9 Match Star Ratings For WWE Hell In A Cell 2019
They ruined the Fiend after just his second match? Yowie Wowie!
Usually, the introduction to this column acts an appraisal of the build, because the build and the payoff should each inform the success of the event.
Too often, WWE's sh*tty writers/excellent roster production unit yields uneven and pointless results. If the pay-per-view is excellent, so what? The build very rarely breeds must-see action, and the results are too often squandered.
This is difficult here because WWE, prior to Friday's SmackDown, the most important show of the year, advertised just three matches. Hell In A Cell, once the company's ultimate gimmick attraction, is now as inconvenient to WWE as it was to Mick Foley's ability to walk.
Sasha Banks Vs. Becky Lynch was booked very well - so well that the usual Match One f*ck finish actually warranted the stipulation. The Clash finish came off organic - again, through the physical commitment of the talent, and not a creative regime systemically intent on prolonging everything by lazy default. The Fiend Vs. Seth Rollins was driven purely through the former's star power. The Fiend was framed as an unprecedented threat throughout, Seth Rollins pitiful, but on aggregate, the Fiend character was so intriguing that it obscured how feckless and cold Rollins has become in an untenable babyface role. WWE avoided the WrestleCrap Gooker Iceberg by reorienting the focus of the dire summer Whodunnit to a tag team programme carried by Daniel Bryan's excellent babyface work.
And then they steered directly into it in the main event!
9. KICKOFF: Natalya Vs. Lacey Evans
One of those WWE feuds so interminable that it feels like it started in 2017 - and Bray Wyatt is still a joke, so nothing has changed, really - this wasn't even the last chapter. Did anybody give a toss about the first?
This isn't a bad idea for a programme. WWE is high on Lacey Evans, and Natalya, as profoundly overexposed as she is, is best-equipped to steer her under the harsh glare of TV lights.
It's just a bad programme.
Useful only to chart Lacey's progress, the mat work was an exponential improvement on their catastrophic exchanges at the Royal Rumble. She looked composed here, where she has a tendency to get lost in the work when she juggles it with her more natural ability to project herself. She did well to weave her character work into the actual wrestling, by slapping Natalya on the a*se when applying a hold, and generally, this on-the-job training doubled as a fairly engaging and competent pro wrestling match.
Repetitive and methodical is a marked improvement on aimless and ugly, but still, this sort of thing is surely better suited for the Performance Center, not pay-per-view.
Star Rating: ★★¼
8. Becky Lynch Vs. Sasha Banks - RAW Women's Title Hell In A Cell Match
Tremendous and creative from the jump, Becky responded to Sasha's early heel heat spot by grabbing the chain that locks the Cell and smashing her in the abdomen with it, in a quality, poetic sequence of retribution.
This was an awesome match loaded with intensity and an expertly-crafted sense of animosity that enabled an intoxicating suspension of disbelief. The heel/babyface dynamic was in perfect balance: Sasha, knowing what she had awakened in Becky, attempted a series of flash pins: Becky, beautifully consistent with her character, kicked out of everything, drunk on the prospect of a fight.
Sasha's ring style lent itself perfectly to the stipulation; slight and reckless, the sight of her frame careening off the mesh was as cathartic as it was harrowing, layering the match with several tones, and her Meteora into the ladder looked like (yes) hell on her knees. The pacing was masterful; she played the heel brilliantly, but it was underpinned with a respect. This was committed, and anything but cheap: in an era of 50/50 that is still ongoing, either woman would have emerged a worthy winner.
Becky "prevailed" after weathering a sustained onslaught, but not before attempting a roll-up of her own. This was an inspired sequence that put her opponent over immaculately: that onslaught was so vicious that she, just for a moment, tried to slip out of the fight. Some fans bemoaned the result - who else but Sasha is remotely worthy of prising the title away from Becky? - but for your writer's money, there were no complaints.
Becky Lynch headlining WrestleMania 35 was not her biggest achievement of 2019. Conspiring to stay credible and over in this system is walking-on-water sh*t.
Long may it continue.
Star Rating: ★★★★½
7. Daniel Bryan & Roman Reigns Vs. Erick Rowan & Luke Harper
A cracking, all-action match almost cruel in its fun factor, this card, lol, was trending to be the best of the year.
