Every Bullet Club Member Past & Present: Ranked From Worst To Best

Separating the Kenny Omegas from the Bone Soldiers.

Balor Bullet Club
njpw.co.jp

Bullet Club are wrestling's most recognisable stable, and it's not even close.

Formed by Prince Devitt, Bad Luck Fale, Tama Tonga, and Karl Anderson in May 2013, the nWo/DX-inspired group have conquered the wrestling world. The t-shirts are everywhere, their most prominent members generate more buzz than anyone else outwith WWE, and they're never short of championship gold.

Bullet Club's ranks have gone through major changes over the years, with 26 individual wrestlers coming and going since Wrestling Dontaku 2013. Members past and present have held every single NJPW title since the group was born, but they recruit from all levels of the New Japan hierarchy, with lifelong jobbers sitting alongside former IWGP Heavyweight & Intercontinental Champions on their list of alumni.

Ranking them is difficult, but not impossible. It doesn't take a genius to see that Kenny Omega has played a bigger role in BC's success than Cody Hall, but the upper echelons require a deeper dive, particularly when it comes to former leaders.

With a focus on tenure, accomplishments, wrestling ability, their fit within the group, and contribution to Bullet Club's legacy and identity, here's how they all shape up.

19. The Part-Timers

Tama Tonga Haku
Twitter, @Tama_Tonga

Is it a cop-out to throw all of Bullet Club's part-time members under a single heading? Perhaps, but none of these performers accomplished enough to justify their own individual entry.

Haku is the most relevant to the group's current state. The father of three-time IWGP Heavyweight Tag Team Champions Guerrillas Of Destiny (adoptive, in Tanga Loa's case) managed his sons at July's G1 Special In USA, and wrestled thrice under the Bullet Club imprint in 2016, with his most recent match taking place in November.

Jeff and Karen Jarrett squeezed their way into the Club's ranks at Wrestle Kingdom 9, where 'Double J' worked a six-man tag. 'Bullet Babe' Amber Gallows once occupied a semiregular managerial role, but left when her husband departed for WWE. La Commandante, Mephisto, Rey Bucanero, and El Terrible all appeared in the stable's CMLL subgroup, Bullet Club Latinoamerica, but the offshoot was abandoned years ago.

We could cast the net even further and include other one-timers like Scott D'Amore, but let's not go there...


18. Bone Soldier

Captain New Japan Bone Soldier Bullet Club
Twitter

Bone Soldier (or 'Boner,' as Kenny Omega affectionately called him) joined Bullet Club after turning on Yoshitatsu last September, and proceeded to stink the joint up as the most useless member the group has ever had.

Seriously, just look at the state of him. Decked out in a crap Halloween mask, BC t-shirt, and a pair of tracksuit bottoms snatched straight from the Sports Direct discount rack, everything about him was low rent. He was a jobber in his past life as Captain New Japan, and this continued in Bullet Club, with Omega famously dubbing him "an intergalactic disaster" in December 2016.

Bone Soldier's last NJPW appearance came on January 5th, and he was released two months later. May we never speak of him again.


17. Frankie Kazarian

Frankie Kazarian is a fantastic wrestler, even at 40 years old, but he barely stayed with Bullet Club long enough to brew a cup of tea. He joined their ranks by turning on long-time partner Christopher Daniels in February and represented the black and white for a couple of weeks, but it was revealed to be a ruse the following month.

Kazarian swerved the BC's Adam Cole in an ROH World Championship defence against Daniels, allowing 'The Fallen Angel' to take the title, revealing the whole thing as an elaborate set-up. It was a fun angle, but the briefness of his sojourn makes it impossible to place Frankie higher than any other full-time member not named 'BONE SOLDIER.'


16. Cody Hall

Cody Hall Scott Hall
http://dailywrestlingnews.com/

While most New Japan trainees start their careers as character-less rookies grinding their way through an endless stream of five minute opening bouts, Cody Hall took a different path. He was introduced as Bullet Club's personal trainee in January 2015, but still lost most of the tag matches he competed in, taking the fall so senior BC members wouldn't have to.

Hall's run came to an end at Invasion Attack 2016, when he was badly injured after catching a Matt Jackson dive. He was sidelined until January 2017, when NJPW quietly removed his profile from their website, though he has since resurfaced in Pro Wrestling NOAH.

An awkward, clunky wrestler, Cody shared his father Scott's size, but was far too green to make much of a mark during his NJPW run.


15. Chase Owens

Chase Owens
NJPW1972.com

Chase Owens knows his role in Bullet Club. NJPW don't bring him in for every single tour, but when Chase is around, it's usually his job to eat pinfalls in tag matches. New Japan know he can lose without consequence, and while his teams occasionally win, you can almost guarantee that Owens will be the one to take the fall when BC lose.

