Biggest Winners & Losers of AEW Double or Nothing 2024
With title wins and big losses, who had the best and worst showings at AEW Double or Nothing 2024?
The five-year anniversary of All Elite Wrestling was celebrated in grand fashion with AEW Double or Nothing 2024 this past weekend, which saw many moments that will stand the test of time.
New champions were crowned. Title-holders reestablished their dominance with impressive victories. Friendships fell. New alliances were forged. A franchise player renewed his dedication to the company. All of this went down with a ton of blood, sweat and tears as a handful of wrestlers stood tall in victory, while others were crushed by defeat.
Some of those wins and losses mean more than the others, and will likely have a much bigger impact—positively or negatively—going forward. So let's break down the biggest winners and losers of this event!
10. Winner: Will Ospreay
Winning any match is a positive. Capturing a championship in the process makes it significantly more valuable. But going out there and putting on a great performance on top of that? That's the trifecta that Will Ospreay accomplished in the opening match of the main card.
Ospreay took Roderick Strong—widely considered one of the best in-ring talents of this generation—and put him firmly in the rung below him on the ladder of top wrestlers in the company. Even with interference from The Undisputed Kingdom, Strong wasn't able to get the job done.
The Aerial Assassin has been on a run like no other, fitting in AEW like a glove and making the argument that he's fast on his way to becoming the benchmark of what AEW stands for: strong wrestling skills, fast-paced action, tenacity, and an unparalleled passion for performances between the ropes. All of that was signified here and winning the International Championship isn't just a matter of obtaining a midcard title, but a sign that Ospreay may lead AEW into the next era.
With this belt, we can assume he will be prominently featured for quite a while, defending the championship on a regular basis and being entrusted to tear down the house at future pay-per-views as a marquee name no matter who his opponents are.
9. Winner: MJF
Cutting a promo on a pay-per-view and still coming out of it as one of the most talked about performers who stole the show is impressive. At least, it would be to most people, but not when it comes to MJF.
He's always had the gift of gab—so much so that it allowed him to stand out before he was able to showcase his in-ring skills and establish himself as one of the most important assets to AEW's growth.
Now that he's not only returned from his injuries and at least partially taken care of his Adam Cole problem (as it remains to be seen how long that feud will continue), MJF spoke on his contract status, doubling down that AEW is the company he wants to continue building his legacy in and that he's going nowhere.
While that's upsetting for fans who wish to see him lock up with WWE Superstars and join in on all the fun going down there under The Paul Levesque Era, MJF made an emphatic statement that being here in AEW is his choice, rather than just where he's at for the time being. That should be a rousing morale booster to the locker room after a rough few years of talent like CM Punk leaving, Cody Rhodes going off to become an even bigger star and the constant rumors and speculation of who else will jump ship next.
MJF not only had a moment in getting some revenge on his former Brochacho, but he dissed some of the gimmicks that weren't working well in 2023, reinvigorated his spirits and gave fans something huge to pop about.
8. Loser: Trent Beretta
On paper, Trent Beretta's loss to Orange Cassidy isn't as big of a deal as some of the others on this list. After all, no titles were on the line, nothing was at stake and he didn't even lose in any embarrassing way that would make him look like a fool.
However, his heel turn isn't working out all that well, and it's becoming obvious he made the wrong decision in abandoning his friends.
Not only did he lose here and, in a kayfabe sense, didn't get the bigger paycheck and will go down in the rankings, but failing to make a statement that proves turning on his buddy was the right decision is a bonus failure.
Then, instead of learning a lesson about it, he continued to dig the hole deeper by pushing Rocky Romero aside in anger after the match, who was only trying to help console him. That may result in losing his third friend in a row, leaving him with no allies to go forward and turn his career around.
What he hoped would be a triumphant moment to put Cassidy in his place ended up being a defeat that should make him question his mistakes.
7. Winner: Chris Jericho
Chris Jericho walked into this three-way for the FTW Championship as the underdog, despite his years of experience and status as the biggest star of the three. But there's a reason he is perpetually forging new stables of underlings to do his bidding, and why this current incarnation is called The Learning Tree.
And that is because it works, which Jericho proved by retaining his title.
The entire match, Hook and Katsuyori Shibata had moments where they double-teamed him. It could have been an easy route for them to take him out and then settle who the next champion would be between the two of them. But Jericho's cunning allowed him to stay in the fight long enough to avoid any pitfalls until what seemed to be the bitter end.
That's when his intelligence and preparedness came into play, as having backup in Big Bill and being able to utilize him in a No Disqualification match paid off. More so, having found a second contingency plan was the real key, as he took an adversary in Bryan Keith—who nearly became one of his opponents in this match—and turned him into an ally sometime before the event.
Keith's interference was the difference-maker that gave Jericho the victory and allowed him to walk out still the champion, with a second ally to help him hold onto that belt going forward.
6. Loser: Don Callis
The last we saw of Don Callis at Double or Nothing would indicate that he had a great night. He was all smiles, talking about how The Don Callis Family had reasons to celebrate, and that on Dynamite, he will be offering a contract to a new member of the team.
But what's under the surface is that it actually wasn't a successful evening for Callis himself. Merely, his associate Will Ospreay was the only one who actually left the event with something to gloat about.
