AEW Double Or Nothing 2021: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True

Unnecessary swerves, shock title changes and flat surprises at AEW's Double Or Nothing.

Tony Khan Orange Cassidy
AEW/Twitter/@TonyKhan

Some staunch defenders of All Elite Wrestling will see the title of this piece and start furiously typing complaints about the mere thought that Tony Khan's company could produce a nightmare pay-per-view. In fairness, AEW tends to know what its audience wants, and Khan delivers perhaps 90% of the time.

The weak conclusion to Revolution's 'Exploding Barbed Wire Deathmatch' between Jon Moxley and Kenny Omega should act as a cruel reminder of everything that can go wrong on the night though. That was awful, and it's the one lasting image of an otherwise solid enough show.

What if it happens again? No, not the sparklers (AEW will steer clear of those for a while), but the nightmare fuel - what if Double Or Nothing 2021 turns out to be a night people look back on with shaking heads and tuts rather than nodding ones and praise?

Positivity has no place here. Straight up, this is everything that could go wrong come Sunday night. Unwanted title changes, "surprises" that fall totally flat and unnecessary swerves that Vince Russo would be proud of are law.

They wouldn't, would they...?

10. Miro Goes Back To Square One

Miro AEW
AEW

Nightmare: That Miro drops his newly-won TNT Title to big Lance Archer and ends up mired back in the midcard glut. WWE loyalists will then be able to point and laugh at the notion that AEW would book the ex-Rusev better than Vince McMahon's league.

Chances Of Happening: Very slim, but title changes are always possible.

Someone on the booking staff might point out the Archer should be protected too. AEW don't tend to shy away from clean decisions in major matches, but the odd screwy finish is rarely regarded as a disaster. It would, however, be a nightmare for Miro if the company whipped that belt away from him after just a few weeks.

He'd plummet right back down the card, and might land next to Kip Sabian again. Remember that? It was a horrendous way to debut the man, and it'd be a real step backwards if he was asked to shed his prize already.


9. Sting Squashes A Promising Tag-Team

Sting Scorpio Sky
WWE

Nightmare: Sting's first "proper" match since joining AEW could be a glorified squash that runs through his greatest hits without any hint of concern for Scorpio Sky and Ethan Page. Meanwhile, face painted pal Darby Allin plays second fiddle to some WCW reprise.

Chances Of Happening: Alarmingly, rather good.

Sky and Page have been talking a good game in the build up to this match, and that has this fan pretty worried for them come Double Or Nothing. They'll be bashed around with skateboards, one of them will eat a few Stinger Splashes, and Sky could be nailed on to tap out for the icon's Scorpion Death Lock.

Now, Sting and Darby winning isn't a problem, but Allin is the one who should get the deciding fall.


8. Anthony Ogogo Sh*ts The Bed

Anthony Agogo AEW
AEW

Nightmare: Ex-boxer Anthony Ogogo has looked decent during his first run of AEW appearances. The way he dominated Austin Gunn on a recent episode of Dynamite was a good sign, but...pay-per-view is a different animal. What if he struggles to overcome the pressure against Cody Rhodes?

Chances Of Happening: Yours truly is torn.

On one hand, Rhodes is good enough and over enough to offset Ogogo's lack of experience. On the other, this is Double Or Nothing; it's practically AEW's version of WrestleMania, and the company can't afford to court any annoyed glances about the fact they're putting a wrestling rookie in there.

Though Anthony is no stranger to pressure situations, this isn't a real fight. He'll have to work with Cody to ensure they come out smelling of roses on the night, and that could be challenging for him. Here's hoping they keep it simple so Ogogo's confidence isn't rocked by a poor showing.


7. Hikaru Shida Retains

Hikaru Shida
AEW

Nightmare: That Hikaru Shida's year-long reign continues despite the fact that it's time to make a change and put the belt on a red hot Britt Baker. AEW's decision-makers may get cold feet and decide that they want to stick with Shida for a little while longer.

Chances Of Happening: Slim.

Baker's performance opposite Thunder Rosa on the 17 March Dynamite earned rave reviews, and it felt like a real game-changing moment for her AEW career. The dentist is someone Tony Khan should be building this division around now - not Shida. She's had her time in the sun, and is firmly established enough to survive without the belt.

It'd be rather crap if AEW went the swerve route and had Rebel cost Britt the chance to become champ (or something like that) too. This writer doesn't expect that'll happen, but it's hardly out of the question, especially if AEW would rather keep plodding on with Hikaru.


6. The Casino Surprise Is Hook

Team Taz Brian Cage Ricky Starks Hook
AEW

Nightmare: There's one spot left in the annual Casino Battle Royal for this Sunday. Most wrestling fans on social media are licking their chops at the prospect of another surprise - some are even guessing that Paul Wight, who has been announced as a guest commentator, will work his first AEW match.

Then, BOOM! It's Hook.

Chances Of Happening: There's a great chance that Taz's lad will get the nod and be a late addition to the Battle Royal line up. If that happens, then don't be stunned to hear audible groans from fans in attendance, or see countless tweets bemoaning the lack of some incoming ex-WWE star.