His role means it wouldn't be right to have him finish any higher, but Owens is much more talented than his NJPW record would suggest. He's an extremely hard worker who rarely leaves anything in the tank, his fundamentals are rock solid, and he has a couple of strong Best Of The Super Juniors runs to his name. Still only 27 years old, there's an outside he'll eventually become a pushed wrestler, but it's unlikely at the moment.


14. Hangman Page

Hangman Page
ROH

Ring Of Honor's Hangman Page joined Bullet Club back in May 2016. He hasn't been typecast as a pinfall-eater, but is rarely pushed to the group's forefront, and typically lurks on the periphery.

Page and stablemate Yujiro Takahashi were unsuccessful in their attempt at wresting the IWGP Tag Team Titles from The Briscoe Brothers last August. The duo put a winning record together in the 2016 World Tag League, but Hangman had to wait until July 2017 for his next big title opportunity, when he lost in the first round of the IWGP United States Heavyweight Championship tournament.

Page's biggest triumph came on August 20th, when he and The Young Bucks became ROH Six-Man Tag Team Champions. He still has much to prove as a Bullet Club member, but this victory elevates him above the cannon fodder.


13. Yujiro Takahashi

Yujiro Takahashi
NJPW World

Yujiro Takahashi caused a huge stir by becoming the first Japanese wrestler to join Bullet Club in April 2014. He became NEVER Openweight Champion shortly after, but has since fallen out of the spotlight, and it's unlikely that he'll ever be a featured performer again.

Yujiro is one of the most maligned wrestlers in NJPW, but he's better than many fans care to admit. A simplistic American style heel, he wouldn't stick out as much if he weren't surrounded by some of the most spectacular wrestlers on the planet, but this is New Japan, where "perfectly mediocre" puts you in the lower percentile of workers.

Only Bad Luck Fale, Tama Tonga and The Young Bucks have been part of Bullet Club for longer than Takahashi. He'll probably remain with the group until the day they finally split, because what else are NJPW going to do with him?


12. Marty Scurll

Marty Scurll
njpw1972.com

Marty Scurll is one of the hottest commodities in wrestling at the moment. Slick in-ring skills, electric charisma, a unique gimmick: he has it all, and if there's any justice left in the sport, he'll develop into a massive international star within the next few years.

He has the potential to become one of the Bullet Club's most prominent members, but he has only been part of the group since May, when he joined them in Ring Of Honor. From there, 'The Villain' participated in NJPW's Best Of The Super Juniors tournament as a BC representative, finishing with a respectable 4-3 win/loss record, but failing to advance to the finals.

Scurll is already over with Japanese crowds, and possesses more star power than any other Bullet Club member not named 'Kenny Omega.' A longer tenure should see him shoot up these rankings, but for now, this is as high as it gets for him.


11. Tanga Loa

Tanga Loa
NJPW1972.com

A disaster when he first debuted for NJPW, Tanga Loa reeked of the worst sports entertainment stereotypes. The former Camacho stood out for all the wrong reasons: he was slow, basic, and completely out of sync with his opponents, and his Guerrillas Of Destiny tag team struggled to get over as a result.

Fortunately, Loa has grown immensely since then. Him and Tama Tonga (his adoptive brother) have improved greatly as a team, and while neither is in the company's upper echelon between the ropes, they're always good for a brawl. They're no longer unwanted guests in the division, and with three IWGP Tag Team Championship reigns to their name, GoD have become a staple.

He'll always be one of the Club's least spectacular members, but Loa finally looks comfortable in his role, and will hopefully continue to grow and evolve throughout his New Japan run.


10. Doc Gallows

Doc Gallows NJPW
NJPW.co.jp

Doc Gallows joined NJPW as part of 2013's World Tag League, forging an immediate alliance with Karl Anderson, who was one of Bullet Club's major players at the time. They won that year's tournament, and soon became a staple in the heavyweight tag division, notching three separate title reigns before eventually departing for WWE together in 2016.

Gallows is a serviceable big man whose loud, brash personality meshed perfectly with Bullet Club's western ethos, but he has never been a particularly exciting wrestler. He's adequate, but several levels below his long-time tag partner in terms of in-ring ability, with his deficiencies particularly noticeable as a singles wrestler in the G1 Climax.

Doc's size and strength should have made him a good choice as the group's enforcer, but BC have always had Bad Luck Fale to fill that particular void, meaning that the current WWE Raw star was used exclusively as a tag wrestler outside of major tournaments. Regardless, Gallows played a prominent role during one of Bullet Club's most important periods. Him and Anderson were cornerstones of an oft-neglected division, and while their matches rarely set the world on fire, their push supersedes this.


9. Adam Cole

Adam Cole
NJPW

Adam Cole joined Bullet Club in May 2016, and remained part of the group until Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks unceremoniously booted him out 12 months later. This probably wouldn't have happened if Cole wasn't on the verge of signing with WWE at the time, but it was a memorable conclusion to what had been an unremarkable BC run.

