Ranking The 28 Greatest Hell In A Cell Matches In WWE History

8. Brock Lesnar Vs. Undertaker (No Mercy 2002)

The top eight Hell in a Cell matches are heads above the rest. A more specific set of criteria was used to separate them, ranging from buyrates and attendance (how many people paid to see them) to crowd response to the usual match grading rubric (storytelling, psychology, quality of the feud, near falls, and climax). With the worst buyrate of the Hell in a Cell matches considered, the bloody war between Brock and Taker failed to contend with the other candidates. It is historically underrated, though, in terms of performance. Broken down to the purest of elements, it really does not get much better than their story. The fact that they managed to produce such a great match inside the Cell in an era in which it was almost a foregone conclusion that the participants would venture outside the structure is a testament to both Taker€™s ability and Brock€™s uncanny, prodigious rise to prominence in his first year in WWE. Taker vs. Brock was a brutal battle, but the violence was not about what one man was willing to do to his own body €“ a novelty that arguably wears off with repeated viewings. Rather, it was about one man beating the other to a pulp. Both wore the proverbial crimson mask like no other pair in Cell history, so it holds the distinction as the €œbloodiest€ Cell match. It tends to get lost in the shuffle during these types of discussions. It was historically memorable, but not to the extent of its peers. Perhaps it suffers from €œawesome match on a card destined to be forgotten€ syndrome given that it took place on a B-level PPV during a time when the buyrates were sinking.

7. Triple H Vs. Kurt Angle Vs. Undertaker Vs. The Rock Vs. Rikishi Vs. Steve Austin (Armageddon 2000)

If ever there was an example of the difference between greatest and best, it would be the 6-man Hell in a Cell match from 2000. A match that does not sniff the top 10 when ranking the gimmick€™s history on performance alone, it has qualities that made it a candidate despite critical misgivings. Frankly, this one has gotten mixed reviews more than any other in the top 8. It was an era-specific garbage brawl with distracting involvement from Vince McMahon and, even thirteen years later, still screams of being €œwe need to pop a buyrate, so let€™s bring back the Cell.€ It was the second longest Hell in a Cell, so it had plenty of time to play out and tell a thorough tale, but it could have been viewed as too much Attitude Era junk. However, this is not just about pure performance. It featured huge names, including five of the greatest 20 WrestleMania Era stars. There were some intangibles unique to all its peers (Rikishi€™s fall, Austin raking Triple H€™s face around the entire Cell structure, the sheer amount of blood spilt, the huge fight around the ring). Though it does not rank well critically or historically, it did well financially. In accomplishing its goal of popping a buyrate (1.15), it boosted its Hell in a Cell profile considerably. Some people love this match; some thought it was average. The goal of objective subjectivism is to strip away much of the emotion that skews historical comparison. Its place in the top 8 is not safe, but its intangible and fiscal statistics will keep it in the conversation.

6. Triple H Vs. Batista (Vengeance 2005)

As time passes, the story of a match has to be the part that you best remember or it otherwise becomes dated. Novelty is what makes special effects fanatics go crazy at the movies to light up the box office, but if the film that features the modern graphics in one decade produces a plot that cannot match its visual artistry, then it will struggle to hold up against scrutiny as technology advances a decade later. The story of Batista vs. Triple H played out masterfully, culminating in a feud that remains one of the finest of its generation. Though their final clash €“ a wonderful edition of Hell in a Cell cut from the same mold as the Taker-Brock match €“ did not feature the financial rankings necessary to compete for the top spot, the cumulative match rating data surprisingly trumped some of its predecessors. Batista showed us his full potential, providing one of his best outings (with only his work against Undertaker in its league). Hell in a Cell has drawn some strong buyrates over the years, making it difficult for a match like HHH-Batista - that performed well as the #1 bout on a PPV with good box office numbers - to stand out. Trips and Bats had their big drawing showdown at WrestleMania 21, but it did not receive high critical marks. The roles, compared to the other contenders, were reversed for their Hell in a Cell match. Vengeance €™05 was the benchmark for brand-only PPVs during the Raw vs. SD era, drawing a near equal buyrate (0.92) to that year€™s Survivor Series. Unfortunately, the strong number for 2005 ranked just 7th out of 8 amongst Hell in a Cell matches in the latter third of this discussion.

5. Triple H Vs. Mick Foley (No Way Out 2000)

For anyone that believes that Shawn Michaels could come out of retirement to wrestle another match and it not significantly change the memory of WrestleMania 26, I point you to exhibit a) Triple H vs. Cactus Jack from 2000 with Mick Foley€™s career on the line. Foley lost and rode into the sunset for all of a few weeks before coming back to wrestle the WrestleMania 2000 main-event. Even then, the world did its best to rearrange the order of the February and April 2000 PPV bouts, putting the Fatal Fourway for the WWE Championship first in their minds. When Foley returned for a series of matches that did not stop until recent years, the legacy of No Way Out 2000 was forever tarnished. Yes, Foley gave us another spectacle the likes of which nobody else could match in his second and final Cell. No, however, it does not belong in the conversation anymore with the other ultra elite versions of Hell in a Cell. It is still top 5, but it is poised to be passed several times in a way that HBK vs. Taker and Foley vs. Taker will not be. Had Triple H vs. Foley maintained the stipulation that Foley€™s career ended, then this would be a totally different match. The finish, once the last gasps of life in a legendary career, now seems anti-climactic. Watched today, the bout appears structured only to get in Foley€™s crazy bumps and lacks the story of the Royal Rumble Street Fight from a few weeks prior. Foley vs. Trips was a great match, but it is a sinking ship. The only thing keeping it in the top 10 is the poorer quality of modern Cell bouts.

