CM Punk: 7 Reasons He Could Have Been The Biggest WWE Star Of 2014

In 2011 we had the 'Summer of Punk' which was one of the most thrilling periods of the new WWE decade. It was that rare time when you witness the birth of a star, CM Punk emerging from his epic 'Pipe Bomb' promo and match of the year with John Cena to dominate the next two years. Following on from a 434 day WWE Title reign we witnessed the Punk legacy extend further as he wrestled top stars such as The Rock, Undertaker and Brock Lesnar in 2013. Things didn't look all too bad for CM Punk as 2014 started. You would have expected him to have had a major match at Wrestlemania 30, similar in card position to last year with Undertaker. That would have led into contract negotiations to extend his deal past the July expiry. What no one expected was what actually occurred €” Punk sensationally walking out of the company at the end of January. Just when you thought things were finished for the star, over the weekend came the news we had all hoped for. According to Dave Meltzer of The Wrestling Observer, a credibile source (a very top industry star) has said Punk will 100% be returning in Chicago on Monday Night Raw. That didn't happen. The Chicago Raw has came and gone without any CM Punk return. To call it a missed opportunity is an understatement. The company and the star could have collaborated to create something bigger than 2011, from which Punk could have became the biggest star in the company this year. Even more so than Daniel Bryan or John Cena, this could have been Punk's year, but now all is lost, here's why ...

7. It's A 2011 Reboot But Bigger

In 2011 the WWE and CM Punk conspired to do a worked shoot that propelled the star to main event stardom. His 'Pipe Bomb' promo in which he berated the WWE and set himself against the WWE machine was genius. Not since Steve Austin and 3:16 had we seen such a naturally delivered promo that MADE a character. It was all built off Punk's very real woes with the company and as such it engaged fans in a big way, ultimately making Punk a cross over mainstream star, known to even people who don't watch WWE. In 2014 we saw a strikingly similar situation, Punk was unhappy with the company and this time he really did quit. That has made it so much bigger of a story. If Punk returned it would have been even bigger than 2011 because this time there was such a vaccum of answers. We have had his absence for over a month which has made fans appreciate the star even more, the demand for CM Punk has never been stronger. As a result his return would have seen him spike tv ratings, draw PPV buys and sell more merchandise than ever before. The 2011 Pipe Bomb storyline would have ended up being rebooted with this whole walkout situation and CM Punk had the chance to do even bigger business than last time around. He is a made star with the most interesting story in WWE right now despite being AWOL. Bouncing off of that he could have dominated the rest of the year. Instead Raw transpired without him, devastating the hopes of Punk fans for a second coming.

6. He Is A More Reliable Main Event Act Than Daniel Bryan

Daniel Bryan is immensely popular right now, but if CM Punk had returned last night in such an inflated manner it would have given the Chicago native a great opportunity to reclaim his place as the number 2 star behind John Cena. Punk was excellently positioned to overshadow Bryan. In terms of wrestling skill they are very similar, but when it comes to promo quality it is Punk who is the undoubted superior. When both are working at their absolute best, Punk just about shades it as the better talent. For that reason he would have long term managed to best Daniel Bryan in 2014. In the short term, Bryan is the star of Wrestlemania season. But he is an unproven talent to run on top and when he did in Autumn we witnessed PPV numbers bomb. If he can survive away from the underdog role when he has achieved his goals remains to be seen. Punk in contrast is a proven draw. He has the experience to run on top in WWE and is a much safer bet than Daniel Bryan. The YES movement is popular but coming off the walkout worked shoot angle we would have expected CM Punk to be the very hottest act on the roster. What we actually saw happen on the Chicago Raw was Daniel Bryan solidify his popularity in a war of words with Triple H, leaving very little scope for Punk to now come back as the number 2 guy in the business.

5. Nobody Can Match Punk For Promos And Matches

Now that he has had a month off to recharge his batteries, with a worked shoot angle to motivate his enthusiasm, CM Punk should have been more than ready to re-emerge on to the WWE scene with the energy needed to dominate. When he is at his best he is untouchable, no one will outperform him. We fully expected Punk to return firing on all cylinders with a major Mania program and new contract to fuel him. WWE obviously thought otherwise, choosing to stay firm with their Batista vs Orton direction and Bryan / Authority clash. The re-emergence of Punk at his peak would have allowed him to demand top billing in 2014. His promos and in-ring work won't be topped, which would have left WWE little choice but to book him at the top of the cards. Punk has demonstrated that he can last in a major role for a sustained period of time when he dominated the WWE title for 434 days starting in 2011 and lasting until 2013. His return would have created a level of momentum which he has the experience to sustain, he has the acumen to hold onto that kind of buzz. Instead he hasn't been given the chance. One of the hottest potential angles ever that could have fuelled an epic main event run through 2014 has been wasted.

