Every WWE Royal Rumble 'Final Four' - From Worst To Best

19. 2003 - Kane, Batista, Undertaker & Brock Lesnar

2003 was the Year of the Hoss. That's why the Royal Rumble was closed out by the Brothers of Destruction, Brock Lesnar and Batista lifting and throwing each other at the ground. Granted, it wasn't Kanye Batista or even Evolution Batista (the faction wasn't formed until the next night on Raw), but he was on peak person-throwing form here. It's honestly a pretty cool little moment, with Taker getting his spine busted, and Brock throwing suplexes and F5€™s only to walk into a Tombstone. What€™s more, there's a great deal of history between some of these guys: Kane and Undertaker, obviously, but Lesnar would eventually wind up as one of 'Taker€™s greatest rivals. Even Batista managed a great match against The Deadman at a WrestleMania. The only things that really drag it down are the eliminations themselves. The unfrozen viking prince that is Brock Lesnar should not be running up and dumping people from behind when they're not paying attention. He should be throwing them over the top rope and into the fifteenth row while drinking a Coors Light, or something. €

18. 1995 - Lex Luger, Crush, Davey Boy Smith & Shawn Michaels

The 1995 edition featured four fresh faces who had never been World Champion before, which is always cool. Luger had already half-won the previous Rumble, but this year included the added wrinkle of his then-tag partner, the British Bulldog, in the final four. Davey Boy and Shawn Michaels had been the first two entrants, and battled each other on and off throughout the match. Also, Crush was there. Michaels ultimately wins it, of course, after the oft-replayed spot where only one of his feet touch the ground and he dumps a prematurely celebrating Davey Boy. He wouldn't be able to unseat Diesel at WrestleMania, though, and both of them wound up playing second fiddle to a Lawrence Taylor novelty match. 1995 was a dark year.

17. 2009 - Cody Rhodes, Ted DiBiase, Triple H & Randy Orton

Randy Orton and Legacy actually accomplished that thing that stables try to do in Rumbles, eliminating all the competition to craft a final four that perfectly suits their plans. Unfortunately, they had already kicked out Manu, so the fourth man wound up being Triple H. Aside from Cody Rhodes, I'm indifferent at best when it comes to the performers here, but the execution more than makes up for that. If this were 3-on-1 against, say, John Cena, then you could be justified saying there's no drama and that he'd eliminate them all without breaking a sweat, but Triple H embraced the drama and it (mostly) worked. It was a unique idea and worked well in execution, but did lead to one of the most lacklustre WWE Championship matches in WrestleMania history.

16. 2011 - Wade Barrett, Randy Orton, Santino Marella & Alberto Del Rio

Points in favor of this quartet: three of the four combatants would be new to the main event scene. Counting against: the one established guy was Randy Orton, the dullest professional wrestler to ever become a top-tier superstar. This also marks the most over that Santino Marella would ever be, as he materialized from the aether to Cobra ADR in the face. He blew it, because Santino Marella, but for a hot minute it really looked like the Milan Miracle would be the one to stop Alberto€™s WWE Title destiny being fulfilled. In fact, that person was Edge, who beat Del Rio at 'Mania in a disappointing 10-minute curtain-jerker that wound up being Edge's final match.

15. 2012 - Big Show, Randy Orton, Chris Jericho & Sheamus

I dare you to read the four above names aloud and not fall asleep by the time you hit "Sheamus". Maybe that's because I can't shake my feelings about the dead-in-the-water 2016 versions of these guys, though, because if I remember correctly, Sheamus was actually pretty over when he won this thing. Jericho wasn't exactly in peak form here - not suited intellectual Jericho nor pigtailed goofus Jericho - but he was freshly returned and FELT like he could recapture some of that magic at some point. In fact, both Jericho and Sheamus found themselves in World title programs at WrestleMania, although Jericho proved unable to unseat CM Punk and Sheamus defeated Daniel Bryan in a notorious blink-and-miss-it match, which wound up making Bryan a bigger star than the Irishman ever was.

