AEW All Out 2022: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True

Unwanted swerves could make All Out the dirt worst AEW pay-per-view yet.

Tony Khan CM Punk
AEW

WWE could steal all the headlines by booking a nightmare-inducing double turn on Saturday's Clash At The Castle special in Cardiff. Never one who wants to be outdone by his competitors, All Elite boss Tony Khan might watch that and scramble through some more last-minute changes for his own pay-per-view: Sunday's All Out.

Start getting worried, folks.

Sorry, but there's almost no positivity here. The article is all about the absolute worst things that could happen this weekend, after all, and that doesn't leave a lot of room for sunshine or happiness. If all (or even most) of the things detailed here happen, then All Out 2022 could actually be the least-appealing AEW supershow ever.

That'd be depressing from a company which hasn't made a habit of regular letdowns on pay-per-view.

Unwanted title wins, "hot" issues that bore the t*ts off a knackered live crowd, complete disappointments when it comes to unannounced surprises and a main event revenge story so foul it'll leave many spitting mad on Twitter - so many bad things could happen on Sunday, and this list has the worst of them.

10. AEW Swerves On The Trios Titles

Kenny Omega The Young Bucks Elite
AEW

Vince Russo f*cking loved a right good (good?) swerve during the dying days of WCW. The 'other Vince' just couldn't resist taking fan expectations and then doing the complete opposite; that was true even when those expected results made more sense from a booking perspective.

Anyone other than The Elite becoming AEW's first Trios Champs would be Russo-esque. In fact, it might make some fans converge upon the back halls of the Now Arena to find out whether or not he was actually in cahoots with Tony Khan and booking some matches on the undercard.

Either The Dark Order or Best Friends will wrestle Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks for those brand new belts, but neither should come out on the winning end. Sadly, this fan can see Will Ospreay getting involved to screw over Omega before launching a singles feud with him.

That'd leave the Trios Title struggling from day one. GREAT.


9. House Of Black Look Weak (Again)

House Of Black AEW
AEW

Want more Trios-related misery? You got it.

Malakai Black, Brody King and Buddy Matthews routinely try to put on the best matches they possibly can. That noble effort has the unfortunate side effect of making everyone from Dark Order to even Fuego Del Sol look on par with them, and that just shouldn't be the case in 2022.

AEW might've booked themselves into a corner here though - Miro needs to keep looking like someone willing to take the fight to the belly of the beast, so he can't afford a loss. That means his team will score the win unless Black is written to pin Darby Allin (or Sting takes an 'L').

The outcome? House Of Black will look like chumps yet again as Excalibur screams into his headset about how dominating they've been since forming. Christ knows what impact Julia Hart is supposed to be having on the faction too. She needs some actual purpose.


8. Jade Cargill Slips Down The Card

Jade Cargill
AEW

Concerns were expressed when AEW slapped some goons behind Jade Cargill (her 'Baddies') and had her act just a wee bit too cowardly. That contradicted her prior booking, but it's not the only change Tony Khan has made. Stokely Hathaway replacing Mark Sterling as her mouthpiece is another.

Why? Jade can talk.

Regardless of who's in her corner, Cargill must hold onto that TBS Title. She's been synonymous with the thing since day dot, and it'd be a total waste if this clumsy feud opposite Athena (one which also involved Kris Statlander until she got waylaid by injuries) was the end point of Jade's mighty push.

The unbeaten champ story has been undercooked during promos with Athena anyway, so it won't really register with fans if she takes the strap on Sunday. AEW really shouldn't be booking title changes for the sake of it, and that's what this switch would come across as.

Keep that belt where it is.


7. Some Hot Issues Don’t Take

Jungle Boy JR Christian Cage
AEW

Three undercard singles battles stand out on the card.

Chris Jericho vs. Bryan Danielson is one of them, but more on that later. For now, it's important to give Jungle Boy vs. Christian Cage and Ricky Starks vs. Powerhouse Hobbs some shine. In fairness, AEW has done a decent job of building both. However, they're hidden away on a jam-packed lower card glut.

Do not be surprised if fans in Illinois use Starks vs. Hobbs to visit the restrooms, check out some merch or go buy another round of beers for friends. That's a constant worry on cards as busy as All Out's - bouts that deserve fan attention might not get much of it.

Apathetic, scattered cheers for JB or Ricky's wins could be detrimental to their respective developments as future All Elite main-eventers, and no f*cker wants that for these lads. Both could probably have been doing with more focus rather than fighting for house room next to throwaway six-man tags and other multi-mans.


6. Tony Khan Adds Another Match

Sammy Guevara Tay Conti
AAA

Aw sh*t.

Restraint, apparently, isn't something Tony Khan does very well. He's penning All Out 2022 like some kid playing fantasy booker on a message board circa 2001, and that's evidenced by the fact the entire card is 14-matches strong/long. Fourteen!

It could end up being 15-strong too, because some bigger names are noticeably absent from the lineup. There's no Sammy Guevara, for example, and Eddie Kingston has been relegated to the pre-show for another match vs. Tomohiro Ishii. That, dear reader, could be half of Eddie's shift this coming Sunday evening.

