Booking 10 WCW Concepts In Modern-Day WWE
Southern Comfort
Wrestling old-timers often spoke of the industry being cyclical. It was commonly a promoter's justification for financial downtime beyond creative malaise, but remarkable boom periods in the 1980s and 1990s added certain weight to the theory. Following WWE's 2001 purchase of WCW though, the paradigm shifted again.
From that point onwards, merely competing with the monolithic McMahon empire for a share of the market was success enough - there was no longer time to wait around for an upswing whilst innovations and trends were there to be devised and monetised.
Despite being the only organisation best placed to roll out retreads and retries since then, WWE have been frustratingly stubborn about reissuing purchased concepts as their own. Countless new formats were rolled out with mixed fortunes despite proven entities figuratively shelved alongside the literal signs and set dressings inside the company's cavernous storage facility.
But the clunky evolution of WWE continues in earnest. Just 24 hours before the organisation presents the 30th edition of a show conceived with the expressed purpose of driving a stake through the heart of Starrcade, NXT will host the first ever McMahon-endorsed WarGames match. A Greensboro, North Carolina house show exactly one week later has been branded in the image of the NWA/WCW 'Grandaddy Of Them All'.
If yet more changing times reflect an overdue warmth towards the Atlanta outfit, there are countless ways WWE could re-badge selected favourites. More than ratings, buyrates and gate receipts, this would perhaps highlight just how cyclical the industry still is after all.
10. Triple Decker
Triple decker cages are something of a punchline for wrestling historians thanks to the atrocious mismanagement of otherwise impressive structures in WCW.
A 'Russo's Revenge' Nitro WarGames match was an abysmal waste of time thrown on television in a failed bid for a ratings point, but it at least made use of the expensive structure commissioned as a stage for David Arquette's heel turn earlier that year. The 2000 vintage at least bettered 1996's horrific Doomsday Cage. A blocky, ungainly structure that housed one of the worst matches of all time, it was a fittingly unpleasant setting for a rotten eight-on-two match won easily by babyface conquerors Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage.
As of writing, Shane McMahon has hurled himself of WWE's highest height twice in the last two years, but what's the need in him going for the hat-trick at this point? He should save his next tumble for the roll-out of this magnificent mental monster. He doesn't even need Vince Russo's nod to go ahead with such a stupid stunt.
It's easy to once again rely on Russo as a punching bag for worthless execution, but after WWE's persistent success with Hell In A Cell, the logic for the bigger and (not really) better version was clear enough. He wasn't even the first WCW head honcho to try and do things three times bigger than WWE...
9. World War 3
Bouyed by the growing success of Monday Nitro, World War 3 started life as another of Eric Bischoff's 'cheeky b*stard' moments of madness. Using as much of Ted Turner's money as he could justify, 'Easy E' looked ahead at WWE's pay-per-view calendar and saw the historic and beloved Royal Rumble in his sights. So he doubled it, one month earlier.
It wasn't a creative triumph. WCW had neither the creative nor production nous to pull the undertaking off. Little happened as 60-men battled across three rings in the contest's early going, but you'd be none the wiser from the lousy coverage of it all until it reached the proverbial nitty gritty.
But when WWE successfully dabbled with a 40-man Royal Rumble in 2011, the company proved their willingness to gamble away a beloved format for even greater success.
The three-ring set-up would perhaps be a bold leap too far, but the prospect of a two-hour, 60 man Rumble would be spectacular beyond anything they've ever attempted. In fact, do away with the 'man' element altogether - a multi-superstar intergender Rumble inclusive of all would be a Rumble to celebrate diversity in fiercely divided times.
8. Monster Truck Sumo
The Giant returning less than two hours removed from getting pushed off a building without a mark on him was arguably the stupidest thing WCW ever committed to screen. It begged the viewer to ask questions of his descent, his landing and the point of even having a wrestling match with the seven-footer if he was impervious to death itself.
But massive cars with muscly arms and skulls on them? Fighting on a rooftop? Yes please!
As with many outlandish 1990s ideas from WCW's insanity factory, there's a good chance they could be repurposed into something broadly credible by 2017 WWE.
