NXT TakeOver WarGames II: 8 Things It Got Right

Exhausting performances, superior card pacing and mini-tributes that'll give you Holly-wood...

NXT Takeover WarGames II
WWE.com

"Mamma f'n mia".

Those were play-by-play man Mauro Ranallo's exasperated words as The Undisputed Era, War Raiders, Pete Dunne and Ricochet thundered through their 47-minute WarGames main event at NXT TakeOver. Whilst the headliner was high spot after high spot and had the crowd hanging on every upcoming stunt, it was also an energy-sapping display that could've done with a little editing to trim the fat.

That's nit-picking, but it's also genuinely nice to criticise a headliner for almost being too good. Think about that for a minute, then spare a thought for those on the main roster watching on Saturday night. They must've been quietly wondering what the hell they'll have to pull out at Survivor Series to top the so-called 'developmental' guys and gals.

WarGames II was exhausting at times. The five matches fans witnessed pulled no punches, left no stone unturned and any other mentally-stimulating idioms you can think of. It was exactly what it needed to be though, and WWE (to their credit) let the roster do their thing without intrusive booking or familiar tropes getting in the way...


8. Keeping The Card Short

NXT Takeover WarGames II
WWE.com

Five matches was all TakeOver: WarGames II needed to be.

Think back to bloated main roster shows like SummerSlam, the Greatest Royal Rumble and (more recently) Crown Jewel. A scatter of the matches on all three of those cards meant little, and that rendered them totally forgettable. At NXT's latest slice of heaven, every single bout WWE presented had something unique to offer.

By the time the WarGames lads had left Dave Meltzer with a dirty, sloppy grin on his face at the end of their pulsating main event, it still didn't feel like NXT had kicked the arse out of things. That's remarkable, because it shows that a shorter card can work in an era when beating viewers over the head with content is the law.

It's easy to look back on TakeOver and remember each match individually. That doesn't happen often under WWE's banner nowadays, so it shouldn't be overlooked as a major reason why WarGames II was such a success from start to finish. Whomever made the call on length (it was presumably Triple H) deserves applause.


7. Matt Riddle’s Shooter-Style Win

Matt Riddle Kassius Ohno
WWE.com

In just seven seconds, Matt Riddle went from laid-back surfer dude with a curious MMA background to red-hot star-in-the-making who will surely be part of the NXT Title scene within the next 12 months. This, complete with credible indy legend Kassius Ohno being put in his place, was a superb piece of business.

It was also an example of quality trumping length.

Riddle and Ohno didn't need countless near falls, neck-breaking spots or played out 'This Is Awesome' chants from a crowd who revel in such verbal displays of affection. All they required was one promo interruption, one call out, one knee strike and one celebration from NXT new 'Bro'. Simple, but effective as hell.

Within the modest span of his squash match win, Riddle illustrated his shoot-fighting ability and looked like a killer. Special credit must go to the announce trio for putting over his win as a statement; they, just as much as the wrestlers, had a role to play in elevating the former UFC man.


6. Giving The Two Out Of Three Falls Match The ‘Opening’ Spotlight

Shayna Baszler Kairi Sane Jessamyn Duke
WWE.com

OK, so Shayna Baszler vs. Kairi Sane technically wasn't TakeOver: WarGames II's opening match, but it was treated as such by the announcers following Matt Riddle's coming out party in WWE. Mauro's line about 'getting back to the scheduled matters at hand' spelled out the fact that this NXT Women's Title bout was the true card kick off.

You won't be surprised to learn it was another blistering battle.

Any match carrying the best Two Out Of Three Fall stip has a job on its hands to keep fans invested. Everyone knows that, with few exceptions, the match will go 1-1 before the pace quickens for a tiebreaker. Although this did go level before Baszler's win, the speed was there from the off. Everyone involved can be proud for mixing up the standard formula.

This was women's wrestling like the main roster rarely sees these days. Hard-hitting strikes, impassioned roars and facial expressions a-go-go, drama stemming from outside influences and a realistic, real-fight feel that sold the competitive spirit between champ and challenger were all hallmarks.


5. The Bells & Whistles In The Women’s Title Match

Jessamyn Duke Marina Sharif Dakota Kai Io Shirai
WWE.com

Also unlike the usual interference-laden TV matches we see on Raw and SmackDown, the additions of Jessamyn Duke, Marina Shafir, Dakota Kai and Io Shirai actually helped the NXT Women's Title match.

All the bells and whistles WWE tacked on to Baszler vs. Sane served to differentiate it from everything else on the card. Keep in mind that no other bout on the show had any interference from workers who weren't supposed to be involved in the match. That was a sweet touch and gave the women's scene some spotlight.

