9 Ups & 5 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (Nov 27)
SmackDown's quality soars again as 'The Man' comes back around.
Welcome back, Becky Lynch, and welcome back, SmackDown's quality levels.
Last night wasn't quite on par with the blue brand's strongest 2018 offerings, but it was a clear return to form after the previous week's mediocrity. Though the highs and lows were relatively tepid, nothing that transpired within these two hours was trash, our complaints are minor, and even the less enjoyable segments succeeded in pushing their respective storylines forward.
Lynch's return yielded a typically memorable opening promo and a big TLC pay-per-view bout, with a third party joining Becky and Charlotte Flair after triumphing in the night's thrown-together battle royal main event. Elsewhere, AJ Styles was back in the house and throwing barbs at Daniel Bryan, though his foe was nowhere to be found. The Miz and Shane McMahon's weird relationship continued, The Usos and Bar battled for supremacy, and Rey Mysterio sought revenge on Randy Orton after the previous week's unmasking.
WWE's late-year pay-per-view logjam leaves them with just two more weeks to build to TLC. SmackDown is off to a solid start, and while last night wasn't perfect, we have faith the writing team will overcome any concerns before 16 December. They've earned that trust.
Let's get to it...
Downs...
5. The Andrade Almas Box Score
Number of days since Andrade 'Cien' Almas' main roster debut: 197.
Number of full-time employees he has defeated one on one: 4.
Current losing streak: 4.
Days since last singles victory: 78.
Hey, at least his valet got to wrestle...
4. Miz & Kofi Get Silly
The Miz and Kofi Kingston's sharp seven-minuter delivered solid fundamentals and was growing into an exciting little clash by the end, only to unravel through gross overbooking.
Their setup segment's tone and The New Day's ringside presence meant this was always likely. That doesn't make it any less distracting, though. We got Miz removing a turnbuckle pad, Big E covering said 'buckle with pancakes, Miz going after Xavier Woods, Miz pretending E attacked him, Miz for after a chair, Xavier snatching it, and Kingston scoring the opportunistic finisher/pinfall, all in a few minutes. It was way, way too much.
Not all screwy finishes are created equally, and The New Day's antics aren't always so troublesome. This wasn't awful; just tiresome, and while we didn't expect any kind of four-star banger out of these two in a midcard TV bout, last night was disappointing.
3. Third Wheelin'
The viewers' mileage will have varied on WWE's decision to insert a third party into Charlotte Flair vs. Becky Lynch. This column sits on the negative side. It may prove to be a tremendous bout, but SmackDown's heels and faces marching out in processions made the non-talkers look like passengers and muddied the Flair/Lynch dynamic, which was carrying a good segment prior to Mandy Rose's music hitting.
WWE have booked a three-way Tables, Ladders & Chairs match to prevent a concrete finish. Just like much of the original Becky vs. Charlotte feud, then. And Flair vs. Ronda Rousey. It seems like they're terrified of having one woman pin another at the moment, and that has rarely been as annoying as when this transparent plan came to fruition at the top of this show.
Though their latest programme only concluded a few weeks ago, Flair vs. Lynch made great sense, given recent developments. Now, a third wrestler with no significance or relevance to the storyline has been thrown into the mix. Again, we're sure it'll be a good bout, but the circumstances through which it came together didn't hit the mark.
2. A Stodgy Battle Royal
Though there's more than the action to unpack with last night's TLC qualifying battle royal, the action itself was bland and unsatisfying before a slight pick-up towards the end.
It was as by-the-numbers as such matches get. A textbook layout saw a wide brawl break out at the bell, Zelina Vega's early exit, and a commercial break leading into more listless brawling. The jobber cull continued with The IIconics and Lana, before the numbers were eventually whittled down to Mandy Rose, Asuka, Sonya Deville, and Naomi.
There was little in the way of in-match storytelling, even with the Sonya/Mandy split dynamic. Rose's great-looking knee to the post before her elimination was excellent, though, and the final Deville/Asuka showdown was well put together, though it was impossible to buy that the former Absolution member had a chance of winning.
Again, this wasn't terrible; just dull. A little more effort from whoever laid the battle royal out would've gone a long way.