Star power is a real problem in Casino this year. The only ones who feel "big time" are Christian Cage and maybe Matt Hardy. Even so, it's Cage who must win and bag himself a World Title shot. Having anybody else take home the prize would be a disastrous outcome.


5. Matt Hardy Wins The Battle Royal

Matt Hardy
AEW

Nightmare: That Christian Cage doesn't win the Battle Royal and AEW instead spring an unwanted surprise by putting Matt Hardy in the frame for a crack at Kenny Omega. One can almost hear the collective 'meh" coming from fans if that's the case.

Chances Of Happening: Swerves are always an available option.

Everyone and their gran is predicting Cage for the win, mainly because he's the only one involved in the match that people actually want to see against Omega come the next pay-per-view. AEW might not be able to resist booking against the obvious, which would mean that Hardy is a viable alternative to his old TLC foe.

Not a great one though.

Being brutally honest, the wheels have come off Matt's AEW run. He can moan at critics on Twitter all he likes, but there's nothing all that fun about what he's been doing since approx two months after his debut last year.


4. The Tag Title Bout Disappoints

Jon Moxley Eddie Kingston
AEW

Nightmare: Jon Moxley and Eddie Kingston don't appear to have longevity as a tag. Yes, that statement could be shown up in coming months, but it just seems like AEW have placed them in the doubles ranks because they have nothing left for either man to do as singles right now.

That, along with some midcard placement, could hurt their bout with The Young Bucks.

Chances Of Happening: This will either go one of two ways.

One: Mox, Kingston and The Bucks are mega-motivated to show the world what they can do and produce a tag effort that rivals some of the best in recent AEW history. Two: AEW's big Tag Title match ends up being a stall-fest, the quartet slow the overall pace to a crawl and it doesn’t live up to prior tag classics the division has become known for.

The Bucks need to be proper heels here, and Jon/Eddie must be fired up to bring it. If they don't, then this'll fall flat as a pancake.


3. Kenny Omega Drops The Strap

Kenny Omega Orange Cassidy Don Callis
AEW

Nightmare: AEW, in some desperate ploy to book their own underdog champ akin to Daniel Bryan in 2014 or erm...TNA's Eric Young in 2014, decide last-minute to put the World Title on rising star Orange Cassidy. That turns out to be a short-term idea, and Orange drops the belt back to Omega on an upcoming episode of Dynamite.

Chances Of Happening: Surely. F*cking. Not.

Kenny waited almost two years to take his place at the top of the AEW Title tree, and it'd be incredibly random if his first reign ended in a rather second-rate Triple Threat against Cassidy and old partner-come-rival PAC. The most likely outcome here is that Omega pins Orange (presumably by cheating) and spins off into a full-blown singles feud against him.

Cassidy isn't everyone's cup of tea, but he is a good worker and earned his stripes against Chris Jericho previously. That doesn't quite mean he's ready to become the top man in the entire promotion though. Not yet anyway.


2. Sammy Guevara Joins The Pinnacle

Sammy Guevara Chris Jericho
AEW

Nightmare: That Sammy Guevara gets fed up of Chris Jericho "holding him back" and decides to swerve jump to The Pinnacle on Sunday night. Don't forget that Sammy submitted to try and save Jericho back at Blood & Guts - his character might start to question the Inner Circle's leader.

Chances Of Happening: Pretty decent.

Guevara fits the mould of a brash young upstart who'd selfishly ditch Jericho's crew to start running with MJF's. Sadly, that'd dilute The Pinnacle already. It also wouldn't make much sense considering Sammy was the one who warned Jericho about MJF's mutiny in the first place.

This is pro wrestling though. Logic often takes a backseat in favour of surprises.

The Pinnacle don't need Guevara, and he doesn't need them. If anything, post-Inner Circle, he needs to start establishing his own voice on AEW's roster away from a stable. He's been in one for a while now, so the time is right.


1. The Pinnacle Loses

The Pinnacle
AEW

Nightmare: Or, this happens; The Pinnacle lose their rematch with The Inner Circle at 'Stadium Stampede' and AEW decide to go 50/50 with the feud so they can blow it off in yet another big gimmick match further on down the road.

Chances Of Happening: Again, surely not.

AEW seemed to paint themselves into a corner with the stip that Jericho's boys must disband as a group if they lose at Double Or Nothing. MJF, FTR, Wardlow, Shawn Spears and Tully Blanchard are only just getting started, whereas the IC have been around for an age.

It'd be a nightmare if the writers elected to go 1-1 in gimmick bouts just for the sake of another epic in a few months. That's not quite as satisfying as The Pinnacle winning, stamping their dominance all over the roster and sending The Inner Circle to splitsville.

What other nightmares could come true at AEW Double Or Nothing 2021? For more like this, check out AEW Double Or Nothing 2021: 10 Things That Must Happen and 18 Things You Probably Missed From WWE Raw (May 24)!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.