Ranking All 28 WWE Royal Rumble Winners

Which Rumble victory was the most satisfying?

For the better part of three decades, wrestling fans have come to expect and be treated to an annual tradition that is all but guaranteed to entertain. The Royal Rumble has grown throughout the past 27 years to become an institution that is almost as synonymous with WWE as WrestleMania itself. Try to imagine a year without the Rumble€ it€™s virtually impossible at this point. The Royal Rumble match marks the official beginning of the road to WrestleMania, a march toward WWE€™s biggest pay-per-view event of the year. The Rumble also gives fans the first official confirmation of a world title match, with the winner of the Rumble €œheadlining€ Mania. Since the Rumble is a once-a-year event, winning it is seen as a distinct and prestigious honor €“ those who have won are held in varying degrees of high esteem. Basically, if you win the Royal Rumble, you€™ve got a huge spotlight cast on you for at least three months, longer if you manage to win the world title at WrestleMania. The Rumble can help launch a career, even more so than winning a world title. But not all Rumble winners are created equally, and not all Rumble winners ascend the ladder of success. Before 1992, there was no tangible prize attached to winning the Royal Rumble. The €™92 Rumble was contested for the then-vacant WWF World Championship, while every Rumble since has been for a WrestleMania world title shot. Some of those who have won the Rumble have gone on to win at Mania and become major stars. Others have lost, squandering months of build-up. So let€™s take a look at the 28 men who have won the 27 Royal Rumbles and see how they stack up against each other.

28. Vince McMahon €“ 1999

WrestleMania title shot: Never cashed in; Went to runner-up €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin Without a doubt, this is the worst Royal Rumble winner on record, as Steve Austin and Vince McMahon entered at #1 and #2 respectively and proceeded to spend the vast majority of the match outside the ring. The ending pretty much mirrors how many Raw matches end today: someone (in this case, the Rock) comes out and distracts someone (Austin) and the opponent (Vince) picks up the victory (eliminating Austin, in this case). McMahon refused to face Rock, so WWF Commissioner Shawn Michaels named runner-up Austin the #1 contender. McMahon would face Austin in a steel cage match for the title shot at St. Valentine€™s Day Massacre, where Big Show would debut and inadvertently help Austin win. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_fu5C2804w Austin went on to win the WWF Championship at WrestleMania XV, but what should have been a straight road to WrestleMania instead was full of unnecessary hairpin turns.

27. Big John Studd €“ 1989

WrestleMania title shot: N/A The winner of the first 30-man Royal Rumble, Big John Studd was not a world title contender, nor was he an up-and-comer. Rather, Studd was on the downswing of his wrestling career, retiring just five months after winning the Rumble. It€™s viewed that this was more of a reward for Studd€™s career and contributions to WWF€™s boom period in the 80s than anything else. Seeing how the Rumble was only in its second year and hadn€™t yet been established as a major event, it€™s understandable that WWF would choose to give Studd a nice sendoff into retirement.

26. & 25. Hulk Hogan €“ 1990-91

WrestleMania title shot(s): N/A Pop quiz: Who is the only reigning world champion to win a Royal Rumble match? If you answered anything other than €œHulk Hogan,€ you should probably take a remedial course in Wrestling Politicking 101. Hogan won the 1990 Rumble while holding the world title, eliminating Mr. Perfect last. At the time, an easy argument could have been made that Perfect eliminating Hogan €“ even by accident €“ and winning could have elevated him and made him an instant title contender. However, Hogan would go on to lose the title to Ultimate Warrior a few months later at WrestleMania VI. (The two had an awesome confrontation during the Rumble.) At the €™91 Rumble, Hogan was not the champ, but he would win and then go on to challenge Sgt. Slaughter for the title, which the Iraqi sympathizer had won at the Rumble. Thankfully Hogan won the Rumble, because he certainly needed the momentum to successfully defend freedom and beat Slaughter.

24. Lex Luger €“ 1994

WrestleMania title shot: Lost to Yokozuna at WrestleMania X When you talk about Rumble winners who squandered their world title shot, Lex Luger has to be at the top of the list. Ignoring the backstage stories of Luger revealing that he was scheduled to win the title and thus losing his spot, the debacle that was the €™94 Rumble is a huge blemish on the event€™s overall history. As many know, Luger and Bret Hart were the last two in the €™94 Rumble, and they tumbled out of the ring together. Replays were €œinconclusive,€ so both men got title shots at WrestleMania X. Luger went first, while Hart faced his brother Owen in arguably the best Mania opening match in history. Luger lost by DQ for shoving guest referee Mr. Perfect, which has to be the worst world title match ending in WrestleMania history (save maybe for Cena versus Miz at WrestleMania XXVII). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=soJhHsBhI6I Luger would be shuffled down the card and leave WWF in mid-1995, kicking off the Monday Night War by appearing on the inaugural episode of WCW Nitro.