14. 2004 - Chris Jericho, Kurt Angle, Big Show & Chris Benoit

The good: none of these men had won a Rumble before this. New winners are always fun. The bad: All four men had already been World champions, taking some of the grandeur out of the story. It just doesn't have the same dramatic weight when they've all already been to the top of the mountain, you know? Even worse: Big Show repeating his signature €œhow is this even my job?€ Rumble elimination spot. The worst: Chris Benoit. If real life hadn't made this match and the WrestleMania XX main event heartbreaking instead of heartwarming, this would have to rank in the top 5.

13. 2010 - Shawn Michaels, Batista, John Cena & Edge

This is a pretty great field in terms of star power. All four men had been World champions, while Michaels, Batista and Cena had also won Rumbles in the past. Edge's entrance was a surprise, as he'd been out with an achilles tendon injury for a long time. Jericho sold it beautifully. I'm not a fan of a babyface entering at the end of the match and tossing out a few weary rivals for an easy win. I mean, it's not against the rules or anything, but neither is taking a count-out loss to retain a title and I don't see babyfaces lining up to exploit that loophole! It's just an extremely opportunistic move, which is why it fit Edge like a glove. The Rated-R Superstar got a hero€™s welcome for his return, and he got the win by dumping his blood rival Cena, who had pulled the same trick two years before. Unfortunately, Edge wasn't able to defeat Chris Jericho at WrestleMania, which takes a bit of the thrill out of this victory. Still, a damn good, star-powered final four.

12. 2006 - Rob Van Dam, Triple H, Randy Orton & Rey Mysterio

Ah, yes, 2006, the year Rey Mysterio played Eddie Guerrero. Zoom in about 150x on Rey's armband, that's pretty much what watching this match feels like. Okay, maybe I'm being too harsh. WWE's exploitation of Eddie's death never sat well with me, and Rey Mysterio deserved a Rumble victory that was truly his own, not a commercial for Latino Heat's legacy. Still, the assortment of competitors was poetic. Alongside Rey was his former tag partner Rob Van Dam, himself a beloved star that had never been taken too seriously by WWE. Across the ring from them were Triple H and Randy Orton, the prototypical, homogenized, safe WWE Superstars. Rey outlasted them after wearing them down and stood revealed as the fans' choice to carry the company forward. That never really came to fruition, but it's still a wonderful moment for the ultimate underdog.

11. 2002 - Steve Austin, Mr. Perfect, Kurt Angle & Triple H

It's tough to bet against this field: perennial Rumble MVP Steve Austin, fresh-from-injury mega face HHH, G.O.A.T. contender Kurt Angle and somehow-as-good-as-ever nostalgia entrant Mr. Perfect. Of the three, Perfect was the least-likely candidate, but the fact that he had reappeared in peak form and made it to his first final four since 1990 made it seem that anything was possible. Ultimately, Triple H was the right choice: he was white hot as a face at this point, while Austin would be better positioned against the incoming nWo invaders. Unfortunately, the follow-up to this Rumble deflates it quite a bit. Triple H's title feud with Jericho was disappointing, and closed out X8 to the sound of crickets because the fans were positively drained after Rock/Hogan. Also, Austin wrestled Scott Hall in a throwaway midcard bout, Angle wrestled Kane in the same, and Mr. Perfect was dumped on Heat. "Deflated" might not be a strong enough word.

10. 2001 - Billy Gunn, Kane, The Rock & Steve Austin

WrestleMania X-Seven is almost universally considered to be the best ever iteration of the event, and the build to it started in earnest here. It's a four way showdown between Kane (who had just eliminated a full third of the field), Steve Austin (who had already won two Rumbles, tying the record), The Rock (himself a former winner and would-be Hollywood star), and €œThe One€ Billy Gunn. What's that? You don't remember Billy Gunn working as ur-Tye Dillinger in 2001? This year's performance by Kane set an elimination record that went unmatched for more than a decade, and cemented his still-held record of most lifetime eliminations. He made a perfect final boss for Steve Austin, who spent most of the match bleeding out on the floor. His solution to this momentum deficit (repeatedly braining Kane with a handy chair) foreshadowed his iconic, hyperviolent heel turn in the 'Mania main even a couple of months later.

Contributor

Long-time fan (scholar?) of professional wrestling, kaiju films and comparative mythology. Aspiring two-fisted adventurer.