AEW All Out: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best

Pac and Omega put on a clinic.

AEW All Out 2019 Kenny Omega Pac
allelitewrestling.com

All Elite Wrestling made another convincing case for themselves as a thrilling alternative to WWE with their All Out pay-per-view, which while not decisively winning the weekend from NXT UK TakeOver: Cardiff, nevertheless served up a packed slate of quality matches.

There were two genuinely great bouts, a number that weren't far off, and not a single dud among the bunch.

It's fair to say that AEW does need to smooth out a few teething problems - camerawork and production could be better, and the show pacing is brutal - but where it mattered most, All Out was a rousing success.

With the company's weekly live show set to debut next month, this was clearly a table-setting exercise to get the house in order for then, and that it most certainly did, giving fans a deliciously entertaining heel champ who can steer things in the right direction moving forward.

And whichever show you enjoyed the most this weekend, has there ever been a better time to be a wrestling fan? Talk about an embarrassment of riches...


10. The Dark Order Vs. Best Friends

AEW All Out 2019 Dark Order Best Friends
allelitewrestling.com

Result: The Dark Order scored the win - and a first round bye in the AEW Tag Title tournament - after putting Trent Beretta down with the Fatality (13:40).

Rating: The weakest match of the night was still a totally decent, watchable bout with some great selling from all involved. The crowd wasn't too into it and the two teams didn't have the strongest chemistry, but still worked hard to deliver a solid fight.

Nothing in the actual match itself, however, was better than "Freshly Squeezed" Orange Cassidy's post-match debut, with his hands kept firmly in his pockets. Brilliant. 6/10


9. Casino Battle Royale

AEW All Out 2019 Nyla Rose
allelitewrestling.com

Result: Nyla Rose throws out Britt Baker, with some help from Bea Priestley, to win (20:35).

Rating: The Casino Battle Royale remains a bit of an eccentric stipulation that doesn't really add much, but the match itself did bring a few creative ideas to the table to shake up the typical formula.

Leva Bates' spot with the books was hilarious and it was nice to see Awesome Kong given more to do this time, though Nyla Rose was the early standout and held her own for the entire match.

Sadly the crowd was dead for most of the match and it probably didn't need to be more than 20 minutes long. Still, it entertained pretty consistently - which, for a Battle Royale, isn't easy - even if the shenanigans ending was pretty corny. 6/10


8. Shawn Spears Vs. Cody

AEW All Out 2019 Cody Shawn Spears
allelitewrestling.com

Result: Cody takes Spears out with the Cross Rhodes for the win (16:20).

Rating: How about Cody's Star Trek-inspired entrance, huh? Nice to see him embracing the goofiness. The match itself was a physical brawl as expected, while not in any way a technically finessed showdown.

This was probably the most WWE-esque match on the card, as often seems to be the case with Cody. It didn't really need the interference shenanigans, but seeing Arn Anderson murder Spears with a Spinebuster sure was fun regardless.

There will be many questioning the booking of a Spears loss here, but hopefully it's in the service of the long game. 16 minutes was a tad on the long side for what it delivered, but it was good enough. 6/10


7. Cracker Barrel Clash: Darby Allin Vs. Jimmy Havoc Vs. Joey Janela

AEW All Out 2019 Joey Janela.jpg
allelitewrestling.com

Result: Havoc puts Janela away with an Acid Rainmaker into a barrel (15:00).

Rating: It's easy to cringe at the product placement present throughout the match, but at least it was done in a creative and fun way - and we got a "we want barrels!" chant out of it.

But for the most part this was a fun little car crash of a match that leaned into its silliness and delivered a number of memorable spots - Janela monkey-flipping with his chair, that brutal sunset flip through the table, and Allin making inventive use of both barrels and a skateboard.

Everyone got their licks in even if Janela was clearly the star of the show, yet Havoc's win was also a neat surprise. Predictably, though, the multi-man formula drew heavy attention to itself throughout, so it gets a slight ding for that. 7/10


6. Private Party Vs. Jack Evans & Angelico

AEW All Out 2019
allelitewrestling.com

Result: A Poisonrana/Cutter combo keeps Angelico down for the count, giving Private Party the win (11:35).