There's a chance Tony will stick Kingston in there with Ruby Soho against Sammy and Tay Melo. Would that be necessary? Hell no, but "necessary" and "this match is happening in AEW" are rapidly becoming estranged from one another.

Failing that, perhaps Guevara and Melo will defend their AAA Mixed Tag straps against another thrown-together duo. Hey, it could happen. It shouldn't, but it could.


5. Hikaru Shida Somehow Gets Picked

Hikaru Shida
AEW

Thunder Rosa has shot down rumours she's this generation's Shawn Michaels by claiming her back injury is 100% legit. Regardless of everything going on behind the scenes with Rosa, AEW couldn't hesitate - they had to put on some sort of Women's Title bout this weekend, and that's why there's a four-way for the interim gold.

Toni Storm has to win it.

This entry could easily end there, but there's a nagging fear at the back of this fan's head. Now, don't get him wrong, he's a fan of Hikaru Shida, but...she'd be the least-enticing of the quartet to score a win, become interim champ and then hang around waiting for Rosa to return.

That's Toni's spot, especially because she was lined up to challenge for the belt proper in the first place pre-Thunder injury. It'd almost feel like AEW were going backwards by plonking a title on Shida again. The same probs goes for Britt Baker at this point.


4. The ‘Joker’ Is A Letdown

Sonjay Dutt AEW
AEW

If there's one thing Tony loves more than long pay-per-views, it's signing more wrestlers. His roster is ridiculously deep in September 2022, and it just got deeper thanks to the arrival of ex-WWE man W. Morrissey on this week's episode of Dynamite. The former Big Cass just became #AllElite.

He won't be Sunday's 'Joker' entrant in the 'Casino Ladder Match' then, but who will be? Truthfully, some of the names being tossed around by fans on social media are a bit crap. Nobody's suggesting that anyone from IMPACT would be awful gets, but it's definitely a case of diminishing returns with these "surprises" nowadays.

Going in, people predict someone huge like MJF or even Bray Wyatt. If they don't get that, then they'll naturally be disappointed and greet Johnny Elite (or whomever) like a wet fart. Continually leaning on this 'Joker' thing is a risky play by AEW, so they better have someone cool in reserve.

Or else.


3. An Iconic Match Doesn’t Live Up To Hype

AEW All Out 2022 Bryan Danielson Chris Jericho
AEW

On paper, Chris Jericho vs. Bryan Danielson has the potential to be one of AEW's best supershow clashes this year. Both men will be motivated to put on a show, and Bryan will surely bring out the best in Jericho on the night. Or, y'know, the whole thing will be a crushing letdown.

No positivity, remember?

It's a nightmare thought to imagine that this battle of true greats could flounder, but stranger things have happened on major cards over the years. Perhaps the simmering subplot of Daniel Garcia remaining in JAS or joining the BCC will overshadow everything else that happens bell-to-bell.

If so, then this could end up being more Jericho vs. Kevin Owens from WrestleMania 33 than Chris and Danielson would care to admit. Hopefully not. Fingers crossed both legends bring their 'A' game, the Garcia stuff complements their match and this turns into one of the better showings All Out has on tap.


2. Jon Moxley Gets Pushed Aside

CM Punk Jon Moxley
AEW

Jon Moxley was Tony Khan's panic button when injury robbed CM Punk of a proper AEW World Title reign shortly after he won the belt at Double Or Nothing in May. Mox stepped into the breach by beating Punk's original foe Hiroshi Tanahashi to become interim champ at Forbidden Door, but will he get proper thanks for it?

Or will All Elite reverse the squash they booked on Dynamite recently?

That made Mox look like the man, and yet it could've been a one-off. The mere fact that Khan has scheduled a rematch for All Out suggests Punk will fight back from injury, use adrenaline to offset his foot-related agony, get his win back and become full-time champ all over again.

It'd be such a shame to see Moxley get shoved to one side just because of what happened to Punk. He's been the best contingency plan imaginable given the circumstances, and Jon deserves more than to be cast out suddenly.


1. It’s The Worst AEW PPV Yet

Tony Khan
AEW

Punching out this entry doesn't sit well.

AEW's pay-per-views are undeniably long, but the quality is high and most matches feel like they belong there in the first place. All Out 2022 already feels different then, because some bouts (the six-mans, mainly) are exhibition style and would likely be better-placed on Dynamite or even Rampage.

The rushed, last-minute aura of that hastily-arranged main event also sticks out like a proverbial sore thumb. This decision-making is so atypical for AEW, but here it is happening in front of your very eyes. Could it be then that All Out will tank in key area and be deemed the worst All Elite supercard yet?

Nobody, including you, this writer, this writer's cat or even his postman, wants that to be the case. However, All Out is coming across more like a 'B' pay-per-view than Tony Khan would want to publicly admit, and he has to take responsibility for that.

What other nightmares could happen at AEW All Out 2022? For more like this, check out WWE Clash At The Castle: 10 Things That Must Happen and WWE Clash At The Castle: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.