Every NXT TakeOver Main Event In History: Ranked

16. Adam Cole Vs. Tommaso Ciampa – Takeover: Portland

NXT Takeover Portland
WWE.com

A marquee match if there ever were one. Adam Cole was in the middle of arguably the best NXT Title reign that the brand had ever seen and standing in his way was a psychopath, hell-bent on reclaiming the title that he never lost.

Ciampa was at his fiery best here with every single one of his strikes being delivered with seething intensity and strategic purpose. In turn, Cole responded with a meticulous targeting of Ciampa’s surgically repaired neck that made even the most bloodthirsty fan cringe. The scene of Ciampa’s neck bouncing off the edge of the announce table after a thunderous wheelbarrow suplex from Cole alone was purely sickening.

The match eventually devolved into a war of attrition, both men throwing everything they had at each other, desperate to hear the ref's hand slap the mat for the third time, but neither man gave in. With every kick out it became more believable that Ciampa was going to reclaim his ‘Goldie’. Even Undisputed Era’s interference couldn’t keep Ciampa down, but the shocking turn of Johnny Gargano could.

Cole had escaped by the skin of his teeth, while DIY began to write yet another chapter in their harrowing story. Take a bow, all involved.


15. Samoa Joe Vs. Finn Balor – Takeover: London

Finn Balor TakeOver London
WWE

From the second that a high-pitched woman’s scream echoed throughout the arena, you just knew that this one was going to blow the roof off of the SSE Arena.

A ‘Jack the Ripper’ style demon Vs. The ‘Samoan Submission Machine’, both men at the top of their game and ready to fight for NXT’s greatest prize in front of one of the greatest crowds to have ever graced a WWE event. From the outset, both men were ready for a fight. Joe was the most motivated that he had been in years and it showed, with his series of stiff elbows, chops, punches and kicks sending shivers down viewer’s spines. Thanks to Balor’s incredible selling, violently convulsing his body whenever he was hit or slammed, the world was reminded that Joe is an absolute beast of a human.

The finish came with an appropriate amount of Shakespearean drama, with both titans battling upon the top rope, Joe fell and Balor drove a daggering Coup De Grace through his heart for the win. The sheer atmosphere of the match, coupled with such outstanding ring work made a perfect ending to a great night for NXT.


14. Charlotte Flair Vs. Rhea Ripley Vs. Io Shirai – Takeover: In Your House

Io Shirai
WWE.com

Just the second time that the Women’s Title had been given the nod to go on last at Takeover and what a worthy trio to have such an honour.

Charlotte’s 2020 return to NXT was a godsend for the twelve-time Women’s Champion, as it opened her up to fresh matchups like this one. All three women involved in this one had excellent chemistry and complimented each other nicely. Flair was every bit the arrogant champion that her father was here, letting Shirai and Ripley wear each other out for most of the match. Speaking of Shirai, she never felt out of place in a match that was built largely around the Flair and Ripley rivalry, making sure that her impressive agility took the spotlight.

Throughout the contest, you could see Flair’s hubris become her downfall, as arrogance turned to desperation. Not even the use of a kendo stick could give her the edge and there was just no stopping the ‘Genius of the Sky’ Shirai. One transcendent mid-figure eight moonsault later and Shirai was the new champ. A nice passing of the torch for the NXT Women’s division as the faces of two eras past were able to make way for the future.


13. Johnny Gargano Vs. Tommaso Ciampa – Takeover: Brooklyn 4

NXT TakeOver Brooklyn IV Tommaso Ciampa Johnny Gargano
WWE.com

For the third straight Takeover event, the former partners turned enemies clashed once more in yet another weapons-based stipulation. Last Man Standing was on the cards and fans were hungry for Gargano to take the strap.

Many spots were set up in the first few minutes and quickly forgotten about, that’s just how good of a distraction the back-and-forth action was. When the exposed wooden boards and stacked tables did eventually come into play it was as shocking as it was expected. The story that Gargano and Ciampa were able to craft over the thirty-three-minute contest is a testament to just how talented they both are. Ciampa took the ‘everything but the kitchen sink’ phrase a little too literally by piling the entire ringside area on top of Gargano at one point, yet it still wasn’t enough. Ciampa was defeated and he knew it, but he also knew how to turn this weakness into a strength, suckering Gargano in, inviting more and more punishment.

Not learning his lesson from their previous encounters, Gargano was once again too emotional to see reason, falling right into the trap and ended up losing by his hand. It was a result that was as frustrating as it was brilliant and yet another feather in the cap of the incredible DIY saga.


12. Team Ciampa Vs. The Undisputed Era – Takeover: War Games 2019

Kevin Owens NXT
WWE.com

The first-ever women’s War Games had already happened earlier in the night, so the men had to try and outshine the historic match to prove it was worthy of the main event slot. The match itself had a touch of mystery about it as well, with Team Ciampa only going in with three men, the question on everyone’s lips being who would fill the fourth spot?

The Undisputed Era were a delight as always within the double-ringed structure, dominating Ciampa’s team with heel tactics and an abundance of weapons. As the clock ticked down to the mystery man, the atmosphere in the arena hit a fever pitch, before an explosion of support for the returning son of NXT – Kevin Owens.

With him, Owens brought carnage and along with Keith Lee and Dominik Dijakovic, he proved once more that War Games is a big man’s match with all three men stealing the show with their seemingly impossible feats of high-flying agility.

It was a match that had been months in the making and it delivered one hell of a contest, as well as writing the next few months of NXT’s major angles going forward. This was a win-win situation if there ever were one.


