9 Match Star Ratings For AEW Full Gear 2020
More stars for your Bucks.
The build to Full Gear was tremendous, and even the programmes that did not click virtually guaranteed in-ring excellence to compensate.
Jon Moxley and Eddie Kingston built their I Quit match with some of the most raw, emotive promos ever cut on US wrestling television. An ingenious storyline - how could Eddie Kingston quit, when he promised his own mother that he wouldn't? - it was executed with a sense of feeling few other performers have ever been able to engineer. The Kenny Omega Vs. Hangman Page dynamic hadn't even settled into its final form, and it was built over almost a full year of subtle, captivating work. There's long-term storytelling, and there's this.
FTR Vs. The Young Bucks spluttered at the last lap, after months of exceptional slow-burn. The Bucks were more sullen than they were irrepressible tosspots - were they trying to make literal that 2016 dream match, and...why? - but the ankle injury storyline restored, to an extent, the face/heel balance.
The match card and the Dynamites that built it promised something great. Special.
Did Full Gear deliver?
The high resolution broadcast provided by FITE TV complete with unlimited replays can be accessed at a cost of £19.99. Please check for geographic availability.
9. BUY IN: Serena Deeb Vs. Allysin Kay - NWA Women's Championship Match
Serena Deeb is good enough to coach the inexperienced women of AEW to greatness.
Dustin Rhodes receives much credit for his dedicated graft, and it shows, in the evolution of Dr. Britt Baker. But Deeb is fast becoming the most overlooked performer in a generation. She is a sublime technical wrestler.
In a division with output that too often looks cooperative, like there are beats to be followed and not a spell to cast, Deeb is unreal at getting the struggle of pro wrestling over. She took the larger Kay to the mat with some gorgeous and smart chain wrestling early before honing her attack on the hands. The minutiae here was exceptional. Not a millisecond goes by without Deeb working through to victory. Even when she failed to transition into a hold, she still looked like she was going for it, and not breezing through to the next phase of the match. She smacked Kay in the abdomen in an attempt to draw her hands for additional leverage in one example of her sense of detail.
Kay was on form too, playing the impetuous powerhouse, but Jesus Christ is Deeb fantastic at this. The very second Kay left her head prone, Deeb locked her in a front chancery. Getting licks in on Deeb feels like an achievement, such is her level of control.
The roll-throughs; the aggression; the projection of all these qualities: Deeb is great, Kay looked great for finally crashing her to the mat in her offensive phase, and this was a bang-tidy match.
Star Rating: ★★★½
8. Kenny Omega Vs. Hangman Page
A fantastic professional wrestling match, this was as phenomenal for what it wasn't, as much as for what it was.
It wasn't an epic, drawn-out melodramatic war. In a key story beat, one that will inform the future of this long-term legacy rivalry, it was among the shortest singles matches Omega has worked since he became a superstar. It was very stiff - they beat the sh*t out of each other at times - but it wasn't laced with hatred. That day will come. This was business to him. Quite efficient business. How must Page have felt in the aftermath is the sort of subtext only the Elite are capable of folding into their work.
A relentless pulsating sprint of a match worked within the trademark Omega vein, virtually all of this was blinding. The level of thought and attention applied to the work was great. When Omega launched himself from the barricade with a moonsault, Page for a split second looked back to the ring with one eye on the count. Omega's return trajectory caught his eye, and he got flattened. This was an unreal spot because it was as beautiful as it was impactful as it was convincing. You didn't catch the catch. They made it seem like it didn't happen.
Both were on another level, which elevated the story. In this match of two former partners who know one another intimately, the advantage was always so narrow. Omega ducked the Buckshot with heart-stopping timing and accuracy before the thrilling bomb exchange of the finish, which arrived when Page, after countering virtually everything else, had no answer for the One-Winged Angel. He could only claw desperately at Omegas' scalp. He was a way to go, but that's reassuring.
This arc has been so incredible that it's going to create an all-timer of a pop, when one day he kicks out of it.
Star Rating: ★★★★½
7. Orange Cassidy Vs. John Silver
There are two mainstream North American pro wrestling promotions.
Both are fantasy booking-proof.
WWE is fantasy booking-proof because there is no point. They will punish you, and they will exhaust almost every single match combination either before or after it is meant to matter.
AEW is fantasy booking-proof because they do sh*t you can't think of. They encourage their performers to get over on their own watch, and when they do, they get f*cking over.
John Silver - who absolutely would have eaten sh*t, had he gotten over in WWE - ate Orange Cassidy's pockets so that Cassidy couldn't put his hands in them. Because Johnny is Hungiee. It was a tremendous sight gag - the perfect means of illustrating their dynamic - and this was a tremendous match for the slot.