1. The Most Patronising Payoff
So the whole point of Shane McMahon hijacking the World Cup tournament, getting crowned 'Best In The World,' taking centre stage for SmackDown in the Survivor Series men's elimination match, becoming the last blue man standing, hitting two Coast-to-Coast dropkicks, all while teasing a megalomaniacal heel turn... was so that he could indulge in bad backstage comedy bits with The Miz? Cool.
This feud may yet blossom. Miz is one of WWE's strongest personalities, and a guy adept at turning whatever lemons he's handed into lemonade, while Shane still has value as a stuntman. Last night was bad, though. Miz looked foolish, McMahon came off too cool for school, and the gags didn't land. Poor across the board.
SmackDown's writing team are better than this, as are the performers. Last week, with Miz playing a gloriously insincere piece of sh*t, was solid. This? A clear downturn, and we can only hope things improve next time.
Ups...
9. Before The B*llocks
While much of what WWE had The Miz do last night was tedious, his and The New Day's early-show backstage segment was alright.
A decent way to kill a few minutes, it saw the entertaining quartet bantering back and forth, starting with a couple of Marine 6 jibes. 'The A-Lister' buried the trio for bragging about winning a Survivor Series bout that "didn't count," then announced he was going to see Shane McMahon about setting a match up, before Big E inadvertently outed himself as a "closet Mariner."
E's questionable taste in movies aside, this had enough personality to carry it until the Ups column. It was a typical New Day outing and nothing anyone needs to go out of their way to check out, but such light, breezy segments are what helps separate SmackDown from Raw. They're certainly preferable to Drake Maverick p*ssing on robes.
8. Big Show Turns... Again!
Big Show's SmackDown 1000 turn was a hilarious easter egg on a night full of nostalgia, as 'The World's Largest Athlete' flipped his alignment for the 31st time in his WWE career.
Amazingly, just six weeks later, Show did it again last night, knocking Cesaro out before he and Sheamus faced The Usos.
The Banter Era remains undefeated. WWE don't give a f*ck.
7. AJ The Reflective
Deposed former WWE Champion AJ Styles was in fine form last night, cutting a typically fiery babyface promo all about regaining his former prize.
'The Phenomenal One' started by stating that the 14 days he'd been without the belt felt longer than the 371 he was champion. He took aim at the way Daniel Bryan had dethroned him, decrying the former General Manager's heel turn and assault, before announcing they'd rematch at TLC on 16 December. This led to AJ calling Bryan out there and then. Daniel, though, was nowhere to be found, but Styles "doesn't take nights off," and signed off by telling Bryan to roll out of his hyperbaric chamber and "bring the title to TLC, because it belongs to [me]."
Though the segment's gloomy prologue reeked of the on-the-nose melodrama currently peddled by Johnny Gargano in NXT, the promo worked, and the crowd were behind Styles throughout. Rather than the typically drippy WWE babyface, AJ is full of thunder. There's no bullsh*t to this feud. He wants revenge and his belt back. That's all we need, and it'd be nice to see WWE keep it simple (stupid) like this more often.
6. Prepare For Violence
One week removed from stealing an otherwise tepid episode of SmackDown by heinously unmasking Rey Mysterio, Randy Orton was back on the stick last night, taking the luchador's scalp with him. The proceeding promo was exactly what we've come to expect from 'The Viper' lately, which is to say it was strong.
Calling the previous week's actions "euphoric," Randy once again trashed the significance of the "piece of trash" in his hands, claiming not to care about Mexican wrestling traditions. Mysterio was just another victim. All Orton wanted to do was "embarrass him, and knock him off the pedestal fans have put him on," and of course, out came Rey, neck brace and all, ready for a fight.
This went predictably poorly for the high-flyer. Though he was quick to gain the upper hand, Randy soon took over, seizing upon Rey's injured state to destroy him inside the ring and out. A draping DDT preceded Orton dumping Ray to the outside before crushing his larynx with a steel chair, only to be chased off by road agents, keeping their heat alive for next week.
5. Old Demons & A New Foe
Hats off to WWE for giving Jeff Hardy full acknowledgement for 20 years of service last night. Though your writer worked himself into a shoot early on, assuming this was leading to a retirement announcement, it was a nice way to reward a flawed wrestling idol.
Hardy's promo was laced with emotion and gratitude. Introduced by Michael Cole, Jeff thanked the fans for his support, paid tribute to his family, ran through some highs and lows, then shot those retirement concerns out of thin air. He was having fun... and then Samoa Joe showed up.
