Ranking All 30 WWE SummerSlam Main Events

20. 2001 – Booker T. (C) Vs. The Rock

Booker T The Rock SummerSlam 2001
WWE

At the height of the Invasion, WCW/ECW desperately needed to gain the upper hand in its ongoing blood-feud with WWF. Someone needed to make a statement.

Instead of WCW World Champion Booker T. or WCW’s everyman Diamond Dallas Page (arguably the biggest WCW star to make the jump after the 2001 buyout), WWF had 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin switch sides and lead The Alliance.

All of that should have been a tip-off as to how the 2001 SummerSlam main event would go, with The Rock defeating Booker T. despite repeated interference from Shane McMahon. The match itself was good, but Booker was made out to be a geek, losing his WCW title for the second time in four weeks (the other was to Kurt Angle).

This match could have made Booker into a star and a legit threat in the main event, but instead it would mark his last world title reign for five years.


19. 2006 – Edge (C) Vs. Cena

Edge John Cena SummerSlam
WWE.com

On paper, this had all the potential of being a classic. And while it's still a good match, the “champ loses if he’s disqualified” stipulation helped drag it down a little.

Edge had won the title a month earlier from Rob Van Dam after RVD was busted with pot. During the feud leading up to SummerSlam, the Rated-R Superstar kicked off what would become a periodic tradition: physically abusing Cena’s father.

During the match, Lita tried to interfere on Edge’s behalf, only for Edge to try to talk her out of it since he’d lose his title. In the end, Lita would feed Edge brass knuckles and take an FU, allowing Edge to hit Cena with the knucks and retain the title and his moniker as the Ultimate Opportunist.


18. 2007 – Cena (C) Vs. Orton

John Cena Randy Orton Summerslam 2007
WWE.com

Remember when John Cena vs. Randy Orton was a fresh matchup? (Pepperidge Farm remembers.)

This was the first time the two had met in a one-on-one match for the WWE Championship. Eleven years later, WWE has repeated that matchup a couple dozen times, to the point that many fans will chant “boring” or some other derisive phrase no matter how good of a match they are putting on.

On this particular night, the two superstars had their usual solid match, with Orton very nearly pulling out the victory, but once again Cena would Rise Above Vipers and put Orton down for the three count. Shortly thereafter, Orton would continue the tradition Edge started and punt Cena’s father in the head on Raw.

Hmmm… Maybe John Cena Sr. should avoid showing up at WWE events?


17. 2004 – Benoit (C) Vs. Orton

Randy Orton Headlock Chris Benoit SummerSlam 2004
WWE

This would be the first failed attempt to push Randy Orton as the savior and face of the WWE.

After improbably winning the World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania XX, Chris Benoit would see his title reign end after five months in a hard-fought battle. Orton had lost his Intercontinental Championship the previous month, then won a battle royal to become No. 1 contender for the belt.

The story during the match was Orton staying with and matching Benoit, who brought his usual aggressive style to the fight. In the end, Orton won and Benoit shook his hand. The next night, Evolution would kick Orton out of the group in an attempt to launch Randy into the stratosphere as a babyface champ. That effort lasted all of four weeks, before Orton lost his title to HHH.

But don’t worry, Orton would get a few more world title reigns.


16. 1997 – Undertaker (C) Vs. Hart

Shawn Michaels bret Hart SummerSlam 1997
WWE.com

In hindsight, maybe Bret Hart should have refused the WWF Championship at SummerSlam.

Undertaker and Hart squared off in a main event title match that had the combustible element of Shawn Michaels as the special guest referee, and the stipulations that if Hart lost, he couldn’t wrestle in the U.S. and if Michaels favored 'Taker, he couldn’t wrestle in the U.S. again.

The match started slow, gaining steam as Shawn and Bret jaw-jacked throughout, and then 'Taker and HBK got into it. The match famously ended when Bret spit on Shawn and Michaels swung a steel chair… and hit Undertaker. Hart covered, and Michaels counted three.

The victory would only be temporary though, as Michaels and Hart would square off three months later at Survivor Series… in Montreal.


15. 1998 – Austin (C) Vs. Undertaker

Steve Austin Stunner The Undertaker SummerSlam 1998
WWE

The Austin Era was in full-swing during the summer of 1998, with only a one-day Kane championship reign to derail the beer-fueled train. 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin would hold the WWF title (save for that one day) for nearly six months, which was an eternity during the late '90s.

