9 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dynamite (6 Oct)
Hangman Page returns, Hikaru Shida gets spoiled, the TBS Title is unveiled, Super Elite prevail.
Between New York City, the debuts of Adam Cole and Bryan Danielson, and CM Punk's return from the abyss, All Elite Wrestling has had a lot of big nights recently - and another one just played out in Philadelphia.
As newsworthy as weekly wrestling shows get, a Dynamite that brought a new championship's announcement, a decorated former champion chasing her 50th win, and key progressions for some of the promotion's biggest players was highlighted by Adam Page's comeback. A thunderous response awaited Hangman in his first appearance in two months as the build to what should be the biggest moment in company history was brought back into the zeitgeist.
As if Tony Khan was ever going to throw away over two years of careful, precise storytelling for some shiny new toys. Concern trolls be damned.
Malakai Black, Cody Rhodes, Chris Jericho, MJF, Darby Allin, and a host of others all made major moves here. In the ring, Serena Deeb faced Hikaru Shida, the Super Elite fought Danielson, Christian Cage, and Jurassic Express, Sammy Guevara put his TNT Title on the line against Bobby Fish, and more.
Let's light the fuse...
Downs...
3. Rushing To The Finish
Putting the Brian Cage vs. Ricky Starks blow-off match on this week's Rampage at least prevents Team Taz from getting too held up. Starks vs. CM Punk is the more exciting bout, particularly after Punk's match with Powerhouse Hobbs and verbal sparring sessions with Taz, and the Cage program has lost a lot of juice lately. Holding it off for longer would have made little sense.
But this is a double-edged sword, because last night's Starks/Cage segment didn't hit.
This felt like another hurried, insubstantial interaction in a feud characterised by such things. Before Cage got injured and had to take time off television, the format was identical to last night, with Ricky and co. playing the pricks, big Brian running out for the save, and the tension continuing. This happened again here, and Cage's run-out fell flat.
AEW has given viewers little reason to invest in this storyline. It's best to move on from it now, though this segment only highlighted the flaws in how Cage/Starks has been presented thus far.
2. Arn AndARSON
The Armed Anderson meme had the juice sucked out of it last night when Arn showed up on Cody Rhodes' lawn, woke him from his slumber, set fire to a suit, and spoke of burning The American Nightmare's excesses away.
On-the-nose symbolism and a contrived setup (why would a production crew be stationed outside Cody's house at this time of night? Why wouldn't Arn just, like, do this backstage?) left this feeling like a bad Raw segment. The core premise is fine, with Anderson trying to restore Rhodes' killer instinct, but the execution was as excessive as Arn claims Cody has become.
Pulling this back to a more grounded, wrestling-centric setting is essential next week. This step towards the cinematic felt like more of a comedown than a step forward.
1. A Clunky Casino Ladder Match, UNTIL...
Full credit to the participants of last night's Casino Ladder Match for working hard, and particularly PAC, Andrade El Idolo, and Matt Hardy for their maniac bumping. The lengths that these professionals go to for entertainment should never go unappreciated and Dynamite's main event was certainly packed with gif-worthy moments.
But this was an awkward, clunky match prior to Hangman Page's arrival, which we'll get to later in the article.
A collection of high spots and awkward table-setting moments with little tying them together, this convergence of multiple feuds (Jon Moxley vs. Lance Archer, PAC vs. Andrade, Hardy vs. Orange Cassidy) was at least more cohesive than the first Casino Ladder Match, but only just. The pops were there, absolutely, but it's difficult to invest when wrestlers are visibly working to get plunder in place when they could be taking advantage of their opponents, inflicting further punishment on the road to victory.
Particularly troublesome was one spot that left Archer standing around clumsily, waiting for a countdown after setting the ladder in place. More mistimed than anything else, it made the former IWGP United States Champion look foolish, as in kayfabe, he'd spurned an opportunity to win by gawking.
Ups...
9. Dante Martin In The Spotlight
A couple of things were set up for Dante Martin last night, which is deserved. The Top Flight man has been a standout performer in his increased Dynamite opportunities as of late - and it's nice to see that rewarded.
