How Wrestling's Present Brilliance Has RUINED Its Future

Why does everything look the same?

survivor series 1997 bret hart shawn michaels
WWE.com

If you grew up in the millennial age as a fan of pro wrestling, you saw it all.

Wrestling didn't start in 1984, and Vince McMahon didn't bring wrestling out of the smoky bingo hall and into the brightly-lit arena - but it might as well have, for fans of a certain age, because they matured and evolved hand in hand with the form itself. If you're pushing 40, the WWF was calibrated to your totally naive and undiscerning child's mindset in the late '80s and early '90s. The heroes sold in wildly histrionic fashion, when the baddies were "getting them", and you went apesh*t in your living room when even Brutus 'The Barber' Beefcake rained down 10 punches on the top turnbuckle. When your friends on the schoolyard drifted away, as the fad died, you fell for Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels. You understood that wrestling was an art, not a trend, and idolised North America's two best practitioners of it. You were under the spell of the athleticism, the technique, the storytelling prowess of the WWF Workrate Years. Then, as you entered awkward and scary adolescence, captivated by violence and the aspirational grown-up feel of it, the crazed arena-wide brawls, backstage fights and dangerous stunts captured your imagination. Much of the work was rudimentary, but ladders and tables were sick. You didn't know what CTE was back then, so rather than "horrifyingly reckless", unprotected chair shots to the dome were in fact "kewl".

Your tastes were more wide-ranging by your late teens, and you enjoyed Kurt Angle and Blitzkrieg as much as you did Steve Austin's lava-hot shortcuts, but when the Invasion was botched, the feeling probably wasn't quite the same. Worse was yet to come: if you were a millennial, you may have even felt betrayed by what was now known as WWE. They, and they were right to do it, eventually marketed their product towards the younger fan. "You've just lost yourself a customer!" you shouted helplessly as John Cena broadened his act to become Hulk Hogan's spiritual, homophobic successor.

What was this sh*t?

Does WWE even know how good Paul London is?

And so you ventured outside of the monopoly. You may have read Power Slam magazine or the Wrestling Observer or trawled the boards and discovered the ROH DVD market, or went back in time and finally realised that the AJPW King's Road era was as good as everybody said it was. There's a good chance, if your fandom took you in the direction of AEW and were first inclined to embrace all forms of wrestling, that you embarked on a completionist journey of the hipster circuit. That you watched When Worlds Collide and the Super-J Cup.

If you grew up in the millennial age as a fan of pro wrestling, there's a very strong probability that you are a bit bored and jaded these days.

CONT'D...(1 of 5)


ROH

That may be because the wrestlers you watch now went on a similar journey, whether they were in it early enough to trade tapes or wanted to see what else was out there on the torrent sites after a once-hidden past. The digital unlocking of every style, of so much brilliance, the international scope of the form available within seconds, informed the brilliance of pro wrestling's incredible artistic modern era. The very recent past was seminal, the present day yields great work weekly - but the future looks decidedly grim.

This process started a long time ago - the original Tiger Mask fused together two disparate styles, while the Great Muta was a breathtaking fusion of the junior and heavyweight disciplines - but it began to accelerate in the 1990s with the formation of Michinoku Pro Wrestling, nothing like which can ever really exist again. That "puro-lucha" blend, improved upon by the electric pace of Dragon Gate years later, was a breathtaking experience: the best of two forms alien to the US fan mashed together to extract the maximum excitement. What forms can be spliced together now that, not to be too reductive, almost every form has slowly bled into one another?

The best generation of independent wrestlers - that first wave of ROH geniuses - borrowed liberally from the high-end '90s Japanese scene and/or took their beloved WCW cruiser division to new, literal heights. There was no point in working WWE-style matches in front of a hardcore crowd in desperate need of an alternative. What those legends didn't know is that they too would be imitated to the point of dilution.

Rip Rogers was dunked on for his tired grifter "...dive" rant a few years ago. It was an inarticulate, reductive and desperate bid for relevance - but it wasn't without a kernel of truth. A lot of modern pro wrestling, the unreal execution of which notwithstanding, resembles itself to a numbing extent. Standing, defiant, turn-taking chop exchange premised on the idea of machismo. A wicked suplex variation that isn't sold, because the wrestler who just took it uses the adrenaline to pop back up and return the favour before eventually collapsing to the mat, expecting a "This is awesome" chant on the double-down. You do in fact see it all the time.

CONT'D...(2 of 5)


Jon Moxley Penta
AEW

When a wrestler does take the advantage early, many of them fly to the outside of the ring to launch their frame into their opponents.

It's weirdly instinctive, like they can't help themselves but chase that pop, and to underscore that, CM Punk built Darby Allin in the media ahead of his AEW debut at All Out '21 by declaring that everybody should retire their dive. Nobody does it like Darby (and they don't). Punk should have listened to his own veteran advice: he injured himself with a far inferior dive at the very same event a year later. Punk isn't the only wrestler to stumble into this lack of discipline, to just do stuff that you've already seen on the undercard and that he isn't exactly outstanding at - and what's worrying is that he can really play.