An effervescent mini-banger, Silver absolutely stepped up and proved he belonged on the fairest and most competitive playing field seen in decades. He has this incredible knack of unleashing stiff-as-sh*t, warp-speed combinations to swarm his opponent in the heat of the action, and that's where Cassidy also excels. This was a breathless pop-generator when it peaked. An inspired dynamic built and executed beautifully, there was also a poetic, long-term flair to the finish.
Silver is too explosive and entertaining - the man pulled off a one-handed gorilla press slam! - to not be a breakout babyface. He hinted at his future by failing to execute Mr. Brodie Lee's discus lariat in a magnificent spot of world-building.
Star Rating: ★★★¾
6. Cody Rhodes Vs. Darby Allin - TNT Championship Match
What a flawless end-to-end presentation.
Cody played the megastar top athlete, surrounding himself with an entourage that doubled, on a night he played heel to get the heft of Allin's culmination over, as enablers of his hubris. Allin rode in on a sh*tty, busted car and did this on his own to sell the story of his career.
This match acts as irrefutable counterarguments for two bad faith takes: Cody is an elite in-ring talent, and AEW, when it wants to be, is the most effective company at evoking the big fight sports presentation.
Cody built weight to prepare for his opponent and realised a game plan in the guts of the match. He targeted Allin's arm with a consistent hammerlock. In a match of contrast and comparison - Allin was so great, in revealing the substance behind his technique - he modified every last defensive weapon to work around the injured arm, proving himself something far more than the gutsy bag of bones. The work was a level beyond hermetic. The struggle was captured exquisitely, and Allin sold like he was the greatest babyface in a generation, but he did so with such intelligence that it resonated well above the anguished histrionics of so many other babyfaces.
Two versions of an awesome match blended seamlessly together, the Darby Vs. Cody series has ruled, and this blew every previous encounter away.
Star Rating: ★★★★¾
5. Hikaru Shida Vs. Nyla Rose - Women's Championship Match
The layout was incredible, and it all peaked to a glorious get the f*ck in let's go moment, when Shida lifted Nyla from the mat to avenge her bullying squash match flexing. And for a while, both women executed it well enough. But it fell apart by the finish, it went too long, and much of the work was loose and weak. The big moments connected so softly that it became very difficult to suspend one's disbelief.
Elements of this were fantastic.
Nyla Rose modifying her big high spot to crush Shida's knee was a great twist in particular. It was too late to elevate the closing stretch beyond the barely respectable, but Shida finally summoned the strength back to clobber Nyla in the face with an overkill barrage. It might have resonated as a great, protective finish, but by then, the spell of immersion had been broken. It's difficult to tell the story of tenacity overcoming the monster when there's so little fire and so little threat.
The post-match angle fell flat - the relationship between Nyla and Vickie Guerrero has barely been established - but an elusive long-term booking path is clear now: Britt Baker dethrones Shida, Nyla turns face to one day gun her down.
It's now a matter of the extent to which AEW is committed to treading it.
Star Rating: ★★★
4. FTR Vs. The Young Bucks - World Tag Team Championship Match
In a small complaint that didn't matter at all by the finish, the dream match took a while to heat up. It was jittery for a while there. At one point, Dax Hardwood and Cash Wheeler seemed to get in each other's way doing something as simple as wrapping Matt Jackson's leg around the post.
A special mention must be made to Excalibur here. It's no exaggeration to state that his all-timer of a commentary performance added the elusive quarter-star to this instant classic. The big moment in the match was mistimed - Wheeler was a little slow threatening the swipe, and it felt like Matt Jackson took the hard landing on his bum ankle for no reason - but Excalibur covered for the beat.
Wheeler atoned by performing like a maniac. He speared Nick Jackson off the apron in a positively awesome spot that worked to put the Bucks over. He had to kill the guy. He couldn't just sweep his leg. Nick devised the absolute perfect spot to account for Matt's last stand. He took a brutal powerbomb through the timekeeper's table. Dax played sh*t-out-of-luck bully to perfection by injuring his hand and flailing it wildly in desperation. Matt Jackson was on another level entirely.
All four men were incredible here in what was as much a story of tag team wrestling itself as it was a battle between the two greatest practitioners of the genre. This was not a hollow and contrived series of tribute spots; this was a story of FTR slowly conceding that the genre has in fact evolved. The moves borrowed from the '80s didn't work; they only scored narrow near-falls in what was - like the art itself has become - a graduating hailstorm of action.
After a small moment of (deliberate) confusion, Wheeler convinced Harwood to Meet him in the Middle. And, in the end, with their own arsenal exhausted, Wheeler betrayed his code to put over the Bucks by attempting a springboard 450. He failed. The Bucks won, and on the strength of that reaction, they were right to wait as long as they did before strapping up. But they didn't bury the past.