As part of that reign, Austin battled The Undertaker at SummerSlam, earning his stripes by defeating another main event star on his way to becoming the biggest star of the era. The two fought back and forth, highlighted by a top rope leg drop from 'Taker through a table.

Austin would prevail, but the following month, a double pin on the champ would result in the title being left vacant for two months.


14. 2012 – HHH Vs. Lesnar

Lesnar Triple H
WWE.com

The goal here was an epic battle between the former UFC champ and The Game, and they almost delivered. Unlike Brock Lesnar’s previous match against John Cena, the right man won. But also unlike his previous contest, this one lacked the same amount of brutality.

Lesnar had broken HHH’s arm a couple of months earlier with a Kimura lock, which set up this match. Brock focused on Hunter’s arm, while HHH took advantage of a shot to the stomach (with the corner of the announcers’ table), which aggravated (kayfabe) Lesnar’s legit stomach issues. After hitting each other with everything in their arsenal, HHH connected with a second Pedigree – only to be suckered into a Kimura lock that ended with another broken arm and a tapout victory.

Of course, HHH would get his win back on a much bigger stage eight months later, but that’s beside the point.


13. 2015 – Undertaker Vs. Lesnar

Undertaker, Lesnar, SummerSlam
WWE.com

This is a tough match to rank when you weigh match quality against the finish and overall implications.

To be clear, Brock Lesnar had not been pinned or submitted since WrestleMania 29 in 2013, a period of more than two years and 10 matches. Included in that run was Lesnar ending The Undertaker’s unbeatable undefeated streak at WrestleMania XXX. A rematch between the two was a great idea, and having 'Taker play the grizzled veteran gunslinger going heel was a nice twist.

But Undertaker didn’t really play the villain too much, at least not enough to get booed, which created a weird dynamic. Then you have the finish, which involved a phantom tapout from 'Taker (seen by the timekeeper, which didn’t count), a low blow by 'Taker and Lesnar passing out in Hell’s Gate. It was a cluster of an ending to what was a pretty good match up to that point.

And then Brock decisively won the feud at Hell in a Cell (and went another year-plus without being pinned or submitted), making the dubious loss even more of a blemish.


12. 1996 – Michaels (C) Vs. Vader

shawn michaels vader
WWE.com

While it isn’t Big Show vs. Rey Mysterio, the 1996 SummerSlam main event followed the big man vs. little man playbook to great effect. Shawn Michaels had to use his quickness to counter Vader’s brute force, but he also had to contend with Vader’s speed and agility. For a 450-pound man, Vader moved quite well.

The match see-sawed for about 12 minutes until Vader seemingly won via countout. But seeing how the title doesn’t change hands on a count-out, manager Jim Cornette demanded a restart. Michaels then used Cornette’s tennis racket and got disqualified, but again Cornette pleaded for the match to continue. The two exchanged and kicked out of each other’s finishers, but Vader got cute and missed a moonsault. Michaels’ moonsault press connected, however, and that proved to be the difference.

The backstory here is that Vader originally was booked to win, but Michaels had a meltdown, leading to the two false finishes. It’s a shame, as Vader would soon slide down the card and fade out of WWF within two years, having never tasted gold in the company.


11. 1999 – Austin (C) Vs. HHH Vs. Mankind

Stone Cold Triple H Mankind SummerSlam 1999
WWE.com

Take three of the biggest stars of the era and throw in one of the most renowned WWF/E personalities of all time (and the then-governor of the state hosting SummerSlam) and you’ve got the makings for a truly memorable night.

Now have one of the most popular wrestlers on the roster winning the WWF Championship. You’ve just hit a home run for the fans in attendance.

Steve Austin, HHH and Mankind were no strangers to each other, and it showed in this triple threat title match. Unlike other special guest referees, having Jesse 'The Body' Ventura fill the role added something special to the match. He wasn’t another wrestler thrown in to further an angle (see Shawn Michaels in the Undertaker-Hart match two years earlier), nor was he a total outsider brought in to pop PPV buys (see Mike Tyson at WrestleMania XIV).

Mankind winning the title by pinning Austin (who was the biggest star in the company at that point) was a special moment, but he ultimately served to be a transitional champ, losing the belt to HHH the next night.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.