Daniel Bryan's opening burst of offence tore the roof off. Flying at his two colossus opponents from all angles, just as they were assuming control, the way he times and paces everything is ingenious. He inspires hope and pumps the blood as a matter of course, and his chemistry with Roman Reigns was electric, too; he manoeuvred Rowan into unique versions of his partner's Superman punch in a pop-pop-pop opening shine.
The eleventh hour tornado stipulation suited the dynamic perfectly: just when it was thought Roman had kicked out (and his ability to do so at 2.99 put over Rowan and intensified the drama very effectively), Luke Harper blasted him from out of nowhere.
When the pace slowed, interest didn't follow suit, because Bryan is so great - almost too great - at selling; the way he clutches his head breeds the same sort of anxiety Shawn Michaels once generated with his crumpled, agonising selling of the back. There was a note of Hiroshi Tanahashi to Bryan's performance here, too, in that he applied the LeBell Lock in a perfectly logical transition for a moment of real peril. Everything built to the big spot carnage of the crescendo, where, in contrast to last month's No Disqualification match, it meant something.
WWE received fierce, totally warranted criticism for the main event fallout, but they turned sh*t into shinola with this feud.
Star Rating: ★★★¾
6. Randy Orton Vs. Ali
For most of the duration, this was a typical Randy Orton match.
He played off the size disparity in a manner that was sensible if unexciting in a match that played out to near silence. He backdropped Ali onto a table in a great spot, but it's funny: for all the outrage over AEW's poor officiating at Dynamite, nobody ever complains about this Orton trademark. People cry bias at the optimistic AEW coverage, but if anything, there are different rules for different companies in favour of WWE. The inconsistency is so ingrained that it's accepted.
A lot of people raved about the finish, which was baffling. It was a damning illustration in microcosm of what WWE ritually does to its performers.
Ali evaded Orton's first RKO attempt with a slip-out handstand, which drew a big reaction for its creativity and athleticism. And then, because he is a WWE babyface and WWE babyfaces are fools you simply are not allowed to invest in, he immediately went to the top rope and risked the catch RKO Orton attempts in every match in which he wrestles a smaller opponent.
Up, then down, over, then out: Ali isn't worth your time, sadly.
Star Rating: ★★½
5. The Kabuki Warriors Vs. Alexa Bliss & Nikki Cross - Women's Tag Team Title Match
A pretty bloody good match that also didn't work, because fans were wholly unprepared to boo the gradual Kabuki Warriors heel turn with any conviction.
This is what people talk about when they talk about WWE being out of touch: who was going to boo Asuka and Kairi Sane? Asuka is defined as WWE's most sinfully wasted talent at this point, and Kairi Sane is fundamentally likeable. She is a sweetheart with an admirable organic fire. And Alexa Bliss and Nikki Cross, who together do form a good and enjoyable act, granted, only just turned heel.
This isn't going to work - anybody can foresee that, except for the people who make these decisions - but the match did in terms of its content, if not its story.
Because Kairi is so talented, she can play heel well, even if nobody was prepared to accept it in the intended spirit. She toyed with Alexa Bliss in a good (nominal) heat spot, feigning respect, and strutted up to Nikki Cross only to poke her in the eye in a quality spot that fell apart when she, as the heel, found herself in the old referee-is-too-distracted-to-count-the-pin bit. That's a babyface predicament.
Iffy storytelling aside, this did draw mild support on behalf of Cross and Bliss, and as a welcome showcase of the formidable talent of the Kabuki Warriors, this worked. Except it also didn't work.
WWE, everybody.
Star Rating: ★★★
4. Braun Strowman & The Viking Raiders Vs. The O.C.
What was the point of this?
This unscheduled match somehow ended in a disqualification, as if Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson A) suddenly need protecting, B) haven't already been stigmatised as jobbers, and C) will benefit from the finish.
A DQ is meant to drive support behind the babyface's eventual quest for just retribution. The War Raiders have already decisively defeated Gallows and Anderson multiple times, so where is the drama here? A decent TV-quality match overshadowed entirely by a typically empty nothing-ever-matters WWE finish, AJ Styles was on form here, at least: his cutoff spots were creative, allowing the heat and action to build, and the over, explosive Ivar benefitted from AJ's tidy heel work. His physical burst of offence worked as release from the tension AJ engineered, not that it mattered. It didn't bury anybody, but it didn't help anybody. It merely existed, and AJ's hysterical post-match sell-job was pure house show stuff befitting of the match.
How hard is it?