And then things got really interesting.
Cutting through the SmackDown roster, Joe spat words with typical excellence, taking aim at Hardy's infamous personal problems. He claimed that Jeff had only succeeded in letting the people down time and time again. People like Hardy "never change," and while Jeff's highlight package was "great," the oft-troubled star probably "doesn't remember any of it."
Joe stopped short of answering Jeff's challenge, but this should make for a great reality-based programme for this fresh upper-midcard pairing.
4. Nakamura Destroys Rusev
As great as it would have been to see Shinsuke Nakamura and Rusev wrestle a full United States Title clash, what we got in the match's place was entirely effective.
'The King Of Strong Style' attacked before the bout could get started. He battered and bludgeoned Rusev all over the place, knocking him to the floor with a Kinshasa. This wasn't deemed enough. Another followed on the outside, with Nakamura ignoring the officials' protestations, before backing up the ramp with the United States strap held high, his dominance secured.
Shinsuke's never going to be the violent delight he was in New Japan, but segments like this hark back to the brutal brilliance that made him so captivating in the first place. Though he has declined, his value as a performer is still evident, and after their underrated Fastlane scrap earlier this year, Nakamura and Rusev should deliver the goods at TLC (if that's where they end up facing).
3. The Man Comes Around
F*ck yeah, Becky's back.
F*ck yeah, her concussion doesn't seem to be as bad as first thought.
F*ck yeah, the Charlotte Flair feud is back on... sort of.
And f*ck yeah, this segment ruled... kind of.
SmackDown's opener hit all the right marks prior to the goober invasion, as Lynch and Flair rekindled their rivalry ahead of what looked like a singles match at TLC. Their dynamic is fantastic. Though it seemed they were buddying-up prior to Survivor Series, it was all stripped away last night, and while Becky was as cocksure as ever, Charlotte was just as engaging, delivering diatribes with the kind of potency she only seems to be able to muster when working heel.
A spirited exchange of verbal jabs led to Charlotte challenging Becky there and then. Paige interjected before this could come to pass, and the rest of the roster soon made their way out. The dynamic up to that point was impeccable. Having Becky back so soon after he Nia Jax-induced concussion is a relief, too, and thank god she'll seemingly be able to wrestle by 16 December.
2. Obviously, This Was Good...
Look, it was The Usos vs. The Bar. What did you expect?
Though SmackDown's tag team storylines have suffered in 2018, the in-ring action is almost always excellent. Such is the calibre of performer. The Revival's wreckage aside, each of WWE's finest main roster tag teams currently ply their trade on the blue brand. They can't help but build fun action when placed in the ring together without a daft stipulation, and that's exactly what transpired last night, as The Usos and Bar whetted appetites for the TLC pay-per-view.
It was a notch or two below what these teams are capable of on a bigger stage. That's the point, though. This was a taster. An appetiser. A warm-up. If they'd went all-out last night then they'd have had nowhere to go at the pay-per-view, which is supposed to be the point where feuds peak, so kudos to these four talented guys for not emptying their tanks.
Cesaro's pre-match knockout punch keeps The Bar protected in defeat and the pinfall sets TLC up perfectly. They're going to kill it on 16 December.
1. Asuka Wins!
Asuka winning SmackDown's TLC qualifying battle royal was exactly the right outcome to close the show. Props to them for not sh*tting the bed and delivering a needless "swerve" winner (no offence to the underrated Sonya Deville), and let's hope this is a sign that the writers are genuinely interested in rebuilding the fallen 'Empress.'
Flattened by Nia Jax at Survivor Series, Asuka was presented as the battle royal's clear standout. She eliminated several others en route to victory, and though she gave Deville plenty during the closing stretch, Asuka came out of it looking stronger than she has in a while. More importantly, the crowd were into it. They still haven't given up hope in this one-of-a-kind performer, and while Becky Lynch and Charlotte Flair remains SmackDown's biggest female stars, perhaps there's hope for Asuka yet.
WWE supposedly had Charlotte snap on Ronda Rousey so they'd have three stars on Lynch and the former UFC Champion's level. They could've had four if it wasn't for Asuka's summer burial. Those unbreakable pillars could've held the Women's Revolution up on their own for a long, long time, but 'The Empress Of Tomorrow' closed an episode of SmackDown standing tall, and that's a big step forward.