Lucha Underground's 34 Wrestlers - Ranked From Worst To Best

Ranking every competitor from season one of Lucha Underground.

Ever since it debuted nearly one year ago in October of 2014, Lucha Underground has been, arguably, the best wrestling show on television. That's due, in part, to the incredible production value of the show, and the gritty, stylized, even noirish feel of the universe it establishes, but the performers are great as well. With its considerable production costs, Lucha Underground couldn't exactly afford to pull a TNA and hire any and all former WWE performers they can in hopes of attracting a mainstream audience. Instead, LU opted to assemble a truly eclectic roster of Tough Enough competitors, West Coast indy standouts, AAA luminaries, and, yes, a few WWE expatriates, but only those that fit into the milieu that they've strived to create. Each of these wrestlers has been rated based upon their in-ring skills, their character/gimmick work, and their overall performance throughout season one of Lucha Underground. A few basic notes before we begin: 1) Regular teams that have always competed as such are rated as teams only, while teams that have notably completed individually are rated on their own with team accomplishments taken into consideration. 2) Wrestlers who have switched gimmicks or identities at some point during the season are listed as their initial identity, with later accomplishments also noted. 3) NPCs -- managers, announcers, officials, and all other non-competitor characters -- are disqualified from consideration, mostly because if they weren't I'd be forced to list Dario Cueto 33 times. That guy is pure gold.


34. Vinny Massaro

Pros: - 17 years of experience - Made it to the ring without getting pinned or submitting - Father of Diva Search winner Ashley Massaro (citation needed) Cons: - Looks like a Raw jobber from 1994 - Hasn't won a single match - Didn't get to cosplay Skeletor with the cool jobbers They say that pro wrestling is all about image, but that doesn't explain how Vinny Massaro gets bookings. To be fair, lots of guys became huge stars despite looking like slovenly truck drivers, but whatever else Mr. Massaro is, he's no Arn Anderson or Dusty Rhodes. I can't be sure what he actually is, though my best guess is "a genetically modified abomination featuring Manhattan Center Raw jobber DNA spliced into a Nasty Boy base genome." Sorry if it seems like I'm hating on Vinny a lot, but he's just so clearly the jobberiest jobber that ever jobbed and I'm enjoying that immensely. Season two should open with Vinny opening his mailbox and Pentagon leaping out to break his other arm. Final Rating: 1/2*

33. Famous B

Pros: - Looks great in purple and gold - Is apparently famous - Indisputably better than Famous C Cons: - Has no victories in Lucha Underground - Has only appeared very sparingly - Also not an electric skeleton Famous B is another of Lucha Underground's stock company of jobbers, and realistically they should all be tied for last place. However, my research indicates that Famous B won a single (dark) match during the season, which not all of them can say. Also, he actually looks like a pro wrestler, and not a greasy, man-sized goatee like some others *cough* Massaro *cough.* Bottom line: Cut-rate JTG > Santino's disheveled uncle. Final Rating: 3/4*

32. Ricky Mandel

Pros: - He's been with LU since the very beginning - He's got a great head of hair - 1/3 of the current tríos champions (kind of) Cons: - Spent most of the season as a jobber - Is possibly the Indy Wrestlingest dude of all time - Seriously, he's getting piledriven at your local high school gym right now, go look During Ricky Mandel's first match, Matt Striker tried to sell him as a guy whose traditional American pro wrestling background made him an interesting counterpoint (and a threat)to the rest of the roster. That's certainly true -- of Cage. If anything, Mandell is the typical American indy wrestler; he may as well be out there throwing armdrags in his WWE-issued security guard uniform. Luckily, Mandel has experienced a career resurgence following his transformation into an electric skeleton. You see, after going nowhere as himself, Mandel was repurposed as Trece, one-third of Mil Muertes' Disciples of Death. Final Rating: *

31. Argenis

Pros: - Hails from a great wrestling dynasty - Had a number of good showings throughout the season - 1/3 of the current tríos champions Cons: - Still had a very unsuccessful season - Debuted as a threat, then devolved to jobber status - That's probably worse than just debuting as a jobber The life of Argenis must be a strange one. He's the younger brother of Sin Cara/Místico, who's been both the biggest box office draw in Mexico and the biggest, most high-profile bust in WWE history. Is that a huge relief for him, or does the whole family just pretend that never happened, and Argenis is totally the Kendall Windham of Mexico? Or Johnny Ace, or whatever. Lanny Poffo, maybe, he does wear pink a lot. Anyway, Argenis has done a little bit better for himself than the rest of LU's jobber brigade: he was introduced alongside Cage, Angélico and Aerostar, all of whom went on to bigger and better things. For his part, Argenis was repackaged as Barrio Negro as a Disciple of Death, where he's had considerably more success. Final Rating: *1/4

