CM Punk: 10 Reasons We Need To Let Him Go

We gotta face facts - it's time to move on from The Best in the World.

I€™m totally aware that writing an article about why we need to let go of CM Punk is in itself hypocritical. I will absorb said hypocrisy, and promise not to follow up with €œ10 More Reasons Why We REALLY Need to Let CM Punk Go€ or €œ10 Reasons To Hold Out Hope That CM Punk Comes Back€. That€™s not to say that other writers won€™t have something to say about CM Punk, but this was a topic that I felt would be fun to explore. First things first, my personal opinion on CM Punk: I am a CM Punk fan. I loved him in ECW, I loved his feud with Jeff Hardy, I ADORED the Straight Edge Society, I consider the Summer of Punk one of the most thrilling times in WWE, and I was so happy that he got his shot at The Streak. I didn€™t begrudge his sudden departure, and I didn€™t think he€™d come back (which doesn€™t make me super smart or psychic). I have read a lot of pieces on his walk-out, and I can understand why there has been upset, anger, bitterness, and feelings of betrayal. I can see it from the breach of contract standpoint, and I can see it from a disappointed fan€™s standpoint. But here is how I feel about it, 3 months later, and why I feel we need to let CM Punk go.

10. He€™s Moved On

It might be different if CM Punk had passed away, and we were all grieving the loss and re-hashing his career. But this is clearly a conversation that he doesn€™t care to be a part of. Since his departure, he has not conducted a single interview to talk about WWE. He has kept a low profile, aside from an appearance to support The Talking Dead show, and paparazzi-style sightings at hockey games. For the most part, CM Punk is sending a message: he has no interest in answering questions or sharing his side of the story. One could guess that it€™s because he€™s still under contract, in which case time will tell. But after 3 months and a LOT of words being written on CM Punk, without his input, it starts to sound like one hand clapping. There is only so much that can be said, only so much conjecture can be made, when the subject of that conjecture has got the wrestling community set to Ignore Mode. It€™s like breaking up with your significant other, and continuing to phone them when they haven€™t answered for 3 months. Your friends would tell you to let it go!

9. We Have Better Things To Talk About

I feel confident in saying that we have plenty of options available. Since Punk€™s departure, which admittedly gave us something exciting to talk about, WWE has given us many reasons to shift our attention elsewhere. Rumour had it that Punk was due to face Triple H at WrestleMania XXX, and who would have thought that the change of plans would have had such glorious results? Triple H turned his attention to Daniel Bryan, and showed us that he is a master at heel promos, and still has still got it, in spades, when it comes to wrestling. Triple H was so darn good at being bad, it made Daniel Bryan€™s victory that much sweeter. And if that feud wasn€™t enough to soothe your Punk anxiety, we€™ve had the rise of Cesaro, the continuing brilliance of The Shield, and Bray Wyatt showing that he can hang with the main event players. NXT has been churning out new, exciting talent, and the WWE Network had a successful launch. Why are we still talking about CM Punk?

8. Everything€™s Already Been Said

For as many well-made points about Punk being right to leave, there have been equally well-made points about his being wrong. If his health and safety were being compromised, and he didn€™t feel that his grievances were being addressed, then he did the right thing. If he was exhausted by the way talent was being used, and sick of his complaints going unheard, then at least he acted on his frustrations. He made a grand gesture to express his disgruntlement. But that gesture left a lot of people upset, because their favourite wrestler wasn€™t going to be wrestling, AND he broke his contract by leaving €“ at a climactic time of year for the company, and with no notice. It makes sense that a guy who was so passionate about pro wrestling, whose fans felt very passionate about him, would induce such a passionate reaction. But I really don€™t think there is anything new to be said. He should have left! He shouldn€™t have left! It€™s become the equivalent of beating a dead horse. Everything has already been said, many times over. The once-hot topic has gone lukewarm, and nothing is appetizing at this temperature.