The House Of Horrors was the most miserable gimmick match of the year, but it's an exception that proves the rule for contemporary company silliness. As Vince McMahon gets older, his visions seem to get even more ludicrous, not least when viewed through a restrictive PG prism.
Braun Strowman's path of rage this year has been on the right side of farcical every time, including his own death-defying re-emergence from a trash compactor.
'The Monster Truck Among Men' vs 'The Big Red Monster Truck' would be a perfect way to pay off Strowman's current feud with Kane. Maybe a trip similar to The Giant's would have the requisite impact.
7. World Cup Of Wrestling
Pro Wrestling World Cups, done right, can be absolutely brilliant. Absorbing and engaging clashes of styles, the battles can make shows unlike any other especially when an organisation indulges in the abilities of globally renowned talents for one-time only affairs.
WCW didn't get the formula quite right when they handed over Starrcade 1995 to the concept, but an admirable USA Vs Japan thread offered up some intriguing efforts that strayed bravely from the organisation's traditional output.
As evidenced with the Cruiserweight Classic, WWE's access to talent in the modern age affords them the opportunity of bringing together far more than just two great nations for a similar idea.
It was something even TNA couldn't screw up during their daftest days. Utilising their own X Division talent as well as performers from all over the globe, they promoted their own version of the competition to critical acclaim from the minuscule audience that actually saw it.
In Shinsuke Nakamura (and to a lesser extent, Asuka), WWE have managed to finally promote Japanese talent without resorting to dated stereotypes. Furthermore, unlike the failed Jinder Mahal experiment, this tournament could actually further this localisation strategy.
6. BattleBowl
BattleBowl was a slightly convoluted WCW idea that by today's standards doesn't even seem that tricky to follow.
The format (and one-time standalone pay-per-view) saw wrestlers entered into a 'lethal lottery' in which they'd be paired with random partners for a single elimination tournament. The pairings that won their respective matches were entered into a Battle Royal finale with a title shot or relative prize for the overall winner.
It required a brief explanation, but WWE and especially TNA have since travelled far beyond the short bullets needed to put this across to a loyal audience.
The closing match would require some tweaking to remove obvious comparisons to the Royal Rumble, but the remainder of the format would be perfect for an inter-brand supercard. Raw and SmackDown Live! rivals paired together would create exceptional tension in tournament matches, whilst the prospect of rare main event conflicts otherwise excluded by brand divides would effectively tease future encounters.
Vince McMahon allegedly hates the King Of The Ring tournament because unknown potential matches don't sell as well as confirmed clashes. BattleBowl theoretically poses a similar problem, though a bracket loaded with sixteen mixed up megastars in today's landscape would realistically sell itself.
5. Bash At The Beach...At The Beach
One of several cases of WCW's visual imagination trumping WWE's during financially testing times for Vince McMahon, 1995's Bash At The Beach was another daring move from Eric Bischoff to try and elevate the company's perception as a lifetime second string.
To this end, Tony Schiavone barked mad lies about attendance, Ric Flair and Randy Savage's encounter was bolstered by lifeguards instead of lumberjacks, and Hulk Hogan and Vader's steel cage main event was woven into the plot of an episode of Baywatch.
2017 WWE is bigger and bolder an organisation than even the most bombastic 1990s WCW arrangement. An extra-summery SummerSlam held on one of USA's luxurious beaches perhaps an even more dazzling tropical climb would promise an entirely esoteric viewer experience in this era of identikit broadcasts and versatile super-HD screens.
Furthermore, the company could sell travel packages that double not just as a dream fan experience but also a spectacular vacation. Thousands pay to travel across the world for WrestleMania with many presumably prepared to part with similar coin to be part of a fabulously unique experience.
With WWE Network original content still high on the company's list of priorities, they could even film hours of clickworthy beach craic to trot out over the coming months following the event.
4. Hog Wild
Between 1996 and 1999, WCW presented a pay-per-view from the black hills of South Dakota slap bang in the middle of the enormous Sturgis Motorcycle Rally. It was, like so much of WCW's output, an exercise in indulgence. But it wasn't without its charms.