4. A Match With Bryan Would Have Been 5 Star

Cena Punk Bryan and Punk seemed destined to clash in 2014. There's limited space in WWE for two performers who are so similar, they would have been on a collision course both on screen and off screen. The fact is in WWE, you have the number 1 guy (John Cena) and then traditionally the number 2 guy underneath has been Punk. That all changed toward the end of 2013 when Bryan stole in as the most popular star in the company, largely for the same reasons Punk was popular €” elite wrestling ability and mic skills. Now that Punk has some compelling fan fuel of his own again, he could have taken his spot back. The pair would have met in a match at some point this year as both have WWE title credentials. The match would have ended up being the contest of the year. Previous efforts have been amazing and with both men having so much stock right now it would have been big stakes. It was a 5 star match waiting to happen, but we will have to make do with the likes of Bryan vs Triple H instead.

3. Punk Has The Mainstream Crossover Ability

The reason WWE should have got behind Punk in a big way again despite the recent dispute is Punk offers star quality. He is known in the mainstream media, casual fans are aware of his persona. By booking him in a big way, the company had a chance to increase views from the vaguely interested audiences. Wrestling fans will always watch wrestling because they love it, but casual channel hoppers watch for big characters such as The Rock and John Cena €” with Punk having that same status since his 2011 run. Another factor that makes Punk more marketable is his UFC connections. During his sabbatical we saw him watch his friend Ronda Rousey at UFC 170 in Las Vegas. Punk has a cool factor for MMA fans and some of that audience tune into WWE just to see the likes of Lesnar and Punk. Someone like Daniel Bryan lacks that same ability, wrestling fans love him, but as a crossover star we don't know if he has the same level of perception as Punk. WWE have blown it with Punk by not bringing back one of the few full timers who can give them exposure in wider markets outside of wrestling.

2. A New Contract Would Have Ensured Punk Is Booked Right

Punk wobbled in his role as a WWE star because the creative team let him down. Even his 2011 push was marred by poor booking, infamously Kevin Nash feuding with Punk over a Triple H text message. In 2014 things could have been different. If Punk agreed a new contract he would have enjoyed huge leverage when doing so. WWE are desperate for proven full time drawing potential and Punk has that factor. In negotiations he could have made sure to get assurances when signing of what his future will hold. Expect him to have increased creative control at the top of his list of wants in any new deal. What this means is that Punk won't allow himself to end up in lame feuds with the likes of Ryback or Curtis Axel. He would have returned for the big time. WWE would have had to put Punk in the biggest matches and feuds of 2014 because quite simply he wouldn't bother coming back for anything else. This is a multi millionaire who can take it or leave it, what a shame that WWE couldn't give him what he wanted, now us the fans have to suffer the fallout with a diminished product. The best worker in the world is a big loss for us to take.

1. A Heel Turn Would Have Extended His Great Year

CM Punk would have been coming back as white hot babyface in Chicago, riding the momentum throughout the next few months. As one of the most versatile workers on the roster he could then have turned heel at the end of Summer, extending his main event run even further. It's what we witnessed in 2012 and it worked brilliantly, Punk is after all at his most entertaining as the bad guy. His matches suit a mean streak and his promos are more must see €” probably because he is a bit of a d*** in real life as many of his friends have joked. In contrast, the man in competition for his spot, Daniel Bryan, is a babyface through and through. He has the Austin problem of being typecast now in his role. The big issue for Bryan will be maintaining fan interest once he loses the underdog character and becomes Champion. We have seen it time and time again in WWE, we love a riser just so we can rip them down €” see Shawn Michaels, Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio. CM Punk is different. The versatile worker can do it all and he can do it better than anyone else in the company. Coming back with such HOT interest he could have been about to dominate the rest of the year as "The Best In The World!" But this is WWE. We the fans don't always get what he want, and last night in Chicago, we were certainly let down. Whether blame rests with WWE or Punk is open to debate, but what is certain is this, fans are sad right now. WE WANT PUNK!

WWE Writer

Grahame Herbert hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.