23. Batista €“ 2014

WrestleMania title shot: Lost to Daniel Bryan at WrestleMania XXX This is still fresh in fans€™ minds, but it€™s safe to say that history will not be kind to Batista, even if he doesn€™t really deserve all the criticism. Batista returned to WWE last year to much fanfare after a four-year absence, immediately declaring that it was his goal to win the Royal Rumble and headline WrestleMania. While fans (and WWE) definitely missed having some star power on Raw, Batista (and the WWE brass) had an obstacle in his path: massive fan favorite Daniel Bryan. Fans had pretty much married themselves to the idea of Bryan winning the Rumble and overcoming the Authority once and for all by capturing the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. When that didn€™t happen at the Rumble, fans revolted. Batista€™s mega-push was dead before the Rumble match itself had ended. He would be shunted into a secondary role as WWE scrambled to shoehorn Bryan into the main event, where he would give fans what they desperately wanted. Worse yet, Batista was the one who tapped out €“ and he still never got his one-on-one title match.

22. Alberto Del Rio €“ 2011

WrestleMania title shot: Lost to Edge at WrestleMania XXVII You would think the winner of the biggest Royal Rumble match in history €“ as WWE likes to bill the only 40-man Rumble ever €“ would have been treated as a big deal. But for Alberto Del Rio, his victory serves more as a footnote in WWE history. Del Rio entered at #38 and would win the Rumble after overcoming a last-minute surprise attack from Santino Marella of all people. If you go back in history, Marella is by far the most lackluster runner-up ever, which made Del Rio€™s victory pretty anti-climactic. He would go on to lose at WrestleMania to World Heavyweight Champion Edge. Edge would then retire a week later and his best friend Christian would defeat Del Rio in a ladder match for the title a month later. Del Rio€™s destiny would have to wait.

21. Randy Orton €“ 2009

WrestleMania title shot: Lost to Triple H at WrestleMania XV Wrap your head around this one: Randy Orton won the 2009 Royal Rumble by last eliminating Triple H. He then lost his title match at WrestleMania to€ Triple H. Orton would then go on win the title a month later from Hunter. On top of this ridiculous booking was the equally ridiculous storyline of Orton assaulting all the members of the McMahon family, which finally brought Triple H and Stephanie€™s real-life marriage into WWE canon. This also includes the unintentionally comical Triple H home invasion that has become legendary for all the wrong reasons. Orton-Triple H would have been a decent grudge match on its own at Mania, but WWE decided to have Hunter win the title at Elimination Chamber, bringing the WWE Championship into the mix. Then that match went on in the main event and was completely overshadowed by the legendary (for all the right reasons) Undertaker-Shawn Michaels match. This is the very definition of failure.

20. Hacksaw Jim Duggan €“ 1988

WrestleMania title shot: N/A Hacksaw Jim Duggan never won any titles during his tenure in WWF/E, yet he remains one of the company€™s most popular stars. Probably his biggest claim to fame (other than carrying a 2x4 to the ring) is winning the inaugural Royal Rumble match in 1988. The Rumble back then was a brand-new concept, consisting of 20 men. The event itself was televised rather than put on PPV, and the Rumble match consisted mainly of midcarders rather than the main eventer-populated match it is today. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IYKsDkRNPc0 Despite this and the fact that there was no title shot awarded, nothing should take away from Duggan€™s signature WWF/E accomplishment. He deserves kudos for his place in history.

19. €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin €“ 1997

WrestleMania title shot: Stripped due to controversial ending of Rumble It€™s hard to rank a Rumble victory in which the winner never cashes in his title shot this high, but when you consider that it was a major stepping stone in the ascension of €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin to the top of the WWF, you have to give it special consideration. Austin pulled his best Eddie Guerrero impersonation and cheated to win the €™97 Rumble, getting eliminated while the refs were tied up, then snuck back in and won. He would not get his title shot because of the controversial ending, instead being stuck in a four-way match at IYH 13, which he lost. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2hAu_k5q63U Instead, Austin faced Bret Hart (the man who eliminated him and then who he €œeliminated€) in a no DQ submission match at WrestleMania XIII, which would help launch Stone Cold into the stratosphere.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.