Rating: This was a very solidly crafted flip-fest that totally woke the lethargic audience up, delivering exactly what it advertised within a tight, snappy runtime.

All four of these guys are stars in the making, though Private Party positively stole the show with their crowd-pleasing work, netting a well-earned victory in the process.

If only all kickoff matches were this exciting and fast-paced, right? 7/10


5. SoCal Uncensored Vs. Jurassic Express

AEW All Out 2019 Luchasaurus
allelitewrestling.com

Result: Daniels kills Stunt and Jungle Boy with a Best Meltzer Ever to land the win for SCU (11:45).

Rating: What a great way to open the show proper - this was an insanely fun match featuring two teams the crowd couldn't love more.

Luchasaurus continues to be one of AEW's real breakout stars, his ridiculous combination of freakish size and athleticism getting him over hard with the crowd.

SCU meanwhile played the tenacious veteran roles as exceptionally well as ever, ensuring their younger opponents looked strong in defeat while bolstering their own brand.

A very good match that could've been great with a few more minutes to give fans that extra something. 7/10


4. AEW Title: Chris Jericho Vs. Adam Page

AEW All Out Chris Jericho Adam Page
allelitewrestling.com

Result: Jericho kills Page with The Judas Effect to become the first ever AEW Champion (26:25).

Rating: This was yet another smartly-booked Jericho slugfest that proved he can still operate at a shockingly high level while creatively working around his physical limitations.

It was too long, yes, but there was a clear attempt to evoke the feel of an epic NJPW main event, and they certainly achieved that for the most part.

The Judas Effect continues to be a totally flat finisher, though, ending the match on a bit of a whimper even if Jericho's win was the right call.

By no means a particularly memorable main event, but it did what it needed to by confirming Jericho as AEW's marquee heel moving forward. A smart decision if there ever was one. 7/10


3. Hikaru Shida Vs. Riho

AEW All Out 2019 Riho Hikaru Shida.jpg
allelitewrestling.com

Result: Riho steals the win with a crucifix rollup, earning a spot against Nyla Rose for the AEW Women's Title (13:35).

Rating: This was a terrific sprint with incredible pacing, amazing energy from both women and some outstanding near-falls, especially in the final stretch.

The size difference between Shida and Riho made for a compelling story and got the crowd effortlessly behind Riho for the entirety.

One suspects these two could've put on all-timer if given more time in the ring, but for what it was this was very, very good. 7/10


2. AAA Tag Titles - Ladder Match: Lucha Brothers (c) Vs. The Young Bucks

AEW All Out 2019 Lucha Brothers Young Bucks
allelitewrestling.com

Result: The Luchas retrieve the straps, retaining them in the process (21:00).

Rating: These guys work insanely well together, obviously, so this didn't disappoint in any way.

The pacing and storytelling were great, and there were so many fantastic marquee moments - the Canadian Destroyer off the ladder and the unmasking spot, to name just two.

You can certainly argue it over-extended itself with too many almost-finishes to the point where it negatively impacted the match, and as a result the actual ending came off slightly anti-climatic.

But for the majority the layout was smart and exciting, and all four men gave everything they had to make this a barn-burner. 8/10


1. Kenny Omega Vs. Pac

AEW All Out 2019 Kenny Omega Pac.jpg
allelitewrestling.com

Result: Pac puts Omega to sleep with the Brutaliser (23:20).

Rating: Though the Moxley situation is unfortunate, giving fans a dream match as a replacement was a smart move, and it sure as hell delivered. Omega and Pac played off one another superbly, the pacing was perfect and the sparring was physical as hell.

They were given a ton of time to deliver a main event-caliber match, and even with Pac being as great as he is, him triumphing over Omega was a pleasant surprise (though a time limit draw also would've been a fine call).

Both men sold the exhaustion brilliantly in the final stretch with some remarkable selling, and Pac couldn't have asked for a stronger AEW debut. Match of the night by a nose. 8/10


In this post: 
AEW All Out
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.