9 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SummerSlam 2024 (Results & Review)

Roman Reigns returns and WWE switches FOUR titles at a memorable SummerSlam.

WWE SummerSlam 2024 Roman Reigns Solo Sikoa Bloodline
WWE.com

The Original Tribal Chief is back and better than ever.

It was the worst kept secret in wrestling, but seeing Roman Reigns return at SummerSlam to shoot down wannabe Bloodline boss Solo Sikoa and then stare down Cody Rhodes was an incredible scene. Roman's comeback will live long in the memory, but that wasn't the only killer moment WWE's latest PLE had to give.

Triple H booked no less than four title changes on the same card. On top of that, the writers scripted a full-on Judgment Day implosion and kept excitement high for more violence to come between rivals like CM Punk, Drew McIntyre and Seth Rollins. That trio even found time to reference SummerSlam 1997!

Admittedly, the show did feel long, but that had more to do with epic video packages and lengthy entrance routines than anything else. In-ring, SummerSlam smashed it for the most part; there were only a few drab bits here or there. One segment defo could've been cut and nobody would've missed it.

Here's all the good and bad from a show well worth watching.


Downs...

3. A Match That Summed Up Bayley’s Reign

WWE SummerSlam 2024 Nia Jax Bayley
WWE.com

Bayley's title win at WrestleMania 40 was f'n awesome, but her actual run with the gold hasn't been much to write home about since. The bulk of her match vs. Nia Jax acted like a summary of everything wrong with it. The bout was far too slow and plodding until an admittedly banging finish came along to save the day.

Some folks reading might not like this, but Bayley would probably be better off going heel again. She's much more effective in that role nowadays. That's been one of the biggest issues with her title reign: Bayley has never felt all that sympathetic, and her return to high-fiving fans has been a little...sudden.

Oh well, it's onto the next anyway.

Of course, this is just one person's opinion on matters. Others may feel differently, and that's fine, but yeah - your writer was a bit disappointed by the lack of oomph during the first 9-10 minutes of what he'd called a potential sleeper hit going in. It wasn't that.


2. It Didn’t Feel Violent Enough?

WWE SummerSlam 2024 CM Punk Drew McIntyre Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Ready for another point you might shout down?!

The overall level of hatred during the build to Drew McIntyre vs. CM Punk was scorching, but it didn't really come across during their first match against one another. Perhaps that had more to do with Seth Rollins being a constant distraction as special guest referee than anything else, but the lack of brutality stood out.

Being fair, all three guys have history and had a story to tell, but it would've helped the match big time had Drew or Punk been more sadistic throughout. They pretty much just wrestled a regular match other than the opening punch out. Beyond that, the story was way more about Rollins than Punk vs. McIntyre.

Again being fair to WWE, there's still more to come. Bad Blood is approx two months away, and there's ample time to build to a Hell In A Cell war between both men (or something like that) for the show. Dunno', it did kinda feel like Seth was too much of a distraction for the pair's first scrap.


1. That Unnecessary Pre-Main Skit

WWE SummerSlam 2024 Jellyroll The Miz R-Truth Austin Theory
WWE.com

Credit to Austin Theory for taking bumps like Jellyroll was The Undertaker. Hopefully, WWE recognises what they've got with Theory and pulls the trigger on his teased babyface turn soon. What's the alternative? Him working cameos next to Grayson Waller forever because they've got nothing else to do on PLEs?

The Miz and R-Truth working a bit with A-Town Down Under wasn't needed. Sorry, it wasn't. Sure, WWE wanted to tout the live gate and get Jellyroll involved again, but the segment came far too deep into an already-long show to work. By that point, people just wanted to see the main event and Roman Reigns returning.

Instead, they got a flown-in musician guest hitting moves.

The fact this is in the top 'Down' spot says everything about SummerSlam 2024 though. It was a 'let-me-up' skit, not an abomination, but 100% could've been deleted from the format sheets without anybody blinking. Hey, maybe Jellyroll is about to become Bad Bunny and work a match!


Ups...

9. Bron Breakker Arrives

WWE SummerSlam 2024 Bron Breakker
WWE.com

Strap in for the good, because there's a lot of it.

Honestly? This was far, far, far from the best match Bron Breakker or Sami Zayn will ever have, but Bron scoring the win to become Intercontinental Champ deserves an 'Up' anyway. The ex-NXT star looked over the moon to hold that belt, and fans should brace themselves for some seriously great things from Breakker.

