9 Promos That Killed Wrestlers' Careers

Sorry, Billy, but The Rock's gotta do what The Rock's gotta do.

The Rock Billy Gunn Promo
WWE.com

There are a few main ways to lose your job in the wrestling business. Injuries, behind-the-scenes scandals, and shoddy in-ring works are all common ways to see your contract terminated, but sometimes all it takes to end a career is one bad promo.

We all know that a great promo can kickstart a career and transform a mid-carder into a household name. But not everyone in the industry is lucky enough -- or, more accurately, talented enough -- to have their own Austin 3:16 moment. They don't get their own Hulkamania train to leave the station. Instead, they find themselves sputtering out something about "the right gay guy" at "the wrong time" and making Vince McMahon's head explode.

And while there are plenty of bad promos out there, it takes a special kind of promo to end someone's career. Sometimes a person stumbles through their words so terribly that they're never allowed another chance on the mic. And sometimes it's the guy on the receiving end of a verbal burial that gets the axe.

Behold the promos that had effects so dire they effectively killed off entire careers.

9. The Brood Break Their Silence...And Gangrel Quietly Goes Away

Gangrel seemed to be in the perfect position during the Attitude Era. He was the leader of a hot young stable that was playing off the popularity of "nu-Vampire" movies like Blade, and his silent (you might say brooding) gimmick allowed him to get extremely over with the fans without having to do anything besides look vaguely menacing and perform competently in the ring.

And then they had him speak. Oh how they wish they could turn back time on that decision.

After a brief feud with The Ministry of Darkness, Gangrel and his compatriots were absorbed by The Undertaker's faction, and became the group's whipping boys, constantly proving their loyalty by enduring beatings and actual floggings. It was brutal stuff. When The Brood then split from The Ministry -- after The Undertaker tried forcing Edge and Gangrel to sacrifice Christian, no less -- the stage was set for an intense and dramatic promo.

Instead, we got the immediate vaporization of their mystique. While reciting lines in a stilted, nasally timbre, Gangrel sounds less like a Lost Boy than he did a Goonie-in-training, and his "evil laugh" is as embarrassing as they come.

Subsequently, Gangrel was basically banned from the mic, Edge and Christian were pulled away from him -- though briefly replaced with Matt and Jeff Hardy -- and the vampire enthusiast never regained his initial popularity.


8. Alex Wright's Debut As Berlyn Does Not Go Well

Alex Wright was a quality mid-carder for WCW who got himself over with crowds with his dopey dance moves. His on-again, off-again feud/partnership with Disco Inferno remains one of the best examples of WCW finding success with talent outside the nWo and main event picture.

But as was common during the spiraling last years of the company, Wright got a useless makeover in 1999. Decked out in all-black, he now went by the name Berlyn, an arrogant German who refused to speak English, instead opting to communicate through an interpreter.

That last part made for one of the most awkward and jumbled debut promos of all time. Mean Gene Okerlund would ask Berlyn a general question, Berlyn would respond in German, and then a woman with the mic skills of an unripened banana would translate. It did not make for compelling television.

The crowd practically booed him out of the building -- and not in a "we love to hate you" sort of way -- making the character dead on arrival.

Wright dropped the gimmick shortly thereafter and returned to his happy dancing ways alongside Disco Inferno in 2000, but the mojo was pretty much gone. After a brief tag title reign, Wright got shuffled around the card until the company was bought out by WWE in 2001.

Unsurprisingly, his contract was not picked up.


7. Eli Cottonwood's Mustache Promo Eliminates Him From NXT

Speaking on the mic is an integral part of becoming a big-time superstar, and it's important to know if a young talent has the verbal skills necessary to make it in the business. To figure out whether the rookies on NXT were destined to become the next Rock -- or deserved a mime gimmick -- the judges devised an exercise that forced them to create an impromptu promo about a random subject.

Unfortunately for Eli Cottonwood, this exercise would not only expose his Achilles' heel, but slice it open and let it bleed out all over the mat.

The word the seven-foot lovechild of Kane and the Great Khali drew was "mustache". What came next is one of the most cringeworthy promos to occur this side of Jumpin' Jeff Farmer.

First, Cottonwood explains what a mustache is. Then he explains that he doesn't have a mustache, nor does anyone else in the ring. Then he says that "a mustache is for a real man" before clarifying that he does have a good mustache and that he could grow an even better one in a couple of days. Presumably, because he's a real man.

A real mustache man.

Not surprisingly, Cottonwood would be the next rookie eliminated from competition, and this promo ensured his career would be crushed before it ever took off.


6. Brad Maddox And The Cocky Pr*cks Incident

Brad Maddox
WWE.com

Here's a lesson for all the young up-and-comers in the wrestling business: Just because your promo isn't being broadcast on television, that doesn't mean the things you say won't get you into trouble. Exhibit A: Brad Maddox.

Maddox toiled around in WWE for a few years in ancillary roles, as a referee, as RAW General Manager, and finally as one half of a jobber tag team. And maybe it's the fact that Maddox wasn't exactly lighting the wrestling world on fire that made it so easy to fire him for committing a rather slight infraction.

Before competing in a dark match in Indianapolis, Maddox cut a promo where he called the crowd a bunch of "cocky pr*cks". He was fired the very next day because Vince didn't appreciate the language he used.

Maddox didn't think what he said was inappropriate, especially considering his job was basically to warm up the crowd before the cameras started rolling. And it would be easy to pick out one or two things other superstars say on television each week that are worse than what he said that night.

But when you're that low on the totem pole, it doesn't take much to earn Vince's wrath.


