Every WWE To AEW Defection Ranked From Worst To Best
Jon Moxley and FTR proved that they WERE misused in WWE. Certain others...?
Ever since All Elite Wrestling debuted Dynamite on TNT in October 2019, they have quickly become the number 2 wrestling promotion in all of North America and elsewhere.
They’re competing against WWE for ratings and demos and critical acclaim the way fans always clamoured and hoped TNA one day would. They’ve also attracted and caused a group of major acts from WWE to defect as well as under-utilized and under-appreciated talent to give them the platform and pay they deserve. More and more wrestlers are seeing the benefits of working for AEW rather than WWE, with lighter schedules and much more freedom. It’s well known WWE overly scripts their promos as well as banning its talents from using Twitch, OnlyFans and promoting third parties on social media, much to the discouragement of its roster.
AEW on the other hand gives its talent independence and a creative licence, which is why every few months it seems another wrestler from WWE leaves for AEW as soon as their contract expires or they’re granted a release. WWE haven’t had to deal with defections like this in over 20 years from its time battling WCW in the Monday Night Wars.
Here, every true defection - Cody and Chris Jericho were already in different promotions before AEW formed - gets ranked...
11. Matt Hardy
Matt Hardy left WWE in 2020 due to overwhelming creative differences.
He was essentially only being used on TV as an enhancement talent around this time to get over new stars like Ricochet and Buddy Murphy. Matt felt he had a lot more left in the tank, so announced his departure from the company through his official YouTube channel, leaving his brother Jeff to swim on his own in WWE.
On the March 18th episode of Dynamite, Matt debuted in AEW with his Broken character. Whilst it was nice to see him in a new setting, there was criticism online that the Broken gimmick had become stale and sluggish at this point. Nevertheless, it still produced highlights like the creative Stadium Stampede match at Double or Nothing where Matt teamed with The Elite to take on The Inner Circle, which involved a fun spot involving the stadium pool (stand-in for the Lake of Reincarnation).
Then there was the Broken Rules match with Sammy Guevara at All Out where he somehow avoided a major injury when his head hit the concrete floor from high above a scissor lift. Then there was the Elite Deletion match held between the two at the Hardy Compound which was fun and nostalgic but also very divisive.
He’s recently switched gears and gone straight with his gimmick as ‘Big Money’ Matt managing Private Party. It’s like MVP instead of Michael Hayes managing The Hardy Boyz in the late ‘90s. He’s turned heel in the process and fought with Adam Page, losing to him at Revolution.
Matt’s been entertaining in his new role, but most of his time spent in AEW has been a tiring rehash of his time as Broken in TNA.
10. Miro
Miro left the WWE and his Rusev name behind in April 2020 after being put through the wringer with a long drawn-out storyline involving his real-life wife Lana making him look like a cuckold by regularly making out with Bobby Lashley.
Miro has described the creative freedom as a strong reason for signing with AEW in September 2020 when he debuted The Best Man gimmick with his expensive Gucci attire and aligning himself with Kip Sabian for his upcoming wedding with Penelope Ford. Highlights of his six-month run with AEW have included making him out to be the charismatic dominant force he was always meant to be. He and Sabian/Ford have been feuding with the Best Friends and their laid-back cheerleader Orange Cassidy as of late. Many are hoping AEW continues building on the momentum Miro has made in his short run, hoping he can one day become a top guy. Tony Khan is demonstrating patience with Miro, with Miro even admitting it would be the wrong call to have him come in and win a major championship like the TNT title straightaway, commenting:
“If I had come to AEW and become champion on day one, there were going to be 90 other million people who were going to be like, ‘Oh, well, look at this. He’s just another a former WWE guy just coming in and taking the title. And look, we have Hangman Page and the Bucks, and everybody else is just waiting for their opportunity.’”
9. Paul Wight
In February of this year, Paul Wight shocked the wrestling world when it was announced he was AEW-bound to wrestle on occasion, believing he had a lot left to give wrestling - which was evident from the incredible shape he had gotten himself into in recent years - as well as provide commentary alongside Tony Schiavone for their new YouTube series AEW Dark: Elevation.
Prior to debuting with AEW, the former Big Show was used as just another legend whenever he would infrequently appear on WWE television to put over current talent, like Randy Orton choking him on Raw in January. Wight only signed in February, so you can’t judge him on what he’s done so far with the company, but for potential alone, AEW singing him is intriguing.
Show has years of wrestling knowledge under his belt, having worked for WCW for four years and WWE for over 20, which he can instil in younger talent on the AEW roster.Wight has commented on his signing:
“It’s so invigorating. It’s like getting a blood transfusion I would have to say. I feel like a young kid all over again. I can’t wait to get out there and do my job, and then lace up my boots and get to perform with these athletes and get to know them.”