As a Bullet Club member, Cole found plenty of success in America, but little in Japan. He became ROH World Champion for a second time in August 2016, but lost the belt to Kyle O'Reilly in December. Cole then regained the gold to a muted reaction at Wrestle Kingdom 11, before Club member Frankie Kazarian turned on him in February, costing him the title again.

Tensions simmered between Cole and BC leader Kenny Omega throughout 2017. The group ran a storyline in which The Young Bucks tried to have him expelled in March, but this didn't come to fruition until a few months later. Though Cole was a huge deal in ROH, he was rarely anything more than a spot-filler in New Japan - Bullet Club's home promotion.


8. Cody Rhodes

Cody Rhodes Juice Robinson
NJPW1972.com

It was clear that NJPW planned on building Cody Rhodes up from the moment he debuted. The company rarely book random singles bouts, but they slotted 'The American Nightmare' into a clash with Juice Robinson at Wrestle Kingdom 11. The new Bullet Club man was successful, and while he was made to wait four months before returning to Japan, he followed it with a win over David Finlay in May.

A victory against Michael Elgin at Dominion 6.11 set up the biggest match of his career: a shot at Kazuchika Okada's IWGP Heavyweight Championship at New Japan's G1 Special In USA. Cody was unsuccessful, but it was one of the strongest performances of his career, and is momentum endured.

Away from NJPW, Cody became Ring Of Honor Champion in June, and has since defended the belt against the likes of Christopher Daniels and SANADA as a BC member. He has become one of the group's most prominent members in a short period of time, and while Rhodes has yet to get over with Japanese crowds, his success on the other side of the Pacific justifies his position.


7. Tama Tonga

NJPW New Beginning Niigata Tama Tonga
NJPW World

Tama Tonga calls himself the 'Bullet Club OG,' and he isn't wrong. Haku's firstborn son joined BC the night they formed in May 2013, with him and Bad Luck Fale the only founding members left in the company. He represents the black and white to the fullest, and his partisan loyalty manifested during this year's G1 Climax tournament, when he brazenley questioned leader Kenny Omega's allegiance during their singles bout.

Tonga is widely considered one of New Japan's most underrated wrestlers. He's a unique performer who glides around the ring like nobody else in the business and has proven his ability to have a decent match with almost anybody in the company, but a big singles push has never materialised. Nonetheless, Tonga has remained a constant midcard presence through his run, with his career gaining significant traction from 2016 onward.

The 'Bad Boy' became an NJPW champion for the first time at Wrestle Kingdom 10, capturing the promotion's relatively meaningless 6-Man Tag Titles. He has since become a three-time IWGP Heavyweight Tag Champion alongside his brother, Tanga Loa, and posted a decent 4-5 record in the 2017 G1 Climax. Tonga will never be a main eventer, but his recent success, tenure, and importance to the group validate this high position.


6. Bad Luck Fale

bad luck fale
NJPW

Bad Luck Fale has been Bullet Club's 'Underboss' since the stable's inception. It was his allegiance with Prince Devitt that kicked the whole thing off, and while he has always been a limited wrestler, Fale's significance within the group can't be denied.

A textbook monster heel, Fale struggles to impress against lower tier opposition, but always performs well when paired with the likes of Hiroshi Tanahashi and Kazuchika Okada. The company protect him well, his Bad Luck Fall finisher is rarely kicked out of, and beating him is treated as a big deal. This means Fale is often thrown into high stakes matches to put the company's top guys over, and enhance his own prestige as he pushes them to the brink of defeat.

In terms of tangible success, Fale defeated Shinsuke Nakamura to become IWGP Intercontinental Champion in June 2014, though he dropped the belt three months later. He's always booked strongly in the G1 Climax, and often goes over the company's biggest stars, keeping his threat level high. His basic skillset means he'll never be pushed all the way to the top, but he'll remain an effective enforcer for the duration of his run.


5. The Young Bucks

Young Bucks ROH
ROH

The Young Bucks' spot-heavy style isn't for everyone, but their success is undeniable.

Matt and Nick Jackson are the world's most recognisable tag team, and even if WWE is the only promotion you watch, you've probably heard their names. Their cocky attitudes, gif-friendly style, and standout performances for every major company not owned and operated by Vince McMahon have made the Bucks a global phenomenon, and their importance to Bullet Club's current success can't be understated.

The duo haven't always played a prominent role since joining the stable in 2013, but their alliance with Kenny Omega has changed everything. The Elite are the first three wrestlers many fans think of when Bullet Club's name is mentioned, and this isn't just down to their eye-catching in-ring performances, but their business away from the squared circle.