Strowman is about to do something of significance with Tyson Fury. Have him annihilate somebody to put himself over ahead of it. But who? Who? Hmmm. Perhaps a tag wrestler WWE has shown zero interest in promoting as a player? Then again, what would that accomplish, really? Who did he beat?
Nobody in either scenario.
Star Rating: ★★¾
3. King Corbin Vs. Chad Gable*
*Apologies for the typo; this of course was a match between King Corbin and Shorty Gable. Greg Hamilton said that name when he declared him the winner! It's canon now!
And King Corbin was fired back into the cannon from which he was shot, as WWE sought to rebuild him as the King Of The Ring, because he is now 50/50 with Shorty. 50/50/50, actually: he got his "heat" back following a post-match attack backstage on Shorty, as RAW-Hell In A Cell rolled on.
This match was average at best. The fans barely reacted to it, possibly because Corbin, a half-serious proposition after impressing in a well-booked tournament with real stakes, is now comedic fodder once more. Shorty is also so smol, which didn't help the atmosphere, but he's usually so good that fans forget his awful booking and gradually react to the awesome performance. This didn't happen at Hell In A Cell, which marked a reversion from King back to Baron. The pace was lethargic and didn't escalate, and he was back on his chinlock bullsh*t. It never felt like Shorty was in real peril, and so his well-performed comeback spots didn't soar.
The worst match of the series by some distance, WWE ruined a good thing.
That's just what they do.
Star Rating: ★★¼
2. Charlotte Flair Vs. Bayley - SmackDown Women's Title Match
Another strange and poorly laid-out match that didn't command much of a reaction from the crowd - possibly because the dynamic was all over the place and weighted almost entirely in favour of the babyface challenger.
This was so weird it was scarcely believable: if WWE can do anything, it's the sort of binary, babyface versus heel storytelling that built the company. Possibly because that dynamic was subverted - Charlotte is a pure heel, and Bayley a pure babyface - Charlotte didn't much operate like a babyface, and Bayley didn't operate much like a heel.
Charlotte patrolled the ring in a general's performance, cutting off Bayley's offence relentlessly with a fairly detestable streak. She laughed piously at Bayley's inability to land a big boot, slapped her across the face with a cruel, beaming smile on her own, and simply moved out of position when Bayley attempted to land a cross-body. Bayley looked so feckless here that it overstepped sympathy and into pure pity territory, and she wasn't even the babyface.
She rallied, briefly, and subverted her tube man crowd appeal as a taunt, but Charlotte again cut her off. It never remotely resonated as a comeback because there was nothing from which to come back. She dominated Bayley, and by the time Bayley initiated the heat spot sequence, it carried no weight.
She cried for an eternity in the aftermath, but over what? The defeat, remorse over her change in attitude, or another banner year?
Star Rating: ★★
1. Seth Rollins Vs. The Fiend - Universal Title Hell In A Cell Match
WWE "tells stories".
That's what separates the company from the small-time competition, per its rhetoric. Here, WWE sought to tell the last act of a horror film inside of a wrestling ring, in which the Fiend was impervious and able to withstand pain as a result of his presumed supernatural powers. Those powers didn't concern the referee into calling off the match, even though they handed the Fiend a distinct advantage. Seth's attempted use of a sledgehammer was deemed an act of violence too far, and so the referee, in the end, called off the match in fear for the safety of the challenger. By God, that supernatural entity has children! He also had and attempted to use a bigger hammer, in a match with no rules, but that hammer was ineffective. Like, f*cking hell. Way to get a new weapon over.
*Conan O'Brien on the Simpsons voice*
"Only I may use the Sledgehammer."
*Triple H dances*
WWE's horror film, truly, was garbage day.
Seth's Curb Stomp was completely devalued, but WWE hoped it would be negated by this new, cinematic context. The Stomp here was the repeated plunge of the knife into the heart of the psychopathic monster, but here's the thing: this was still a pro wrestling show, and the problem is they killed the context, too, by bathing the arena in corny red light and taking far too literally the presentation of this new Wyatt character.
This actually worked in patches. Wyatt, who should be f*cking livid after this - the inspiration needed to get this character over is as impressive as how WWE conspired to botch it - carried a preposterous character believably, somehow. Fans reacted to his cool no-sell spots, for a time. And then the supernatural entity was nearly stretchered away because WWE either through institutional gumption or Saudi/Fox interference could not deliver a finish.
WWE ruined that which couldn't be ruined. WWE ruined the Fiend.
F*ck.
This.
Company.
Star Rating: -★