Eric Bischoff, Hulk Hogan and various other wrestlers really loved motorbikes, and the Ted Turner war chest afforded their hobby a slot in the pay-per-view calendar despite the shows drawing zero dollars at the gate.
It was an imperfect model, but again one that wouldn't require much tweaking for WWE to make an absolute killing from. Much like the original 'Tribute To The Troops' Christmas shows from various military bases around the world, the relatively intimate setting makes for a spectacular visual as fans jockey for position to get a better view of the superstars.
A key issue beyond the free entry with WCW's version was the audience's disinterest in the product at large, but pre-promotion would circumvent any such issue. NXT has already piloted something similar by running events at major music festivals inside smaller tents and stages. A higher profile production wouldn't be out of budgetary or creative reach for WWE.
3. King Of The Road
The original 'King Of The Road' encounter between Dustin Rhodes and Blacktop Bully still receives abuse two decades on from opening WCW's inaugural Uncensored pay-per-view - itself a concept universally derided as routinely one of the year's worst shows.
The match, objectively speaking, was atrocious. The sparse, hay-laden truck was the antithesis of wrestling's penchant for the grandiose, whilst the combatants were banned from doing anything too violent thanks to the company's standards and practices overlords. This despite the fact they were fighting on a moving car. The silliness was a literal career killer - both were fired from the organisation for blading during the bout.
But WWE could work wonders with this sort of disaster. A combination of some of the entertainment industry's slickest live production and 22 years of technological advancement would increase the action and drama tenfold, not least if the vehicle in question wasn't a farm truck.
The company love f*cking about with cars as it is. WWE superstars have done all sorts with vehicles, even during the PG era. Braun Strowman and Roman Reigns could continue their never-ending tensions with an entirely new spin on the ambulance match. Let one race to a hospital with the two monsters fighting inside. Arriving at a medical facility will be, if nothing else, hugely convenient.
2. Spring Break
Amongst some of the detestable idioms Michael Cole is force-fed each week on Monday Night Raw, 'fun to watch' remains the most infuriating. Not only does it trivialise the wafer-thin veneer of competitiveness that still exists, it's so often not bloody true.
WWE TV and especially Monday Night Raw can sometimes be a real grind. The weekly show is chasing viewers away by the thousands, particularly in a last hour the company can't decide between boosting or burying.
WCW's spring break sojourns were a ludicrous waste of money and resources over the years, but the aesthetics represented a mindset completely alien to the comparably stoic WWE philosophy.
That Eric Bischoff managed to sneak the concept through as an annual tradition as he did with the Sturgis pay-per-view visits was another boon for talent that undoubtedly enjoyed the company-funded hedonism dressed up as professional wrestling. As with most comparisons, WWE would certainly run a tighter ship, but the first water-bound SmackDown Live! would add a whole new meaning to 'blue brand'. Shane McMahon's clash could even be fought on a record-breaking high dive board - at least one into a huge pool might be a little more memorable than his most recent stunts.
1. WarGames
The wide gap between euphoria and gloom in the life of a WWE fan is often narrowed by the company's choice of champion. With a beloved figurehead, even the darkest tunnel reveals as a ray of light, but a morale-sapping titleholder can have a fatal impact on genuine emotional investment. AJ Styles liberating the WWE Title from Jinder Mahal was the most recent significant shift for fans that felt the 'Modern Day Maharaja's reign strangling their love.
It's perhaps a newfound optimism sprung from 'The Phenomenal One's latest triumph that gives fans hope that NXT's TakeOver topliner is really a dry run for a fully fleshed out WWE reinvention.
Triple H's latest progressive push-through is far from an overnight job. He pushed for bringing back the double-cage blockbuster for years, even inadvertently triggering the invention of the Elimination Chamber after Vince McMahon bluntly declared he'd rather devise something brand new than lean on an idea not remotely his own.
Ironically, WWE's booking has rarely leant itself to the concept so well. '#UnderSiege' and the blue and red gubbins that fuels it would be perfectly paid off in a WarGames clash. As it stands, main roster fans may have to wait a year for next year's inter-brand battle, but if NXT breathes new life into the gimmick, a longstanding fantasy of millions could finally become a reality and a brand new Thanksgiving tradition.