Every episode of their 'Being The Elite' YouTube series breaks 100,000 views, and their marketing skills are next level. The Bucks have played a huge role in BC's recent merchandise explosion, and while most of their work takes place in NJPW's lowly Junior Heavyweight tag division, they've done more to help raise the Club's profile than almost anyone else.


4. AJ Styles

AJ Styles IWGP Champion NJPW Bullet Club
New Japan World

No Bullet Club member has ever tasted more individual NJPW success than AJ Styles. He immediately aligned himself with the group upon returning to the company in April 2014, and became IWGP Heavyweight Champion in his first match back. His reign lasted a shade over five months, but encompassed only two successful defences before Hiroshi Tanahashi took the gold in October.

AJ stayed in the spotlight, and took the title back in February 2015. His second reign stretched until July, and he remained Bullet Club's most prominent singles wrestler all the way through to his January 2016 departure, when a Kenny Omega-led assault pushed him out of the group (and the company).

Despite all this, Styles' Bullet Club run never felt 100% natural. He was a convincing heel, but it often seemed like he was being shoehorned into the stable, and it took several months for him to overcome the poor reception his return angle received. This prevents AJ from finishing higher on our list. Sure, he was probably the best wrestler in the world during his run with the stable, but those above him were much better fits.


3. Kenny Omega

kenny omega
www.njpw1972.com

Kenny Omega has been aligned with Bullet Club since November 2014, but didn't become the group's leader until AJ Styles and Karl Anderson left for WWE in January 2016. He has since led the stable through one of their most notable periods, and while the Club's relevance has fluctuated greatly early in his custodianship, Kenny's own impact has been immense.

'The Cleaner' has been an IWGP Intercontinental, Junior Heavyweight, and United States Champion as a Bullet Club member. He was already among the company's biggest stars in 2016, but this year's matches with Kazuchika Okada have shot him to a new level of global prominence. He's a genuine megastar, and his efforts have not only sent his own stock through the roof, but Bullet Club's too.

His tendency to promote The Elite over BC holds Kenny back somewhat, and Tama Tonga hasn't been shy of questioning his loyalty lately. Nonetheless, Omega is always vocal in expressing his desire to drive Bullet Club forward whenever he's on the microphone, and while there are strong suggestions that he'll soon turn face and leave the group, Kenny's leadership has carried BC to stunning new heights.


2. Karl Anderson

karl anderson bullet club
www.wawnation.com

Karl Anderson was Mr. Bullet Club. He was there the night they formed, and his loyalty remained unwavering until the day he departed. Nobody else was a better embodiment of what the group was all about, and while 'Machine Gun' was never a big singles star in NJPW, he was a perfect reflection of his stable's identity.

Loud, brash, and as cocky as they come, Anderson was not only a key player between the ropes, but the group's mouthpiece for long periods of time. AJ Styles became Bullet Club's ace after debuting in 2014, but it was Anderson who assumed Prince Devitt's old leadership role, though he primarily worked as a tag wrestler, scoring three IWGP Tag Title reigns with Doc Gallows.

He may not have tasted the same level of success as the Club's bigger names, but nobody was more important in building, developing, and maintaining the stable's original outlaw spirit. BC lost its heart and soul when Anderson went to WWE. They're more popular now than ever before, but their identity is nowhere near as pronounced as when 'Machine Gun' was around, and they miss his personality dearly.


1. Prince Devitt

Prince Devitt BOSJ Finn Balor
NJPW World

Prince Devitt founded Bullet Club as an extension of his existing allegiance with Bad Luck Fale in May 2014. The duo wrestled Ryusuke Taguchi and Captain New Japan that night, before aligning with Karl Anderson and Tama Tonga to assault Hiroshi Tanahashi (the company's franchise player) immediately after the main event, thus forming modern wrestling's most iconic stable.

The Irishman's leadership lasted less than a year, but it still hasn't been bettered.

Devitt became one of New Japan's top heels upon the stables formation, and while he ultimately failed in his quest to become IWGP Heavyweight Champion, he was able to score notable victories over guys like Tanahashi and Kazuchika Okada, albeit through interference.

Though not as successful as AJ Styles or Kenny Omega, Devitt's unreal chemistry with everyone else in the group separates him from the Club's other aces. He and Bad Luck Fale had a Shawn Michaels/Diesel-esque relationship with 'The Underboss' excelling as Devitt's "bouncer," and his heel persona was endlessly entertaining, allowing him to unleash levels of charisma that often seem non-existent in his current role as WWE's Finn Balor.

Bullet Club were at their most enjoyable with Devitt at the helm. An endlessly creative performer, he was the most natural leader they've ever had, and the group were never more over as heels than they were during this timeframe. Throw his world class in-ring ability into the mix, and you're presented with Bullet Club's greatest member.


In this post: 
Bullet Club
 
Posted On: 
Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.