Everything worked. The live crowd sympathised with Sane when Shayna's Four Horsewomen pals brutally beat her behind the ref's back, and they popped huge when Shirai performed a perfect Moonsault from the top rope to the outside. This, hopefully, will set up some six-woman tags on NXT over the next while, and could lead to something special at TakeOver: Phoenix in January.

Baszler and Sane were already 2-2 in matches against one another going into WarGames II, so they probably needed something extracurricular to keep the story fresh. What a match, what intensity and what a build towards future feuds.


4. Crowning Aleister Black Number One Contender

Aleister Black
WWE.com

Aleister Black is once again a contender for the NXT Title and Johnny Gargano's maddened obsession with tearing down Tommaso Ciampa resulted in him losing sight of his morals. Those were the chief plot points coming out of Saturday night's TakeOver match between Black and 'Johnny Wrestling'.

The heelish tendencies Gargano displayed here showed his flexibility as a performer too. He couldn't rely on the underdog babyface comeback tale, and so he had to slowly descend into desperation as Black countered his every move and picked up the win. Do not be shocked if this leads to a Triple Threat title scene heading into the new year.

Gargano's plunge into madness is an angle that has legs beyond this.

For now, it's nice to know that Black (one of the best workers in WWE full stop) is back in the top title mix again. He and Ciampa will be able to have some duelling banter on the Network before Gargano sticks his nose back in and lets his bitterness over Tommaso's betrayal warp his own mind.


3. Velveteen’s Dream Getting Shattered

Tommaso Ciampa Velveteen Dream
WWE.com

Beyond the Hollywood Hogan-style appearance, tributes to Hulk, Randy Savage and Ric Flair via borrowing their signature moves and all the other pizzaz that comes with a Velveteen Dream match, there was a hidden story. He, more than anyone else in NXT, will have to learn to dispense with flash for the sake of it if he ever wants to become champion.

That was what this writer took away from his loss to Tommaso Ciampa anyway. Maybe it's a little too in-depth, but it's cool to be able to look beneath the surface of storylines, isn't it?

At TakeOver, it was the right call to keep the belt on Ciampa and further Velveteen's heartache as a nearly man who has captured fan hearts. The best know how to make a loss mean something, and this star-enhancing defeat arguably meant more to Dream's career than an unlikely title win would have. There's no rush with this guy.

Velveteen is a special kind of performer. He proved that by making the sh*tting 'Leg Drop Of Doom' work on a card that included double Moonsaults, weapon shots galore and the titular WarGames stipulation. For now, he's better off title-less.


2. Booking The Babyface Win

NXT Takeover WarGames II
WWE.com

Last year, NXT's original WarGames effort was less about putting forth a stirring babyface struggle and more about the gimmick itself. The Undisputed Era, SAnitY and the team of AOP and Roderick Strong were cheered for their risk-taking and hard work, not because of character alignment.

The second chapter in this NWA revival was a bit more straightforward.

Adam Cole (Bay Bay) and chums were the definite villains of the piece, and WWE did everything to ensure fans were right there for Pete Dunne, Ricochet and the War Raiders as good guys. The headliner was laid out meticulously so that people rooted for the faces. Just as well, 'cause they were the chosen winners.

As Dunne and Ricochet pondered their own unfinished business against each other atop the cage, fans were ready to bathe the heroes in adulation for overcoming every trick in the book from Cole, Strong, Kyle O'Reilly and Bobby Fish. A heroic win was absolutely the right call.


1. Reverting To Classic War Games Rules

NXT Takeover WarGames II
WWE.com

So was reverting to the classic WarGames layout.

In 2017, the first NXT reprise lacked the traditional format of heels having the constant numbers advantage over the babyfaces. WWE put that right this year, and they even found time to make The Undisputed Era look like The Four Horsemen in their prime by locking Pete Dunne in his mini-cage so they could beat down his friends four on three.

It was smart of the company to book a Hanson loss to Kyle O'Reilly on recent NXT tapings and explain this as the reason why Undisputed held the cards. Of course, this classic storytelling comes with some shortcomings; namely, the match can't end before all eight men are involved, meaning it's wrestling for wrestling's sake.

Regardless of that small nuisance, it was necessary. This should now be the template that every WWE-promoted WarGames match follows, and it should never go back to being anything other than dirtbag heels vs. brave babyfaces.

Dusty Rhodes would have been proud.

What else do you think WWE got right at NXT Takeover: WarGames II? Let us know down in the comments!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.