7. It€™s Rude To The Active Roster

I€™m referring to the chanting. And while I€™ve written elsewhere about respecting fans€™ rights to chant whatever they want at shows, I do feel like after a while, these €œCM Punk€ chants walk the line between tedious and rude. I know, how else to protest Punk€™s departure? We€™ve already tweeted and facebooked and blogged and had Punk signs confiscated. All we have left are our voices (our real ones!) and our wallets (how many people stuck to their vows to stop watching/reading/buying?). The CM Punk chants had their moment, and I€™m not even referring to the Hijack Raw initiative (which in my opinion was like a child playing Lego; all the joy was in the set-up, and then 2 minutes into playing it lost its charm €“ not to mention WWE€™s clever circumventing any hijacking by sending out Paul Heyman). Why can€™t we just chant about what€™s happening in the ring? I€™m not saying that you have to cheer for a boring match, heck you can chant €œBOR-ING!€ then. But these men and women are out there working hard, putting their physical well-being at risk, yes to make money but also to get a reaction from us. How many wrestlers say €œI wouldn€™t have anything without the fans€ and they don€™t necessarily mean because the fans buy tickets. Wrestlers wrestle because they want to make a connection, and feel like they€™ve gotten your attention. Give them something, anything, other than chanting for someone who would rather talk about zombies than wrestling.

6. We€™re Making Too Big A Deal Of It, Just Because We Can

With such easy access to our own personal soap boxes, we can ALL stand up and make ourselves virtually heard. Anyone can create a blog, write a letter to the editor, or rant on social media these days. Regardless of whether we have anything original to say, we will say it, simply because we can. Punk€™s decision to leave WWE, and the way in which he did it, got a lot of people fired up, myself included. I found it very intriguing, and was dying to know the reason(s) why. I wrote about why we shouldn€™t have been surprised that this happened, and how I didn€™t think he€™d be back. It was one of the most read and commented-on pieces I€™ve ever done. My work was but a grain of sand in the expansive desert of CM Punk articles and comments. You would have thought he€™d done something far more shocking or serious. But when you put it into perspective, it€™s almost funny how big a deal it became. And we made it that way, simply because we could. Before we had all of these forums for voicing our opinions, Punk€™s departure would have been big news, but not so sensationalized or drawn out. His keeping a low profile added to the air of mystery and did nothing to extinguish the myriad conspiracy theories (after all, he€™d left and come back before). But it€™s time to deflate the balloon and move on.

5. There Should Be A Statute Of Limitations On Resentment

As I said before, even though I€™m personally on the side of understanding why Punk would leave, I can also see why people would be angry. Heck, HE was angry, I€™m sure, and it can be a contagious emotion. And as fans, we become emotionally attached to our favourite wrestlers. We feel annoyed if they aren€™t being featured in a flattering way, disappointed if they get injured, and joyful when they return. I cried like I was at a funeral when Shawn Michaels and Edge retired. But I stopped crying shortly thereafter (hopefully before the show was over), and I feel like 3 months is long enough to feel resentment towards someone whom we€™ve never met. After this long, expressing our continued bitterness starts to reflect poorly on us, and has less to do with CM Punk. Clearly, CM Punk can still arouse a response in people, but I feel that his actions do not warrant such long-held grudges. We will all feel better if we let it go.

4. It€™s Had No Effect On WWE Business

World Wrestling Entertainment€™s reaction to CM Punk€™s departure has been that of a company that does not care. They have been highly selective with their use of Punk€™s name and image: they have not uttered it on air since he left; they have ignored fans chanting it; they have confiscated signs. But they still categorize CM Punk as a €œFeatured Superstar€ on WWEShop.com €“ because CM Punk is still a money maker for them. While I don€™t have stats on whether sales of CM Punk merchandise took a big hit or a big jump right after he left, it€™s clearly still doing well enough that he is considered home page material. Regardless of what we say about Punk, or the company€™s treatment of him before and after his departure, WWE is going to just truck right along as they please. And many people will pay them for the experience. Furthermore, our fixation on CM Punk has clearly had no ill-effect on the rest of the Superstars. They€™re doing just fine, thank you very much. One less wrestler to jockey for position at the top of the card. One less talented promo-cutter to clash with on the microphone. One more reason to prove themselves, and try to earn our attention away from the Straight Edge Superstar.