8. Tay Conti
The Brazilian native Tay Conti was signed to the WWE for over three years, being a part of the inaugural Mae Young Classic and even competing on the pre-show of WrestleMania 34 in the Women's Battle Royal.
During her time with the company she routinely competed on NXT, at one time even having an affiliation with The Undisputed Era. She had eye-catching potential, but NXT never ran with her the same way they did other female talent like Toni Storm and Tegan Nox. Conti was one of the exemplary talents let go by WWE in their April 2020 budget cuts due to the pandemic, which stemmed from her being creatively frustrated in NXT and asking for her release two months prior.
As soon as her 90-day no compete clause expired, Conti was snapped up by AEW. Teaming with Anna Jay, she wrestled in AEW Women's Tag Team Cup Tournament ‘The Deadly Draw’ and has since had ferocious matches with Nyla Rose and Serena Deeb (for the NWA Women’s Championship) on Dynamite and showed WWE exactly what they missed out on.
Only at the young age of 25, she’s got a lot to give in AEW.
7. Christian Cage
You have to rank Christian for potential and promise alone rather than anything he has done for AEW, given he only signed with the company in March 2021 to the surprise of everyone.
Christian was retired for seven long years until he got inspired from his best friend Edge returning to in-ring competition in January 2020 and worked to make his own return a year later at Royal Rumble 2021, where he entered at number 24 and lasted over 18 minutes, looking like he hadn’t missed a beat. He was so fluid in the ring, and looked in incredible shape. Christian had options at this point in regards to his future: he could continuing working for WWE or take a chance elsewhere.
He went for the latter, and was AEW’s mystery signing revealed at their Revolution PPV, where he adopted his Christian Cage moniker once more. His signing has similarities to when he left WWE and signed with TNA in 2005, in that Captain Charisma currently looks like he’s on a trajectory with Kenny Omega over the AEW Championship. Tony Khan has said of signing Christian:
“I think he’s one of the great wrestlers the past couple decades. He’s had great matches in different companies. He’s a great singles wrestler, a great tag champion. I think he adds a lot here. He’s one of the best minds in wrestling, and he’s in great physical condition. We’re expanding the roster, and having someone awesome and a great headliner like Christian Cage is amazing."
6. Dustin Rhodes
Dustin Rhodes has a story in wrestling like no other.
He’s a journeyman who has competed in nearly every wrestling promotion you can think of multiple times under multiple different gimmicks. His story continued in March 2019 when he left WWE and his Goldust character behind after six years of continued service for a multi-year deal with AEW where he would work as a wrestler and coach.It was first revealed he would square off against his brother Cody at Double or Nothing, the inaugural pay-per-view for AEW.
They had a five star match at the event that took fans on a rollercoaster of emotions throughout. Things went downhill though when he was unfortunately involved in the viral moment of a member of the Dark Order not connecting his cringeworthy punches on him when they beat Dustin and The Elite down on an episode of Dynamite. Dustin has spent most of his time on AEW screens teaming with QT Marshall as The Natural Nightmares. He has been used more prominently behind the scenes than on TV, teaching his knowledge and guidance to newer talent getting accustomed to wrestling on national television for the first time in their young careers.
But make no mistake: you should never overlook Dustin Rhodes for how good he can still go in the ring after years of taking bumps and at the ripe old age of 51.
5. Sting
Sting made the wrestling world gasp when he stunningly debuted for AEW in December 2020, returning to TNT for the first time since WCW, leading to nostalgic feelings from fans.
Prior to coming to AEW, ‘The Icon’ hadn’t wrestled since 2015 when he had to suddenly retire due to a bad neck injury he sustained after landing wrong on a turnbuckle powerbomb from Seth Rollins. WWE humbled him as a Legend after that, inducting him into the 2016 Hall of Fame class.
But Sting believed he had more to offer wrestling, making a last ditch effort to WWE to make the dream match against The Undertaker happen after watching Undertaker’s cinematic classic with AJ Styles at WrestleMania 36 that hid Undertaker’s shortcomings due to age and wear and tear. WWE didn’t go for it, so Sting made other plans, signing a multi-year contract with AEW.
