Broken Matt Hardy In WWE - What Went Wrong?
WONDERF-oh...
Referring to Matt Hardy's carefully crafted chaotic other-world as the "Broken" Universe may be bang on brand, but is perhaps the biggest wrestling misnomer of the decade. In breaking the original version of himself and descend into the stuff of nightmares, he fixed it for numerous performers to receive opportunities beyond their wildest dreams.
Key collaborator Jeremy Borash at long last accepted an overdue offer from WWE having spent the entire of TNA's lifespan toiling against the tide for the good of the cause. Jeff Hardy's 'Brother Nero' alter-ego was an outer-expression of his inner-self, but the personal demons that once plagued him were visibly subdued enough for Vince McMahon to once again take a punt on the 'Charismatic Enigma'. A batsh*t 'Total Nonstop Deletion' edition of Impact bought The Rock & Roll Express amongst others a night's work that almost definitely doubled their fees at conventions and signings for the next few years.
Matt's ticket back to the top was remarkably the most assured after months of magnificent performances in the role, with The Hardy Boyz' scintillating WrestleMania 33 return pop almost entirely reserved for his deranged demeanour. It was put on ice in the immediate aftermath, as fans eagerly awaited a) the end of an ugly rights dispute between TNA's parent company and Matt himself over the gimmick and b) Vince McMahon taking the plunge into a creative pool already filled to the brim by Hardy himself.
What could possibly go wrong?
CONT'D...
Seriously, what could go wrong? The question wasn't hypothetical so much as it was realistically pessimistic.
The manner in which WWE has scythed through almost every "can't miss" NXT prospect over the last few years has been so depressing that it's actually butchered the enjoyment of the otherwise-excellent weekly broadcast. NXT's 2014-15 golden era wasn't just fantastic at surface level; it was augmented by an overarching feeling of hope for just about every performer on the show. Yes, there had to be television time for a Baron Corbin or a Nia Jax, but dark-days-WWE dorks like those two were merely rule-proving exceptions, surely never destined to take up masses of time on Monday Nights.
Beyond that blandness, NXT was the breeding ground for the elite - a place that WWE presumably hoped would render the independent scene OBSOLETE, just as it had Impact Wrestling years earlier.
There was hope, before all was lost.
CONT'D...
Such hope is, in the dim present of 2018, nowhere in sight. McMahon flips the script on your favourites. Bayley was the wary and dignified hero became a pitiful and joyless buffoon begging for hugs from unwilling recipients. Shinsuke Nakamura was the first non-conformist Japanese wrestler to ever work for the organisation, but was reduced to portraying yet another factory floor Far East stereotype. Bobby Roode burst away from his Impact Zone shackles to embody someone perhaps even beyond his 'Glorious' moniker down the road at Full Sail Unversity, yet the Main Roster road has derailed even the veneer that he's anything other than grossly over-gimmicked.
The Hardy Boyz returned to a huge response that likely only reminded Vince of his own belief that he's an unflappable Sports Entertainment genius. There they were; adult versions of the "Boyz" they'd once portrayed, coming of age like the stage upon which they performed. It was probably then he discarded ever putting the weight of his efforts behind whatever other-worldly claptrap one of the lowly wrestlers had dreamed up themselves in a 'rival' promotion.
Broken Matt Hardy wasn't so much likely to go wrong as it was destined to.
CONT'D...
The beginnings of the storyline were all too familiar for WWE - Wrestler A is an abject f*cking loser. Like 95% of all storylines underneath whatever Roman Reigns happens to be up to that week, the angle kicked off with Matt Hardy becoming just one of the forgotten rank-and-file on Monday Night Raw. Following an aforementioned white hot start, the North Carolinian had cooled after his brother went on the injured list following a pleasing feud with Sheamus and Cesaro. Matt was a floater on the show without him - that is to say, a turd in the toilet that is the red brand.
His losses were at least part of a bigger picture. Hardy had gently fostered the "DELETE" chants since his return, and steered into them as he appeared to gradually morph back into the persona that propelled him back to the forefront of the wrestling zeitgeist. Everything was finally returning to how it needed to be. Hardy's eyes were widening, audience anticipation was building and ordinarily critical observers were laughing as loudly as Matt in the gimmick himself.
Laughing, they were. Laughing. It was the best foreshadowing WWE had done in years.
CONT'D...
To their credit, WWE smartly played both hands simultaneously with the descent of Hardy back into his 'Woken' and maddened state. Many had fans had been waiting since Night One of his return for the persona to emerge, but the losing streak was at least a loose narrative thread to justify him slipping into his Universe for the ones that only remembered Matt as a yodelling buffoon cashing in his romantic collapse for a wrestling angle a decade earlier.
Wired and weird, the switch flicked behind Hardy's head along with the staged backdrop. Instead of speaking to Mike Rome ahead of some meaningless filler, he guffawed in front of a cheap bedsheet instead. And did the same again the next week. The day the laughter died was the realisation set in that he was to be paired with the most toxic midcard presence in years.
The biggest surprise breakout star of the past several years was given the least surprising first feud available and was tasked with fixing the IRL most broken character in the entire company.
Delete your account, WWE...
CONT'D...
After long being left to drown by the WWE Universe, Bray Wyatt was given a lifeline by the 'Woken' one. There was a painfully inevitability to it all, too, in spite of game and gutsy fan denial. Bray, Luke Harper and Erick Rowan had engaged in a skit with The New Day in 2016 that liberally pillaged the bones of the original 'Final Deletion' battle between Matt and Jeff, sans nuance, wit and charm. Like The Undertaker slaying beasts in the early-1990s, Wyatt was Vince's new Boy for any gimmick that needed the house lights turning off. Finn Bálor escaped having to dress like a pumpkin when Bray went down with mumps, but Matt wasn't so fortunate.
The pair's hostilities had less electricity than the darkened 'House Of Horrors' Wyatt d*cked about in with Randy Orton a year earlier.
Little of the hackneyed and dated dialogue landed between them, but the company persevered nonetheless as plans were made to have their own crack at producing the madness of king Matt for Monday Night Raw. 'Ultimate Deletion' was...okay, actually, but clearly something Vince McMahon felt too old for even before it aired.
CONT'D...
The production was apparently a collaboration between Hardy himself and WWE's own staffers, but the orders dished out to Michael Cole to belligerently discredit it before it even aired signposted the longterm future of the act. It did at least sink heel Bray Wyatt definitively - he was thrown into to the "Lake Of Reincarnation" but in a very WWE move, didn't actually re-emerge from it. It was in keeping with how the company had ruined the gimmick in almost record time - there was no coming back from the damage already done.
Wyatt's rebirth on the WrestleMania pre-show alongside Matt offered him the first glimmer of light in nearly five years, and the pair going on to scoop Tag Team Title gold was at least a nod that McMahon saw a semblance of money in the madness. Not the sort of cash worth investing in another trip to Hardy's Compound, mind. Those days were over before they'd started, and a need for Matt to take time off to heal his literally broken body put paid to the gimmick too.
Much like the 'The Deleters Of Worlds', this piece has no happy ending, nor really any conclusion beyond the painfully pragmatic. When it comes to Matt Hardy’s Broken Universe, Vince McMahon assumed CONTROL, before eventually ALTering and DELETING it with the dexterity of a teenage fan looking to fix the virus his thirsty search for Paige videos left behind. Bray Wyatt might yet again be saved with a hard reset, but Matt Hardy - broken or otherwise - may now be permanently shut down.