His work has meaning, he links everything together brilliantly, he performs with a rare sense of wit and personality. If even Punk, the least self-conscious in-ring great ever, a wrestler who will smirk at the idea of chasing a star rating and take perverse, contrarian delight in getting a body slam over, can't stop doing extra stuff because it's so endemic - what chance do his successors have? It's not just Punk. Jon Moxley, who has otherwise mastered what he calls death jitsu - a seamless blend of the cool but less ostentatious styles - death match, brawl, worked shoot - is also guilty of the flying high-five.

When the melee sprawls to the outside, almost inevitably, a wrestler will either throw their opponent against the apron or the ensuing struggle back into the ring will result in a suspenseful battle leading to a bump on the apron - package piledriver, suplex, or, and this often looks foolish, a cutter. Even the geography of wrestling is one land now.

A furious cloudburst exchange of counters and finisher reversals often define the finishing sequence, and this rhythm crept in shortly after the resurgence of New Japan Pro Wrestling and its coveted asterisks drifted westward. Over time, this became the new currency of critical acclaim. And, while certain WWE wrestlers may have scoffed at the idea that NJPW was better, they sure did chase it at the same time - the move-set and the rhythm of strong style psychology.

CONT'D...(3 of 5)


Johnny Gargano is sad
WWE

This volley of defiance happens multiple times per week, but frankly, very few if any of these wrestlers are as good at it as Tomohiro Ishii. You rarely believe that they can get up and continue the fight, or scarcely believe that they somehow conspired to get back in it. That recent Pete Dunne Vs. Dragon Lee match on SmackDown was nightmarish. The soulless fighting spirit exchange was completely lost on a bemused audience. They weren't working for them; they were chasing some amorphous "acclaim" that has reached inflation. Years ago.

Fighting spirit rhythm, lucha libre-tinged action: this stylistic merge in the post-weight division age has not been remotely helped by the scenery-chewing dramatic shortcuts paved by the Shawn Michaels school of melodrama. The shocked kick-out face and internal reckoning of one's soul via hand-staring was lame enough, but now that the word "cinema" has entered the wrestling lexicon, half these f*ckers think they are Daniel-Day Lewis with their monologues. And what's worse is that, in terms of action, if you ventured back to the peak of All Japan Women's Pro Wrestling, they have more than half of this supposed golden generation licked.

All of the old cool tapes have been traded and watched, it feels like, and now all that's left is homogenised static and snowstorms.

At times, it genuinely feels like the bast majority of pro wrestlers have actually forgotten how to work a match without a chop battle. It's as instinctive to the pro wrestler as tucking their chin. The idea of genre is dead now. So why do they bother?

They bother because every style is in.

Look elsewhere, in the tiny crevices, and you'll find something that is different, but nothing that is actually new. The hipster choice for 2023 MOTY - Fuminori Abe Vs. Takuya Nomura from October 12 - was an incredible war with a level of violence and intent behind everything unparalleled elsewhere. But, good as it was, it revived something - Bat-Bat - that had lain dormant in the sphere of acclaim and influence.

Wrestling in its post-hybrid era.

So what's next?

CONT'D...(4 of 5)


Bryan Danielson Daniel Garcia
AEW

It's not as if there's a new movement out there unfolding that the majors will one day co-opt - another worrying omen of the future of the form.

So, more pertinently, what is the way out of this increasingly over-familiar sense that it's all been done and that it all looks the same?

The irony of the whole veteran discourse of the last few years - and the irony of AEW arguably declining in quality the more vets were signed to develop the youth movement, the more tenured agents were drafted to reel everybody in a bit - is that the feeling of sameness has deepened. The irony is that a young wrestler, one whose career was actually bogged down when paired with a vet, may possess the answer. In a medium completely overwhelmed by the pursuit of critical acclaim - what is probably the core problem is that everybody is consumed by being the best artistically, and not the most effective at the fictional goal - Daniel Garcia gets it.

He does not self-consciously strive for the "banger" that has infested the medium and rendered it so woefully homogenised. He doesn't need 20-25 very grabby maximalist minutes to tell his stories in a time where match length has long since been conflated with value (when was the last time a five minute match earned five stars?).

Garcia wrestles to his age and level of experience. He isn't a hybrid guy who could do it all and do it immediately just because, to increasingly diminished returns, he could. He makes deliberate mistakes in his matches. He seeks to master the primary genre of technical wrestling but has (purposefully) failed in that pursuit so far - because he's only 25, he was there before this recent push to do jobs, and if he was a specialist immediately, where else was there for him to go?

In a medium diluted by the misappropriation of strong style psychology, Garcia is astute enough to take something from the puroresu landscape that actually makes sense for his character: the tentative, error-strewn arc of the Young Lion. The short answer is in the discipline not to do something.

GUNTHER knows to only take to the skies with his big splash when confronted with a particularly fierce challenge. Bryan Danielson, who is justified in doing a lot because he can do it all brilliantly, worked a match against Zack Sabre, Jr. last year in which neither man left the ring. Cody Rhodes - who still dives! - was clever enough years ago to resuscitate the beautiful simplicity of the earnest North American babyface.

Great wrestling can still mean everything. It need not be boring, but a delineation of style must happen - or, if it doesn't, those who exercise discipline will ascend and extract meaning from the malaise.

You can't all be Kenny Omega or Tomohiro Ishii.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!