So far, Sting in AEW has put over his kindred dark soulmate Darby Allin huge just by association. At Revolution, Sting teamed with Darby to take on Team Taz’s Brian Cage and Ricky Starks (with Hook and Powerhouse Hobbs in tow) in a cinematic street fight that was highly entertaining. Sting has shown he has a lot left to give, with scenarios of him working with younger talent like The Dark Order and Kenny Omega to working dream matches with Chris Jericho and Cody Rhodes (considering his past with his father Dusty) holding promise
4. Mr. Brodie Lee
Since Brodie Lee passed away from a serious lung issue in December 2020, the wrestling world has looked back on Brodie’s career with much fondness and appreciation, especially his short stint in AEW.
In April 2019, the-then Luke Harper requested his release from WWE to fulfil his potential elsewhere having been largely forgotten about. WWE denied the request, and relegated him to being a lackey for his former Bludgeon Brothers teammate Eric Rowan in his feud with Roman Reigns. In December that year, Harper finally got what he wished for and was let go of his WWE contract.
Harper was determined to prove himself as a big-time player when he debuted for AEW on March 18th, readopting his Brodie Lee ring name. It was bittersweet for Brodie, given the show was supposed to take place in front of a jam-packed audience in his hometown of Rochester, New York but there was no crowd due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Lee was declared ‘The Exalted One’, the mysterious leader of The Dark Order. It finally gave Lee a chance to shine in a lead role. In August, Lee squashed Cody Rhodes for the TNT Championship in a fantastic angle where he came across as a monster unleashed by attacking The Nightmare Family afterwards.
Lee had great showings against Dustin Rhodes and Orange Cassidy for the title on episodes of Dynamite before finally losing the belt back to Cody in an outstanding and bloody dog collar match, which would ultimately be his last match before passing.
3. PAC
PAC was regularly frustrated throughout his run on the main roster for WWE, believing he wasn’t being highlighted properly, which is hard to argue.
It felt like Vince McMahon saw him as nothing more than a high-flying cruiserweight who turned down his Mighty Mouse style gimmick. PAC ditched the WWE in 2018 for major promotions that would value his talent and push him accordingly. After wrestling for Dragon Gate, the Newcastle native found that major promotion in AEW after signing with them in January 2019, where he regularly demonstrated what an incredible athlete he is, with his acrobatic moveset like the corkscrew shooting star press, and living up to his name with 12 pack abs to boot.
He’s showcased himself in thrilling matches with Kenny Omega at All Out and in an Iron Man on Dynamite, as well as outstanding contests with Adam Page at Full Gear and Orange Cassidy at Revolution. Anytime PAC’s made an appearance for AEW, he’s delivered.
It’s just a shame he hasn’t been on TV more due to creative differences in Spring 2019 and an eight-month absence from TV in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
2. FTR
Known as The Revival in WWE, Cash Wheeler and Dax Harwood were continuously discouraged and unsatisfied throughout their run on WWE’s main roster for three long years.
After tearing it up in NXT with the likes of American Alpha, DIY and The Undisputed Era, they were promoted to Raw and later SmackDown, and despite winning both the Raw and SmackDown tag titles, they were regularly forgotten about on TV, with WWE’s tag team division not being highlighted at the time.
When Vince McMahon tried to make them a comedy act, that was the final straw for The Revival and they refused to sign contract extensions. Wanting to build the same kind of legacy they did in NXT, they signed with AEW in May 2020 and rechristened themselves FTR. They’ve since won the AEW World Tag Team Championships, put on a classic with The Young Bucks at Full Gear, had one of their heroes Tully Blanchard manage them and are in the newly formed The Pinnacle stable led by MJF who are currently dominating in AEW.
1. Jon Moxley
Jon Moxley sauntering and swaggering to the ring with cockiness and determination is a lasting memory for any wrestling fan watching AEW’s Double or Nothing PPV before he beat down Kenny Omega, Chris Jericho and the referee.
Prior to Double or Nothing, Moxley released a compelling video on Twitter of him being released from jail, which was symbolic of his time spent in WWE. Moxley has spoken of why he abandoned WWE, commenting "If there's one thing I want to do now, I want to prove that WWE's creative process sucks. It does not work. It's absolutely terrible. It's killing the company and I think Vince is the problem. Not so much Vince, but Vince and whatever structure he started building around himself."
Moxley found the creative freedom he was looking for in AEW, where so far he’s been the company’s lead babyface and competed in some of the most brutal matches in modern day competition. His unsanctioned match at Fyter Fest against Joey Janela, his Lights Out match with Kenny Omega at Full Gear, his Empty Arena No Holds Barred match on Dynamite with Jack Hager, his I Quit match with Eddie Kingston at Full Gear, and his fight against Omega once more in an Exploding Barbed Wire Death Match at Revolution.
He also won the AEW World title from Jericho for a record-setting reign a277 days along the way, and looks like he’s just getting started, looking and performing better with age.