5. Road Warrior Hawk Threatens To Kill Himself, Legitimately Kills His Career

So technically this was less a promo than it was an on-air cry for help played like a soap opera, but since this is the exact moment one of the most legendary tag teams of all time ceased to be watchable, it needs to be on this list.

In the late '90s, Vince tried resurrecting the Legion of Doom to breathe some more life into his struggling tag team division. Behind the scenes, however, one half of that team was battling substance abuse. But Vince -- in his infinite shamelessness -- decided to splatter Hawk's personal demons all over the screen, constantly referencing his alcoholism in a storyline that also saw him frequently replaced in matches with a more "reliable" option, Droz.

The most infamous segment in this wildly insensitive angle involved Hawk climbing to the top of the TitanTron, spilling his guts to the fans, and threatening to commit suicide. It was a heartbreaking moment of reality infiltrating a promo. And so, naturally, Droz had to climb up the TitanTron and shove him right off the structure.

It was played deathly serious, with J.R. delivering his line "Oh my god, he fell" like he literally couldn't believe what just happened.

The fans hated it, and so did the LoD. And even though Vince attempted to revive the duo multiple times after this disgraceful incident, it never worked. He'd completely ruined them.


4. Madusa Drops The WWE Women's Title In The Garbage, Along With Her Career

If you were a wrestling fan during the mid-90s, you might recall an incident where the current WWE Women's Champion, Alundra Blayze, showed up unexpectedly on WCW Monday Nitro to literally drop the championship belt into the garbage on air.

It's still regarded as one of the first of many "shots fired" at WWE, one that essentially kicked off the Monday Night Wars and began shifting the balance of power over to WCW and Eric Bischoff.

The promo itself was pretty awkward. Before canning the belt, Blayze made sure to denounce everything she'd done in WWE, awkwardly stating her WCW moniker, Madusa, over and over again and then telling the world, in no uncertain terms, she had nothing but contempt for her former employer.

The stunt was a big ol' cherry on Bischoff and Ted Turner's sundae, but it was a poisoned banana split for Madusa, who toiled away in the WCW for another five years without doing much of note. She would later explain that the moment "ruined" her:

"That was the defining moment for everybody for twenty years. I had to live with that. It ruined me. Basically. I never did an interview for wrestling or went to a wrestling signing. I’ve only done two signings since I retired."

To be fair, she was finally inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2015, but the years in between were far from kind.


3. Stone Cold Chants "B-O-O-RING" During Lance Storm Match

There's no greater sin in the world of professional wrestling than being boring. In this over-the-top, soap opera world, you can be just about anything you want. You can be a supernatural gravedigger with a pyro fetish or a flashy pimp stuck in the '60s. You can be outrageously stupid, you can be excessively egotistical, hell, you can even be overwhelmingly bigoted.

But boring? Well that's the quickest way to find yourself without a job.

And that's why it was so unsettling to watch Stone Cold Steve Austin walk onto the ramp during a Lance Storm match and berate the ECW alum -- with a pillow and blanket in hand -- and start chanting "B-O-O-RING" at him for about five minutes.

Storm had been with WWE for a couple of years at this point, so this was well after the initial Invasion storyline where this would have made sense. Stone Cold comparing Storm's matches to "watching the grass grow" and his mid-nap, obnoxious snoring came off as unnecessarily mean-spirited here.

This promo kicked off a series of silly gimmick changes for Storm, including a Disco Inferno-style dancing schtick that he would never recover from. He was out of the WWE a year later and has spent the rest of his career working the indie circuit.


2. The Rock Destroys Billy Gunn's Singles Career With A New Catchphrase

There's nary a soul on the WWE roster during the Attitude Era that wasn't expertly roasted by The Great One, from the top tier talent all the way down to the kilt-wearing jobbers. But few have been so hastily yanked down the card as Billy Gunn was in 1999.

Shortly after winning the King of the Ring and earning a main event push, Gunn became the subject of one of The Rock's all-time great promos in which he "reenacted" a conversation Billy had with God regarding the lack of respect being shown to him.

"Oh dear God...my name's Billy and I just won King of the Ring. But there's one problem. Everybody still thinks that I absolutely suck!"

The rest of the promo was even more ruthless, and it even spawned the Brahma Bull's "IT DOESN'T MATTER" catchphrase.

Although many will be quick to say The Rock didn't really "bury" Gunn with the promo and point to the moderate success he sustained for a few years afterward -- both as Mr. Ass and in a tag team with Chuck Palumbo -- there's no denying that his career trajectory took an irreparable turn for the worse that night.

Two years later, Edge would accurately call out how "Billy B*tchcakes" hadn't done anything of note since The Rock's promo, proving just how staggering of a blow it really was.


1. The Shockmaster Stumbles Into Infamy, Joblessness

You know what this is. We all know what this is. If you somehow don't know what this is, please email me to tell me if we finally have flying cars in 2099, because you are clearly from the very distant future.

The Shockmaster is the go-to punchline when talking about failed gimmicks, failed debuts, and really, failures in general as they pertain to the wrestling business. So it shouldn't be surprising that he comes in at the top of this list.

Fred Ottman had done alright for himself in WWE, both as a face (Tugboat) and as a heel (Typhoon), but any chance he had at a promising career in WCW rolled away with his bedazzled Stormtrooper helmet when he tripped and fell on live TV during his infamous debut.

It's unlikely the ludicrous gimmick would've worked even if Ottman had stayed on his feet, as the wacky costume and warbly-voiced promo was certainly enough to turn viewers off, even in the early '90s.

Give the guy credit for not promptly turning tail and running right back through the giant hole in the wall, but there was no coming back from something like this.

Perhaps more amazing is that everyone else who proceeded to lose their sh*t on the sidelines managed to keep their jobs and places on the totem pole.


Watch Next


Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.