Ranking 6 Best Randy Orton Matches At WWE Extreme Rules

The event that is The Viper's playground.

Randy Orton Jack Swagger
WWE.com

In a little over a week Randy Orton will face off against WWE World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins in a steel cage at WWE Extreme Rules. Another interesting stipulation for their match is that Randy Orton's crowd favorite finisher the RKO will be banned from being used. That puts Orton at a disadvantage for sure.

While Seth Rollins is still in the future for Orton at Extreme Rules he has plenty of history to build off of. This Pay-Per-View event has been around for 6 years and The Apex Predator has had a match at every event. He's fought in a variety of stipulations including Falls Count Anywhere and Last Man Standing while facing off against elite competition such as Batista and CM Punk. Orton has a split record at the event: 3 wins and 3 losses.

The Viper has performed impressively in the past at this show as 4 out of 6 of his efforts have landed him 3 stars or higher by Dave Meltzer, a standard-bearer of match ratings. Orton's most recent effort was in a 6-man tag team match that was regarded as many as one of the best matches of 2014. 

Randy Orton typically shows up as a performer at Extreme Rules and the following are every one of his matches, ranked from worst to best...

6. Cage Match vs. Batista (2009)

Randy Orton Batista Extreme Rules
WWE

Randy Orton and Batista would meet in a steel cage for Orton's WWE Championship due to Orton getting himself disqualified after hitting a ref during their previous title match. Their story took them down a path that involved Ric Flair getting punted in the head inside a cage on Raw while Batista watched helplessly on the outside.

There is not much to highlight for this match because it is way too short to ever get going. The actual bell time for this bout only barely crossed the 7 minute mark which is what made this suffer. Both guys are capable of so much more and just never got the time to make it happen.

After a few teased finishers Batista scores the winning pinfall via Batista Bomb. He held up his title and kept saying that the win was for Ric Flair in what would be the worst Extreme Rules match that Randy Orton has ever competed in.


5. Extreme Rules Match vs. Jack Swagger (2010)

Randy Orton Jack Swagger
WWE.com

Jack Swagger entered this event shortly after cashing in his Money In The Bank briefcase to obtain the World Heavyweight Championship. Because Orton had two previous wins over Swagger he was granted a title shot in an Extreme Rules match by former Baywatch star David Hasselhoff. "The Hoff" was guest hosting Raw shortly before this but otherwise he's irrelevant to this match.

Only a few moments during this match would either competitor really capitalize on the stipulation. Orton would smack Swagger over the head a few times with a trash can and he did it with such ferocity that made it easy to forget how flimsy those things look.

Later, Orton would set up a chair in the middle of the ring for the purpose of dropping Swagger onto it via RKO. However Jack would block this attempt mid-RKO and cause Orton to smash the chair with his own back. That set up a gut-wrench powerbomb by the Oklahoma native who then covered him for the win.

The match was slow much of the time that Swagger had control, so much so that the announcers kept pointing it out. They'd question why he wasn't attacking and just standing there. That, coupled with the fact that this Extreme Rules match never really became extreme keeps this one from being higher on this list.


4. Falls Count Anywhere vs. Kane (2012)

Kane Randy Orton Extreme Rules
WWE

Daddy issues are the setup to this match. After already meeting several times in the ring over the previous months this rivalry got personal when Kane attacked "Cowboy" Bob Orton a few weeks prior. Randy would then give equal retribution when he beat up up Paul Bearer on a later episode of Smackdown. 

Kane made good use of their stipulation as they almost immediately go out into the crowd and battled all throughout the sea of people. They kept it moving, giving their extended time out of the ring a real rowdy feeling.

They finally exited the crowd and went backstage. Like most backstage brawls this quieted the people considerably. It wasn't wasted time though because Zack Ryder briefly showed up to pummel the backside of Kane. Remember Zack Ryder? He was fun.

When they finally made it back into the ring there was a series of exciting nearfalls to finish this match. Kane would almost win once with a Chokeslam and sold his frustration after only getting 2 well.

Kane ultimately attempted to finish Orton with a Tombstone Piledriver on a steel chair. Randy would reverse it and instead connect with his RKO for the win. The ending, and this match in general, was really well done and fun to watch. The match quality is fairly high from here on out.


3. Extreme Rules Match vs. Big Show (2013)

Big Show Randy Orton Extreme Rules
WWE

Randy Orton would team up with Big Show (as well as Sheamus) to battle against The Shield at WrestleMania 29. They would lose that match causing Show to be angry with the teammates that he felt let him down during that match. They found themselves crossing paths several times between the Pay-Per-Views which would lead to this Extreme Rules match.

Unlike the previous match on this list that was fought under an Extreme Rules stipulation this match made good use of foreign objects. Big Show at one point sent himself crashing through a ladder propped up on chairs when he tried to splash on Orton who was laid out on it (pictured above). Orton went for an RKO afterward and Show shockingly would kick out.

Randy would connect with an RKO again later in the match, this time dropping Show's head on a steel chair. Orton would opt to punt the big man's skull before going for the cover this time which would score the win for The Viper.

This match was fun and at only around 13 minutes it never felt like it dragged on or was boring. With still two more matches left on this list it is easy to see that Orton's body of work is fairly impressive for this event.


2. Last Man Standing Match vs. CM Punk (2011)

Cm Punk Randy Orton Extreme Rules
WWE

CM Punk would make his way to the ring flanked by the New Nexus in this Last Man Standing match against Randy Orton. There would be an Anonymous GM message prior to the match start stating that New Nexus would be banned from ringside.

Kendo sticks and steel chairs would be used liberally as these two beat the snot out of each other. It would feel like they tortured each other's bodies throughout this 20 minute brawl. Orton would even clear off an announce table to deliver an RKO only for the table to not collapse. These two would often interrupt each other's 10-counts just to not pass up the chance to inflict more damage on each other.

The ending would come in spectacular fashion after a devastating top-rope RKO was used against Punk. Referee Charles Robinson would begin his 10-count that would see both men almost not make it to their feet. While Punk never did Orton would finally stand up for the win at the tail end of the count of nine.

One more entry left in Randy Orton's Extreme Rules library of matches. It might seem implausible that another could be better than this brawl but this next one absolutely tears the roof off in a two team brawl that is a modern classic. On to this treat of a match...


1. Shield vs. Evolution (2014)

Shield Evolution Extreme Rules
WWE.com

At the end of The Shield's run they had established themselves as one of the most dominant forces WWE has seen in a while. Many speculated that the heel stable would be ready for a split but a sort of face turn extended their run slightly longer. The newly reformed stable of Evolution (minus Ric Flair) banded together to take on the young Hounds Of Justice in this epic 6-man tag match at last year's Extreme Rules event.

In this Match Of The Year Contender, Evolution truly performed in a way that was best for business. Triple H, Batista, and Randy Orton would be the ultimate platform for the young stars of The Shield to shine. 

While the more memorable spots were the moments where The Shield was on offense, arguably that was the best booking decision. It might have been Seth Rollins who dove fifteen feet out of the sky on a ledge in the crowd but it was veterans like Randy Orton there to receive the future WWE World Heavyweight Champion.

Everything about this bout was amazing and Orton's veteran stable were the perfect heel counterparts to the young team of Rollins, Ambrose, and Reigns. This was the best match that Randy Orton would be involved in at Extreme Rules.

How will his match against Rollins for the 2015 edition of Extreme Rules stack up compared to these?


Contributor
Contributor

I'm a dad who loves professional wrestling. Find me on Twitter @MitchNickelson or email me at leonardbeats@gmail.com.