Can Matt Riddle Break The WWE Main Roster Curse?

Big smile out there.

Matt Riddle
Oli Sander / The Ringside Perspective

“It doesn’t matter if you like me, hate me, I beat your favourite wrestler, it doesn’t matter, by the end of the show: “Bro”. “Bro. Bro…””

That wasn’t just a promo Matt Riddle cut to Vice Sports. Something happens when Riddle makes his entrance. The crowd, in unison, chants “Bro!” Bro!” Bro!” under his spell. To conflate our ’90s hip hop references, they are hypnotised when the opening synth whistles to “Regulate” creep onto the PA system. To borrow his phrase, it doesn’t matter if you yourself don’t ascribe to bro culture. It doesn’t matter if you’re a boring, bespectacled geek off the street, more likely to drink wine than smoke weed. It doesn’t matter if you hate jocks, or if you hate dude-bros. Riddle, with his massive, beaming, almost dumb grin, makes everybody feel like they belong.

There’s something of The Rock about him. He’s so obviously the coolest man in the room—with a subcultural aesthetic at odds with the geekier pro wrestling fandom—but he’s not remotely detestable. He’s just popular, in a word.

He makes sure to fist-bump as many of his fans as possible. He nods along to his entrance theme—it helps that it is a total jam—and transmits a sense of fun. He’s having, or has had, the time of his life on the Independent circuit with an act precision-engineered to put smiles on faces, not that he does any cynical engineering. It’s all so effortless to him, or at least, that’s how it appears.

He’s unique, as well as transcendentally charismatic. He was a real fighter - and a d*mn good one - and comes equipped with the attendant badass, legitimate aura. In addition to winning over crowds, there are few if any better acts out there at allowing them to suspend their disbelief. He is a phenomenal and credible pro wrestler like no other. He is still inchoate, but incredible, and improving all the time.

CONT'D...(1 of 4)


Adam Cole NA Title
WWE

His 2018 matches with Will Ospreay were among the best in arguably wrestling's best ever in-ring year. Using his opponent’s battered neck as a suspenseful and harrowing narrative driver, or simply putting down his warp speed aerial attacks with his own brutal striking game in ultra-heated advancements of the ever-evolving pro wrestling art, Riddle is no one-dimensional performer. He’s as over as anybody before he even steps foot in the ring, but expresses an ambition within it belying his carefree disposition.

Matt Riddle is NXT-bound, and he is virtually guaranteed to succeed on the yellow brand. He gets over everywhere.

A prospective NXT run promises something very special. Adam Cole presents himself as the coolest man in the room. That’s the heat, and a programme between the King and the pretender would provoke Cole into a response that allows him to showcase his incredible range of flustered facials. Riddle Vs. Tommaso Ciampa is money. Ciampa would have to do some sick sh*t, even by his standards, to engage the breezy Riddle in psychological warfare. Riddle Vs. The Velveteen Dream could light up the Orlando power grid in itself, there is so much star power radiating from both men.

But an NXT run is not the issue.

It never is.

CONT'D...(2 of 4)


Finn Balor Money In The Bank Briefcase
WWE.com

Unfortunately, Matt Riddle is also main roster-bound. WWE tends not to handle such promotions well - to such an extent that the very word “promotion” has become grimly ironic. Riddle gets over everywhere - but can he stay over in the one promotion in which it doesn’t matter if a performer gets over?

Bobby Roode is not Glorious; he is Deluded. Shinsuke Nakamura promised a new chapter of WWE in-ring storytelling at TakeOver: Dallas; he is now an old throwback to the foreign menace trope, albeit one that is subverted and actually entertaining. It took two brilliant teams to take the Authors Of Pain somewhere approaching their invincible storyline limit at TakeOver: Orlando. On RAW, they are barely a match for Titus O’Neill.

There’s being jaded, and there’s that: a complete betrayal of how acts got over in NXT so incredibly moronic that it doesn’t just ruin RAW and SmackDown as programmes worth investing in. The buzz surrounding NXT TV itself has been lost. Evidently, the TakeOver specials are amazing. We’re reaching a wonderful point at which Saturday nights are at least equal to WWE’s best ever Sundays throughout its rich, three decade-plus pay-per-view in history - but the TV show isn’t appointment viewing, like it was in 2015, because there was hope for the future in 2015. There isn’t anymore.

Finn Bálor has nothing to smile about, having been booked to avoid Brock Lesnar and perform in meaningless midcard fare, but smiles anyway in a borderline agonised manner. He is told to wear a big smile out there, he does, and nobody believes he is genuinely happy, representing in micro WWE’s critical macro issue with the complete artificiality of the product.

Matt Riddle is different, though.

CONT'D...(3 of 4)


WCPW Cody Rhodes Matt Riddle
Oli Sandler/The Ringside Perspective

Matt Riddle is a performer you can well imagine Vince McMahon wants to push, as opposed to a performer he signed to spite the competition. Riddle, and this isn’t (just) the facetious surge of optimism it should be, genuinely beams on his way to the ring. He doesn’t need such direction from Vince McMahon. He is a performer as attuned to his wavelength as any other.

Riddle brings with him much sought-after combat sports credibility. A jovial killer, McMahon may see him as some beautiful child of John Cena and Brock Lesnar boasting a chant of Yes!-sized potential. He’s tall, too, and his physique is shredded. McMahon, famously, likes an ass-kicker. It doesn’t matter how technically gifted, even over, a WWE wrestler is. It doesn’t matter how much potential they hold to make money; unless the duress is unavoidable, McMahon will not push them.

Riddle is an ass-kicker. On the Ultimate Fighter, he left Dan Simmler literally whimpering on the mat, his eyes rolled into the back of his head, after breaking his jaw. It was a disturbing scene, but nothing too graphic for WWE’s PG parameters. With a loose relationship allowing WWE use of UFC footage, there are few better means of building the character on television if, as is customary, he is simply parachuted into the post-WrestleMania RAW.

His promo game isn’t exceptional, but then, what does that matter? The ability to cut a promo means less now than it ever has. Riddle can’t cut a great promo, but he wouldn’t be permitted to, anyhow.

The spectre of Mary Jane looms over everything. WWE only waited this long to sign Riddle as a result of his controversial exit from UFC. Though he is a documented and flagrant cannabis user, were it such an issue, WWE would not bother signing him at all. Naturally, the inherent vulturism of the media would see any potential backlash levelled at WWE when Riddle is positioned most prominently. The media waits. They circle. Regulator may yet become the ironic chapter title of his WWE journey, but then, the media doesn’t care much for WWE, nor the drug itself. If it isn’t Riddle, it isn’t anybody. There is no act in WWE nor elsewhere that meets Vince McMahon’s Superstar criteria.

Riddle may yet be the answer to the riddle, and if he somehow isn’t, any fading optimism surrounding WWE’s desire to push anybody beyond Roman Reigns at the top level will go up in smoke.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!