11. Team McAfee Vs. The Undisputed Era - Takeover: War Games 2020

NXT TakeOver War Games 2020
WWE.com

Pat McAfee in a War Games match. That is a sentence that shouldn’t work. The match itself shouldn’t have worked. However, the former NFL punter had been working even harder than he did for his Takeover: XXX singles bout with Adam Cole. The heel captain didn’t look like the odd man out once, in fact, his presence ended up being a huge factor in why this match is so far the best War Games match that WWE has put on since its return.

Not only did McAfee shine, but his whole team made their presence felt, especially Oney Lorcan and Danny Burch who relished the opportunity to finally be in the main event spotlight, having some excellent encounters with O'Reilly and Fish. Pete Dunne continued to remind everyone watching that he is a bonafide star and one day will most likely be the face of WWE, as his exchanges with Cole and O'Reilly were simply electric.

As always, Undisputed Era were entertaining as hell, proving why the War Games stipulation is their signature. Plus, O'Reilly getting the winning pin only furthered his singles star status. Overall, all future War Games matches in WWE will have to use this as the measuring stick.


10. Finn Balor Vs. Kyle O'Reilly – Takeover: 31

Finn Balor
WWE.com

This match will certainly go down in WWE history as Kyle O’Rielly’s coming out party. He had been on the cusp of singles greatness for some time and this chance to go toe-to-toe with one of NXT’s biggest stars in Finn Balor was all the opportunity O'Reilly needed to break out on his own.

The two men had a banger that was almost as stiff as a chop from WALTER. Seriously, this one was hard-hitting, watching it you got the feeling that the pair were pushing the barrier as hard as they could, being as violent as possible until Vince McMahon pulled the plug. O'Reilly showed off his Brazilian Ju-Jitsu skills with kicks so stiff that Balor almost certainly would have ended up internally traumatised for weeks after. While Balor continued to shed all doubts that he had lost the star power that he had built previously in his first NXT run.

At the end of it all, both men were bloodied, they were bruised and they were the talk of the wrestling world, with the match being touted as one of the year’s best by far.


9. Bayley Vs. Sasha Banks – Takeover: Respect

Bayley Sasha Banks NXT TakeOver Respect
WWE.com

For the first time in NXT/WWE pay-per-view history, the women went on last. The stage was set, thirty minutes on the clock, blood rivals ready to beat the hell out of each other and the whole wrestling world was watching.

The pair were determined to show the company what they had been missing out on by sleeping on the women’s division. That they did by producing thirty straight minutes of wrestling that was every bit as good, if not better than their male equivalents were producing at the time.

Bayley was the perfect face, refusing to play dirty, whereas Banks produced the best work of her career. All of the falls were booked smoothly and the drama was written to perfection with the crowd eating up everything the women did. Seriously, name a more dramatic heel moment than when Banks stole Bayley’s biggest fan Izzy’s headband and mocked her for crying.

The action was combustible right down to the final seconds with Bayley overcoming the odds and toppling her nemesis once and for all. The post-match celebration was a nice touch and rightly acknowledged the scale of history that the women had just made. In its essence, it was truly a trailblazing match for all to follow it.


8. Finn Balor Vs. Pete Dunne – Takeover: Vengeance Day

Balor Dunne TakeOver Vengeance Day NXT WWE
WWE

Finn Balor just loves to continue to outdo himself. The best thing about ‘The Prince’ is that he never seems to be content with his performances, constantly striving to be better. As a result, he continues to churn out classics like this one.

This match was everything a wrestling fan loves in a match; everything was done with intent and purpose. Every strike was targeted with strategy, every slam was done in an attempt to end the match and even the rest holds were chosen to look dangerous enough that there could be a tap out at any second. It was textbook wrestling and a real testament to how talented both men are, especially Dunne who once more grabbed yet another one of WWE’s proverbial ‘brass rings’ to add to his ever-growing collection. Only a mere two months into 2021 and the pair were able to set the tone early and present a Match of the Year candidate.

The aftermath of the shocking Undisputed Era implosion didn’t detract at all from the outstanding action that preceded it, only proving even more so, just how good this match


7. Johnny Gargano Vs. Tommaso Ciampa - Takeover: Chicago II

Nxt TakeOver Chicago 2 Johnny Gargano Tommaso Ciampa
WWE.com

This wasn’t a wrestling match; it was never going to be and hence the Street Fight stipulation was appropriate as both men were going to tear each other limb from limb. Both men were fuelled by pure hatred and the action spilled into the crowd almost instantly.

Throughout the whole contest chants of “Johnny Wrestling” filled the arena and the unhinged Ciampa took a disliking to this as his strikes increased in violence with every chant. Rubbish bins, steel chairs and even stop signs were used to try and downright murder each other, but neither man were ever going to let the other win. Ciampa proved why he can be the best heel in the entire wrestling business with every single thing he did throughout the match made you hate him even more. From the call back to the same event a year previous when he slammed Gargano’s dazed head into the stage board to the spitting on and disposing of Gargano’s wedding ring, Ciampa was truly the ‘Psycho Killer’.

The finish was brilliant in its simplicity, Gargano’s emotions got the best of him and Ciampa played him like a fiddle. But it was made quite clear that things were far from over between the pair.


Contributor

Just an Australian wrestling fan who grew up admiring the sport that we all know and love. All round wrestling fanatic, wouldn’t mind if you just sat down and listened to his humble opinions on the wrestling world.