He'll be a headliner by this time next year, let's be frank about it. Guy has all the tools, and he's only going to get better with more experience. It was a bit of a bummer that Bron and Sami only got around five minutes of ring time at SummerSlam, but the sheer vibe Breakker gives off as a star on the rise managed to offset that.

Zayn is a smart enough worker to maximise his minutes every time too, and he bent over backwards to make sure Bron looked like a worthy successor. Pitch: WWE should book Breakker vs. Ilja Dragunov again and use a series of matches between them to elevate both.

Pretty please?


8. The Final Few Minutes Of Nia’s Domination

WWE SummerSlam 2024 Nia Jax Tiffany Stratton
WWE.com

The downside to Nia Jax vs. Bayley was maybe 90% of the match. That remaining 10% pulled the nose up to present Bayley how she should've been produced all along - she looked like a sympathetic babyface valiantly fighting against the odds before succumbing to Nia's power game. Why didn't WWE do more of this between 'Mania-SummerSlam?

Back-to-back Annihilator squashes from Jax worked as a finish. Yep, it's a pity the rest of the match was so slow and plodding, because that ending sequence was fab. Having Tiffany Stratton run in to tease her Money In The Bank cash-in also worked out, and the way Tiff slyly stared down Nia's title post-match implies their friendship won't last.

That's storytelling, people.

The rant you'll find in the 'Downs' section had more to do with disappointment than anything else. Yours truly was hoping for better bell-to-bell, but he can't deny that Nia ruthlessly exploiting a distracted Bayley then ripping away her title was excellent heel work.


7. ‘Dirty’ Dom Rings True

WWE SummerSlam 2024 Dominik Mysterio Liv Morgan
WWE.com

Speaking of excellent heel work.

Dominik Mysterio cost Rhea Ripley the chance to become Women's World Champ, then smooched the lips off Liv Morgan and left with her. This was a top swerve to kick off the night. Rhea's mix of heartbreak and anger was wonderfully captured. She proper nailed that reaction when the cameras lingered on her.

Ripley is about to blow up as a mega-babyface, so this needed to happen. 'Dirty' Dom is a forever heel, and will come into his own as a character post-Judgment Day. It wouldn't be a shocker if he screws Morgan over too, and reveals that he was only using her to indulge his own sick/twisted gaslighting.

The story of the match saw Rhea constantly pop her dislocated shoulder back into socket so she could continue thumping Liv. It was fine, but couldn't hold a candle to the Dom Dom drama. His manipulation was Eddie Guerrero levels of brilliant. Better yet, he's only getting started.


6. LA Knight Sees Logan Paul’s Tricks Coming

WWE SummerSlam 2024 LA Knight
WWE.com

Logan Paul's sporadic title matches had started to settle into a groove. His hangers-on poke their noses in to cause distractions, then Logan grabs brass knuckles from someone and belts opponents to steal the win. In a clever twist, LA Knight was well-prepared for LP's bullsh*t at SummerSlam.

He dodged Paul's shenanigans, then won his first title on WWE's main roster. Cleveland popped big for LA (ahem), and now Knight finally has something tangible to back up his star power. Also, having two male babyface champs on SmackDown for a while will be interesting. Knight will have to play second fiddle to Cody Rhodes, but that's fine.

If anyone can make it work, it's Knight.

It's worth saying that Paul is still a naturally-gifted athletic freak. His springboard moonsault to the outside was unreal, and he's clearly one of the best celebs to ever work some matches generally. In fact, Logan is beyond that now. He has earned his spot on this roster. Fingers crossed he doesn't disappear until 'Mania season.


5. CM Punk Costs Himself

WWE SummerSlam 2024 CM Punk Seth Rollins
WWE.com

The real story coming out of CM Punk's first WWE singles match since 2014 was that he cost himself the win by letting old wounds reopen then get the best of him. Punk likely had the match won, but spotted Seth Rollins wearing the same sentimental bracelet Drew McIntyre had stolen. All bets were off once Punk saw that.

Seth implored him to focus, but couldn't resist poking the bear by saying "nobody wants you here". Punk bit, then McIntyre took his head off and bagged the win. Arguably, that needed to happen. Drew couldn't keep coming up short, and it's poignant that Punk's own actions paved the way for his greatest rival to win on PLE.

Keep this feud going for as long as you can, Hunter. It's a winner.

Personally, as examined in the 'Downs', this fan would've liked to see a bit more violence from Drew and Punk mid-match, but it's hard to bitch about the storytelling. Punk's old issues with Rollins reared their ugly head, and that came back to haunt him. To top it all off, McIntyre has the bracelet again.