Malakai Black ambushed Martin during an in-ring interview with Tony Schiavone, answering Dante's open challenge by dropping him with a roundhouse kick. Later, Lio Rush cut a promo on the up-and-comer, offering to take his money and career to the next level, furthering the cash-spinning gimmick he established this week.
A developing but exciting prospect, Martin's ceiling is stratospheric and it seems he will be given every opportunity to hit it in AEW. His will be a slow, careful rise to the top, and he doesn't need to win immediately, but the Rush angle has intrigue and the bout with Black will surely bang.
8. RETRIBUTION Attack Darby Allin
A surprise to see RETRIBUTION on last night's episode of Dynamite, as Slapjack, T-Bar, and the other mask-clad goons beat Darby Allin down backstage, dropping him on guardrails and choking him with a skateboard in a brutal angle.
The disguises were an odd idea, given that The Pinnacle were immediately identifiable as Allin's assailants. Nonetheless, this was a suitably ugly assault after Allin had poured further sympathy upon himself in a sitdown interview with Jim Ross, in which he retold the story about his uncle perishing as a drunk driver while he was in the car with him, hence why half of his face is permanently covered in corpse paint.
Sandwiched between the developments in the MJF feud was an effectively TV squash pitting Allin against Nick Comoroto. A simple story of Allin using his superior speed, aggression, and propulsiveness to foil the bigger man was told well. Comoroto controlled Darby through the break but had been caught off-guard by a pre-bell dive and eventually fell to the Coffin Drop.
7. Heat Without Shortcuts
Dan Lambert drew monster heat in Philadelphia. The crowd was so loud that he was barely audible as he cut his promo, struggling to make himself heard as he challenged The Inner Circle's Chris Jericho, Jake Hager, and Sammy Guevara to match on American Top Team's home soil next week - and he did this without uttering a single "millennial" or adjacent insult.
With his shtick drawing "what?!" chants last week (a universal sign of rejection in wrestling, Steve Austin appearances aside), this is further proof that Lambert should drop the alt. right grandstander schtick and present himself as more of a Cornettian curmudgeon. Objectively, the other material wasn't working. This stuff can.
Jericho and Hager running out to save Sammy Guevara with Judas still playing was contrived, but served a greater purpose. Lambert getting increasingly annoyed by the fans still signing Fozzy while he was trying to speak was key to his heat. Now, he'll lead the Men of the Year and former UFC Heavyweight Champion Junior dos Santos against The Inner Circle in Miami, with Jorge Masvidal in ATT's corner, surely setting up the blow-off singles match with Jericho.
6. CM Punk Calls Out Daniel Garcia
The time for CM Punk to drop the "glad to be back!" tour and jump into a meatier, more hateful feud is approaching, but until his grateful, smiling promos start losing steam and stop resonating with the crowds, these things are an easy Up.
Punk's words are real and organic. This is an authentic presentation of where the man is in life, which is why the segments work. When Punk speaks of missing the wrestling community, the impact the city of Philadelphia has had on his career, and how pleased he is to be back, he isn't acting.
And now he's wrestling Daniel Garcia on Rampage. As another details-first wrestler, the 22-year-old should mesh well with Punk, who continues working his way through AEW's roster of hot young prospects.
CM Punk's life is good - and so is this content.
5. Guevara Goes Fishing
Bobby Fish coming out to his and Kyle O'Reilly's old ROH theme, Dance Away, was a fun moment for fans with decent memories, and the debuting veteran worked a good match with TNT Champion Sammy Guevara, highlighted by its selling.
Guevara made Fish's strikes look extra impactful by throwing his body around and putting over their impact as he was laid into. Bobby, meanwhile, folded himself like an accordion on the match-ending GTH, which came from Sammy dodging a kick.
Solid rather than spectacular, the match saw Fish going to the strategy of sweeping Guevara's legs while he was on the top rope several times. He ended up hitting an avalanche Falcon Arrow of his own in a good outing that re-establishes the old theme of the TNT Title being an open gauntlet that anyone can theoretically come in and challenge for.
4. The TBS Championship
Tony Khan's big Dynamite announcement was delivered by Tony Schiavone and Aubrey Edwards, who unveiled the new TBS Championship in the ring, putting it over as both an important moment for the women's division and a celebratory move ahead of Dynamite's switch from TNT on 5 January.
