How Triple H Can Save WWE 205 Live

Salvaging a broken brand.

WWE

For WWE fans of a certain ilk, 2016's Cruiserweight Classic was a godsend.

In a refreshing break from the company's usual soap opera dramatics, the workrate-centric competition appeased hardcores by pushing match quality back to the forefront, with a cast of simple, relatable characters working bouts on-par with anything found on the independents. Regardless of whether or not it was intended as such, it felt like pure, unbridled fan service, generating immense buzz for future tournaments and the Cruiserweight division's impending revival.

Sadly, this enthusiasm was dashed within the first few weeks. Champion TJ Perkins was quickly ostracised, matches were but listless affairs on Raw's undercard, and the ring style eschewed everything that made the tournament so exciting. Fast, fluid, dramatic action was out, resthold-heavy stall-fests took over, with the cruisers' inability to offer anything the heavyweights weren't already delivering rendering them moot.

By the time 205 Live was born in November 2016, the idea of a CWC-style show was fanciful. Filmed before a tired, disinterested crowd, it immediately became WWE's most skippable brand, languishing in the lower depths of the Network's weekly top 10.

It took over a year for Vince McMahon to acknowledge the malaise, but his solution failed. The Chairman felt 205 needed stronger personalities, and thus, Enzo Amore was in, and 2017 standout Neville was out. Though an entertaining heel, the new champion couldn't prompt a turnaround, and he was released amid sexual assault allegations four months after his ascent.

The beleaguered brand lost its figurehead and McMahon's interest. Where could it possibly head next?

Back to September 2016, and the Cruiserweight Classic.

Amore's departure provoked an immediate upturn. Mustafa Ali and Cedric Alexander wrestled an awesome main event harking back to the tourney's style on the January 23rd episode. The changes were permanent, and days later, the reason behind them became apparent.

Triple H, the man who'd brought five-star matches back to WWE by transforming NXT into workrate heaven, had taken the reins. Vince was gone. In washing his hands of 205 and handing it to his son-in-law, the Chairman made the best possible decision. The sharp, uncomplicated focus that made the CWC so special is back, and four weeks into its reinvention, Triple H's new pet project has already become one of WWE's most exciting shows.

The action is outstanding, Drake Maverick has been a revelation as a relatively hands-off general manager, and the roster are no longer hampered by one-note gimmicks and heavy stylistic restrictions. Hardcore fans, rejoice, for WWE have finally answered your prayers.

But with over a year's worth of damage still to repair, 'The Game's' work is far from done. Fortunately, he has plenty of options on the table...

CONT'D...


205 Live Empty Arena
CC BY-SA 2.0 Wikimedia Commons

The first change is one fans have been calling for since the show's inception.

Filming 205 Live after a full episode of SmackDown has been an abject failure, with audiences struggling to muster even a polite murmur for the poor cruiserweights. Granted, reactions have improved with the recent upturn in quality, but for the most part, the show's atmosphere is more like a moon landing than a wrestling show.

There are a couple of options. The first is heading to Full Sail University, but given how quiet that burned out crowd became during last year's NXT tapings, giving them more wrestling may not be the best idea.

Instead, Hunter should consider filming 205 Live before SmackDown. This would be a gamble, as the brand would need to become a big enough draw to ensure fans actually turn up early for the show, but it'd be a vast improvement on the current situation. At least 205 would catch the audience before the expending their enthusiasm, ensuring greater engagement.

Dedicating at least 35-40 minutes to in-ring action makes sense, too. Triple H has already done this in recent weeks, and he'd be wise to continue down that path.

205 Live is in desperate need of an identity, and after failing as 'Little Guy Raw,' it could find a niche as WWE's most wrestling-centric brand. Give fans at least one or two bouts the calibre of Cedric Alexander vs. Mustafa Ali and Roderick Strong vs. Hideo Itami every week, and they'll be happy.

Personnel is an issue, and with just 13 fully active roster members, the Cruiserweight division badly needs some bodies. Calling on the likes of Mark Andrews and Roderick Strong as moonlighters has been the solution so far, but 205 needs a permanent answer. Recruiting these guys on a full-time basis would be a good start, and afterwards, 'The Game' may choose to pluck the likes of Oney Lorcan and Fabian Aichner from developmental: two talented guys who've lost their way at Full Sail.

But these aren't exactly marquee names. Even the division's current stars aren't going to draw big audiences on their own, and thus, 205 Live badly needs some star power. Enter Rey Mysterio.

The former WWE Champion is reportedly looking for a part-time deal, but what bigger name could Hunter possibly throw on 205? Mysterio is a genuine Cruiserweight wrestling pioneer. He spearheaded WCW's own division, and his recent Royal Rumble return generated immense buzz, with the YouTube clip drawing over 12 million views. He's exactly what the show needs to attract greater audience, and who wouldn't want to see him back after his livewire showing on January 28th?

Speaking of star power, how about bringing make one of the few wrestlers whose performances actually made 205 Live worth watching in 2017? Neville's career is gathering dust at the moment. There's a chance he'll never wrestle for the company again, but if the show does succeed in drawing a larger audience (and Triple H treats it with greater importance than Vince), there's a clear roadmap for his return. It'd take some heavy negotiations, though, and probably a big bag of money too.

With a new shooting schedule, wrestling-centric focus, and new roster in-place, the final step is implement the oft-rumoured trios titles. Admittedly, the company already have a lot of belts, but this is something they've never done before. It'd help feed into the Cruiserweights' new identity, and six-man tags are steeped in Lucha Libre history, making this a smart move on several different levels.

WWE already have a handful of readymade teams available. Gran Metalik, Lince Dorado, and Kalisto are Lucha bros, and have teamed up several times over the past few months. A third wheel could easily be added to the Mustafa Ali/Cedric Alexander bromance, and the former 'Zo Train can renew their old alliance (without the corny gimmicks, of course). There's a lot to play with here.

Ultimately, 205 Live needs to cater to fan desires that aren't already satisfied elsewhere on the roster, and that's what ties everything together.

CONT'D...


Triple H
WWE.com

205 failed as 'Little Guy Raw,' and while Enzo Amore's arrival created buzz initial, there was no upturn in viewership. Vince McMahon's mission to rebuild the show as a more character-driven enterprise would have failed regardless of whether he was released or not. Raw and SmackDown already scratch this itch, and while it's hard to blame the Chairman for reverting to the booking technique he knows best, it's clear that the Cruiserweights are better off under Triple H's stewardship.

'The Game' recognises what needs to be done. 205 isn't yet on-par with NXT, but it's being rebuilt in developmental's mould, and already feels like a brand reborn. The wrestlers are finally free to express themselves again, and the Cruiserweight Classic is no longer an echo of the past.

Drake Maverick, like William Regal, is a General Manager who isn't here to steal the spotlight, but rule his land with refreshing fairness. The Title tournament is a direct call-back to the CWC. Guys like Drew Gulak and Jack Gallagher have shed gimmicks that, while entertaining, kept them firmly rooted in the midcard. Cedric Alexander, Mustafa Ali, TJP, and countless others have genuine purpose again.

These are the perfect foundations on which to build 205 Live's bright new future. Far from dead in the water, it has a tremendous chance of prospering under Triple H's leadership, and if NXT is anything to go by, it'll soon find success.


Watch Next


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.