Matt borrowed from Arn Anderson to get back on offence in a marvellous spot that told its own story: all of this great. Rejoice in all of it.
Ultimately, on the strength of an out-of-this-world selling performance, Matt Jackson made 1,000 distanced outdoor fans sound like 10,000 packed into a major indoor arena. After months and months of great if bittersweet wrestling, this felt like a return to the old normal when it peaked. That crowd was pulled all the way into this story, and so was I. The words call an audible call an audible screamed silently in my mind throughout the unbearable drama of the last 15 minutes, in fear of FTR winning. A real, red-hot wrestling crowd were desperate for the Bucks to overcome. They were begging, and it was loud, and it was impossible, but it was happening, at last. Real wrestling. Not the very best of a bad situation.
Real, seminal, live pro wrestling in 2020.
Star Rating: ★★★★★
3. Matt Hardy Vs. Sammy Guevara - Elite Deletion
Subjectively, this didn't work.
It went too long and diminished the joy it was able to elicit on occasion. The two mud-based gags were sublime, mind - just a fantastic one-two punch perfectly crafted to pop the tribalist, defensive base. This sort of dig proves divisive, naturally - especially when they're often so needless - but you can't not credit Matt Hardy for crafting them from the platform of the match itself. It was impossible not to pop at Gangrel. Some of the wrestling was rather exciting, and the finish was cleverly done, or it would have been, had the uneven tone and goofy soundtrack not undermined it.
Objectively, did this even work in its own, heightened context?
It's some indictment, that it felt so incongruous in the promotion that exists to serve every pro wrestling fan. Even for a forgiving critic with eclectic tastes, that uneven tone felt self-defeating. It just wouldn't end, either. It just wouldn't end. It told the story of the feud, if nothing else.
The real issue is that the Broken universe isn't an enduring match genre or wrestling philosophy, all of which AEW embraces. It was a moment in time. This was creative, funny, and maybe deserves some detached credit in isolation, but it disrupted the tone and the vibe of the show and felt ancient and kitsch.
This universe is one plate too many at the "buffet".
Star Rating: N/R
2. MJF Vs. Chris Jericho
MJF Vs. Chris Jericho wasn't a blow-away awesome wrestling match. It wasn't a war.
It was fated never to reach that gear, given how early we are into a unique heel versus heel storyline premised more on peacocking gamesmanship than the pure animosity to come.
It was a match far more interesting than great. This might scan as a criticism - this was a semi-main on a premium pay-per-view worked between two top stars - but it isn't: this, for the story it told and what it built towards, was a television match. That doesn't describe its quality but rather its ambition. This packed in a lot of tremendous detail and creativity with an eye towards the future.
The dynamic didn't yield an effective big fight tone, but you can tell that its players had a great deal of fun and spent a lot of time putting it together. Literally shadowing one another in the ring as they did on the stage, in a great spot that served the story so well - MJF and Jericho are a sort of d*ckhead hive mind just waiting to sting itself - Jericho lulled MJF into the Lionsault, knowing MJF knew he was going to do it, and rocked him with the Codebreaker after MJF knew to expect the counter. This was a lovingly-crafted chess match.
In the end, the protege outsmarted the master. He promised to do "anything", but that anything was a red herring designed to lull him into a roll-up.
A very, very smart - if laboured and not enormously exciting - pro wrestling match.
Star Rating: ★★★½
1. Jon Moxley Vs. Eddie Kingston - World Championship I Quit Match
In a strange but no less potent way, this benefitted from (or at least wasn't hurt by) a crowd sapped by the Elite Deletion. A harrowing match best watched pensively and in a state of genuine apprehension, this, ironically, was a restrained death match main event.
It didn't aim to pop the crowd with unhinged stunts but draw them, against their moral compass, into a gruesome attritional war. This wasn't crafted to impress, but to disturb and convince. Eddie Kingston's incredible presence never allowed it to descend into dreaded methodical territory, and it was much, much too stiff to be drab. Kingston's strikes were disgusting, and in a moment that benefitted from the pace and informed the heft of the finish, he teed off on Mox's face with a barbed wire-wrapped fist in a fast and shocking moment of violent electricity.
Restrained probably isn't the word, when Mox ended up with thumbtacks in his f*cking head only to effectively garrotte Kingston at the finish. But there was nothing superfluous to this, nothing that climbed just to fall down.
That finish was incredible. Mox advised Kingston to "protect his neck" in the build. Set on shredding it with barbed wire, pausing only to keep him conscious to extract the result, Mox had it won. In a superb bit of acting, referee Bryce Remsburg knew it, and pleaded with his old friend.
"You're done," he said, and he was.
Star Rating: ★★★★