4. Edge Vs. Undertaker (Summerslam 2008)

Edge vs. Taker was the perfect blend between the Hell in a Cell matches born of the Attitude Era€™s body-punishing style, the Brand Split Era€™s faster pace-counter-near fall-heavy style, and the PG Era€™s emphasis on deeply layered storytelling. It showed how to go outside of the Cell without falling off the top and concentrated on circling back to the key points of their lengthy storyline.

3. Undertaker Vs. Mankind (King Of The Ring 1998)

This match is a good example of why we need to draw the line in the sand between €œgreatest€ and €œbest.€ Taker-Mankind was not even a good match, if we are having an honest discussion. If you were to sit down and try to watch this match three times in a row, could you honestly do it? Is there something about it that makes you want to sit down and watch its 17-minute duration numerous times in a row? Though it is difficult to be harsh on a Foley Hell in a Cell match, the fact of the matter is that Mankind vs. Taker is a two move match. We are historically comparing greatness, which requires a certain firmness of stance. Minutes into the match, the most awe-inspiring visual in wrestling history takes place when Foley gets thrown off the Cell. From then on, Foley is only half there. It is amazing to watch him gut his way through the match, particularly after the inadvertent fall through the top of the Cell just a few short minutes later (how did he finish that match, for crying out loud?). So, let us be reasonable and call a spade a spade. This match simply was two unbelievable stunts and a fall on some thumb tacks. BUT€ It is THE most memorable Hell in a Cell match; even more so than the original. When people think Hell in a Cell, most revert to memories of Foley falling off the top and through the announce table. €œThat killed him,€ hollered Jim Ross. €œAs God is my witness, he is broken in half!€

2. Undertaker Vs. Triple H (WrestleMania XXVIII)

There was just something about seeing that Cell lowered from a structure built above the ring in an open air stadium, was there not? That was quite a sight. The fact that the men enclosed within the Cell were its two most successful combatants €“ the two wrestlers that made the gimmick their own €“ added a sense of history to it. HBK offered the premier example of how to be the special guest referee, as well. WrestleMania added quite a bit to it, too, going beyond just quantifiable economics. The crowd in Miami was going nuts for the entire match, adding an element that has made lesser matches just as (if not more) memorable. Unlike the lesser matches, Taker vs. Trips was a thrill ride that flawlessly pressed all of the right emotional buttons. It featured plenty of false finishes, had arguably the most dramatic climax, and featured two of the best performances by two of the greatest of all-time. They even added a little bit of blood in an era where you almost never see anyone get juiced. It was an unbelievable spectacle for reasons that should stand the test of time. Bottom line: if a match can make its case for being the greatest WrestleMania match of all-time, then it is not a difficult stretch to assume that its case for greatest Hell in a Cell match is secure.

1. Shawn Michaels Vs. Undertaker (In Your House: Bad Blood)

As mentioned earlier, it requires a step back when attempting to rank and file the greatest matches of a particular gimmick. HBK vs. Taker featured the story that the Foley-Taker bout lacked, the novelty that the Foley-Taker bout had (just to a lesser extent), the historic distinction of being the very first of its kind, and the incredible quality that had critics piling on the elusive 5-star accolades. What happens when you compare it, point-by-point, with the more recent Cell matches? The finish was specific to the debut of Kane. Several of the candidates offered finishes that were, at the very least, better suited for the feud that was being completed. Nevertheless, it was still very good and holds up well enough to keep it in the conversation with the others. Taker was still at a point in his career where he relied on the guy across the ring to do most (if not all) of the expressions and selling to tell the story (due to his gimmick). HBK was marvellous, but Taker did better in the bouts with Lesnar and Triple H. It still shines in the thoroughness of the story told. Of all the candidates from the early days of the gimmick, the original gives by far the best overall performance. It also provides the incredible, never-seen-before stunt expected of the early Cells. In essence, it tells the story that you might see today, but features the visual, awe-inspiration of the late 90s/early 00s. It ranked 7th in buyrate with just a 0.64. All in all, the original Hell in a Cell is still an outstanding watch €“ not quite the incredible candidate for best match of all-time as it once was, but still a story that you could pop in the DVD player and watch a few times a year without getting bored. HBK vs. Taker maintains its spot when watched back-to-back-to-back with the other top candidates.

Contributor
Contributor

"The Doc" Chad Matthews has written wrestling columns for over a decade. A physician by trade, Matthews began writing about wrestling as a hobby, but it became a passion. After 30 years as a wrestling fan, "The Doc" gives an unmatched analytical perspective on pro wrestling in the modern era. He is a long-time columnist for Lordsofpain.net and hosts a weekly podcast on the LOP Radio Network called "The Doc Says." His first book - The WrestleMania Era: The Book of Sports Entertainment - ranks the Top 90 wrestlers from 1983 to present day, was originally published in December 2013, and is now in its third edition. Matthews lives in North Carolina with his wife, two kids, and two dogs.