30. El Mariachi Loco

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Z36PG7eUPw Pros: - Plays a pretty mean trumpet - Has perhaps Lucha Underground's most comically mundane secret origin - Gets so excited by minor successes that he shimmies uncontrollably Cons: - Missed the middle 3/4 of the season - Never picked up a win as El Mariachi - Was not managed by Antonio Banderas, despite the Robert Rodriguez connection El Mariachi Loco is clearly at the top of Lucha Underground's jobber heap. He's got a distinct personality and comically mundane backstory; on a show that has characters who are literally immortal creatures, they made sure to establish this guy as a waiter from a local Mexican restaurant, moonlighting as a luchador, who is also crazy. Though he's got no wins under his belt as El Mariachi Loco, he's also Siniestro De La Muerte, one of the three Disciples of Death. Though I think we'd all prefer to see our man achieve glorious victory and play that victory fanfare we've all been waiting for, you can't fault a guy for picking up championships. Final Rating: *1/2

29. Del Avar Daivari

Pros: - Great mainstream exposure from WWE and TNA - Had a fantastic debut - Great traditional heel work Cons: - Never particularly impressive in the ring - Poor win/loss record - Not managing anyone The former Sheik Abdul Bashir arrived in the Temple as a spectator, a Persian Tony Stark in a velvet blazer who was really into tríos matches. One spilled drink later, though, Daivari was off to the races, if by "races", we mean "getting beaten up by Texano and then losing a bunch of matches." Daivari was always better as a manager than as a wrestler, and now he's a gin-soaked real estate mogul who spends most of his time distractedly checking his phone. He should be putting together a squad of comical jobbers, not paying off Big Ryck to stand at ringside until he gets pinned. Oh man, what if Lucha Underground is a long con to bring back Muhammad Hassan? Maybe Mil Muertes will show up at Local Medical Facility with his earthquake rock and bring Hassan out of that coma. Still waiting on that update, JR. Final Rating: **

28. Marty "The Moth" Martinez

Pros: - Much larger than most of his opponents - Former Tough Enough competitor - Descends from a tribe of Aztec moths and therefore has AZTEC MOTH BLOOD in his veins Cons: - No wins to his name - Insists on constantly flapping his arms around in what he believes to be moth motions - Has never seen a moth before and has no idea what they are or how they move Marty "The Moth" Martinez is an inspired character: a lucha fanboy in a homemade, iron-on AZTEC PRIDE t-shirt that so loved the Temple that he was compelled to sneak in through the air ducts to throw bad dropkicks. It may sound dumb, and it is ( it's SO dumb), but trust me: don't underestimate your own desire to see a Matt Morgan-looking goober prance around and flap his arms like they're wings. Like NXT's Dana Brooke, though, I'm not sure if he's a genre-bending deconstruction of a bad wrestler, or if he's a legitimate oaf that lucked out because they needed a dude that could stumble around convincingly. He is a genuinely powerful athlete, though, and he towers over most of his competition at the Temple. Hey, Lucha Underground, maybe pick a guy who's not built like the Mighty Thor to be your Santino, huh? Final Rating: **1/4

27. Super Fly

Pros: - Really good at moonsaults - Really good at handsprings - Have you seen his moonsaults and handsprings? They're really good Cons: - Possibly the blandest high-flying luchador you'll see - Lost his mask to Sexy Star - His heel turn didn't make him a bigger threat in the least Super Fly started out as the lamest técnico on the show. He can throw a great moonsault, but this is Lucha Underground; everyone on the show can throw a moonsault. I'm including Konnan, and that guy has styrofoam hips. Super Fly was therefore a somewhat athletic luchador with very little personality and an Aldo Montoya mask. How are we supposed to get excited about El Dandy with a jockstrap on his face when Fénix, you know, exists? I wish I could say that Super Fly really got some forward momentum going after he lost his mask and turned heel, but nope: same underwhelming dude, now with Samoa Joe's dick painted on his face. Final Rating: **3/4

26. Bengala

Pros: - Looks like a blessed combination of šltimo Dragón and Tiger Mask - Trained by Mexican legend Negro Casas - Won one of the seven medallions Cons: - Arrived very late in season one - Cat-themed luchadors are a dime a dozen - He's not even the best cat-themed luchador on the show According to Matt Striker, Bengala is "Mighty", though to my cynical eyes he looks more like a pudgy Mexican dude wearing a lady's sexy Halloween costume of Tigatron from Beast Wars. That doesn't mean he's not a good wrestler, naturally; the guy can fly with the best of them, and he has a particularly beautiful handspring back elbow. The thing is, there are so many more impressive luchadors on the show. Bengala's not bad, per se, but isn't he basically superfluous? The closest parallel I can think of is from the cruiserweight heyday of WCW, when they'd already brought in Rey Mysterio and Psicosis and šltimo Dragón, so they just went all in and imported, like, Lizmark. Bengala is Lizmark. A Lizmark that licks himself like a big weirdo kitty. Final Rating: ***

Contributor

Long-time fan (scholar?) of professional wrestling, kaiju films and comparative mythology. Aspiring two-fisted adventurer.