The men's scene has benefited immensely from the TNT Title, which has given wrestlers extra purpose outwith the immediate World Title picture. One can only hope it does the same for AEW's women, who, despite their growing ranks, continue to struggle for focus and engagement, with the promotion still facing a mountain of work before shaking off the critics.
Skye Blue, Jade Cargill, Thunder Rosa, and Ruby Soho all commented on the upcoming tournament in follow-up promos, before a defiant Britt Baker claimed she was delighted that the division now had something else to obsess over rather than her. Immediately, the TBS Championship was presented as something to strive for.
3. A Popping Openers
Botches happen and honing in on them with laser focus is rarely worthwhile, particularly when wrestlers react to them and adjust the match's course to ensure they don't have a detrimental impact on its flow. This unfortunately wasn't the case here. Kenny Omega fell on his backside as the Super Elite attempted to powerbomb Luchasaurus. The move was sold regardless, and the brief-hiccup took some of the juice out of an otherwise popping Dynamite opener.
This was still a great match, though. That Jurassic Express, Christian Cage, Bryan Danielson, and the Super Elite started in the ring told fans that the wrestlers were going to use the majority of the 20-minute time limit. They did that with a well-structured bout that featured all the highspots you require and expect from a bout like this, including a dive train that ended with Adam Cole faking out and taunting instead, and a red-hot Omega/Danielson sequence following their Match of the Year candidate in New York City.
Christian was taken out by an Indytaker on the outside, leaving the babyfaces a man down. They fought valiantly, but valiance, in the end, wasn't enough, and Jungle Boy tasted a four-way BTE Trigger for the loss.
Wisely holding back on interactions between Cole and Danielson preserved what will be a money-spinning feud in the future. Recent interactions between Danielson and Nick Jackson, Cole and Jungle Boy, and Danielson and Omega were well-incorporated too, and everything was over.
A success.
2. Serena The Spoiler
Serena Deeb played an excellent spoiler in what was set up to be Hikaru Shida's 50th win in AEW, defeating the former Women's World Champion via a concentrated attack on the Japanese star's neck.
AEW informed the moment's cruelty by having Aubrey Edwards show a plaque dedicated to Shida's landmark before the bout. The stage was set for a big, emotional moment for one of the hardest working people in the company, and it was snatched away from her by a cold, calculating veteran with no regard for such pageantry, who worked Shida's neck and knee throughout, leading the payoff with the Serenity Lock.
Deeb rejecting Edwards raising her hand and smashing Shida in the face afterwards was pure playground bully stuff. It was perfect. The cleanest and most technical worker in the division pushed and pressurised Shida throughout, absorbing various fightbacks on the road to the biggest win of her own AEW run, hopefully setting The Professor of Professional Wrestling up for something big.
1. Hangman's Heroics
A switch flipped when Hangman Page made his grand Casino Ladder Match entrance as the Joker.
Philly erupted for the homegrown hero when he emerged, ran through his moveset, and grabbed the poker chip. Structurally, everything fell into place as well. Page was at the heart of a series of highlight-reel moments chained together with the fluidity lacking earlier in the match. His Deadeye to PAC from the top of the ladder and through a table was gnarly and his Buckshot Lariat on Lance Archer came completely out of nowhere, blowing the roof of the spot.
Then, when he felled Jon Moxley and claimed the World Title shot, pandemonium.
The win is as interesting as it is exciting. He'll now face Kenny Omega, presumably, but having slowly climbed the ladder, leaping various mental hurdles along the way, on more than one occasion now, Hangman has effectively scored a fast-track to a World Title shot. How will the Anxious Millennial Cowboy cope with this, particularly after being beaten down so brutally by Omega and his cronies in his last appearance?
Page is back, the people are into it, and those concerns (real or otherwise) that he was going to be lost in a Punk/Danielson/Cole-induced shuffle were blown away in a few brilliant minutes here. This is the kind of thing you watch the show for. Long-term investment is paid off and rewarded in AEW and in Philly, the reactions spoke for themselves.