During that match for the International Championship, Callis tried to convince Ospreay to severely injure Strong with a Tiger Driver. Ospreay hesitated, decided not to be that cruel, and it nearly cost him the match. But he managed to maintain his integrity and won the title in spite of his mentor's advice, proving that he doesn't need him and Callis may be more of a burden to his soul than a benefit.
This was reiterated later in the evening when Konosuke Takeshita did the opposite, listened to Callis, opted to go for a steel chair and it led to Jon Moxley being able to take a breather and turn the weapon onto Takeshita. The commentary team made a point to stress that based on the match's scales being so heavily in Takeshita's favor for the majority of the contest, it was listening to Callis that led to his defeat.
Takeshita may look at this loss and blame his manager, whose advice only got in the way of him earning an IWGP World Heavyweight Championship opportunity, and Callis may find himself soon losing his two biggest contracts.
5. Winner: Adam Copeland
Simple things first, Adam Copeland successfully retained his TNT Championship over not only a game Malakai Black, but the interference of The House of Black's fellow members, Brody King and Buddy Matthews. It was an impressive victory in a brutal match that will go down as one of The Rated-R Superstar's highest marks as champion.
The performance itself is worthy of praise, too. To go out at this stage in his career and take that punishment while putting on a great show proves yet again, as if it were ever in question, why Copeland is one of the all-time greats. Never count him out to showcase his skills, even with all the injuries he's sustained.
But there were a few extra wins that helped make this even sweeter, such as his reunion moment with Gangrel. It's always fun to see legends return and after feuding with his best friend and fellow Brood member Christian Cage for so long, having an ally that is still on your side is a huge boost.
Finally, to cap it all off, Copeland was able to regain possession of his wedding ring that had been stolen by Black two weeks ago, righting that wrong and putting to bed that the negativity of The House of Black wasn't strong enough to break those bonds.
4. Winner: Mercedes Moné
Arguably the biggest winner of this entire list is Mercedes Moné, your new TBS champion.
Leaving WWE was a tough decision, but one she felt she needed to make. She bet on herself and went to New Japan Pro Wrestling, where she was instantly the top talent in the women's division, only to suffer some setbacks that put her career on hiatus.
After overcoming her injuries, Moné made her debut in AEW and spent the past few months cutting promos and developing an air of pessimism. Many fans wrote her off as a flop, frustrated that her angle wasn't good enough, her presentation was lacking and not getting in the ring was becoming annoying.
She needed to step up and prove why she's one of the best women in the business, and she not only put on a performance that should silence those doubters, but she did so by defeating someone who put her on the shelf and stole her title in the process.
Now, Moné can say she backed up her words with her bite and is going to be a major part of this women's division as she only takes a back seat to one other woman in Toni Storm.
3. Loser: Willow Nightingale
Just as Mercedes Moné levelled up, Willow Nightingale fell down the totem pole. Not in the sense that she's no longer a talent to be on the lookout for, as she's still going to be one of the best women in this division and should arguably gain even more popularity out of sympathy for her loss, but in a kayfabe sense, this was an awful night for her.
Of course, losing the match to Moné stings. All those words Nightingale said about proving she could beat her and the confidence boost that would have come with that, as well as the sweet sense of pride in shutting Moné up, didn't ring true. Coupling that with losing the championship so soon after winning it makes that loss even harder, as you never know when the next opportunity will come around.
But to make things worse, Nightingale also lost her two closest allies immediately after the match when Stokely Hathaway and Kris Statlander turned on her. She wasn't even able to seek comfort in the arms of her friends.
Now, she'll have to climb this uphill battle alone, which will no doubt mean she's on a shaky foundation with her confidence levels much lower than they've been in recent months.
2. Winner: The Elite
The Elite took a bold stance when they started to take over the company and were met with opposition from Tony Khan, Kenny Omega, and the wrestlers on Team AEW.
Had they come up short in the Anarchy in the Arena match, it might have proven they were overconfident and overstepped their boundaries. There may have also been serious consequences to be dished out later.
Instead, they're beaten up, but they were victorious, dealing a huge blow to anyone who stands in their way of this mutiny in the works, and this victory is only going to give them more drive and motivation to continue their evil ways and push the boundaries even more.
It was as much of a symbolic victory as it was a literal one. The first shot in the war between The Elite and AEW went their way, nearly all subsequent skirmishes have turned out well for them, and the first real battle goes to their side. The momentum is in their camp. What they do with it can only spell disaster for their enemies.
1. Loser: Team AEW
Anarchy in the Arena was Team AEW's chance to turn the tide in this war, and they failed. Where do they go from here, now that they're going to be fighting from a greater disadvantage than they were going into this match?
FTR, Darby Allin and Bryan Danielson gave their all and even brought a flamethrower to the dance and it wasn't enough. Their reward for standing up for the company was blood loss, puncture wounds from all the thumbtacks, and who knows what other injuries suffered from all this brutality.
Tony Khan himself was also a victim of this attack, and while he walked out less damaged than the others, to go from "fearing for his life" in the All In CM Punk incident to being battered and bruised for the second time means he's more vulnerable than ever.
Some might think there's nowhere to go but up from here, and that AEW has hit rock bottom, but based on the weeks leading up to this even more painful loss, there's a chance it's only going to continue to go downhill and Double or Nothing could be viewed in retrospect as the Battle of Chickamauga in this civil war.