Scenes.


4. World Title Match Exceeds Expectations

WWE SummerSlam 2024 Damian Priest GUNTHER
WWE.com

There were a few worried glances when WWE announced that GUNTHER would be challenging Damian Priest for the World Title at SummerSlam. No-one expressed concerns for each man's skills individually, but going heel vs. heel was an interesting choice and easily could've backfired. This just in: It bloody didn't.

If anything, GUNTHER vs. Priest exceeded expectations.

It was a bruising back-and-forth bout that might've well been match of the night. The finishing stretch, which included Finn Bálor-led story, was as hot as they come. More on that shortly. First, let's praise Priest for matching GUNTHER's strict match style and showing his chops as a main event star.

The outcome was similarly pleasing. Something feels right about GUNTHER holding a big gold belt. Do not be shocked if he's World Champ all the way up until next year's WrestleMania. The Imperium leader and lengthy title reigns go together like sun and sand.


3. Finn Bálor Effectively Ends Judgment Day

WWE SummerSlam 2024 Finn Balor Damian Priest
WWE.com

Now, onto Bálor's part in things.

Finn turned on Priest and cost him the World Title. That brought old tensions between the stablemates back to the boil, and all-but-puts a fork in Judgment Day following the Dom and Rhea stuff earlier on in the show. Bonus points go to Damian for being the kind of smart worker who actually pays attention to replays on the big screens.

After seeing that Bálor had saved GUNTHER by putting his foot on the rope during a pin, Priest saw red and goozled Finn with a big hand around the throat. That newfound obsession with getting revenge let GUNTHER recover long enough to hit a powerbomb then lock in a submission for the win. It was one submission too many for the champ to fend off.

Priest and Rhea being babyface counterpoints to Finn and Dominik as heels has legs. JD McDonagh will surely slot in right next to his mentor Bálor, and he'll become a set-up punching bag for a ticked off Priest. Judgment Day had some run, but nothing lasts forever.


2. Going ‘Bloodline Rules’ Worked Out

WWE SummerSlam 2024 Cody Rhodes Jacob Fatu
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes vs. Solo Sikoa had some job on its hands following that sensational Priest vs. GUNTHER clash. Few (if anyone) believed Solo had a realistic chance of taking the WWE Title from Cody heading into SummerSlam, but Sikoa matched Rhodes every step of the way and certainly didn't look out of his depth in such a lofty spot.

There was a broader reason for adding in that 'Bloodline Rules' stipulation on SmackDown, but the actual match always needed some extra juice. Run-ins from Tama Tonga, Tonga Loa, Kevin Owens and Randy Orton woke the live crowd up, then Jacob Fatu made an impact. Fingers crossed he didn't get legit injured on that table bump, by the way.

An injury is the last thing Fatu needs, especially when the Bloodline storyline is about to heat up all over again.

There was always a concern that people would sit on their hands during Cody vs. Solo because Roman Reigns returning was inevitable, but they didn't - not really. In fact, approx 15 minutes in, fans got right into what Rhodes and Sikoa were doing. 'Bloodline Rules' and all the chaos that comes with it helped.


1. The Original Tribal Chief Returns

WWE SummerSlam 2024 Roman Reigns Solo Sikoa Bloodline
WWE.com

This was always going to be the top 'Up'.

Cleveland lost their collective minds for Roman Reigns. His reworked entrance track has more of a babyface flavour than it did before, but it seems the 'Original Tribal Chief' still has an edge to him. Good. He shouldn't become some smiling good guy for no reason. This is an angry alpha male returning to reclaim what's his.

Reigns didn't hang about after posing mid-entrance. He hit the ring, and attacked Solo with dual finishers. The pre-spear "Ooooooooo-waaaaaah!" was particularly ace. Fans had been waiting all night to do that. Roman's return and attack on Sikoa also confirms that a Bloodline civil war will dominate SmackDown for the rest of 2024.

Anything Reigns does with Jacob Fatu should be incredible as well.

Everyone knew this comeback was on once WWE began showing Reigns on-screen during TVs, but it was simply phenomenal to live in the moment on the night come SummerSlam. Four years ago, Roman introduced the world to his 'Tribal Chief' era after a flimsy babyface run. In 2024, he returned as an all-conquering hero.

It feels right.

What did you think of WWE SummerSlam 2024? For more wrestling, check out 10 Forgotten Finishers Wrestlers Suddenly ABANDONED and 10 Fascinating Facts About WWE In 2019!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.