tonight he looked at the lights and got his opponent all the way over.


6. Johnny Knoxville Vs. Sami Zayn

Sami Zayn Wee Man
WWE.com

This went well.

Sami Zayn and Johnny Knoxville worked a prop comedy hardcore match that featured cameos from Jackass favourites and fans stuck with it in spite of malfunctioning kit and the odd hesitation disrupting the flow throughout. Again, this went well.

It didn't electrify (very little did on the entire show, to be honest), but considering it went nearly 15 minutes, the crowd never wavered in their will to help get this over the line. Zayn was fantastic here - his carrying and conducting of the situations placed in front of him was masterful. Wee Man, Chris Pontius and the rest of the Jackass lot made endearing appearances on the side of their best mate, and the giant mouse trap was novel even if it almost entirely f*cked up the finish of the match.

Any later on the card and the crowd might have been less patient, but this was early enough on the show for the audience to assume that the fluff was going to be in short supply elsewhere on the card.


5. Women's Tag Team Fatal Fourway

Sasha Banks
WWE.com

At WrestleMania 35, Sasha Banks found herself on the wrong end of a booking decision that finally forced her away from a job she adored. It had been a long time coming in truth, but a loss that night - or at very least what that loss represented - was enough.

Alongside Bayley, she’d wanted to make the brand new Women’s Tag Team Titles mean something. In defeat, they both knew this was highly unlikely. They knew future contests could be reduced to heatless slogs devoid of investment from either side of the barricade.

Smash cut to.

Look, Banks in particular threw herself into this with such gusto that one has to respect the cause. She desperately wants to get this partnership with Naomi over. Naomi herself was ace. As too were all of the wrestlers in patches, but half of the “77,000” in the building will never live to speak about it thanks to the p*ss or popcorn break they were invited to take by the laziness along the way.

The tower of doom was good, the result was great and the effort was frankly remarkable considering the lack of it from their paymaster. This was precisely a television match and absolutely f*ck all more though. For titles to matter on the 'Grandest Stage', at least something needs to feel a little...grand?


4. Edge Vs. AJ Styles

AJ Styles Edge
WWE.com

Both Edge and AJ Styles have experienced the dreaded feeling of a major WrestleMania match not really capturing the imagination of a massive audience. Both men, more than once, have known that they’re in something that could have been better in another building, or on another night, sludging through a solidly worked but unspectacular outing on WWE’s ‘Grandest Stage’.

And it happened again.

To perhaps view this through the prism of WWE fans only really invested in big visuals or the odd half decent false finish, this was "awesome". The pair generated a near fall or two, and Edge's entrance and exit along new ally Damian Priest gave people enough hope to think they'd seen some sort of quiet classic.

They'll know for sure they didn't when they watch it again. Or if - the thing was overly boring and indulgent despite good hold work and a minimising of the sh*thouse theatrics from Edge. One senses with Priest's defection that this all has further to go. Cheer up, goths, and move on to something new, eh?


3. The New Day Vs Sheamus & Ridge Holland

The New Day
WWE.com

A strange set of circumstances suddenly made this match more of a conversation-starter than it might have been in its original Night One slot.

Cut for time due to all the other things going on, the quartet-plus-Butch were inserted here but couldn't have felt more like an obligation as they raced through their match in a mere 1:40.

The New Day, Sheamus and Ridge Holland would already have been working under something of a cloud thanks to the absence of the beloved Big E. But on a blisteringly hot card that had no time for them on Saturday, that he supersubs were only given one hundred seconds to tell the story felt unnecessarily cruel.

Indulgence of others robbed them on Saturday, while the ineptitude of their bosses did the same the next night. When expectations are set as low as they were for this, it proved an ugly embarrassment that they couldn't clear the bar.

Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods looked amazing in their Big E tribute gear. Let that be the sole takeaway of note in place of anything that happened in the ring.


2. Pat McAfee Vs. Austin Theory / Vince McMahon Vs Pat McAfee

Stone Cold Steve Austin
WWE.com

Pat McAfee is not yet the WWE Champion. But he should be.

Arriving to Seven Nation Army alongside the Dallas Cowboys and wearing the privilege and status one knows all that affords, McAfee was immediately the biggest deal in a ringside area that also included Vince McMahon himself.

A slightly milquetoast match with Theory here followed, but McAfee was dextrous enough to hit all his high spots to get the win before another excuse for Stone Cold Steve Austin to get a gigantic pop was served up. In this case, it was in the form of an horrendous McAfee/McMahon match that the latter won with help from his mew friend. The villains celebrating triggered the glass smashing, and McMahon took a Stunner even worse than the first one he ever absorbed.

The disparity between the live and television presentation was probably at its most cavernous here. Austin was jovial, sincere and funny, not least when the decrepit McMahon flailed and fell into an abysmal Stunner. 65,000+ might have buzzed, but it was too hard to imagine many at-home experiences were having a similar time.


1. Brock Lesnar Vs. Roman Reigns

Roman Reigns Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

On the go-home edition of Monday Night Raw, Roman Reigns invoked memories of Brock Lesnar opening his head up in their controversial WrestleMania 34 main event.

He noted how his family and friends didn’t recognise him. They certainly didn’t acknowledge him, and nor did the crowd that night - the contest was profoundly rejected by the crowd despite the man responsible for the disdain changing the structure and the finish on the day to try and wrong foot them further.

It was, atmospherically, tonally and critically a complete mess.

It turned out to be foreshadowing the eventual quality of their bout.

A lot of generous takes may suggest this was perfectly fine, or predictable in the right way, or important to do simply because gives Reigns his decisive victory over 'The Beast' once and for all but is this even true? They could just decide on the spot to run this back but actually develop the far more interesting strand Reigns' on-screen acting was trying to achieve.

WrestleMania punters left with something of a whimper rather than a roar, and not for the first time, it was because of a Brock Lesnar/Roman Reigns main event.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.