3. It€™s Just Business

It€™s easy for us to take it personally, because we get so emotionally attached to our favourite wrestlers. Likewise, I€™m sure Punk took his job very personally at times, because it occupied so much of his life. He grew up wanting to be a pro wrestler, and even after realizing his dream, continued to dream bigger. Pro wrestling was obviously a big, emotional deal for CM Punk. And I€™m sure emotions played a huge role in his decision to leave, just as emotions played a huge role in fans€™ reactions. But if we distill the event into its most simple form, it was a man walking off the job. A construction worker deciding that it wasn€™t work the risk. A marketing executive deciding that he was tired of the politics. A Hollywood actor deciding that the movie business, no matter how good everyone else thinks it is, has run its course for him. People will be disappointed. People will judge. But the construction worker doesn€™t care what the person who was going to live in the building he was working on thinks, nor does the marketing executive who gets criticized by the people who loved his commercials, nor the actor whose fans idolize him. And for someone who works in a creative field, and a high-risk one at that, when it starts to feel like a job, it might be time to go home. The business of his breaching a contract is strictly between CM Punk and WWE. As far as I can tell so far, neither party seems too bothered by it.

2. He€™s Not Coming Back

This is partially my personal opinion, one that I€™ve held since Day One, since I view Punk as a guy who will stand by his convictions €“ sometimes even to the point of spiting himself. He had also indicated that he didn€™t intend to wrestle into a ripe old age either. A series of events may have simply accelerated his decision. In addition to being my personal opinion, we have the cold hard fact that his contract expires in July: each day that ticks by means a decreased chance that he will return. No amount of our talking about it is going to bring him back. There€™s nothing that can be said on our part to suddenly convince him to change his mind. If it hasn€™t happened yet, it€™s not going to happen. It goes back to the boyfriend/girlfriend analogy: if they haven€™t come back to you after 3 months of re-hashing your relationship, chances are they aren€™t coming back at all. The next PPV, Payback, is being held in CM Punk€™s hometown of Chicago. Cue rumours of Punk€™s return, to be followed by a Punk-less PPV. I won€™t dispute that it€™s fun to guess at surprise appearances €“ it€™s the best part of the Royal Rumble €“ but I€™m feeling quite jaded about the Punk return. Maybe they€™ll never be able to hold an event in Chicago without fans wondering if Punk will make his comeback. And maybe John Cena will turn heel!

1. If (When) He Does Come Back, It Will Be More Interesting

With all that being said, CM Punk coming back would be far more interesting to me if we all stopped talking about him for a while. Let the subject lie dormant, trust me it will do wonders for how you feel about him, one way or the other. As much as some people love spoilers €“ and I do not €“ tell me it€™s not a lot more satisfying to be surprised? Chris Jericho has proven himself the master of shocking returns, especially amazing in the social media age. He is very selective with how he shares his life with fans online; he gives enough to keep people engaged, but without spoiling what€™s next. CM Punk may not be engaging us at all, and as a matter of fact I find it poetic and lovely that his last tweet read, €œThanks for all the support. Keep being you guys, it's pretty cool.€ Why not play a role in what could be a great story, by letting it go. Think of him as a guy who got burnt out, and needs to regenerate away from the nattering masses. I€™m sure he appreciates that people voiced their opinions, and got mad as hell, and chanted, and did whatever they felt was necessary to express themselves. But I imagine that it€™s also exhausting, even if he€™s not sitting at home poring over the fan pages and dirt sheets. What wrestler wouldn€™t prefer to come back when everyone is least expecting it, rather than scrutinizing his every move? Now I€™ve almost got myself convinced that he€™ll come back. Almost.

In this post: 
CM Punk
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Follow me @kickyhick :) I hold a degree in English Rhetoric & Professional Writing from the University of Waterloo in Canada. I've done technical writing, executive presentations, and recruiting materials for BlackBerry, and I write for non-profit organizations. My favourite project so far has been combining my passion for writing with being a die-hard wrestling fan. It's a pleasure to write here for WhatCulture, and also for TJRwrestling.com.